1/50
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Policy
A deliberate system of principles to guide decisions and achieve rational outcomes
• A statement of intent, implemented as a procedure or protocol
• Statement of goals and objectives that create a framework for decision-making
Public policy
• Created by government bodies to influence behavior and well-being of the public
• A system of laws, regulatory measures, courses of action, and funding priorities
• Includes what governments choose to do … or not do
Health policy
Defined by the World Health Organization as the decisions, plans, and actions that are
undertaken to achieve specific healthcare goals within a society
The 3 Streams & Policy Windows (Kingdon)
• Policy, Politics, Problem Streams
• Policy Window ‘opens’….when the opportunity presents itself; when various factors align
Contextual Factors (Buse)
• Situational: Focusing events
• Structural: Political and Economic systems, Demographic composition
• Cultural: Beliefs, values, and religious basis
• International: Require coordination across borders
Public policy stakeholders/actors
Academia, Government, Community, Media/comms, HC delivery systems, Employers and businesses
4 Types of Actors/Stakeholders Specific to America’s Health Care System
1. Purchasers/Consumers
• Individuals/Patients
• Organized Groupings (businesses/employers & government)
2. Insurers – Take $ from purchasers to pay providers
• Businesses & government may be both purchasers & insurers
3. Providers – People & Institutions (Dr’s, RN’s, hospitals)
• HMO’s & ACO’s may be both insurers & providers
4. Suppliers (HIT/EHR, pharmaceuticals, supplies & equipment)
Policymaking at three levels of government
National, State, Local
Structure of the U.S. Government
Federalism: government system that includes the national government, which shares sovereign powers with fifty state governments.
Separation of powers: separation of branches under the constitution by
the legislative, judicial, and executive branches of government.
3 Core Functions
Assessment, Policy Development, Assurance
10 Essential PH Services
Assess and monitor pop. health
Investigate, diagnose, address health hazards and root causes
Communicate effectively to inform and educate
Strengthen, support, mobilize communities and partnerships
Create champion, and implement policies, plans, and laws
Utilize legal and regulatory actions
Enable equitable access
Build a diverse and skilled workforce
Improve and innovate thru evaluation, research, and quality improvement
Build and maintain a strong organizational infrastructure for PH
10 Great Public Health Achievements
Control of infectious diseases, Family planning, Healthier mothers and babies, Motor vehicle safety, Tobacco as a health hazard, Declines in death from heart disease and stroke, Fluoridation of drinking water, Immunizations, Safer and healthier foods, Workplace safety
Flexner Report (1910)
American Medical Association hired Abraham Flexner to study US med schools
Established biomedical model as the gold standard of medical training; de emphasized Homeopathic medicine
Reduced the number of medical doctors wishing to serve in underserved areas
Reduced opportunities for medical education for prospective Black physicians
Created medical elitism
Sheppard Towner (1921)
Federal legislation aimed at providing federal funds to states for Community Maternal & Child Health Promotion
Reduced infant and child mortality
Publicly-funded clinics, health education classes and materials, conferences for providers and public health workers
Hill-Burton (1946)
Federal legislation in support (millions of dollars) of building community hospitals
and training health care professionals
Contingent on communities matching funding
Did not fund public health insurance programs
Goal: address the shortage of hospitals and improve access to healthcare services, especially in rural and underserved areas
Effect: increased disparities & institutionalized racism
Policies to combat negative effects:
• Civil Rights Act 1964
• Medicare 1965
U.S. Federal Public Health & Health Policy Goals
Expansion of access
Expansion of infrastructure
Cost control/effectiveness
Public health/safety/protection
Health/HC research
Retrenchment/Reductions in access
Scope of MDC and MDA
Medicare
20% of US pop. in 2023
Medicare Advantage - projected to be 33.8 mil in 2024, more than 51% on MDC
Medicaid/CHIP
88.4 mil in Sept. 2023 (down from 90.9 mil in 2022)
Largest source of behavior and long-term care spending
Federal Spending
$944 bil on MDC, 21% of National Health Expenditures
$806 bil on MDA, 18% of NHE
Medicare (MDC)
People 65+ and some younger w/end-stage renal disease or disabilities
Universal/auto-enrolled at 65
Social insurance model - ppl pay throughout life to benefit at end
Pay via payroll deductions
Administered by federal government
Parts A-D
MDC Coverage
Part A
Hospitalization
First day pt. pays via deductible
60-90 days, pt. pays small amt.
91-150 days, pt. pays larger amount (double)
Skilled Nursing Facility
First 20 days MDC pays 100%
After, pt. pays small amt.
+100 days pt. pays all
Hospice
MDC pays 100%
Part B
MDC covers professional services (MD, PT, etc.)
