1/25
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What Was the Challenge?
Dramatic Population Increase and Rapid Loss of Natural Areas Due to Residential and Commercial Development
What is a Riparian Forest?
A Forest Right on the Edge of Water
What is the Goal of the Econ Conservation Program?
To Conserve Riparian Wildlife Habitat on Private and Public Land
What Approach Was Used?
Intergovernmental Approach, Which Includes the Regional Water Management District and 3 Levels of Government
What are the Regulatory Tools Used?
Water Management District Regulation, Local Government Comprehensive Plan Provisions, and Local Government Ordinances
What are the Non-Regulatory Tools Used?
Land Acquisition and Conservation Easements
What Was Factor 1: Policy Development Process?
Studies Suggest That Deliberative, Evidence-Based, Inclusive, and Transparent Policy Development Initiatives May Lead to Positive Outcomes
What Was the Finding to Factor 1?
Policy Development Process Was Deliberative, Inclusive, and Effective
What Was Factor 2: Scientific Findings and Rational?
Conservation Programs Based on Scientific Data and Concepts are More Likely to be Legally and Politically Defensible
How Wide Was the Buffer Zone?
550ft to Protect ~50% of Basin Species and a 2nd Buffer Zone to Protect 1st Buffer Zone from Edge Effects
What Was the Finding for Factor 2?
Ecological Values, Threats, and Scientific Rational for RHPZs Were Thoroughly Documents and Effectively Communicated
What is Factor 3: Regulatory Framework Analysis?
Conservation Programs That Address Shortcomings of Existing Laws and are Based on Careful Analysis of Government Authority and Limitations are More Likely to be Politically Acceptable and Legally Defensible
What Was the Finding for Factor 3?
Critical Regulatory Gaps Were Identified and Legal Authority for New Conservation Measures Were Analyzed and Effectively Communicated
What is Factor 4: Non-Regulatory Tools?
Non-Regulatory Approached Such as Land Acquisition are Effective Conservation Tools
What Was the Finding for Factor 4?
Land Acquisition Has Significantly Contributed to Habitat Conservation in the RHPZ. Regulation Buys Time Required for Government and Land Trusts to Secure Funds, Negotiate With Landowners, and Purchase Land
What is Factor 5: Hardship Relief Flexibility Mechanisms?
Regulatory Programs Limiting Private Land Use May Create Economic Hardships for Landowners and Make Government Vulnerable to 5th Amendment Regulatory Takings Challenges
What Was the Finding for Factor 5?
SJRWMD and Local Governments Include Flexibility Mechanisms That Likely Reduce but Don’t Eliminate Legal Challenges
What is Factor 6: Legal Challenges?
Have There Been Any Administrative or Judicial Decisions That Have Impacted Program Implementations?
SJRWMD vs Consolidated-Tomoka Land Co.
Facts: In 1997, Distric Proposed Established RHPZs for Two New Water Basins
Initial Ruling: Invalid as a Matter of Law
Issue: Has the Agency Exceeded its Grant of Rulemaking Authority?
Holding: Rules Proposed by the District are a Valid Exercise of Delegated Authority
Reasoning: FL Statute Authorized SJRWMD
SJRWMD vs Koontz
Regulatory Taking Challenge
Facts: Koontz Bought Land Within RHPZs With Intention for Later Commercial Development, Applied for Permit and Permit Was Denied
Issue: Are the Districts Permitting Conditions a Regulatory Taking?
Holding: Who Knows lol
SJRWMD vs Griffin
Facts: Portion of Large Development Within RHPZ. Development Was Found to Meet Standard. Adjacent Landowner Challenged Issuance of Permit
Issue: Whether the Developer Provided Reasonable Assurance That the Requirements of SJRWMD Rules Were Met
Holding: Admin Law Judge Recommended Permit be Issues
What Was the Finding for Factor 6?
Legal Challenges Have Occurred but Have Not Substantially Diminished Program Effectiveness
What is Factor 7: Ongoing Assessment?
Since Adoption, Has the Government Assessed the Program Effectiveness and Made Adjustments if Needed?
What is the Finding for Factor 7?
The SJRWMD Has Only Reviewed the Impact of the Habitats Continuity and Ecological Integrity on a Individual Permit Basis
What is Factor 8: GIS Analysis?
Whether GIS Analysis Suggests the Program Has Been Beneficial
What are Some Key Takeaways?
Program Has Conserved Riparian Habitat
Regulation is a Viable Conservation Method
Regulation Slows Development
GIS Data Analysis Yields Important Data and Insights