1/142
Abortion and Exotic Surgeries
What is the main problem of resource allocation in healthcare?
Determining how to best distribute resources
What two different levels do you distribute resources?
Marco and Micro
What is a positive right?
An entitlement to perform certain actions or to be in certain states.
What is a negative right?
An entitlement that others do not perform certain actions or put you in certain states.
What are three possible sources of rights?
Government or institutions, God, and simply being human.
What is the relationship between rights and duties?
Having a right creates an obligation or duty for others to provide it or not interfere.
What is Rawls' original position?
A thought experiment in which people make rules without knowing who they will be in society.
What is the veil of ignorance in Rawls' theory?
Not knowing your identity or position when deciding what rules are fair.
What does Robert Nozick believe about justice?
No person or government has a right to resources properly owned by someone else.
What are exotic life-saving treatments?
Treatments that are scarce because demand is greater than availability.
What are the two major questions about ELT selection?
Who gets selected for treatment, and who gets to make the selection?
What are Rescher's two stages of ELT selection?
Stage One: Inclusion or exclusion. Stage Two: Selection.
What three qualities should ELT selection criteria have?
simple, plausible, and rationally defensible.
What does the constituency factor mean in ELT selection?
A hospital can exclude a patient who is not one of its clients.
What does the progress-of-science factor mean in ELT selection?
A hospital can include patients based on the staff's research interests.
What does the aspect-of-success factor mean in ELT selection?
A hospital can exclude patients who are unlikely to benefit from treatment.
What does the relative likelihood-of-success factor consider?
The individual patient's likelihood of successfully benefiting from treatment.
What does the life-expectancy factor consider?
Whether the patient has a long life ahead.
What does the family-role factor consider?
Whether the patient is a parent or has other family responsibilities.
What does the potential future-contributions factor consider?
Whether the patient may make beneficial contributions to society.
What is Rescher's conclusion about ELT selection?
A selection system is necessary, but no single system is uniquely best or optimal.
What is ARESLD?
Alcohol-related end-stage liver disease
What is the number one kind of ARESLD
alcohol cirrhosis
What is ESLD?
End stage Liver disease
What causes ESLD
conditions other than alcohol
What did the HCFA recommend about liver transplants for patients with alcoholic cirrhosis?
Medicare should cover transplant surgery for patients who were abstinent.
What was the final HHS decision about abstinence before liver transplantation?
No required period of abstinence was established for patients diagnosed with alcoholic cirrhosis.
Why are donated livers considered a limited resource?
Livers are non-renewable
What percentage of ESLD patients have ARESLD according to the notes?
more than 50%
What was the main concern about public support for liver transplantation?
Without public support, organs might not be donated
What did Moss and Siegler propose about patients with ARESLD?
They should not compete equally with other candidates for liver transplantation.
How did Moss and Siegler respond to the objection that alcoholism is a disease?
They argued that ARESLD develops after 10–20 years of heavy use
Do moss and Siegler believe that alcoholism can be treated?
yes
What is ageism?
Prejudice or discrimination based on age
What is the main assumption of the anti-ageist argument?
Life has absolute value to everyone who wants to continue living.
What does the anti-ageist argument say about the value of different amounts of life?
life is equally precious to those who value their lives.
What is the fair-innings argument?
People are entitled to a reasonable lifespan
What age does the fair-innings argument identify as a reasonable lifespan?
Over 70 years
What does the fair-innings argument say people are entitled to before reaching a fair innings?
They are entitled to reach a reasonable lifespan.
What is one major problem with the fair-innings argument?
Determining a non-arbitrary age threshold.
What is Thomson's first step in defending abortion?
Assume for the argument that a fetus is a person with a right to life.
What is the basic anti-abortion argument Thomson examines?
Every person has a right to life
What does Thomson's violinist analogy demonstrate?
Having a right to life does not automatically give someone the right to use another person's body.
What does Thomson believe about bodily autonomy?
People have a right to control what happens to and inside their bodies.
When does Thomson consider abortion permissible to save the mother's life?
When the mother has a right to defend herself against a threat to her life.
According to Thomson, does a fetus automatically have a right to its mother's body after rape?
No
What does Thomson argue about pregnancy when precautions were taken to prevent conception?
The fetus does not automatically have a right to use the mother's body.
Does Thomson believe all abortions are morally permissible?
No
What is the difference between justice and moral decency?
Justice concerns what someone has a right to; moral decency concerns what someone ought to do even without a legal or moral obligation.
What is a Good Samaritan according to Thomson?
A person who does more than what is morally required.
What is a Minimally Decent Samaritan according to Thomson?
A person who does what is morally decent but no more than necessary.
