1/243
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Continuity versus discontinuity debate
A major debate in developmental psychology about whether human development occurs gradually and incrementally or through distinct stages
Continuous development definition
The view that human development occurs through relatively gradual stable and incremental changes over time
Discontinuous development definition
The view that human development occurs through distinct stages that are uniquely different from one another
Stage theory of development
A theory proposing that human development progresses through distinct stages separated by periods of substantial change
Development within continuous theories
Development occurs gradually with relatively small changes accumulating over time
Development within discontinuous theories
Development involves periods of relative stability within stages followed by periods of radical change between stages
Metaphor for continuous development
Continuous development can be compared to climbing a slope because progress occurs gradually and smoothly
Metaphor for discontinuous development
Discontinuous development can be compared to climbing a set of stairs because progress occurs through distinct steps
Difference between the slope and staircase metaphors
The slope represents gradual continuous change whereas the staircase represents distinct developmental stages separated by more substantial changes
First assumption of stage theories
Human development follows a fixed sequence of stages that individuals cannot skip
Fixed sequence of stages
Individuals must progress from one developmental stage to the next in a predetermined order
Second assumption of stage theories
All people pass through the same stages in the same sequence at approximately the same time
Universal sequence of development
The idea that all individuals follow a common order of developmental stages
Third assumption of stage theories
Developmental stages are influenced by biological maturation of the brain
Biological maturation in stage theories
Individuals cannot progress to the next developmental stage until their brains have matured sufficiently and the necessary biological structures have formed
Relationship between brain maturation and developmental stages
Progression to a new stage depends partly on the maturation of biological structures required for that stage
First continuous development rebuttal
Developmental stages are not clearly separated because the boundaries between them are blurred
Continuous perspective on stage boundaries
Developmental changes may overlap and do not necessarily occur at clearly identifiable points
Second continuous development rebuttal
There are substantial individual differences in when and how people mature and these differences may be more important than common developmental patterns
Individual differences in maturation
People develop at different rates and may reach developmental abilities at different times
Why individual differences challenge stage theories
Large variations in developmental timing make it difficult to argue that everyone progresses through the same stages at approximately the same time
Third continuous development rebuttal
Environmental influences also shape development and may be more important than genetic maturation
Environmental influence on development
Experiences and environmental conditions contribute to how individuals develop rather than development being determined only by biological maturation
How environmental influences challenge stage theories
Development may be shaped by different experiences and circumstances rather than following a universal sequence determined mainly by brain maturation
Main disagreement about developmental timing
Stage theorists emphasize common sequences and approximate timing while continuous development theorists emphasize individual differences and gradual change
Main disagreement about developmental structure
Discontinuous theorists propose distinct stages while continuous theorists argue that developmental boundaries are blurred
Main disagreement about influences on development
Stage theorists emphasize biological maturation while continuous development theorists emphasize the importance of environmental influences
Continuity and discontinuity as opposing perspectives
The perspectives differ in how they explain the pace structure and influences of human development
Why the continuity versus discontinuity debate may be a false dichotomy
Both gradual development and distinct periods of change may occur simultaneously and interact with one another
False dichotomy in developmental psychology
Treating continuity and discontinuity as mutually exclusive explanations when both may contribute to human development
Interaction between continuous and discontinuous development
Human development may involve gradual incremental changes as well as periods of more substantial developmental transformation
Why the truth may lie between the two perspectives
Real developmental processes are complex and may include common patterns individual differences biological maturation and environmental influences together
Research focused only on universal developmental stages
Some studies investigate common stages shared across individuals without sufficiently considering individual differences
Limitation of research focused only on universal stages
Ignoring individual differences may produce an incomplete understanding of how development occurs
Research focused only on environmental influences and individual differences
Some studies investigate environmental effects and individual variation without measuring genetic predispositions or evidence of universal developmental stages
Limitation of research focused only on environmental influences
Ignoring genetic predispositions and possible common developmental patterns may produce an incomplete explanation of development
Confirmation bias in developmental psychology research
Researchers may design studies in ways that support their existing theoretical beliefs and overlook evidence that challenges them
How theoretical orientation influences research
A researchers theoretical perspective influences how a study is designed and what conclusions can be drawn from its findings
How research design contributes to confirmation bias
When a study is designed to test only one theoretical perspective it may produce evidence that appears to support that perspective while failing to investigate alternatives
Why studying only one perspective can produce incomplete conclusions
Research that measures only universal stages or only individual and environmental differences may overlook the interaction between these influences
Fischer and Silvern 1985 argument
They argued that because evidence supports both continuity and discontinuity the problem may lie in treating them as opposing and separate arguments
Meaning of Fischer and Silvern 1985 statement
Evidence for both perspectives suggests that human development cannot be adequately explained by treating continuity and discontinuity as mutually exclusive
Research proposal activity on continuity and discontinuity
Researchers are encouraged to design a study that investigates whether development is continuous or discontinuous using a sample method procedure and analysis plan
Research design needed to investigate continuity and discontinuity
A strong study would measure development repeatedly over time and investigate both common developmental patterns and individual differences
Importance of longitudinal research for studying development
Repeated measurements over time can reveal whether abilities change gradually or show periods of more substantial transformation
Importance of measuring individual differences
Measuring variation between participants helps researchers determine whether developmental patterns and timing are similar across individuals or differ substantially
Importance of considering biological and environmental influences
