Ethical Issues and Challenges: Genetic Research and Deception

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/59

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Practice flashcards covering ethical issues and challenges in genetic research and deceptive clinical/behavioral research methodologies.

60 Terms

1
New cards

What is the primary focus of genetic research?

It involves the study of how genes influence the health of individuals and populations.

2
New cards

What are the four different aspects of genetic research mentioned in the lecture?

Basic, clinical, epidemiological, and social research.

3
New cards

What three entities or sources may genetic research involve?

Research subjects, tissue samples, or genetic information derived from genetic tests.

4
New cards

What is the purpose of pedigree studies in genetic research?

To explore patterns of inheritance and study the incidence and progression of a disease in families.

5
New cards

What unexpected outcome can arise from conducting pedigree studies?

They may reveal unexpected information about family members.

6
New cards

What is the objective of gene localisation and identification studies?

To identify the location and function of a disease-bearing gene.

7
New cards

What are the four examples of diagnostic and screening studies listed in the lecture?

Newborn screening, carrier screening, prenatal screening, and disease susceptibility screening.

8
New cards

What does gene therapy seek to accomplish?

It seeks to develop disease treatments.

9
New cards

What is the purpose of carrier testing as a category of genetic testing?

Testing for specific genetic disorders in carriers.

10
New cards

What is the purpose of preimplantation genetic testing on IVF embryos?

Selecting or excluding embryos created by in vitro fertilisation (IVF) for implantation into the uterus.

11
New cards

What does the acronym PNGD stand for?

Prenatal genetic diagnosis.

12
New cards

What is the specific objective of prenatal genetic diagnosis (PNGD)?

To identify a specific genetic disorder in the foetus.

13
New cards

What type of genetic testing is administered to asymptomatic individuals?

Predictive testing.

14
New cards

What type of genetic testing is conducted on healthy individuals across a population?

Genetic screening for healthy individuals.

15
New cards

What family issues make genetic information distinct from other scientific information?

It reveals information about relatives, relationships with family members, previously unknown paternity or maternity, and an individual's predisposition to disease.

16
New cards

What does it mean that genetic information is probabilistic?

In most cases, genetic information provides information about risks, not definitive diagnoses.

17
New cards

Which four factors complicate the interpretation of genetic risks?

Clinical validity and utility, laboratory quality issues, risk of misunderstanding risk or test results, and provision of genetic counselling.

18
New cards

What types of access can be negatively impacted by genetic information?

Access to employment, education, benefits, and services such as banking, insurance, and annuities.

19
New cards

Which personal life choices can be affected by genetic information?

Reproductive decision-making and life planning decisions.

20
New cards

What potential distresses can result from the disclosure of genetic information?

Psychological, social, and economic distress.

21
New cards

What positive impacts or reassurances can genetic research offer to a subject?

Reassurance that the subject is risk-free, opportunities for preventative interventions or medical treatment, and satisfaction of participating in research to help others.

22
New cards

Why can individuals lose privacy or confidentiality in genetic research even if they did not provide a specimen?

Because genetic information derived from one person reveals sensitive information about their biological relatives.

23
New cards

What specific disclosure must be made to subjects regarding data privacy and confidentiality in genetic research?

Subjects need to be told who are the individuals or entities that will have access to data.

24
New cards

What two family-related interests must be considered in informed consent for genetic research?

The right not to know information about oneself and the duty of physicians to warn individuals at risk.

25
New cards

What issue regarding tissue samples must be addressed during informed consent?

The use and future of tissues contributed for current and any future approved research, as well as possible commercial uses.

26
New cards

What elements are included under the 'risk of harm' in genetic research?

A probability or likelihood factor, stigmatisation, 'labelling', and a false sense of security.

27
New cards

What self-reflective question does Susan Fish recommend researchers always ask?

'Would I enrol myself or my loved one in this research study?'

28
New cards

According to Susan Fish, what must an investigator do if they would not enrol themselves or a loved one in their study?

They must question their work and only perform scientifically valid and ethically sound research.

29
New cards

How is deception defined in the lecture?

To undertake to deceive others intentionally by communicating messages meant to mislead and lead someone to believe what we ourselves do not believe.

30
New cards

Through what modes or methods can deception be carried out?

