1/163
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the middle east?
A geopolitical term coined in the late 19th century to describe an area of interest for European colonial powers.
What played a key role in generating the IDEA of the “Middle East?”
British colonial domination of India and imperial thinking.
What is epistemic violence and its effect on the middle east?
Marginalizing, discrediting, and silencing previous ways of knowing — hindering pre-existing traditions and earlier ways of understanding the region’s relationships/connections. Looking at an interconnected region with an imperialistic & European perspective and trying to force boundaries and different categorization onto the area can severe long-lasting traditions.
What are maps?
Selective representations that are intended to facilitate a task and make claims/arguments. Map and POWER have a strong relationship.
Denaturalization
Creating a map that seems to be factual, but is actually exaggerated, constructed, and/or inseperable from power relations.
The biggest problems with maps…
There is no perfectly representative map. Something is always distorted (ex. Africa true size) and exert power. They tell a story, good and bad, and are always based on historical context and interpretation of reality instead of showing us the reality.
What are some features of many medieval islamic maps?
Oriented south (Africa is the top), as landmass accuracy is rarely the primary goal. Post, pilgrimage, travel, etc. are often the most important issues. History & theology are often encoded as well.
Ethnicity
Humans create and maintain social groups based on ideas of shared culture, history, kinship, and language. Ethnic groupings are social, fluid, and overlapping.
Is race based on biology?
NOOOOO ABSOLUTELY NOT NO NO NOOOOOO RACE IS NOT BIOLOGICAL AT ALLLLLL
Race
Like ethnicity, race is a SOCIAL CONSTRUCT with NO BASIS IN BIOLOGY. A form of hierarchical grouping that justifies forms of domination and exploitation based on essentialized forms of difference that are usually imagined to be immutable (unchangable overtime).
Racialization
The process of creating and maintaining racial groups.
“Racial Hinge” & “Racial Loopholes”
Using a liminal group (like Iranians, Jews) as a symbolic hinge that opens or closes the door to whiteness as necessary. Legal definition of race historically on occasion doesn’t align with the social experiences of a group.
For example, in USA vs Thind (1923), they ruled that despite the direct ancestral connection of a brown hindu and a blond scandanavian, “the average man knows perfectly well there are unmistakable differences between them today,” and ruled that they aren’t “white.”
In re Najour (1908), despite the claim syrians are non-white, they ruled since Iranians are white linguistically and live in Asia, Syrians must be white too. HOWEVER, in re Halladjian (1909), Armenians were ruled white because they’re Westerners b/c of historical christianity and their oppoisiton to the persian fire worshippers.
Used Iranians to claim white in 1908, but used Iranians “non-whiteness” to claim white in 1909.
Racial Kinship
The linguistic relationship between Persian and European languages were interpreted as racial kinship, and used to justify their imperial and colonial ambitions.
Key Developments in the NEOLITHIC PERIOD (10,000 - 3,000 BCE)
Period BEFORE linguistic writing systems. Domestication of various plants and animals, and the formation of very early states.
Myth of the Agricultural Revolution
Agriculture allowed for more free time, which allowed people to specialize, which specialization lead to complex societies, which lead to state managment and development.
What was the reality of agriculutral development?
A very, very slow process of incremental change — 3,000 years between major developments. 95% of human history is non-agrarian (farming was NOT used). Sedentarism is not necessarily desirable, and it DOES NOT require states. States are NOT “normal” nor inevitable — extremely fragile at this time, b/c not yet a need for them.
Catalhoyuk (5500 BCE) Neolithic Period
Example of a major city before agriculture. Located in Anatolia, with little to no social or economic hierarchy (wealth disparity), no road/city planning, no monumental architecture, essentially community “clump” of buildings with entrances on top.