Measuring both influences helps researchers investigate how maturation and experience interact during development
Overall conclusion of the continuity versus discontinuity debate
Human development is likely influenced by both gradual continuous changes and more distinct periods of developmental transformation
Jean Piaget
Swiss clinical psychologist who lived from eighteen ninety six to nineteen eighty and developed the first major theory of cognitive development
Piaget theory of cognitive development
A stage theory proposing that children develop cognitive abilities progressively through a series of distinct age related stages
Genetic epistemology
Another name for Piaget theory which refers to the study of how knowledge develops
Epistemology definition
The theory or study of knowledge
Piaget research participants
Much of Piaget extensive research was conducted on his own three children
Piaget four major stages of cognitive development
Sensorimotor stage followed by preoperational stage followed by concrete operational stage followed by formal operational stage
Piaget stages and age
The sensorimotor stage occurs from birth to two years the preoperational stage from two to seven years the concrete operational stage from seven to eleven years and the formal operational stage from eleven to sixteen years
Piaget stage theory assumption
Children progress through cognitive developmental stages in a particular sequence as they grow older
Sensorimotor stage age
Birth to approximately two years
Sensorimotor stage definition
A stage in which childrens reasoning is primarily driven by physical movement and sensory experiences
Sensorimotor reasoning example
A toddler accidentally shakes a rattle and hears an interesting sound so they shake it again to reproduce the sound
Why the sensorimotor stage is called sensorimotor
Childrens understanding develops through the interaction of sensory experiences and physical movements
Object permanence definition
The understanding that objects continue to exist even when they are outside an individuals perceptual field
Object permanence during the sensorimotor stage
Children develop the understanding that objects still exist even when they cannot see or perceive them
When object permanence develops according to Piaget
Object permanence is formed by approximately one year of age
Cognitive egocentrism definition
The inability to understand or recognize another persons viewpoint as different from ones own
Cognitive egocentrism during the sensorimotor stage
Children have difficulty understanding that other people may experience or perceive the world differently from themselves
Two important phenomena in the sensorimotor stage
Object permanence and cognitive egocentrism
Preoperational stage age
Approximately two to seven years
Preoperational stage definition
A stage in which children increasingly use symbols meanings and pretend play but cannot yet perform mental operations reliably
Pretend play during the preoperational stage
Children use objects to represent other objects or ideas such as pretending that a stick is a spoon or a box is a house
Symbolic play during the preoperational stage
Children play with meanings associated with objects rather than simply manipulating the physical objects themselves
Difference between sensorimotor and preoperational play
Sensorimotor children primarily explore objects through physical movement and sensation whereas preoperational children increasingly use objects to represent meanings and ideas
Mental operations definition
The ability to perform a task mentally without needing to physically manipulate an object or rely on a symbol such as a drawing
Why the preoperational stage is called preoperational
Children have developed symbolic thought but are not yet capable of performing mental operations reliably
Irreversibility definition
The inability to mentally reverse a sequence of events or actions
Irreversibility during the preoperational stage
Children struggle to mentally imagine reversing an action and returning an object or situation to its original state
Conservation definition
The understanding that an objects physical properties such as quantity remain the same even when its appearance changes
Lack of conservation during the preoperational stage
Children may believe that the quantity of something has changed simply because its physical appearance has changed
Piaget conservation tasks
Experimental tasks designed to investigate whether children understand that quantity remains constant despite changes in appearance
Initial setup of Piaget water conservation task
A child is shown two identical glasses containing equal amounts of water and correctly identifies that both glasses contain the same amount
First stage of water conservation task
The experimenter pours the water from one glass into a different glass that is taller and narrower while the child watches
Question in the second stage of water conservation task
The child is asked which glass now contains more water
Typical preoperational response to the water conservation task
The child points to the taller glass because the water level appears higher
Piaget explanation of failure in the water conservation task
The child cannot mentally reverse the pouring action and therefore focuses on the changed appearance of the water
Irreversibility in the water conservation task
The child cannot mentally imagine pouring the water back into its original glass to recognize that the quantity remains unchanged
Lack of conservation in the water conservation task
The child assumes that the taller appearance of the water means there is more water even though the quantity has not changed
What the water conservation task demonstrates
Preoperational children may focus on the visible appearance of an object rather than understanding that its underlying quantity remains constant
Egocentrism during the preoperational stage
Children have difficulty understanding that another person may see or experience something from a different perspective
When children overcome egocentrism according to Piaget
Children generally overcome cognitive egocentrism toward the end of the preoperational stage at approximately seven to eight years of age
Three mountains task
An experiment developed by Piaget and Inhelder in nineteen fifty six to investigate cognitive egocentrism and childrens ability to understand another persons visual perspective
Piaget and Inhelder 1956 aim
Investigated whether children could recognize that another person may see a different view of the same scene
Three mountains task model
Children are shown a three dimensional model containing three mountains
Features of the three mountains model
The model includes features such as a cross a house or snow that are visible from certain viewpoints but not from others
Initial procedure of the three mountains task
Children are allowed to explore the three dimensional mountain model before a doll is introduced
Position of the doll in the three mountains task
The doll is positioned facing the mountains from a viewpoint different from the childs own position
Question in the three mountains task
Children are asked to identify what the doll can see from its different viewpoint
How children responded in the three mountains task
Children selected a picture from a range of pictures showing different possible views of the mountains
Piaget and Inhelder 1956 results for four year olds
Four year old children almost always selected the picture corresponding to their own viewpoint rather than the dolls viewpoint
Piaget and Inhelder 1956 results for seven to eight year olds
Children began consistently selecting the picture corresponding to the dolls actual viewpoint
Piaget and Inhelder 1956 conclusion
The ability to understand another persons visual perspective develops with age and young children tend to display cognitive egocentrism
What the three mountains task demonstrates
Young children may assume that another person sees the same thing they see because they struggle to separate their own perspective from someone elses