1/30
Looks like no tags are added yet.
entrants classification
first mover: first in introducing a new product or service
early follower: those entering early but not first
late entrants: the rest
first mover advantages
brand loyalty & tech leadership
preemption of scarce assets
exploiting buyers’ switching costs
reaping increasing returns advantage
first mover disadvantages
incumbent intertia
R&D expenses
undeveloped supply & distribution channels
immature enabling techs
uncertainty of customer requirements
factors influencing optimal timing of entry
is there an uncertainty about customer preferences? wait and see
does the innovation provide superiority over previous techs? early
does the innovation require enabling techs, & are these sufficiently mature? early
do complementary goods influence the value of the innovation? are these sufficiently available? early
is there a high threat of competitive entry? early
is the industry likely to experience increasing returns? early
can the firm withstand early losses? early
does the firm have resources to accelerate market acceptance? early
is the firm’s reputation likely to reduce the uncertainty of customers, suppliers, & distributors? early
is the timing of entry a matter for choice for the firm?
sstrong assumption: the firm can produce the tech at any point in the time horizon
tactics to control timing of entry
operations capabilities: fast-cycle or parallel development process
collab capabilities: strategic alliances
organisation capabilities: cross-functional development teams
strategic intent
ambitious long-term goal that builds on & stretches firm’s core competencies & draws from all levels of the org
innovation mgmt fits within the strategic intent of the firm
how firms require analysis of current position
porter’s 5 forces
stakeholder analysis
value chain strengths & weaknesses
could those strengths become a source of sustainable CA
conditions to become source of SCA
resources: rare, valuable, durable, inimitable
tactic resources: intangible & can’t be readily codified
social complex resources: emerge through interaction of multiple individuals
casually ambiguous resources: mechanism between resource & outcome is poorly understood
path-dependent resource: developed over time in response to R&D investment (eg first-mover advantage)
identifying core competencies, core rigidities, & dynamic capabilities
core competence: unique combo of skills, knowledge, & resources that give a company CA
core rigidities: existing core competencies that become weaknesses because a company relies on them too much & struggles to adapt to change
dynamic capabilities: company's ability to adapt, develop, & reconfigure its resources & competencies to respond to changing markets
features of strong core competencies & dynamic capabilities
relevance: create unique differentiation & signif customer value
extent: can be applied across many existing & new businesses
inimitability: hard to copy
core: not too many core competencies
what does strategic intent require?
looking 10-20 years ahead of current market conditions
developing & introducing products beyond market requirements
molding market expectations for the future
identifying resources, capabilities, competencies, & tech gaps
characteristics of innovation projects
expensive
time consuming
risky
how to choose innovation projects
capital rationing: allocation of finite resources over diff possible uses
fixed amount over a year
rank ordering of projects
R&D intensity: % of previous years sales dedicated to R&D
how to rank projects
quantitative: DCF & real options
qualitative: screening, R&D portfolio
quantitative methods of choosing innovation projects
DCF, NPV, & IRR
real options: application of stock options valuation methods to investments in non-financial assets
assumptions: firms invest in their own learning & new capabilities
development projects create valuable future opportunities otherwise unavailable
even unsuccessful projects increase absorptive capacity
real options - quantitative methods
stock option: the right to acquire in t, a stock of a firm S0, at price E
in t, the value of the stock will be St, but in 0 we don’t know St, so there is a volatility (level of uncertainty) about the value of St
the cost of this financial instrument is P
its value in t is Ct = St-E-P = net value of the investments (profits)
P = cost of R&D program
E = cost of future investment required to capitalise the R&D program
St = returns to the R&D investment

further considerations of real options
dynamic model (compared with NPV)
allows adaptability to changes & unexpected situations
investment, hold, or abandonment options can be considered
sometimes, projects with NPV = are worthy of investment because they allow future expansions
higher volatility → higher option value, as their gains are unlimited & losses limited
caveats
real assets may not follow financial assets assumptions
firm may need to undertake the full R&D investment to understand its future value
entrepreneurs & small firms are at a disadvantage
value of a stock is independent of the call holder’s behaviour but value of the R&D investment is not independent of firm
disadvantages of quantitative methods
minimise ambiguity → deceptive
can’t compute the size of an inexistent market
DCF discriminates against risky projects
potensh to acquire future capabilities & learning is disregarded
screening questions: qualitative methods
systematic discussion of potensh costs & benefits of a project w respect to some categories
categories: role of customer or firm’s capabilities, & project’s timing & cost
role of customer in screening questions
market: most likely customers? market size? other markets?
use: how will customers use product? likely subs? new benefits?
compatibility & ease of use: new learning for customer? additional costs?
distribution & pricing: where to buy? installation? willingness to pay?
role of capabilities in screening questions
existing caps: leverage of core competences? competence destroying? manufacturing caps?
competitors’ caps: better caps? would they develop the tech? collabs?
future caps: does it help building future caps? could it be a platform project?
project timing & cost for screening questions
timing: project duration? 1st mover? desirable to be FM? user uncertainty, enabling techs, distribution channels?
cost: cost & cost variability? learning curve? will the firm engage in other costs: adoption, complements development, installation?
R&D portfolio (qualitative method)
main premise: resources are scarce & projects compete for them
mapping of a firm’s development projects in terms of the changes to the product & process
allows integrating other dimensions: cost, profitability, capabilities, core competences, patents
5 categories of a project
identified in R&D portfolio depending on resources needed
R&D advanced development projects → basic projects
breakthrough projects → commercial development projects
platform projects → commercial development projects
derivative projects → commercial development projects
collaborative projects → commercial or basic R&D projects
R&D advanced development projects
new know-how & know-why
necessary to build new capabilities
will be transformed into commercial applications in the future
breakthrough projects
significant changes to products & processes
core products & process defining new markets
platform project
significant changes but not untried techs
improvements across several dimensions
speed, functionality, size, weight, etc
derivative projects
cost-reduced versions of existing products, to add-ons or enhancements for an existing production process
incremental product and/or process changes
collaborative projects
outside the boundaries of the development map
embedded in the day-to-day operations