1/32
Looks like no tags are added yet.
General Principles of Criminal Law
The elements of a criminal offense include the mens rea, or evil mind; the actus reus, the bad or evil act; and causation. Except for strict liability, which has no mens rea, every statute defining a substantive criminal offense proscribes a particular mens rea and actus reus that must be proved by the prosecution beyond a reasonable doubt for criminal liability to result
What is the definition of a crime
A crime is an act or omission that, if proven, merits the formal solemn condemnation of the community
Purposes of Punishment - DRIER
Deterrence, retribution, incapacitation, and educaiton
Purposes of Punishment - Deterrence
often divided into specific and general deterrence
Purposes of Punishment - Retribution
the object is control of harmful conduct in the future by taking retribution against individuals who violate social norms, especially when they commit heinous crimes
Purposes of Punishment - Education
education helps people understand the law, although citizens are expected to know the laws and to follow them (“ignorance is not an excuse”)
Purposes of Punishment - Rehabilitation
Aims to help the convicted person to improve and function in society. The US criminal justice system generally does not operate for this purpose (except for juvenile delinquency programs)
What is the anatomy of a crime?
Actus reus, mens rea, causation, harm or result, attendant circumstances
Actus Reus
(“evil hands”) – acts or omissions
Mens Rea
(“evil hands”) – mindset
Causation
(proximate cause) – Cause and Fact and proximity Test or Substantial Factor Test
Attendant Circumstances
(concurrence has to happen between Actus Rea and Mens Rea at the same time to constitute a crime
Actus Reus Definition
Before there can be a crime, there must be a criminal act (actus reus). The criminal act must be a voluntary, affirmative act causing a criminally proscribed result. The act requirement may also be satisfied by an “omission” or failure to act under circumstances imposing a legal duty to act. A bad thought standing alone cannot result in criminal liability. The actus reus of a crime consists of two components, both of which must be proved
Malum in se
evil in and of itself. the act is inherently immoral
Malum Prohibitum
Evil because it is prohibited. The act is wrong only because the law forbids it
Actus Reus: Voluntary Act - CL
The voluntary act is required for CL and the voluntary act or omission to perform an act when duty exists
Actus Reus: Voluntary Act - MPC
the voluntary act is required for MPC. The MPC categorizations of Involuntary Acts (actor is not culpable) include:
reflux or convulsion
bodily movement during unconsciousness or sleep
act performed under hypnosis
Bodily movement that is not the product of the effort or determination of the actor, either conscious or habitual (someone pushed into a fight not culpable cause did not act voluntarily, a catch-all)
a complete defense to the actus reus requirement is unconsciousness or automatism because then the act is not voluntary
Actus Reus - Omissions Definition
a failure to act when an individual has a duty to act (a legal obligation)
Omissions are permutations of the actus reus injury and are not punished unless they fall under RASK (both MPC and CL use RASK)
what does the Acronym for RASK Omissions stand for?
Special Relationship, Assumption of Duty, Statute, and Contractual relationship
RASK Omissions- Special Relationship
a special relationship requiring action exists, ex. A parent-child relationship
(Other types: Husband/wife, ship crew/passengers, supervisor/employees)
RASK Omissions - Assumption of Duty
a voluntary assumption to care for one who can’t care for himself AND preventing others from helping that person
RASK Omissions - Statute
a statute imposes an obligation
RASK Omissions - Contractual Relationship
this is assumed, it can either be written or oral
Actus Reus - Good Samaritan Statute
these statutes provide a duty to act that is not within the 4 different types of omission of Rask
Actus Reus - Bystander Effect
seeing a crime happen against someone and not acting
people usually don’t act because they assume someone else will
Actus Reus - Possession
this occurs if the possessor knowingly procured or received the thing possessed or was aware of his control thereof for a sufficient period to have been able to terminate his possession
actual possession required direct physical possession/control
How do we prove Possession?
the state must show that the defendant “exercised control or dominion” over the contraband
Standard for Constructive Possession
a person is responsible for this when he knows the object is there and enough time has elapsed that he can responsibly dispose of it under the circumstances