1/23
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the ‘traditional’ idea of the constitution ?
• A constitution based on immemorial usage, history and tradition, national spirit, culture, customs and values, which arises in practice rather than being written down.
What is the ‘modern’ idea of the Constitution ?
• A constitution must be (1) real, i.e. a document; (2) establish the government, not the other way round; (3) comprehensive; and (4) a fundamental law.
What is the UK’s ‘uncodified constitution’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: The UK has no “single coherent code of fundamental law which prevails over all other sources of law”. Its constitution is spread across statutes, events, conventions, academic writings and judicial decisions.
• Explanation: Arrangements “developed over time, in a pragmatic as much as principled way”, so no single source has higher legal status. Parliament can change any part by ordinary statute, and the courts develop it through case law.
• Example: R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5: Lord Neuberger set out this description in a case where the Supreme Court held by an 8–3 majority that the government needed an Act of Parliament to trigger Article 50 and begin leaving the EU. With no written constitution to settle the question, the court relied on common law principles about the limits of prerogative power.
How are ‘conventions and political practices’ a source of the UK’s uncodified constitution ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Conventions are non-legal rules of political behaviour that are treated as binding by those they apply to, but are not enforced by the courts. They regulate how legal powers are actually used.
• Explanation: Many powers that look absolute in law are limited only by convention. For example, the monarch’s legal power to refuse Royal Assent is constrained by the convention that assent is always given: it was last refused in 1708, when Queen Anne vetoed the Scottish Militia Bill. Conventions are enforced politically, through loss of confidence, resignation or public pressure, not by judges.
• Example: (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5: the Supreme Court held unanimously that the Sewel Convention (that Westminster won’t normally legislate on devolved matters without devolved consent) was not legally enforceable, even though the Scotland Act 2016, s 2 had written it into statute. The court said judges are merely “observers” of conventions.
How is ‘judge-made and common law’ a source of the UK’s uncodified constitution ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Constitutional rules and principles developed by judges through case law, rather than enacted by Parliament. They include the rule of law, the limits of prerogative power, and fundamental rights such as access to the courts.
• Explanation: With no written constitution, judges fill the gaps by deciding cases on constitutional questions, and those decisions bind later courts through precedent. Common law can be overridden by statute, but courts still use it to limit the executive. In Miller/Cherry [2019], for instance, an 11–0 court drew limits on prorogation from common law principles alone.
• Example: Entick v Carrington (1765) 19 St Tr 1029: the King’s messengers broke into John Entick’s home and seized his papers under a warrant issued by the Secretary of State. The court held that the executive can only act where the law authorises it, and with no such authority the search was trespass. Entick was awarded £300 in damages. The case established a cornerstone of the rule of law without any statute.
How is ‘legislation’ a source of the UK’s uncodified constitution ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Acts of Parliament that create, change or regulate the institutions and powers of the state, such as the Bill of Rights 1689, the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, the Human Rights Act 1998 and the Scotland Act 1998.
• Explanation: Because Parliament is sovereign, statute is the highest source of constitutional law and can override common law and convention. Constitutional statutes are passed in the same way as any other Act, but in Thoburn v Sunderland CC [2002] Laws LJ held that they can’t be impliedly repealed, only expressly.
• Example: Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, and R (Jackson) v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56: the 1911 Act cut the House of Lords’ power to block bills to a two-year delay, and the 1949 Act cut it to one year. When the 1949 Act was used to pass the Hunting Act 2004 without the Lords’ consent, a nine-member panel of Law Lords unanimously upheld it as valid. Ordinary legislation had reshaped the relationship between the two Houses, a fundamental constitutional change.
How are ‘international law / treaties and their domestic legal effects’ a source of the UK’s uncodified constitution ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame Ltd (No 2) [1991] 1 AC 603: the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 required fishing vessels registered in the UK to be at least 75% British-owned, shutting out Spanish-owned trawlers. The House of Lords disapplied the 1988 Act because it conflicted with EU law, the first time a UK court set aside an Act of Parliament. It did so because the 1972 Act told it to prefer EU law, showing how an incorporated treaty can limit later legislation.
What is ‘codification’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: The process of gathering a country’s fundamental constitutional rules into a single authoritative written document that has higher legal status than ordinary law.
• Explanation: A codified constitution is usually entrenched (it can only be changed by a special procedure, not by ordinary legislation) and supreme (courts can strike down laws that conflict with it). The UK has never codified its constitution, so its rules are spread across statute, common law, conventions and treaties, and Parliament can change any of them by a simple majority. Supporters of codification, such as Douglas-Scott (2026), argue that it would make the constitution clearer and protect fundamental laws from “passing whims of government policy”.
• Example: The US Constitution (1787): a single document of 7 articles, which can only be amended with the approval of two-thirdsof both Houses of Congress and three-quarters of the states (Article V). It has been amended just 27 times in over 230 years. In Marbury v Madison (1803), the US Supreme Court held that it could strike down Acts of Congress that conflict with the Constitution, a power UK courts do not have over Acts of Parliament.
What is ‘entrenchment’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Protecting a law from being repealed or amended by the ordinary legislative process, by requiring a special procedure, such as a two-thirds majority or a referendum, before it can be changed.
• Explanation: Codified constitutions are usually entrenched. In the UK, Parliament can’t entrench legislation, because no Parliament can bind its successors. Any Act can be repealed by a later Act passed by simple majority, either expressly or by implied repeal, where a later Act that conflicts with an earlier one simply overrides it. The only partial exceptions are Thoburn [2002], where constitutional statutes can’t be impliedly repealed, though they can still be repealed expressly, and the “manner and form” argument from Jackson [2005].
