1/34
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the three types of adoption?
1) Agency adoption — Done through the DSWD , who finds adoptive families
2) Relative Adoption — A biological parent relinquishes their child to a relative or a member of their extended family.
3) Independent adoptions — Biological parents go directly to a person they know, or an intermediary. An intermediary is used when they know o fpeople who want to have their child adopted
What is the process for the agency adoption that a adoptive family must go through?
inquiry about adoption —> Application —> Interviews for the case study report —> matching —> Supervised trial custody —> Finalization of the child’s custody
In Relative Adoption and independent, is there a need to go through all of the formalized steps? If no, what specific steps are unnecessary
No, you don’t need to go through matching the supervised trial custody in specific
In relative and independent adoptions, to whom do you file a petition to adopt?
You file a petition with the family Court, the DSWD only becomes involved later on if the Court orders a case and home report
If birth parents directly surrender their child to the care and custody of another person, are they prevented from reconsidering their decision and asking for the child back?
No. Failure of the custodian to return the child actually raises serious civil and criminal liabilities
Give me the broad facts of People v Marquez, alongisde ruling and doctrien
Facts: Aida Marquez was charged with kidnapping of the baby girl, Justine. Justice’s mother, mother, Merano who had entrusted the child to Marquez
Why? Because Aida has basically borrowed Justine just to buy some clothes and food. Aida demanded payment of 50,000 pesos for Justice back,
Aida then gave over Justice to the spouses Castillo, who had grown to love her. She was sold for 60,000 pesos.
Marquez aledgedly gave over the child in an independent adoption.
Issue: Should Aida be found guilty of kidnapping?
Ruling: Absolutely yes.
The crime of kidnapping a child has two essential requisites
1) The offender is entrusted with the custody of a minor
2) The offender deliberately failed to restore the minor to his parents or gaurdian.
In this case, both were met because Aida had failed to give back the baby girl Justice when asked. Regardless of wether Merano had asked Aida to facilitate an adoption, the fact that Merano wanted the child back means she must be returned.
What is a proceeding in REM?
Basicaly, a judicial proceeding meant to establish adoption —> A “Proceeding in Rem” directly translates to a proceeding “against a thing”, meaning a proceeding meant to do something besides affect a person.
The basis of this is, before, adoption could only be established by a judicial proceeding. —> An agreement between birth parents and an adopter could not give rise to adoption
Same way — Registration of birth certificates don’t count
Can you establish adoption through any other means than a judicial declaration?
No.
Lazatin v. Campos
Facts: Lazatin filed a motion to intervene in proceedings for the estate of both
Dr. Mariano Lazatin as his admitted illegitimate child AND
Margarita de Asis, Dr. Lazatin’s wife, as his adopted child.
This through an affidavit that states he was adopted by both
He however has no decree of adoption, but is attempting to prove this through secondary evidence — their support for him, photographs, and documents.
Issue: Is this secondary evidence enough to establish adoption?
Ruling: No, adoption is a purely judicial act (in the form of a proceeding in rem) to create filliation. You cannot prove it through secondary evidence other than the adoption papers
Thus, even private instruments attesting to the fact of adoption is not enough
HOWEVER, secondary evidence can be admitted if adoption proceeding records were actually lost of destroyed. It must be established that these papers actually existed however.,
So Existence —> Execution —> Loss —> Contents
As such, Renato Lezatin cannot properly intervene in the settletn of the estate of Margarita de Asis.
Republic v. CA and Caranto
Facts:
The spouses Caranto wanted to adopt Midael Mazon, but also sought to have his name changed to Micheal, his actual name
The OSG opposed, based on the following issues
Issue:
1) Does the RTC still have jurisdiction over the adoption order, given an error in the newspaper notice?
2) W/N the correction of Midael’s name can be effected in the same adoption proceeding?
Ruling
1) Yes, The purpose of the newspaper notice is mainly to fulfill due process requirements, rather than being a “entirely necessary” requirement. The name being wrong does not void the process, especially given the fact that the name is still close to the original
2) No, because it’s supposed to be a Rule 108 proceeding. That requires the local civil registrar to actually be made a party in the case, alongside the petition itself only stating it was a petition for adoption of Midael.
