1/73
Looks like no tags are added yet.
public policy behind tort law
compensation
deterrence
policy questions
core policy principle
where two people suffer, the loss should fall on the one who caused it- not on the person without the ability to avoid it
civil litigation process
complaint
respond
discovery
summary judgement
trial
fault based liability
intentional torts
negligence
requires showing of wrongdoing
most of torts i and ii
strict liability
no fault required
limited categories only
abnormally dangerous activities
certain animals
battery
physical act
directly or indirectly causes (through object or instrumentality)
harmful or offensive contact (offensive- offends a person’s sense of personal dignity)
with the plaintiffs person (or closely connected)
intent (purpose or substantial certainty- knew contact was substantially certain to result, does not need to intend the specific harm)
eggshell plaintiff rule
defendants take the plaintiff as they find them
even if the extent of the injury was unforeseeable, the defendant is liable for the full extent of harm’
plaintiff had pre existing medical or psych issues
defendant intended to cause a harmful or offensive contact
resulting harm was greater than anyone anticipated
single intent state
With purpose or substantial certainty
duel intent state
with purpose/certainty and intent contact is harmful/offensive
minors in battery
Minors can form intent and be held liable for intentional torts especially in single intent states
insanity
Civil intent is not criminal intent, particularly in single intent
Look out for eggshell plaintiffs liable for extent of injury in intentional torts
No injury required in intentional torts
Usually sufficient if intended contact
assault elements
An act by the defendant
With intent
Intent (purpose or substantial certainty) to cause apprehension of imminent contact OR
Intent (purpose or substantial certainty) to cause harmful or offensive contact (to cause battery)
Contact is imminent
Almost at once
Contact would be harmful or offensive
Same meaning as in battery
The other person is actually put in imminent apprehension
Plaintiff must actually perceive the threat, unseen threats do not create apprehension
special rules for assault
No injury required- offensive contact or fear of offensive contact satisfies for intentional
Harm need not be foreseeable by defendant
Defendant is liable even for eggshell plaintiffs
Extended liability is greater injury or greater fear or distress
Defendant acts with intent
spectrum of conduct
unintentional
negligence
gross negligence
recklessness
intentional
false imprisonment
Act (words or conduct)
Intending
To confine
By barriers, threat, implied threat, duress, asserted legal authority
Within boundaries fixed by Defendant
Victim is conscious of -or harmed by- the confinement
Without consent
confinement
Sufficient to overcome the plaintiffs will to leave
Physical barriers
Physical force that overcomes plaintiffs will
Threats of force
Duress
Asserted legal authority
Actions that overcome plaintiff’s will
Not enough
Economic pressure of fear of losing job alone is generally not enough
If p can escape with slight inconvenience, not enough
Broad geographic scope size of area
Transferred intent
transferred intent
When defendant intends to harm, causes apprehension of har, or confine person A but Person B is harmed, apprehensive of harm, or confined
Can also transfer between torts
Intent transferred between people
Intent transferred between torts
Applies to intentional torts except intentional inflection of emotional distress
consent
Defense by defendant
Traditionally raised by the defendant as a defense
Element for the plaintiff when
From 3d restatement
Confined without consent
Intentional infliction of emotional distress
Extreme and outrageous conduct
Beyond all possible bounds of decency. Factors: position of authority, knowledge of vulnerability, sustained conduct
Not enough: insults, threats, annoyance, indignities, se*ual harassment alone, malice alone
Intentionally or recklessly
Intent- purpose to cause severe emotional distress OR knowledge it is substantially certain to result
Recklessness: conscious disregard of a substantial risk - unique to IIED, not available for battery, assault, or false imprisonment
Causes severe emotional distress
No reasonable person should be expected to endure
Expert testimony or medical bills typically required- plaintiff’s own testimony alone is usually not enough (kazatsky)
Recklessness satisfies the intent element, malice is NOT required
IIED proving third element