Preventative, ambulatory care
Medically necessary services (excluding dental, eye, hearing, Rx)
Part C - MDC Advantage
Private insurance add-on
Combines Medicare Part A and B coverage (and sometimes D) into one plan
Includes extra benefits (eye, dental, gym, hearing, Rx)
Usually lower out-of-pocket but have to use in-network providers
Plans vary by location and company
Part D
Private insurance providing drug coverage
Medicaid (MDA)
Pre ACA Expansion (1965-2014)
Income eligibility - varied by state, adults up to 61% FPL
Categorical eligibility - auto-eligible based on characteristics (age, disability, young child and parent, pregnant)
Federal government paid 50-76%
Post ACA Expansion (2014-2018)
Expansion varied by state
Income eligibility - raised to 138% of FPL in expansion states
Categorical eligibility - gotten rid of in expansion states
Federal government paid 100% in 2014-2016, down to 90% in 2020 onward
MDA 1115 Waivers
Testing innovative approaches to delivering and financing Medicaid
services
Medicaid Expansion (ACA)
Covers low-income adults under 65
Income eligibility up to 138% FPL
Public insurance program
Very low or no premium, minimal cost-sharing
Federal government pays 90%, states pay 10%
Optional for states (2012 SC ruling)
Medicaid in 2024
Start of pandemic - Congress enacted Families First Coronavirus Response ACT (FFCRA) → MDA keep ppl enrolled thru end of pandemic
End of pandemic - MDA unwinding for elderly, disabled, rural, minorities, many lost coverage but still higher than start of pandemic
Key ACA Elements (2010)
Individual mandate (based on MA, get HI or pay tax)
Employer mandate (50+ employees requires HIM options and EBHI)
Guaranteed issue
Insurance marketplaces (HIM)
Coverage until 26 y.o. on parents’ plans
Medicaid Expansion
ACA Mandate Timeline Overview
2010 - ACA signed into law w/individual and employer mandate
2012 - Supreme Court upholds individual mandate as tax
2014 - Individual mandate goes into effect
2015 to 2016 - Employer mandate phases in
2017 - Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (individual mandate zeroed out effective 2019)
2019 - Retrenchment, states not penalized for not expanding
Present - Employer mandate still enforced nationally, individual mandate only in some states
Triple/Quadruple/Quintuple
Improve pt. experience
Better outcomes
Lower costs
Clinician well-being
Health equity
Health Insurance Risk Pools
Need mix of low-risk (healthy, young) ppl and high-risk (elderly, chronic ill) in same insurance pool
If too many high-risk, death spiral of high costs will occur, as low-risk leave due to expensive
Risk
Potential to lose money, earn less, spend more time/payments without additional payment
Bundling services transfers risk from payer to provider
Greater the services added into one payment, the more the hospital has to lose/greater risk
Mitigating risk
Carve-outs on FFS basis
Risk adjustments for elderly and chronically ill
Clear global budget assigning per patient
“Two-Sided Risk”
Shared risk between providers and insurers that could be positive or negative
Based on budget → if providers spends less than global budget, they get some of the saved funds back (ex: given $10mil, spend $9mil, get $500k back)
If go over budget → have to pay back
Often used in ACOs and Medicare programs
1st Generation HMOs
Early 1970s - prepaid group practices
Restricted MD networks
Prepaid enrollment
Hired staff, doctors receive salaries
Own hospitals, have global budget
Regionalized tertiary care and specialized centers
50/50 generalists and specialists
Vertical integration
Kaiser Permanente
Backlash Against HMOs
Perceived gatekeeping, restriction of choice
Pts. felt restricted by limited networks and few choices, frustrated by denied services
Doctors didn’t like increased administrative oversight and restrictions on clinical decisions
Media began putting HMOs in bad light, denying necessary claims to save money
Led to emergence of PPOs - pts. can see out-of-network for higher costs and providers gave discounts, pts. liked having choice
2nd Generation HMOs
Network Model HMOs
More choice for patients
Virtual integration - connected, but independent
Tiered network allowing pts. to see out-off-network at higher costs
Providers could have HMO and non-HMO pts.
