1/42
Comprehensive vocabulary flashcards covering macro- and micro-allocation, QALY formulations and critiques, age rationing theories (Callahan, Daniels, Veatch), autonomy and competence according to Mill and Savulescu, and the ethical arguments surrounding AI scribes in clinical practice.
Macro-Allocation
Societal and governmental budgeting decisions (e.g., funding healthcare vs. education, or funding oncology vs. prenatal care).
Micro-Allocation
Bedside decisions deciding between specific individual patients (e.g., who receives a single available donor kidney or ICU bed).
QALY Formula
Expected Additional Life Years multiplied by Health State Quality Score (on a scale of 0.0 for death to 1.0 for perfect health).
Beneficial Healthcare Activity
Any healthcare treatment or intervention that generates a positive net amount of QALYs.
Efficient Healthcare Activity
A healthcare intervention where the financial cost per QALY produced is as low as possible (maximum QALYs per dollar spent).
QALY Bias Against the Elderly
Older people inherently have fewer potential life years remaining, so pure QALY maximization systematically favors the young.
QALY Bias Against the Disabled
Pre-existing conditions cap the maximum post-treatment health score below 1.0, so saving a disabled person always yields fewer QALYs than saving a healthy person.
QALY Distortion of Priorities
Favors high-volume, cheap non-fatal treatments (e.g., hip replacements) over expensive, life-saving therapies (e.g., kidney dialysis).
QALY Socioeconomic Bias
Incorporating prospective economic earnings or social worth metrics systematically biases care toward the white middle class.
Lockwood's Conflict: Efficiency vs. Need
The direct tension between welfarism ("to each according to what produces the most QALYs") and justice ("to each according to their need").
Lockwood's Compromise
Justice (treating need) acts as a constraint on efficiency, unless differences in prospective suffering or lost life become enormous.
Lockwood's Cheaper Patient Rule
When two patients have equal need and identical disease, treating the cheaper patient is fair because it conserves funds to treat more total people.
Veatch on Consequentialism
A consistent consequentialist must favor age mattering because the utility of saving decades of life vastly outweighs anxiety about aging or family grief.
Consequentialist Arguments Against Age
Callahan's Natural Life-Span View
The claim that medicine should stop life-prolonging care after a natural lifespan (age 75−80) and offer only palliative care.
Veatch's Critique of Callahan
Picking an exact age cutoff is arbitrary, and Callahan's model fails to explain why society should spend any resources on people past the cutoff.
Daniels' Prudential Life-Span View
The claim that individuals should rationally budget their lifetime healthcare to favor youth and middle age to protect their normal opportunity range.
Veatch's Critique of Daniels
Unfair to people who die young because they pay into a social scheme whose late-life benefits they never survive to claim.
Veatch's Over-a-Lifetime Perspective
Used in chronic or non-acute conditions; the younger patient is worse off because they had fewer total life opportunities, so age matters.
Veatch's Slice-of-Life Perspective
Used in acute, agonizing trauma; extreme pain shatters personal identity and past history, making immediate pain the only factor, so age does not matter.
Why Pain Eliminates Age in Slice-of-Life
Excruciating agony collapses consciousness into the present moment; past years lived no longer count as a benefit to the person suffering.
Mill's Harm Principle (On Liberty)
The state or medicine may only interfere with a competent adult's liberty to prevent harm to others; paternalism is impermissible.
Mill on Individual Sovereignty
Over himself, over his own body and mind, the competent individual is sovereign.
Savulescu's Central Thesis on Competence
Being clinically or legally competent does not guarantee that a patient's decision or refusal is autonomous.
Savulescu's Rephrased Question
Instead of asking "What would the patient desire if competent?", we must ask: "What would she now rationally desire if competent?"
Rational Desire Requirement 1: Information
The patient must possess accurate knowledge of relevant medical facts and all available options (without pathological avoidance).
Rational Desire Requirement 2: Logic
The patient's reasoning must be free from errors of deductive or inductive logic (e.g., thinking a surgical risk of death means surgery guarantees death).
Rational Desire Requirement 3: Imagination
The patient must vividly imagine and appreciate what living out each available alternative state would genuinely feel like.
Obstructive Desire
An immediate, panic- or fear-driven desire that actively blocks a person from fulfilling their authentic, deeply evaluated long-term goals.
The Ulysses Analogy (Savulescu)
Ulysses ordered himself tied to the mast; frustrating his immediate screams to be untied preserved his deeper, authentic autonomy.
The Case of Mrs. X (Savulescu)
A competent woman refusing life-saving leg amputation due to cognitive distortions and inability to imagine life disabled; overriding her respected true autonomy.
Jehovah's Witness Autonomous Blood Refusal
Autonomous if based on a non-descriptive or instrumentally valuable spiritual belief reflecting their authentic life philosophy.
Jehovah's Witness Non-Autonomous Blood Refusal
Non-autonomous if based on a false descriptive/factual claim about physical reality or an instrumentally irrational error.
Savulescu's Best-Interest Standard
When a patient's true values and rational desires cannot be determined, clinicians must treat according to objective well-being.
Descriptive Benefits of AI Scribes
Consequentialist Justification FOR AI Scribes
Treating more patients faster reduces ER wait times, unburdens hospitals, and saves more aggregate lives.
Non-Consequentialist Justification FOR AI Scribes
Compensates for arbitrary bad luck; patients do not deserve illness/trauma, and AI efficiency ensures they get the timely care they morally deserve.
Descriptive / Practical Hazards of AI Scribes
AI Scribes Missing Physical Cues
AI only records audio dialogue; it cannot detect visual symptoms (bruising, sudden weight loss, unsteady gait, pallor) that patients don't say aloud.
Ouyang's Core Critique of AI Scribes
Writing clinical charts is how physicians learn and practice clinical reasoning; outsourcing charting removes essential diagnostic skill-building.
Automation and Confirmation Bias (AI)
Physicians passively accepting AI diagnoses without verifying, or developing ungrounded reliance ("AI psychosis").
Consequentialist Objection AGAINST AI Scribes
If future doctors lose clinical reasoning through AI shortcuts, diagnostic errors will rise, producing worse overall health outcomes.
Non-Consequentialist Objection AGAINST AI Scribes
Society demands "good doctors"; relying on AI shortcuts violates the physician's intrinsic moral duty and role responsibility to cultivate diagnostic excellence.