1/46
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What was the aim of the Strange Situation?
To assess the quality of attachments between an infant and their caregiver
How is it a controlled observation?
It was conducted in a laboratory setting
The study being done in a laboratory setting makes it a …
Controlled observation
How was behaviour observed?
Through a two-way mirror
What did observing the child’s behaviour through a two-way mirror allow?
Researchers to record responses without interfering the child’s behaviour
Why was the floor divided in squares?
To allow researchers to track how far infants moved away from their caregivers and measure exploration behaviour
Why were cameras used?
To record the infant’s behaviour, review footage, and improve the accuracy of their observations
How many episodes were in the procedure?
8
How long did episodes 2-8 last
3 minutes
How long did episode 1 last?
Around 1 minutes
What was stage 1?
Caregiver and the infant enter the unfamiliar playroom
What was stage 2 and what did this measure?
Caregiver encourages the infant to explore the room and play with the toys, measuring secure base behaviour
What was stage 3 and what did this measure?
A stranger enters the room, talks to the caregiver and then approaches and attempts to interact with the infant, measuring stranger anxiety
What was stage 4 and what did this measure?
Caregiver leaves the room, leaving the infant alone with the stranger, measuring separation anxiety
What was stage 5 and what did this measure?
Caregiver return, greets and comforts the infant while the stranger leaves. Caregiver encourages the infant to return to playing, measuring reunion behaviour
What was stage 6 and what does this measure?
The caregiver leaves again but the infant is left completely alone, measuring separation response
What was stage 7 and what does this measure?
The stranger returns and attempts to comfort the infant, measuring response to stranger
What is stage. And what does this measure?
Caregiver return again and the infant response is observed, measuring reunion behaviour
From the procedure, what were the 3 attachments identified?
Secure attachment
Insecure-resistant attachment
Insecure-avoidant attachment
What type was each attachment type labelled as?
Secure: Type B
Insecure-resistant: Type C
Insecure-avoidant: Type A
Which attachment type was the most common, what’s the percentage?
Secure, 65%
What percentage of infants were securely attached?
65%
What did securely attached infants show?
Some separation anxiety when the caregiver leaves
Show stranger anxiety towards strangers
Easily comforted when the caregiver returns
Use the caregiver as a secure base when the caregiver returns
Able to play independently while the caregiver is present
Securely attached infants have confidence that their caregiver will provide …
Comfort and support when needed
What did insecure-resistant infants show?
High levels of separation anxiety when the caregiver leaves
Highly distressed and attempt to follow the caregiver when they leave
Highly levels of stranger anxiety
Seek comfort during reunion but also resist comfort
Less likely to explore their environment
What was the least common attachment type and what was the percentage?
Insecure-resistant with 15%
What percentage of infants were insecure-resistant?
15%
Insecure-resistant infants are … whether the caregiver will provide … comfort.
Uncertain, consistent
What was the type given to secure infants?
Type B
What was the type given to insecure-resistant infants?
Type C
What was the type given to insecure-avoidant infants?
Type A
What did insecure-avoidant infants show?
Little/no separation anxiety
Little/no stranger anxiety
Avoid/ignore the caregiver during reunion
Show anger/rejection towards the caregiver
Explore the room independently regardless of who is present
How many infants were insecure-avoidant?
20%
What is a strength of the procedure (PEC)
P: Highly controlled methodology
E: The floor was divided into squares to track how far the infant moved when exploring/distressed. Cameras and two-way mirror allowed researchers to observe and record behaviour without interfering with infant, increasing inter-observer reliability. Behaviours such as proximity seeking, exploring and safe base could be measured objectively.
C: The design is based on systematic observations rather than subjective judgements, increasing validity of the findings
Name the 3 weaknesses of the procedure
Culturally biased
Only measures attachment to one caregiver
Ethical concerns
Give a PEC of the procedure being culturally biased
P: Culturally biased
E: The procedure was developed in the USA, reflecting western ideas of attachment such as independence and separations from the caregiver. Van IJzendoorn and Kroonberg found that attachment types varied between cultures, with more insecure-resistant infants in collectivist cultures. This suggests “Secure” or “Insecure” may be influenced by cultural practices rather attachment quality.
C: This reduced the validity
Give a PEC of the procedure only measuring attachment to a single caregiver
P: Only measures an infant’s attachment to a single caregiver
E: Usually the relationship with the mother is assessed. However, in the modern world family structures are more diverse and an infant may have a different primary caregiver than their mother. Lamb found that infants form strong attachments to the father as well as the mother
C: Incomplete picture of attachment relationships, not fully reflecting the complexity of attachment in modern families
Give a PEC of the procedure having ethical concerns
P: Ethical concerns due to distressed infants
E: Repeated separation from the caregiver and interactions with a stranger, causing distress. 20% of infants cried intensely during separation, showing psychological harm to participants who cannot consent
C: Limits acceptability due to deliberate distress
What is insecure-avoidant attachment?
A child shows little distress when separated from the caregiver and avoids or ignores them during reunion
What is insecure-resistant attachment?
A child shows high distress when separated from their caregiver but both seeks and resists comfort during reunion
What is reunion behaviour?
The way a child responds when the caregiver returns after a separation
What is a safe base?
An attachment figure who provides a child with security from which they can explore their environment
What is a secure attachment?
A child feels safe and confident that their caregiver will provide comfort and support when needed
What is separation?
The temporary removal of a child from their attachment figure
What is separation anxiety?
Distress shown by a child when separated from their attachment figure
What is stranger anxiety?
Distress or fear shown by a child when approached by a stranger
True or false: The strange situation was a standardised procedure.
True