Broadly, what are the requirements to adopt for Filipino citizens?
1) Any Filipino citizen
2) Of legal age
3) In possession of full civil capacity and legal rights
4) Of good moral character
5) Has not been convicted of any crime involving moral turpitude (basta stuff done against moral duties)
6) Emotionally and psychologically capable of caring for children
7) Atleast 16 years old than the adoptee and in a position to support and care for his/her children with the means of the family. (Note: No upper limit to when adoption may happen)
What are the exceptions to the 16 year old gap requirement between adopter and adopter?
1) When the adopter is the biological parent of the adoptee
2) The spouse of the adoptee’s parent
3) The sibling of the adoptee
Is there any law prohibiting relatives from adopting other family membes?
No:
In other cases (Matter of adoption of the minor Edwin Villa), a older sister was able to adopter her younger brother.
Matter of adoption of the minor Edwin Villa
Facts:
Spouses Luis and Edipola Santos filed a petition praying that Edwin V. Mendoza, 4 years old, be declared as their son. Edipola, 32 years old, is the older sister of Edwin. Edwin was a sickly child, and his parents entrusted his care to Luis and Edipola, who reared and brought him up for years thereafter. Petitioner-spouses developed a deep love for Edwin. Edwin’s natural parents (aka also Edipola’s parents) voluntarily gave their consent & conformity for the petitioner-spouses to adopt Edwin.
Issue:
W/N an older sibling may adopt a younger sibling. YES.
Held: Court held there are no provisions of the law that prohibits relatives by blood or affinity from adopting one another. Petition for adoption of Edwin is granted.
Not even really an issue with the dual relationship, since one relationship is natural, the other one is via a legal fiction.
In addition, what really matters is the child’s welfare, and that is upheld by doing this adoption. That’s owki.
Are unmarried individuals unable to adopt?
No, they are allowed
However, there is a preference in favor of the married couple adopting if there is some competition on it.
What were the addtl qualifications of foreign adopters in the FC?
Under the FC, they are fully prohibited from adopting except if they are
1) A former Filipino seeking to adopt a relative by consanguinity
2) One seeking to adopt the legitimate child of his or her Filipino spouse, OR
3) One married to a Filipino and seeking to adopt jointly with their spouse
Why? BEcause of dangers of potential kidnapping of children by foreigners and being culture shocked.
Is there currently a restriction on foreigners adopting? If not, what are the requirements in addition to a Filipino.
No. RA 8552 or the Domestic Adoption Act of 1998 liberalized requirements and made it so aliens can adopt, granted they meet some specific requirements
1) They have the same qualifications as a Filipino (which includes DSWD clearances)
2) Their nation has diplomatic relations in the PH
3) That they have been living at least 3 years in the PH before adoption, and maintain such a residence
4) Certification by their diplomatic or consular office or an appropriate govt agency that he/she has legal capacity to adopt
5) His/her government allows the adoptee to enter his/her country as his/her adopted son or daughter (note, because of Therkelsen v Republic, not necessarily a requirement for citizenship, because too much to ask as a political matter)
Why? Meant really to check if the foreigner has good intentions.
What is residence for foreigners vis a vis domestic adoption?
“Residence” refers to a paeron’s actual and legal stay in the Philippines for atleast three continous years prior to the filing of the application for adoption.
“Continous” doesn’t mean uninterrupted, and instead means they stayed here for a three year period, and that they were only temporarily absent for stuff like profession, business or emergency reasons not exceeding 60 days.
What is the requirement for joint adoption by spouses? Under both the FC and RA 8552.
Under the FC, the spouses must adopt jointly.
Under the FC the reason why is because an adopted child is made a legitimate child, it is natural to require joint adoption if only to promote a harmony beteen the spouses.
In Republic v CA and Bobiles,
Facts:
Bobiles wanted to adopt Jason Conda, a 6 year old kid living with the family. PD No. 603, at the time, mandated that either of the spouses or both of them may file a petition for adoption
The family code then took into effect on August 3, 1988. Under this new law, joint adoption became mandatory
Issue:
Should the adoption be dismissed?
Ruling:
No, because the husband had given his consent to it later via an affidavit of consent. This made him a party anyway.
