1/85
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Public health (Winslow definition)
The science and art of preventing disease, prolonging life, and promoting health and efficiency through organized community effort
C.-E. A. Winslow
Founder of the Yale School of Public Health; wrote the classic early 20th-century definition of public health
Public health (1988 IOM / National Academy of Medicine definition)
What we, as a society, do collectively to assure the conditions for people to be healthy
1988 IOM report
"The Future of Public Health"; described the public health system as in crisis (e.g., no clear universally accepted mission, tension between expertise and politics, uneasy relationship with medicine)
1988 IOM report: problem with mission
There was no clear, universally accepted mission for public health
1988 IOM report: problem with academia
Public health practice was largely decoupled from its academic bases
Three core functions of public health
Assessment, policy development, and assurance
Overarching goal of the 10 Essential Public Health Services
Equity (placed at the centre of the wheel)
Assessment (core function)
Essential services 1–2: monitor population health status and needs; investigate, diagnose, and address health problems and hazards
Policy development (core function)
Essential services 3–6: communicate and educate; mobilize communities and partnerships; create policies, plans, and laws; use legal and regulatory actions
Assurance (core function)
Essential services 7–10: equitable access to care; diverse skilled workforce; evaluation, research, and quality improvement; strong organizational infrastructure
Essential service: "investigate, diagnose, and address health problems and hazards"
Belongs to the assessment core function
Essential service: "utilize legal and regulatory actions"
Belongs to the policy development core function
Essential service: "build and support a diverse and skilled workforce"
Belongs to the assurance core function
Public Health 1.0
Late 1800s onward; tremendous growth of knowledge and tools for medicine and public health, but uneven access to care and public health
Public Health 2.0
After the 1988 IOM report; systematic development of governmental public health agency capacity, but focus limited to traditional agency programs
Public Health 3.0
Engages multiple sectors and community partners to create collective impact and improve social determinants of health (report 2016)
Chief Health Strategist
Public Health 3.0 recommendation: public health leaders should work with all partners to drive initiatives, including on upstream social determinants
Public Health 3.0 recommendations (5)
Chief Health Strategist; structured cross-sector partnerships; enhanced PHAB accreditation; timely, granular, actionable data and clear metrics; enhanced and modified funding (blending and braiding funds)
PHAB
Public Health Accreditation Board; accredits health departments (PH 3.0 says its criteria should be enhanced)
Blending and braiding of funds
PH 3.0 funding idea: combining money from multiple sources to support prevention and social determinants work
COVID-19 impact on public health
Made public health more central; exposed strengths and weaknesses; increased polarization, threats to agencies, and challenges to legal powers and funding
Public health system
Governmental public health infrastructure at the centre, connected to partners such as healthcare, community, employers, media, academia, philanthropy, policymakers, and NGOs
Dahlgren & Whitehead model (1991)
Social-ecological model of determinants: age/sex/constitutional factors at the core, then lifestyle, social and community networks, living and working conditions, and general socioeconomic, cultural, and environmental conditions
Health impact pyramid (Frieden, 2010)
Five tiers of intervention; the base has the greatest population impact and the top requires the most individual effort
Health impact pyramid tiers (bottom to top)
Socioeconomic factors; changing the context to make default decisions healthy; long-lasting protective interventions; clinical interventions; counselling and education
Health impact pyramid: base tier
Socioeconomic factors (poverty, education, housing, safe streets); greatest population impact
Health impact pyramid: changing the context
Making healthy choices the default, e.g., smoke-free laws, fluoridation, folic acid fortification, trans fat ban
Health impact pyramid: long-lasting protective interventions
One-time or infrequent interventions with long-term benefit, e.g., immunizations, colonoscopy, brief smoking intervention
Health impact pyramid: top tier
Counselling and education (e.g., eat healthy, be active); requires the most individual effort and has the smallest population impact
Three buckets of prevention (Auerbach, 2016)
1: traditional clinical prevention; 2: innovative clinical prevention; 3: total population or community-wide prevention
Bucket 1: traditional clinical prevention
Increase the use of evidence-based services in the clinical setting (health care domain)
Bucket 2: innovative clinical prevention
Provide services outside the clinical setting (overlap between health care and public health)
Bucket 3: community-wide prevention
Implement interventions that reach whole populations (public health domain)
Characteristics of a public health approach
Grounded in science; prevention-focused; founded on equity and social justice; ethical; linked with government; inherently political; relies on the broader system and health in all policies; multidisciplinary; dynamic
Health equity
Attainment of the highest level of health for all people; requires valuing everyone equally and addressing avoidable inequalities, injustices, and disparities
Equality vs equity
Equality gives everyone the same resources; equity gives people what they need based on their circumstances
Health inequity
Avoidable, unjust differences in health; the slides equate it with social injustice