Through gesture, disguise, means of action or inaction, and even through silence.

31
New cards

How does the lecture specifically define 'lying' in relation to deception?

'Any intentional deceptive message which is stated.'

32
New cards

In which academic disciplines is deception commonly used as a research method?

Social and behavioral sciences, particularly personality and social psychology.

33
New cards

What is a common example of a deceptive strategy in clinical research?

The use of a placebo.

34
New cards

What is a primary argument FOR using deception in research?

It may produce beneficial knowledge that cannot be obtained otherwise, particularly for behaviors that cannot be observed in naturalistic settings.

35
New cards

What specific emergency behavior is cited as justification for using deception?

Studying why bystanders often fail to intervene by offering aid in emergency situations.

36
New cards

What experimental bias can deception be employed to reduce?

The 'Hawthorne Effects'.

37
New cards

What concern does deception raise regarding the available subject pool?

It may decrease the pool of naive subjects.

38
New cards

How might suspicious research subjects behave if researchers are viewed as 'tricksters'?

They may respond by pretending to be naive and role-playing the part the investigator expects.

39
New cards

What wider societal harm can occur if deception is commonly practiced in research?

The public may assume that authority cannot be trusted and may emulate such behavior.

40
New cards

What is a placebo?

A pharmacologically inert substance.

41
New cards

What is the 'placebo effect'?

Relief of symptoms resulting from placebo administration when persons who feel ill are convinced they will feel better as a consequence of taking a remedy.

42
New cards

Why is the clinical use of a placebo considered controversial and deceptive?

It spreads the practice of benevolent lying and undermines public confidence in the medical profession.

43
New cards

Under what condition is the use of a placebo justified despite being deceptive?

If it is just as effective as the active agent itself and is less toxic, justifying its use due to a low risk-benefit ratio.

44
New cards

What are the two general types of deception outlined in the lecture?

Misleading disclosure and fake or rigged instruments or procedures.

45
New cards

What actions constitute 'misleading disclosure'?

A lack of accurate disclosure by withholding specific information about research or misinforming subjects about the research.

46
New cards

How is misleading disclosure distinguished from double-blind placebo-controlled trials?

It is distinct from disclosed concealment used in double-blind placebo-controlled trials.

47
New cards

How does deceptive research violate the ethical principle of 'respect for persons'?

It manipulates people to do something they might otherwise not want to do and violates their right to choose what to do based on relevant information.

48
New cards

What is the effect on informed consent if the use of deception is not disclosed in advance?

Consent to research is not valid.

49
New cards

What emotional reaction may occur in subjects when deception is discovered?

It may cause distress.

50
New cards

What is the rule regarding the necessity of deception when alternative methods exist?

Deception should not be used if non-deceptive alternatives are available.

51
New cards

What requirement must be met regarding social value before deception can be justified?

The research must have sufficient potential social value to justify the risks associated with deception.

52
New cards

In the NIMH bipolar disorder study, what deception was planned for child participants?

Providing the child with misleading information about one of the tasks.

53
New cards

What debriefing commitments were made to parents and children in the NIMH bipolar disorder study?

Explaining how and why the child was misled, and answering any questions regarding the task and the use of deception.

54
New cards

What is Authorized Deception (AD)?

An approach that makes deceptive research transparent by informing subjects in advance that deception will or might occur.

55
New cards

What four specific disclosures are made to subjects under Authorized Deception (AD)?

They are informed that they will be misled or deceived, no important risks have been concealed, an independent committee has approved the study, and debriefing will occur.

56
New cards

Why might Authorized Deception introduce bias into experimental data?

Telling subjects that deception will or might occur may make them suspicious.

57
New cards

How does using Authorized Deception affect study comparison?

It reduces comparability to previous research conducted without AD.

58
New cards

How can the disclosure of deception under Authorized Deception impact recruitment?

It may lead to reduced subject enrollment.

59
New cards

What four elements must be detailed under reporting standards for deceptive studies?

Highlighting deception, explaining the rationale/lack of non-deceptive alternatives, describing deviations from informed consent and whether AD was used, and describing the nature of debriefing.

60
New cards

What core conflict exists in deceptive research, and where does the burden of proof lie?

It pits scientific validity against respect for persons, and the burden of proof rests on justifying the deception.