Severe emotional distress requires more than plaintiff’s testimony- medical evidence or expert testimony typically needed (kazatsky)
Physical manifestation
If not be sure to have medical evidence
Objective examination of a subjective element:
Subjective- did the plaintiff actually have severe emotional distress
Objective distress so severe that no person should be expected to endure
actual consent
Plaintiff explicitly agrees
Written or verbal consent
Scope matter consent to X is not consent to Y
Substantially similar conduct only
Apparent consent elements
Reasonable person would understand plaintiff’s conduct as consent
Consider scope of consent
Objective standard
Even a reasonable mistake is sufficient
Obrien v. cunard
consent is invalid when
Lack of capacity to consent
Must be capable of appreciating nature and likely consequences of the act
Minors- rules vary by jurisdiction
Mental incapacity- inability to understand the nature of the act
Second restatement- if state criminal law criminalizes conduct for a class of people, that class may also lack capacity to consent in tort law
Mistake as to an essential element of consent
As to an essential element of the consent given
The mistake is known or induced by the actor
Consent under duress
Threat of force or other coercion that overcomes plaintiffs free will
self defense
Defendant reasonably believed
Harmful or offensive contact is imminent
Such harm cannot be avoided
No duty to retreat (majority): may stand ground when defendant reasonably believes threat of harmful contact
Duty to retreat (minority): must retreat safely if possible
Actor uses reasonable force
shopkeeper’s privilege
Actor is a merchant
Actor reasonably believes the other has either taken merchandise or has failed to pay
Honest belief based on reasonable grounds and totality of the circumstances
Actor uses force in the immediate vicinity, in a reasonable manner, and only for as long as necessary
The actor does not use deadly force
conversion the test
1. Intentional exercise of dominion or control over a chattel
intent= intent to exercise control
2. That so seriously interferes with anothers right to control it
Factors: extent and duration of control, amount of harm to chattel, inconvenience caused
Pearson: brief overnight removal and return = not serious enough. Contrast: permanent taking, destruction, or sale= conversion
3. That the actor may justly be required to pay the full value of the chattel
interference with personal propert conversion
Serious substantial interference
Remedy- full value of chattel
Theft, destruction, permanent, deprivation
Long duration, significant harm
interference with personal property trespass to chattels
Lesser interference with property rights
Remedy: actual harm of loss of use
Temporary deprivation, damage
Diminishes value or deprives owner for a period of time
tresspass to land
Intentional act by the defendant
Entry onto -or remaining on- plaintiff’s land
Enter, or intentionally cause something or someone to enter, plaintiffs land
Or remainson, or fails to remove an object from, plaintiff’s land
defense of property
A person may use force to protect possession or prevent trespass
That they reasonably believe to be necessary
reasonable= proportional to the threat- non lethal force only (katko)
Never: spring guns, deadly traps, or force likely to cause death or serious bodily injury
public necessity
Actual or apparent necessity
To protect the public at large
Full privilege- no liability for damage caused
Destroying building to stop a spreading fire
private necessity
To protect actors own property or person
Partial privilege- not liable for intentional trespass itself
But still liable for actual damages caused (vincent)
Privilege applies even if other options were available (ploof)
The cost falls on the person who benefited
negligence
duty
Question of law (judge)
Owe reasonable care under the circumstances- the care required varies with the degree of danger (stewart v motts)
Breach
Did the defendant fail to take reasonable steps to guard against foreseeable harm
Hand formula to determine whether ste[s are reasonable B<PxL then negligence in not taking the precaution
Negligence per se: violation of a statute/ordinance that (1) sets a precise standard (2) protects plaintiffs class, and (3) prevents plaintiffs type of harm=breach as a matter of law (winter)
Unreasonable care under the circumstances and failure to observe industry custom
Damages
plaintiff suffered actual harm
Actual causation
breach actually caused harm
Proximate causation
harm was within the scope of the risk
general duty rule
Did the defendant owe a duty to the plaintiff?
If yes- what is the standard of care owed?