Improved utilization management and focus to outcomes as well as cost
Critics say undermined intent and cost-savings of og HMOs
HMO Act of 1973 - passed by Congress, signed by Nixon → required large businesses/employers with EBHI to offer at least one HMO alternative to FFS
Health Services vs. Consumable Goods
Health Services
Intangible, service-based
Essential, complex, guided by professionals
Often paid via insurance or government
Consumable Goods
Tangible, product-based
Replaceable, easy to compare
Paid directly by consumer
Fee-for-service (FFS)
The Unit of Payment is the Visit or Procedure
Volume-based
Used by some ACOs
Episode Based
Physician or Hospital paid one sum for all services during one illness or procedure
Per diem
Hospital is paid for all services for one day
Capitation
One payment per patient for a time period (year or month)
Global payments
Putting all costs into one payment to save costs over time
2 Types of Cost Control
Financing controls
Regulatory strategies
Competitive strategies
Payment controls
Price controls
Utilization management
Value-Based Care Payment Reform
Pay for performance
Giving bonuses/incentives to salaried physicians for providing certain-level of quality care while saving costs
“Two-sided risk”, have penalty if don’t meet standards
Bundled payments/Global budget
One bundled payment to hospitals and providers
ACOs
Uses FFS but attached to Global Budget model
Need to meet standards to get rewarded, penalties if don’t
Care Coordination
Adds capitation (amt. per pt. per year) to FFS
Encourages health
Role of Big Data in Value-Based Care/Payment
Healthcare Data Analytics
Allows for tracking population health
Shifts from pay-for-service to value-based care
Big Data
Evidence-based information
Sources of big data: research studies, public records, EHR, wearable devices, payer records
Health Insurance Cost Sharing
Premium
Monthly fee to participate in HI plan
Based on age, gender, health factors
Deductible
Amt. must pay before HI kicks in
Mitigates risk for insurers
Co-payments
Flat fee you pay per visit
Ex: $50 for every derm consultation
Younger/healthier pts. - LOW premiums, HIGH deductibles
Older/less healthy pts. - HIGH premiums, LOW deductibles
4 Principles of Medical Ethics
Beneficence - help people in need
Nonmaleficence - do no harm
Autonomy - maintain pt.’s dignity and right to choose
Justice - treat everyone fairly
Ex: Jehovah’s Witness need blood transfusion (autonomy vs. nonmaleficence
Quality vs. Quantity
Quality Problems
Underuse - necessary care not provided, capitation
Misuse - inappropriate medical care, burnout and incompetence
Overuse - unnecessary services provided, fee-for-service
Quality balanced against quantity
FFS OVERUSE - docs doing unnecessary scans, imaging
Capitation UNDERUSE - docs getting paid same for visit regardless of what’s done, don’t do enough services
Emergency Medical Treatment & Labor Act (EMTALA)
1986 - Congress enacted, public access to EMS regardless of ability to pay
Some Medicare hospitals have to provide medical screenings regardless of ability to pay for emergency medical conditions and have to stabilize pts.
Six Domains of Health Care Quality (STEEP AIMS)
Safe - do no harm
Timely - reducing waits and potentially harmful delays
Equitable - care that doesn’t change in quality based on pt.’s characteristics
Effective - avoiding underuse and overuse, application of scientific knowledge
Efficient - avoiding waste
Patient centered - respectful and responsive to individual pts.
PMQI
Helps us identify and analyze problems and generate solutions
Performance Management (PM)
Setting objectives, measuring and reporting progress towards those objectives
Quality Improvement (QI)
Engaging in activities to ensure desired progress is being made on a continuous basis, usually a defined process
Financial Management
Basics
Business plans
Financial statements
Income statement (profit and loss)
Statement of cashflow
Balance sheet (assets and liabilities)
Budgets
Planning tool
Evaluation tool
Annual process involving all levels of organizational management
BUDGETS
Both a PLANNING AND EVALUATION tool (projected activity and expenditures)
Types of budgets
Operating - predicted income and expenses (complete w/analysis) for a specific time period
Capital - evaluating for big expenses such as big projects and investments and planning accordingly
Cash - predicting the how and when of cash flow for the business
Master - combines all the smaller budgets
Uses of Budgets
Setting and measuring performance standards
Evaluating and addressing organizational processes
Conducting audits - comparing planned expenses vs. actual budget
Comparing performance to industry standards
Fiscal year - defined period that occurs at same time, ex: fed. govt. fiscal year is always Oct. 1st
Long range budget - special projects that take place over several years
Electronic Health Record (EHR) Conversion Opportunity Results
Enhance existing documentation practices
Link organizational vision and missions to new technology
Leadership opportunities to improve provider and patient communication
Most integrated hospital networks have EHR
Continuous QI Techniques
Plan-do-check-act (PDCA)
Six Sigma: define → measure → analyze → improve → control
Lean: eliminating waster, improving pt. flow, pt. efficiency and value
Policy Levers
Bill becoming law: have idea → write bill → debate in committee → debate on floor → work with House/Senate committee → negotiate compromises in conference → send to Prez for signature → enforce
Life cycle: discussion and debate → political action → legislative proposal → law and regulation → compliance