In addition, we take into account the welfare of the child.
What is the dillema with allowing a foster family to adopt a child?
On one hand: They love the child na
On the other hand: it is entirely possible this is used as a trial period to go through as many children as they wish, and choose the child they want
What are the guideliens for a foster family wishing the adopt a child? — Foster Care act
1) Foster child is legally free for adoption, and not yet matched for adoption either domestic or inter-country
2) The foster family is qualified to adopt
3) There is real bonding between the foster family and child that would be traumatic for the child
There’s a good relationship beteen foster child and foster parents
The foster siblings accpt the foster child as their own sibling
THe foster child is accepted by the wider family
The child has interacted well with all of them
A case conferecne is conducted focusing on the psycholgogical and social functioning of the child and to ensure the adoption by the foster parents is the best opiton.
Suzuki v. OSG, G.R. No. 212302 (2020)
Facts:
Karl William Yuta Magno Suzuki a.k.a. Yuta Hayashi was adopted by his step father, Hikaru Hiyashi, based on Japanese law. He is now trying to get the adoption recognized in the Philippines.
RTC dismissed this petition on the basis that the OSG said “Well, foreigners cannot adopt under the FC” this was before the inter-country adoption act.
Issue/s:
W/N The RTC erred in ruling that recognition of foreign adoption is not allowed in the Philippines.
Baseline of this was, it was done during FC’s promulgation which allows for
Art. 184, Family Code
The following persons may not adopt:
The guardian with respect to the ward prior to the approval of the final accounts rendered upon the termination of their guardianship relation;
Any person who has been convicted of a crime involving moral turpitude;
An alien, except:
A former Filipino citizen who seeks to adopt a relative by consanguinity;
One who seeks to adopt the legitimate child of his or her Filipino spouse; or
One who is married to a Filipino citizen and seeks to adopt jointly with his or her spouse a relative by consanguinity of the latter.
Held:
Yes. Foreign adoption can be recognized in the Philippines as long that it is judicially proven in a court proceeding. The FC just allows it period and the RTC
erred.
In Re: Petition for Adoption of Michelle Lim, G.R. No. 168992-93 (2009)
Facts:
Monina Lim married Primo Lim, and were then entrusted with the care of two children. They raised them with a registration of birth averring them as their parents.
Eventually, Primo Lim died and Monina married an American named Olario. She now wishes to adopt the children, including Olario who executed a affidavit of consent
Issue:
Can Monina, who remarried, singly adopt?
Ruling:
No
1) She should’ve adopted with Olario during the time he was alive.
2) Olario’s affidavit of consent is insufficient because he failed to show the requirement of adoption for a foreigner (ex., proving his country has diplomatic relations with the PH). She NEEDS to adopt with him in specific
Even if he’s filed a petition for dissolution of marriage, that doesn’t matter because the marriage still subsists, which still requires both jointly adopt.
Who may, as a general rule, be adopted?
FC 183 — Only minors can be adopted, with some exceptions in RA 8552
RA 8552 — Who may be adopted?
1) Any person below 18 years old who has been declared judicially available for adoption (to imitate an old roman law requiring adoption to match with nature)
2) The legitimate son/daughter of one spouse by the other spouse
(3) An illegitimate son/daughter by a qualified adopter to improve his/her status to that of legitimacy;
(4) A person of legal age if, prior to the adoption, said person has been consistently considered and treated by the adopter(s) as his/her own child since minority;
(5) A child whose adoption has been previously rescinded; or
(f) A child whose biological or adoptive parent(s) has died: Provided, That no proceedings shall be initiated within six (6) months from the time of death of said parent(s). —> The point was to allow them time to grieve
Do you still need to have the child go through a court process to be declared open for adoption?
No — RA 9532 doesn’t require this, and the DSWD can do it themselves
Exceptions to a child need to be declared legally up for adoption?