Question of law decided by the judge not the jury
The existence of duty turns on foreseeability:
Was the plaintiff a foreseeable victim of defendants conduct
Limits on duty
Courts use duty to control liability- duty can be limited or negated as a matter of policy
No general duty to rescue a stranger in peril
Special relationships can give rise to additional duties
breach
Conduct that falls below the standard established by law for the protection of others against unreasonable risk of harm
is a question of fact decided by the jury
reasonable person standard
Objective standard- not what this defendant actually thought or felt
Not a standard of perfection- the reasonable person makes mistakes
Characteristics the reasonable person possesses
Average intelligence and knowledge
Same physical characteristics as the defendant
Same knowledge of the circumstances as defendant had or should have had
foreseeability
Reasonable person standard
Reasonably foreseeable danger and conduct that is unreasonable in proportion to that danger
Or use hand formula
Probability (foreseeability of risk x extent of loss/injury if it does not happen
negligence per se
Articulate a specific, precise standard of conduct- not a vague standard
Be designed to protect a class of persons of which plaintiff is a member
Be designed to prevent the kind of harm plaintiff suffered
Even if all three are met- plaintiff still must prove causation and damages separately
excuses to negligence per se
Even when a defendant violates a statute, the violation may be excused
Impossibility- compliance was not reasonably practicable
Literal impossibility not requires- reasonably prctible is the standard
Beyond defendangs control- something outside defendants control places them in a position contrary to the statute
Sudden emergency not of defendants own making- by reason of the emergency, defendant fails to obey to statute
Also a defense to general negligence
Statute provides an express excuse or exception
sudden emergency doctrine
Emergency was sudden and unexpected
Emergency was not created by defendants own negligence
If defendants prior negligence caused or contributed to the emergency, the doctrine does not apply
Defendant used their best judgement or there was insufficient time for reaction and defendant did not use perfect judgement
industry custom
Practice must be fairly well defined within the particular field- need not be universally observed (cruz)
What is the effect of failing to comply with industry custom?
Strong- but not conclusive- evidence of negligence
What is the effect of complying with industry custom
Does not establish reasonable care tj hooper
adult activity
Adult standard of care applies
Hunting, driving, etc
age appropriate activity
Child standard of care applies
Standard- consider the child
Age
Judgment
Experience
rule of 7s
Under 7- incapable of negligence
7-14- rebuttable presumption of incapacity
Over 14- presumption of negligence
special characteristics of an actor
Special skills or knowledge
Superior mental or physical abilities
Physical impairments
characteristics not taken into account
Voluntary intoxication
Mental illness or impairment
byrne v wal mart
plaintiff must present either some evidence or rely on res ipsa
plaintiff must show the condition existed long enough that defendant knew or should have known about it
res ipsa loquitur
allows a jury to infer negligence from the circumstances of the accident itself- without direct or sufficient circumstantial evidence
res ipsa loquitur creates
rebuttable presumption of negligence arises
the jury may infer negligence
pros for d- presumtion creates opportunity for d to have the last word but creates a burden for d to make his case
pros for p- going straight to the jury as inference is good, but as unrebutted presumption is better
re ipsa loquitur requirements
the accident is one that does not ordinarily occur in the absence of someone’s negliegence
the agency or instrumentality was within the exclusive control of the defendant
final element differs (focus on 1 and 2)
injury was not due to any voluntary action or contribution by p
p lack of evidence is through no fault of p
cause of accident not available or evidence of cause is likely only available to d
deciutiis v six flags
res ipsa is a doctrine of necessity, not convenience
1. RI may be used when direct evidence of the cause is not available or is available soley to the defendant
RI asks jurors to apply common sense and common understanding to decide whether an event was likely to occur absent negligence
6 flafs installed, operated and maintained ride, but occupants of other rafts could deflate a raft or grab the walls, thereby slowing or stopping it
eversole v woods
the does not ordinarily occur element
common life experience suggests it would be extraordinary for fuel lines to leak and cause a major fire in a three year old vehicle with no history of mechanical problems without an intervening act of manipulation
niman v plaza house
control: 2 possible interpretations
views the instrumentality as the entire heating system, landlord has control over the whole system, even if tenants control one part
or focus is on the right to control- landlord has the right and responsibility to repair or alter any part of the system, including fitting in the tenant’s apartment
spectrum of evidence
strict liability
negligence per se
industry custom
direct evidence breach
circumstantial evidence
res ipsa loquitur
no evidence of breach
negligence
duty- defendant owed plaintiff standard of care
