1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Obesity - opening sentence
It’s a common problem in the UK that’s estimated to affect around 1 in every 4 adults and 1 in every 5 children aged 10-11
Mokdad et al (1999) - refers to an ‘obesity epidemic’
Can lead to a number of life-threatening conditions:
type 2 diabetes
coronary heart disease
some types of cancer
stroke
can affect quality of life and lead to psychological problems such as depression and low self esteem
Stats
£10.1bn spent on tackling the diseases closely linked to diet
What is obesity?
most common ways to define obesity are
BMI
waist circumference
measuring thickness of fatty tissue using callipers
Genetic explanation for obesity
Polygenic Determination
Adam Locke et al (2015)
studies genomes of more than 300,000 people and identified 97 genes associated with obesity traits
different genes influence difference aspects of obesity
genetic variants play an important role in influencing body fat distribution
fat distribution differs between men and women
researchers identified 97 genome-wide regions that influence obesity, a finding that tripled the number of previously known regions
no single genetic cause of obesity - therefore one weight loss solution will not work for everyone
there may be as many as 400 genes involved in obesity (Watson 2009)
Genetic - families
obesity runs in families
concordance rates for first degree relatives are between 20-50%
indicates a moderate rather than substantial degree of heritability
Casandra Nan et al (2012)
meta-analysis of 12 twin studies involving 8,000 MZ and 10,000 DZ twins
pre-adolescence, young adulthood and late adulthood were recorded
concordance rates ranged from 61-80%
environmental changes over time do not seem to have as big a relative impact on an individual’s weight, suggesting a mainly genetic influence on variation in BMI over the years
suggests a genetic component to obesity from childhood to adulthood
Neural explanation for obesity - serotonin
research suggests some obese patients have lower than normal levels of serotonin
less effective at switching off VMH activity and triggering the cessation (end) of eating as it is serotonin that signals to the hypothalamus that we have eaten to satiety
low-levels could be associated with other co-morbid disorders such as depression
other causes may be periods of stress or low mood - trigger comfort eating
low levels of serotonin may even be genetically inherited
Neural explanation - dopamine
obesity linked to dysfunctional dopamine system
Gene-Jack Wang et al (2001)
obese individuals have significantly fewer dopamine receptors in part of their brain than normal-weight controld
neurotransmitter cannot perform its usual pleasurable reward function in response to eting
overeating can therefore be seen as an attempt to activate rewards centers in the brain that provide feelings of pleasure by increasing dopamine levels
suggests obesity is the outcome of a food addiction that operates neurochemically in ways similar to other addictions such as gambling and drug addictions
AO3 points
Genetic
limitation of twin studies
contradictory evidence
Neural
supporting evidence for serotonin
supporting evidence for dopamine
Both
treatment application
AO3 - limitations of twin studies
P = One of the limitations of using twin studies is that they can be argued to lack validity
EX = Monozygotic twins not only share their genes but, due to them looking identical, it has been suggested that they are also treated more similarly by friends, family and other acquaintances than dizygotic twins and therefore could be said to also share an almost identical environment as well.
EV = Joseph (2002) suggested that since MZ twins are treated more similarly than DZ twins this greater environmental similarity means that heritability estimates are artificially inflated.
C = However, Cassandra Nan et al (2012) conducted a meta analysis of 12 twin studies and found that concordance rates ranged from 61-80%. She found that environmental changes over time do not seem to have as big a relative impact on an individual’s weight which suggests a mainly genetic influence on variation in BMI
LB = Nevertheless, environmental factors can’t be ignored so an interactionist approach may be best way to approach explaining obesity as twin studies may overestimate the genetic influence of biology on obesity.
AO3 - contradictory evidence
P = A weakness of the genetic explanation for obesity is that there is contradictory evidence and evidence for a biological cause of obesity is inconsistent.
EV = Research carried out by Paracchini et al (2005) could not find a link between genes involved in regulating leptin and the development of obesity.
EX = This shows that even if leptin does play a role in obesity, it is not the sole cause and there must be other factors involved.
EXT = Aditionally, it could be argued that the biological explanation for obesity is biologically reductionist as it does not take into account other factors that could be said to contribute to obesity for example, psychological features as explained in the Restraint theory.
LB = Therefore, the biological explanation can be considered to be biologically determinist and so to understand obesity from a more holistic perspective other factors need to be taken into account.
AO3 - treatment application
P = One of the strengths of the biological explanation for obesity is that it has treatment application.
EX = Some research has shown that one of the ways to help patients who may be suffering with dopamine and serotonin deficiencies is to be prescribed drugs that are involved with regulating neurotransmitters.
EV = Wang et al (2001) carried out a study which supported the idea that low dopamine levels leads to obesity and therefore drug therapy should help.
EXT = Furthermore, better treatments for eating disorders like obesity would help financial savings for healthcare systems like the NHS and would therefore reduce these costs to the wider economy.
LB = This is significant as treatments for people with obesity could reduce the strain on the NHS and be life changing for those with obesity to increase quality of life and life expectancy.