1/19
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Mortuary behaviour is universally present in recorded human societies, though it’s extremely diverse
Deathways (or an awareness of death) are sometimes argued to be unique to humans, something that ‘helps make us human’
Evolutionary thanatology (study of death)
We’re actually not the only animals that pay attention to the dead
It’s intriguing to look at some of these behaviours
This has become its own area with crossover participation from fields including animal ethology, primatology, evolutionary psychology, palaeoanthropology and archaeology
Overextension
Anytime we see a certain behaviour exactly once or twice in a species and assume it’s ‘typical’ for that species
just because one in the species did something, doesn’t mean it applies to everyone in the species
Anthropomorphism
The tendency to assign human emotions, responses, and motivations and behaviours to other species
If we ignore overextension and anthropomorphism, we completely risk
Dismissing the emotional lives of other species out of hand
Ignoring potential models for the very beginnings of mortuary behaviour in our hominin ancestors
In eusocial insects (ants, bees etc.), dead colony members would build up in the hive/nest – this could spread disease
As an adaptation to this they practice corpse management – dead individuals are removed or neutralized by:
Carrying the body from the hive or nest (most common response)
Eating the body
Burying the body (covering it in soil; seen in some soil-nesting species)
Death-related behaviour in eusocial insects: these behaviours are triggered by odor. Depending on the species in question, odors may be caused by:
Chemicals associated with early decay – these appear to trigger corpse management in many species
Chemicals secreted by living individuals – these are more variable
These are volatile compounds, either released only at the moment of death or released throughout life (secretion stops at death, and odor vanishes quickly)
They appear to be adaptations to mark dying individuals for prompt disposal before much decay can take place
Death-related behaviour in eusocial insects: these behaviours have obvious selective benefits
Avoid buildup of dead individuals in hive/nest
Reduce disease transmission
Death-related behaviour in eusocial insects: But they have limited relevance for the origins of human mortuary behaviour
they’re odor-triggered reflexes seen in organisms whose behaviour is basically 100% instinctive
The one area of relevance is that they remind us that removing a dead group member from an area where that group lives and eats has some basic practical benefits. This would also be true for our earliest ancestors.
Death-related behaviour in vertebrates: At least some reaction to dead conspecifics (members of the same species) is documented in several vertebrate taxa
In some cases this is limited to general avoidance of dead bodies
Some experimental work using planted odor cues suggests this is triggered by odors of early decay, which would be adaptive in terms of avoiding contagion and also because dead animals attract predators and scavengers
Some groups show more complex death related behaviour
Especially groups I’ll focus on – corvids, elephants, cetaceans, and primates
These groups have also attracted the most research attention – this may be part of why more varied and elaborate behaviour is documented
Death-related behaviour in corvids
In one study, wild crows were shown dead (taxidermized) crows in a number of settings, including held in a human’s hands
Locations where they had seen dead crows were avoided for some time after, and the human was treated as a threat for several weeks
Work like this supports less controlled reports that crows ‘know’ that a dead crow means danger, and respond to the threat appropriately
Reports of corvids gathering around the body of a dead conspecific, making alarm calls, are common but less easy to
Corvids (crows, ravens, magpies etc.)
known for learning ability and this appears to extend to death responses
Death-related behaviour in cetaceans
Observation in these species is challenging given their habitat and longevity – most data are from opportunistic observation
Still, there are reliable and fairly frequent observations of:
Animals staying close to a dead group member, keeping the body from sinking, repeatedly touching/pushing/impacting it – this may be a continuation of documented responses to sick and dying animals
Prolonged carrying (across the snout or dorsal fin or in the mouth) of deceased infants and juveniles, usually by the mother or another female – suggested to possibly be a continuation of protective behaviour
Cetaceans (whales, dolphins, porpoises)
have documented responses focused mostly on deaths of young animals
Death-related behaviour in elephants
Responses shortly after death include smelling and touching the body, vocalizing, trying to lift or pull it up, or standing by it quietly
The body of a dead infant may be carried for some time
Interaction with the dead may continue long after death
Body may be visited repeatedly even after decay is advanced
Elephants often smell, touch and carry any elephant bones they find
African elephants
have well-documented reactions to the dead – both members of their social group and strangers
Death-related behaviour in other primates
Reaction to dead group members is seen in many monkey and ape species
a lot of this behaviour is focused on infants
Most commonly reported interaction of the living with corpses is a mother continuing to carry her deceased infant, sometimes for weeks
The infant is groomed and protected as if it were alive, sometimes despite clear decay or mummification
Chimpanzees may show strong reactions to deaths of group members
The corpse may be inspected, sniffed, touched and groomed
Group members may show signs of distress – vocalizing, hitting the corpse
A mother may carry her dead infant for a prolonged period
The group may avoid the place where a member died for some time
Debated interpretations
It involves debates that are hard to resolve, including how far we can stretch parallels with humans – for example, an ape or dolphin may be clearly distressed, but can we say they’re grieving?
One interesting model is based on which animal taxa we see the strongest and most complex responses in:
Strong death responses reflect the small, tightly knit social groups and intelligence of these taxa
Each individual has complex social ties – their death disrupts these, confusing and distressing others