What does Thomson believe everyone ought to be?
At least a Minimally Decent Samaritan.
Why does Thomson oppose laws that outlaw all abortions?
They would force women to be Good Samaritans rather than requiring only minimal decency.
What does Thomson say about abortions of convenience?
She does not consider them examples of just killings.
What is the main takeaway from Thomson's defense of abortion?
Some abortions are permissible, but not all abortions are morally justified.
What is Tooley's main question about personhood?
What properties must something possess to be a person with a serious right to life?
What is Tooley's self-consciousness requirement?
An individual must understand itself as a continuing subject of experiences and mental states.
According to Tooley, what does having a right to something mean?
If you desire something, others have an obligation not to deprive you of it.
According to Tooley, what does the right to life protect?
The ability to continue as a subject of experiences, not simply continued bodily existence.
What does Tooley conclude about beings that do not meet the self-consciousness requirement?
They are not persons with a serious right to life.
What possible cut-off points for personhood does Tooley reject?
Conception, human form, spontaneous movement, viability, and being outside the womb.
What is the ordinary view of personhood?
Persons are living human individuals.
What does the ordinary view of personhood say should be assumed by default?
It should be the default until someone provides a better view.
What is the main criticism of Tooley's view in the notes?
It attempts to replace the ordinary view of personhood but fails.
What does the reason-versus-imagination argument say about human identity?
A human being remains the same individual from the one-cell zygote through adulthood.
What does the direct-abortion position in the notes claim?
Direct abortions are always wrong.
what does the notes' argument say about the right to life of unborn humans?
Every living human individual has an equal right to life.
What does the notes' argument say about unborn humans as aggressors?
The unborn are not aggressors and are not unjust.
What is the doctrine of double effect?
Serious harm may be permissible as a side effect of a good result, but not as the means of achieving it.
What is the most important consideration in the doctrine of double effect?
The person's intention.
What are Finnis' two main ethical principles for healthcare providers?
Non-maleficence and Justice
What does non-maleficence mean?
Do no harm
What does justice mean in Finnis' ethical principles?
treat like cases alike
According to Finnis, what may a rape victim do to prevent conception?
Take medical precautions against conception as a defense against the attacker's invading sperm.
According to Finnis, is abortion permissible after conception resulting from rape?
No
Why doesn’t Finnis think abortion is permissible after conception resulting in rape
the resulting person is innocent of the father's attack.
How does Finnis apply double effect to mother-fetal conflict?
A fetus may die as a side effect of saving the mother's life if saving the mother is the sole intention.
What is Marquis' first step in analyzing abortion arguments?
Recognizing that both sides use symmetrical arguments.
What are the three general logical parts of abortion arguments?
Claims about fetuses, a general moral principle, and a conclusion applying that principle.
What is the main anti-abortion question Marquis identifies?
How is being biologically human morally relevant?
What is the main pro-choice question Marquis identifies?
How do psychological characteristics make a moral difference?
According to Marquis, what should be the focus of the abortion debate?
Understanding what makes killing a person morally wrong.
According to Marquis, why is killing someone wrong?
death harms the victim by depriving them of a future.
What is Marquis' basic argument against abortion?
Depriving someone of a future like ours is wrong
Why does Marquis believe his argument explains why death is terrible?
It explains that death is harmful because it takes away the victim's valuable future.
How does Marquis' argument address killing non-human beings?
It allows that killing some non-human beings can also be morally wrong
Does Marquis' argument permit active euthanasia?
Yes
Why does Marquis believe contraception is allowed?
contraception does not deprive anyone of a future like ours.
What is Marquis' final conclusion about abortion?
It is never allowed
The main problem of resource allocation in healthcare is determining how to best distribute resources at the __________ and __________ levels.
Macro and Micro
A __________ right is an entitlement to perform certain actions or to be in certain states.
positive
A __________ right is an entitlement that others do not perform certain actions or put you in certain states.
Negative
Three possible sources of rights are the government or institutions, __________, and simply being human.
God
Having a right creates an obligation or __________ for others.
Duty
According to John Rawls, resources should be distributed __________ so that some members do not disproportionately benefit without a net benefit for all.
Fairly
Rawls' thought experiment in which people make rules without knowing who they will be in society is called the __________ __________.
Original Position
The __________ of __________ is the idea that people do not know their identity or position when deciding what rules are fair.
Veil of Ignorance
Robert Nozick believes that no person or government has a right to resources properly __________ by someone else.
Owned
Nozick opposes using taxes to pay for another person's healthcare because it uses one person's resources for another person without their __________ to do so.
Right
Exotic life-saving treatments are treatments that are __________ because demand is greater than availability.
Scarce