• Example: Ellen Street Estates Ltd v Minister of Health [1934] 1 KB 590: the Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act 1919 said that any later Act inconsistent with it “shall not have effect”. When the Housing Act 1925 set a different compensation rule, the Court of Appeal held that the 1925 Act prevailed. Maugham LJ said the legislature “cannot, according to our constitution, bind itself as to the form of subsequent legislation”, confirming that Parliament cannot entrench its laws.
What are ‘constitutional conventions’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Non-legal rules of constitutional behaviour, which Dicey described as “conventions, understandings, habits, or practices”, that the people they apply to treat as binding, but which courts do not enforce.
• Explanation: Examples include the monarch always giving Royal Assent, collective cabinet responsibility, and the Prime Minister sitting in the Commons. Jennings (1959) set out a three-part test for whether a convention exists: (1) are there precedents? (2) do the actors believe they are bound? (3) is there a reason for the rule? Breaching a convention brings political consequences, not legal ones.
• Example: Attorney General v Jonathan Cape Ltd [1976] QB 752: the government tried to stop the publication of former Cabinet minister Richard Crossman’s diaries, which revealed Cabinet discussions from 1964 to 1970. The court recognised the convention of collective cabinet responsibility but would not enforce it directly. Instead it used the law of confidence, and refused an injunction because, about 10 years after the events, publication no longer threatened the confidentiality that the convention protects.
What is the role of the ‘judiciary’ in the context of the UK’s uncodified constitution ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: The judiciary interprets and applies the law, develops the common law, and holds the executive to account through judicial review, but it cannot strike down Acts of Parliament.
• Explanation: Without a written constitution, judges fill gaps by developing constitutional principles, such as the rule of law and the limits of prerogative power, case by case. Under the Human Rights Act 1998, they read legislation compatibly with Convention rights where possible (s 3) and, if they can’t, issue a declaration of incompatibility (s 4), which leaves the Act in force and the response to Parliament. The Constitutional Reform Act 2005 strengthened judicial independence by creating the Supreme Court, which opened in 2009 with 12 Justices, separate from the House of Lords.
• Example: A v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004] UKHL 56 (the Belmarsh case): a panel of nine Law Lords held by 8–1 that indefinite detention without trial of foreign terrorist suspects under the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001 was incompatible with Convention rights, and issued a declaration of incompatibility. The court couldn’t strike the law down, but Parliament replaced it with control orders in the Prevention of Terrorism Act 2005.
How does ‘Parliament’ hold the executive to account ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Parliament scrutinises and controls the government through questions, debates, select committees and votes. Ultimately, the government needs the confidence of the House of Commons to stay in office.
• Explanation: Ministers must answer to Parliament through Prime Minister’s Questions (weekly) and departmental question times, and select committees examine each government department’s spending, policy and administration. Under ministerial responsibility, ministers are answerable to Parliament for their departments, and the government as a whole must keep the Commons’ confidence. Because most of these are conventions, accountability is political rather than legal: a government that loses a confidence vote is expected to resign or call an election. In Miller/Cherry [2019], the Supreme Court held prorogation unlawful precisely because it stopped Parliament carrying out this role.
• Example: The vote of no confidence on 28 March 1979: James Callaghan’s Labour government lost by 311 votes to 310, a margin of one. Callaghan called a general election, which Labour lost to Margaret Thatcher’s Conservatives. It’s the last time a UK government was removed by a Commons confidence vote, showing Parliament’s ultimate power to end a government.
How does the ‘Judiciary’ hold the executive to account ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Through judicial review, courts check whether ministers and public bodies have acted lawfully: within their legal powers, rationally, and by a fair procedure. They can quash unlawful decisions.
• Explanation: In CCSU v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] (the GCHQ case), Lord Diplock set out three grounds of review: illegality (acting beyond legal powers), irrationality (a decision no reasonable authority could make) and procedural impropriety (unfair process). The same case held that prerogative powers can be reviewed too. Courts review how power is used, not whether a policy is wise, and they can’t strike down Acts of Parliament. They enforce the limits Parliament has set and the common law principles, such as the rule of law, that the executive must respect.
• Example: R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51: the government introduced employment tribunal fees of up to £1,200 in 2013, after which claims fell by roughly 70%. A 7–0 Supreme Court quashed the fees order as unlawful, holding that it effectively blocked access to justice, a common law constitutional right. The government had to stop charging the fees and refund those already paid.
How do ‘Elections’ hold the executive to account ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
What is a ‘prerogative power’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
How does ‘political constitutionalism’ hold government to account ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
How does ‘legal constitutionalism’ hold government to account ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
How is the UK’s uncodified constitution ‘multilayered’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
What is a ‘dualist democracy’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
What is a ‘monist democracy’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
What is a ‘constitutional moment’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
What is the ‘hierarchy of norms’ in a written constitution ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
How is the UK’s uncodified constitution considered ‘flexible’ ? (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S
Why can Parliament not change the ‘ultimate legal principles’ (Definition, Explanation and Example)
• Definition: Treaties the UK signs, such as the European Convention on Human Rights and, formerly, the EU Treaties, become part of the constitution only once Parliament incorporates them into domestic law by statute.
• Explanation: The UK is dualist: a treaty binds the UK internationally, but has no effect in UK courts unless an Act gives it one. Once incorporated, treaties can have major constitutional effects. The European Communities Act 1972 gave EU law priority over UK law, and the Human Rights Act 1998 requires courts to read legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as it is possible to do so” (s 3). Because these effects come from statute, Parliament can remove them by statute, as it did with the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018.
• Example: R v S