1) Adoption of an illegitimate child by either of his/her biological parents
2) Adoption of a child by his/her step-parent
3) Adoption of a child by a relative within the 4th degree of consanguinity or affinity
NOTE in RA8552 there are added exceptions/nuances
c: (b) The legitimate son/daughter of one spouse by the other spouse;
(c) An illegitimate son/daughter by a qualified adopter to improve his/her status to that of legitimacy;
Makes it so “son” and “daughter” refers to any child even if above age of a majority
When can a person be adopted above the age of majority
RA8552 there are added exceptions/nuances
c: (b) The legitimate son/daughter of one spouse by the other spouse;
(c) An illegitimate son/daughter by a qualified adopter to improve his/her status to that of legitimacy;
AND when
"“A person has been consistently considered and treated by the adopter as his/her own child aince minority” — so needs a pre-existing family relationship
From whom is Consent necessary to be adopted?
(a) The adoptee, if ten (10) years of age or over;
(b) The biological parent(s) of the child, if known, or the legal guardian, or the proper government instrumentality which has legal custody of the child;
(c) The legitimate and adopted sons/daughters, ten (10) years of age or over, of the adopter(s) and adoptee, if any;
(d) The illegitimate sons/daughters, ten (10) years of age or over, of the adopter if living with said adopter and the latter's spouse, if any; and
(e) The spouse, if any, of the person adopting or to be adopted.
First two — adoptee, second and third concerning children, last is the spouse
Note: VIs a vis the requirement of a biological parent of the child to consent, how does this change with an illegitimate child?
If a child is actually illegitimate, then we only need the mother’s consent. The Family Code sets out — only they exercise parental authority over this child (Art 176)
BUT this is in conflict with the IRR of RA 8552, which defines a “biological parent” as the child’s mother and father by nature, or the mother alone if the child is an unacknowledged illegitimate child.
—> If the child is illegitimate, but acknowledged (a natural child) then we’d need his consent.
In determining the conflict between the two, based purely on statutory construction, which law (IRR of RA 8552) or (FC 176) wins out?
IRR of RA 8552 because it is both more specific and more recent.
BUT Ma’am disagrees with it, because this is a mere implementig rule that requires thec onsent of the father of an acknowledged child.
—> In addition, the simple act of acknowleding a child really shouldn’t extend a father’s right over his illegitimate children, unless there’s a substantial relationship.
(b) The biological parent(s) of the child, if known, or the legal guardian, or the proper government instrumentality which has legal custody of the child;
How does the law rekon this with artificial insemination? Particularly in scenarios where a child was born using another person’s sperm but the father doesn’t consent to the child being adopted by another person.
In the US case of In re Adoption of Anonymous, 345 N.Y.S. 2d 430 (1973), it was decided that it basically is the case that the father of the child whose sperm was not used is still the dad — still needed consent from him
Why? Because the child is his legitimate son parin bruh.
When is parental consent not required for an adoption?
In cases of abandonment
NOTE this is specifically conduct of the parent which evinces a settled purpose to forego all parental duties and relinquish all parental claims to the child — Physical abandonment not enough without financial and moral desertion
Case of Cang v CA?
Doctrine: A father who had migrated to the US and gotten a divorce decree hadn’t “abandoned” his child because he still clearly loved his child and provided support
Facts;
Herbert Cang and Clavano legally seperated. Cang moved to the US and became a citizen, then divorcing Clavano
Cang still supported the children and deposited money to them. Anna Marrie basically allowed their children to be adopted, but Cang opposed
Issue:
Do we need Cang’s consent, since he abandoned the children?
Ruling?:
No, clearly he hadn’t abandoned the chilren since he still supported them. Abandon means complete forsaking
Landingin v Republic?
Doctrine: Merely permitting a child to remain undisturbed in the care of another is not abandonment contemplated under law.
Facts:
Langinign is a US citizen who filed to adopt three kids: Elaine, Elma, and Eugene
The children were natural children of Manuel Ramos, Landingin’s brother, and Amelia Ramos. Eventually, Manuel died and Amelia went to Italy, and abandoned her children
Landingin thus wishes to adopt, he children consent and so does the DSWD
However, the mother has not given written consent to allow the adoption
Issue:
Has the mother abandoned her children, such that we don’t need her consent?
Ruling:
No
Amelia still sends financial support (10,000 pesos a month)
Elaine, the eldest, still consults Amelia
Amelia didn’t abandon her children, she was just abroad for financial reasons.