1/86
Week 1-4
Harold Lasswell’s definition of politics
the process of determining who gets what, when, and how
Heywood & Chin’s definition of politics
what we contest and cooperate over (common concern)
political theory
reflection on political life to both render our current practices/institutions meaningful, and to prescribe and enact change
positive theories
theories that describe how the world works using objective, factual, and testable data
normative theories
theories that prescribe how the world should work based on subjective values, ethics, and opinion
political science
empirical study of politics focused on description and using the scientific method to acquire knowledge
political philosophy
normative search for understanding that clarifies and evaluates political concepts
ancient/classical political thought
era of political thought focused on “the good life”, ethics and virtue, common good
key thinkers in ancient political thought
Aristotle, Socrates, Plato
modern Western political thought
political era characterized by using the individual as the unit of analysis
key thinkers in modern Western political thought
Machiavelli, Hobbes, Locke, Rosseau, James Madison, Adam Smith
contemporary political thought
era of political thought that is often critical rather than descriptive or normative and analyses power dynamics
normative/prescriptive concepts
moral principles, values, or ideals
descriptive concepts
concepts that are securely anchored in a measurable and objective existence
problem of political change
how we understand, manage, prescribe, and justify political change
Hegel’s “Philosophy of Right” (1821)
defined three moments of social eistence:
the family
civil society
the state
foundationalism
the idea that society and politics are grounded by principles that are universal and transcendent
___ is the engine of modernity
reason is the ____ of modernity
progress
making advancements
2 important characteristics of reform
extent - changes should remove undesireable qualities without altering structure’s fundamental character
speed - gradual
utilitarianism
idea that the “rightness” of an action can be established by its tendency to promote happiness
utility
the greatest happiness for the greatest number
Jeremy Bentham
British philosopher who founded utilitarianism
revolution
the replacement of a system or government
characteristics of a revolution (3)
dramatic and sudden change
usually violent
popular uprisings
tradition
anything handed down from the past to present, including customs, institutions, political/social systems, and ideologies
Edmund Burke
political theorist and British politician in late 1700s who was an advocate for conservatism
Burke’s view on society
social contracts “between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are to be born”
conservatism
political stance that began to develop in the 1800s in response to the Enlightenment, advocating for achieving social and political harmony/stability through preserving tradition
forms of conservatism
traditionalism
attempting to reclaim past
change in order to conserve tradition
traditionalism
maintaining continuity with the past; opposes change
attempt to reclaim the past (in conservatism)
desire to undo undesirable change, characterized by dissatisfaction with the status quo and distrust of the future
change in order to conserve
More progressive (moderate) form of traditionalism that believes societies must adapt in order to survive
enlightened traditionalism
political view that seeks to preserve tradition but recognizes that opposing change is self-defeating and reform is preferable to revolution
utopia
an unrealistic and ideal society
modern Western utopia
a style of social and political theorizing that emerged from the eighteenth century onwards in association with the Enlightenment
three features of utopia
rejects status quo (revolution, not reform)
potential for human self-development
bridges public/private divide (complete personal fulfillment)
political utopia common themes
free from want
social harmony / absence of conflict
full emancipation of the individual
reflects ideals of its creators!!
globality
the consciousness of the world as a single place
classical liberalism
at its peak in 1600s-1800s, a political philosophy that prioritizes individualism, negative freedom, and a self-regulating capitalist economy
negative freedom
freedom gained by the absence of interference from other people and the government
socialism
political philosophy that believes humans are sociable and cooperative, not autonomous, and that greed, corruption, and capitalism are the societal problem
divine right to rule
the idea that a ruler is appointed by a deity
Martin Luther’s “95 Theses”
1517 publication that marks the beginning of the Protestant Reformation that argued faith was an intrinsic value and attacked the Catholic Church's corruption
modern political thought is in response to what concept?
divine right to rule
what 3 situations caused people to question divine right to rule?
invention of printing press (1450)
Protestant Reformation
political/religious instability in England
printing press
1450 invention that led to a more literate population
main years of modern political thought
1500s-1800s AD
Locke’s natural rights
life, liberty, and pursuit of property
human nature
The essential and immutable character of all human beings
Jean-Paul Sartre
existentialist who argues that existence comes before essence, meaning that there is no innate human nature, but human nature is defined by humans through ideas/actions
nature vs nurture
key debate of human nature: is the core of human nature fixed or flexible?