breach- negligence i) unreasonable care under circumstances ii) failure to observe industry custom iii) res ipsa loquitur- thing speaks for itself
damages- plaintiff suffered actual harm
actual causation- breach actually caused harm
proximate causation- harm was within the scope of risk
professional negligence rule
standard of care: the degree of care and skill expected of a reasonably competent practitioner in the same class, acting in the same or similar circumstances
sued in pro capacity
negligence arises out of specialized pro nature arising in pro relationship
negligence substantially related to the pro conduct and involved exercise of pro judgment
gambill v stroud
similar locality standard
the skill possessed and used by members of his profession in good standing, engaged in the same type of practice in the locality in which he practices, or a similar locality
national standard rejected because small towns cannot leave a demanding practice to attend seminar and regional medical meetings do not have access to large modern med
sheely v memorial hospital
national standard
a physician is under a duty to use the degree of care and skill that is expected of a reasonably competent practitioner in the same class to which he or she belongs, acting under the same or similar circumstances
same locality rule
physician held to standard of practitioners in same or similar locality
prevents small town doctors from being judged by big city standards
similarity determined by med facilities, practices, and advantages, not population
expert must be familiar with practice in a similar locality
national standard
reasonably competent practitioner in the same class, acting under the same or similar circumstances
may establish higher standard
allows expert witnesses from outside the community
avoids setting lower standard of care in small towns or rural areas
specialist rule
held to the national standard of care even in same locality jurisdictions
general practitioners are national or same
relates to lawyers pro responsibility limitations on advertising yourself as an expert or specialist
expert witness
licensure
expertise
a. board certified by a national or international association that administers written and oral exams in the relevant area of practice or specialty or
b. actual professional knowledge and experience from actively practicing or teaching the specialty for at least 3 of the last 5 years immediately preceding the opinion
c. any combo or active practice and teaching meeting of the 3 of 5 years req
med mal
doing that which the reasonably prudent health care provider or health care institution would not do or not doing that which the reasonably prudent health care provider or health care institution would do in the same or similar circumstances
med mal affidavit requirement
explanation of the expert’s qualifications according to the statutory requirements
at least one negligent act and the factual basis for each claim, based on the available evidence at the time of filing
chiero v chicago
effect of conformance with custom
conformance with custom is indicative of due care, it is now however conclusive
it may be overcome by contrary expert testimony that the prevailing custom itself constitutes negligence
hood v phillips
the ultimate test is reasonableness, not vairence/deviance from common custom
any variance approach rejected- one commonly accepted customary practice does not mean a departure is breach
respectable minority instruction rejected: its not a poll of the medical profession
custom in pro negligence
general rule from tj hooper
indicative of due care- but not conclusive
not always conclusive evidence of due care- a whole industry may have lagged
the test is still reasonableness- not whether the departure was supported by a respectable minority
res ipsa in med mal
a healthy body part not at risk in the operation was injured- this does not ordinarily occur absent someone’s negligence
exclusive control of instrumentality
rebuttable presumption
burden shifts to each defendant to explain their conduct and show their negligence did not cause the injury- helps smoke out the actual wrongdoer
patient did not consent- battery
doctor performs an entirely different operation than the one consented to
contract itself was unauthorized- goes beyond scope of consent entirely
no consent to this contract whatsoever
intentional harmful or offensive contact without consent
patient did not consent informed consent
doctor performs the consented procedure but failts to disclose material risks or alternatives
patient consented to contact but the consent was uniformed
negligence in the disclosure process, not an unconsented battery
matthies- failure to disclose med reasonable alternatives, including noninvasive option
matties v mastromonaco
scope of informed consent: physicans have a duty to evaluate the relevant info and disclose all courses of treatment that are medically reasonable under the circumstances
protected interest: patient autonomy- the patient has the right to make decisions about medical procedures impacting her body, including the right to choose a riskier option
material risks
presented in a reasonable manner to allow patient to make intelligent choice
objective standard- avoids the risk that the plaintiff lies about what she would have done with hindsight
causation standard
matthies and canterbury v spence
a patient can recover when
the risk of harm actually materialized: the undisclosed risk is what actually happened to the patient and
a reasonable person in the patient’s position would not have proceeded with the treatment had they known of the risk or alternative