WHO Constitution and rights
Recognizes health as a human right
Principles of ethical public health practice
12 principles, e.g., address fundamental causes, respect community rights, get community input and consent, empower disenfranchised communities, protect confidentiality unless there's a high risk of significant harm
Ethics: confidentiality exception
Confidentiality may be broken only when there is a high likelihood of significant harm to an individual or the community
Ten great US public health achievements (1900–1999)
Vaccination; motor-vehicle safety; safer workplaces; infectious disease control; fewer heart disease and stroke deaths; safer foods; healthier mothers and babies; family planning; water fluoridation; recognizing tobacco as a hazard
WHO definition of health
A state of complete physical, mental, and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity
Determinants of health
The many factors that strongly influence an individual's or population's health
Three models of determinants of health
Social determinants of health model; County Health Rankings (CHR) model; social-ecological model
Social determinants of health model (KFF): 6 domains
Economic stability; neighbourhood and physical environment; education; food; community and social context; health care system
County Health Rankings model: health outcomes
Length of life (50%) and quality of life (50%)
County Health Rankings model: health factors weights
Social and economic factors 40%; health behaviours 30%; clinical care 20%; physical environment 10%
CHR: largest health factor
Social and economic factors (40%): education, employment, income, family and social support, community safety
CHR: health behaviours (30%)
Tobacco use, diet and exercise, alcohol and drug use, sexual activity
CHR: clinical care (20%)
Access to care and quality of care
CHR: physical environment (10%)
Air and water quality, housing and transit
Social-ecological model (CDC): 4 levels
Individual, relationship, community, societal
Upstream strategies
Improve social conditions, e.g., social and public policies, socioeconomic position, culture and societal values
Downstream strategies
Improve individuals' conditions, e.g., risk behaviours, disease outcomes, mortality outcomes
Direction of public health focus (framework for reducing inequity)
Traditional public health and health systems are beginning to shift upstream
Social cohesion and social capital
In the health inequity framework, the link between socioeconomic position and living conditions
Health indicators
Measures of health status; typically reflect disease and mortality rather than health itself
Numbers vs rates
Numbers are often used for resource allocation and advocacy; rates are more commonly used to assess communities
Prevalence
All cases (existing and new) of a disease in a population during a specific time period
Incidence
Only new cases of a disease in a population during a specific time period
Questions for judging data quality
Where are the data from? Validated source? Collection methods? Current or lagged? Limitations? Potential biases?
Crude vs age-adjusted death rate
Crude: total deaths ÷ population; age-adjusted: corrected for differences in age structure so populations or years can be compared fairly
YPLL
Years of potential life lost before age 75; gives more weight to deaths at younger ages
Leading cause of death by death rate (US 2020–21)
Diseases of the heart
Leading cause of YPLL (US 2020–21)
Unintentional injuries (because they kill younger people)
Why YPLL and death rate rankings differ
Death rates count all deaths equally; YPLL weights premature deaths, so injuries, suicide, and homicide rank higher
Leading causes of death in 1900
Infectious diseases: influenza and pneumonia, tuberculosis, diarrhea and enteritis
Leading causes of death in 2000 and later
Chronic diseases: heart disease and cancer (COVID-19 was 3rd in 2021)
Leading underlying (preventable) causes of death
Dietary risks, hypertension, tobacco use, hypercholesterolemia
Morbidity
Illness or disease in a population (as opposed to mortality, which is death)
Healthy People 2030
US framework of national health objectives, including leading health indicators (LHIs) and morbidity targets
Healthy People 2030 vision
A society in which all people can achieve their full potential for health and well-being across the lifespan
Healthy People 2030 mission
To promote, strengthen, and evaluate the nation's efforts to improve the health and well-being of all people
Healthy People 2030 overarching goals
Healthy lives free of preventable disease; eliminate disparities, achieve equity and health literacy; healthy environments; healthy development across life stages; multisector engagement
Well-being
Being able to optimize physical, mental, and social functioning; the cornerstone of WHO's definition of health but has no standardized measure
Place matters
Life expectancy can differ by years between neighbourhoods only short distances apart
Social Vulnerability Index (SVI)
Mapping tool that ranks how socially vulnerable a community (e.g., a county) is
Education, income, and health
Lower education and lower income are associated with higher mortality and shorter life expectancy
Measures of association in public health
Relative risk, odds ratio, attributable risk
Relative risk
Risk of disease in the exposed group divided by risk in the unexposed group
Odds ratio
Odds of exposure among cases divided by odds of exposure among controls; used in case-control studies
Attributable risk
Risk in the exposed minus risk in the unexposed; the excess risk due to the exposure
Cost-benefit analysis
Economic analysis that expresses benefits in monetary terms
Cost-effectiveness analysis
Economic analysis that uses a nonmonetary outcome, e.g., cost per life saved
Return on investment (ROI) example
A 2022 study found a 10:1 benefit-to-cost ratio for COVID-19 vaccines in New York City