Social Darwinism
people have developed more or less desirable traits which allows them to thrive more or less than other humans; success or failure in life is based on natural characteristics
universalism
human beings share a common character based on genetic inheritance
particularism
there are fundamental biological differences among human beings; these have political significance
(often seen with racialist theories)
Carol Gilligan’s “ethics of care”
idea that women’s moral theory (caring) contrasts men’s (fairness, rights, and rule)
nature (nature vs nurture)
idea that political/social theories should be based on an established concept of human nature, which is shaped by unchanging biological factors
nurture (nature v nurture)
sociological idea that humans are conditioned by social environment and humans/politics are “perfectible” or capable of moral improvement
Marx’s idea of “dialectical” relationship between humans and material world
idea that humans are shaped by modes of production and we shape the experience through labor
Simone de Beauvoir’s “The Second Sex”
feminist text that supports the nurture side of nature v nurture by distinguishing sex from gender and saying that “one is not born a woman, one becomes a woman”
intellect v instinct
debate over the degree to which rationality influences human conduct
rationalism
the belief that the workings of the physical and social world can be explained by the exercise of reason alone
Plato’s “ideal state”
Authoritarian rule by an intellectual elite with a strict division of labor
anti-rationalism
humans navigate the world based on instinct, impulse, and emotion-- not reason
Age of Enlightenment
age of new political thought centered on the use of reason, individual liberty, and the consent of the governed to challenge absolute monarchy and divine right
Competition vs cooperation
debate on whether humans are essentially egoistical & driven by self-interest, or are naturally cooperative creatures
individualism
a normative (intrinsic value, dignity, and worth) and/or methodological (negative freedom, autonomy) commitment to the primacy of the individual over any collective body
“rugged individualism” - Herbert Hoover
Sees the individual as almost entirely separable from society— Individuals can and should be self-reliant
rejection of what idea led to the creation of a welfare state in the USA (New Deal)?
rugged individualism
collectivism
normative theory centered on the social existence of human and collective action
collectivism’s relationship with 1) individualism, and 2) the state
individuals cannot be truly free until there is social equality
the state is a mechanism for organizing collective action
anti-individualism
belief that individual responsibility threatens social solidarity; emphasizes the importance of community
community
a group of people within which there are strong ties and a collective identity
society
a group of people who are interconnected in some way (geographic or trait), characterized by regular patterns of social interaction (structure) and mutual awareness (cooperation)
3 important requirements of a society
interconnected (geographically or by a trait)
structure for interaction
cooperation
social division
a split or divide in society that is a product of inequality or exclusion in social, economic, or political life
social class
a group of people who share and economic and social position, and who are united by a common interest
social contract theory
view of sociopolitical life through a legal contract; an agreement by a people to live under the power of an established government
the state of nature
pre-social and pre-political humanity
consent of the governed
idea that a government derives its power and legitimacy by the approval of its constituents
Hobbes in Leviathan (1651)
an absolute monarch (Leviathan) is needed to control society and keep people from constant conflict
John Locke’s Second Treatise (1680s)
argues for a civil government that protects the natural rights of individuals
Rousseau on State of Nature
view of the state of nature as peaceful and neutral where solitary humans lived free, self-sufficient, and uncorrupted lives
Rosseau’s “The Social Contract” (1762)
political work that argued for direct democracy through social contracts to promote the “general will” and common good
5 key debates of human nature
Nature v nurture
intellect v instinct
competition v cooperation
rationalism v anti-rationalism
individualism v collectivism
Hobbes’ first and second laws of nature
To seek peace and defend yourself
(in order to do #1) agree to give up some liberty through a social contract
Hobbes’ definition of contract
the mutual transferring of Right