Flood Farming
Annual flooding of lowlands deposits rich dirt, allowing for agriculture without the need for centralized state authority.
Hunters/Gatherers vs Agricultural Bloom Population
Hunters had more variety in their diet, making them in better health. Infant mortality increased as well as starvation, however was compensated by a higher birth rate b/c earlier weeing off of breast milk. Grain takes more work, and POORER health.
Wild vs Domesticated wheat & Neolithic Sickle Importance
Wild einhorn was easily destroyed, allowing seeds to be spread further. After domestication, plant evolved to have thicker outside requiring a sickle for harvest. There was a codependency of humans to wheat, and wheat to humans for it to be spread as it evolved.
How did Early States Rely on Agriculture?
If they domesticated the grain, they could control the supply and enforce taxation. This only worked in areas that lacked alternatives for food, as people could just leave if there was avaliable options elsewhere. They used the agriculture to extert their power, and use grain as a currency.
T or F: States don’t invent cities or irrigation.
True. Rather, states use agriculture as leverage to get unfree labor for development, and use it as the basis for power and coercion.
Agriculture doesn’t need states, but _____ need _____.
STATES NEED AGRICULTURE.
3 main developments of early states (4,000 BCE):
Writing, grain, taxation.
T or F, the idea of “Fertile Crescent” was also a myth.
True! The earliest crop and animal domestication was actually in Anatolia, Zagros mountains, and Iranian Plateau — while the earliest states were in Sumer. The idea of the Fertile Crescent essentially combines these two.
The Uruk Period (4,000 - 3,000 BCE)
Characterized by the spread of trade and development of administrative systems across the Middle East. Development of a large city centered at Uruk, and early writing used for administrative purposes.
Increase in settlements, HUGE INCREASE in population/size of Uruk, becomes largest city in Mid East.
The Uruk Vase (3200 BCE)
Shows scenes that shed light on religious and culutral beliefs in Uruk. Figural representation of the ruler and evolution of cuneiform sign for goddess Inana, on a heirarchy, with plants and animals offered to Inana mediated by the king.

Beveled-rim Bowls (Uruk Period)
Simple mass-produced bowls spread across the region, providing an early example of a low-cost product intended for short-term use spread via trade and administrative networks.

Bullae with Clay Tokens (Neolithic & Uruk Period)
Increase in settlement size & concentration of wealth required new administration technology. Cylinder seals owned by administators, often having a unique “stamp” with the owners and used to seal the bullae. Provides a “tamper proof” record of transactions.
Eventually, it develops to where the tokens can be impressed onto the outside, removing the need to break the envelope (bulla) to check records.

Uruk acts as the “State Building Starter Kit.” What does this include?
Monumental Architecture
Bureaucracy and Tax Collection
Wealth Inequality
When did writing really begin to emerge?
Between the Uruk and Early Dynastic Periods, 3200-2800 BCE.
What acted as inspiration for the earliest writing?
Narrative art. Images are transformed into pictograms, which uses icons or symbols to represent certain meanings like, for example, the Goddess Inana.
What emerges by 3250 BCE in Uruk?
A new method of accounting using pictographs on clay tablets to represent commodities and locations, whereas dots used to represent quanitites. These texts are NON-LINGUISTIC (don’t represent sounds of one specific language).
Logographic Writing
Sign in writing system standing for word or concept, not a sound. Like an emoji!
Cuneiform
A writing system (not a language) using logographic signs pressed by a reed stylus on clay. The script evolves to represent syllables as well as logograms by 2800 BCE.
T or F, mespotamian society is bilingual.
TRUE! They speak Sumerian AND Akkadian.
Syllabic Writing
Words are broken down into syllables, with one sign representing each syllable — signs repurposed from logograms.
The Early Dynastic Period (2900 - 2350 BCE)
The development of fully linguistic writing and competing smaller city states.
Productive Semitic
Name of the family of related languages that includes Akkadian, Arabic, Armaic, and Hebrew.
Racialized use of “Semitic”
Assumption that people who speak any of the semitic languages descended from the same ancient group and thus constitute a race or ethnciity. It would be like assuming all English speaking Americans belong to the same race/ethnicity.
Sumerian
Refers to the Sumerian language or residents of Sumer (southern Mesopotamia) — but not all Sumerians spoke Sumerian (bilingual region!) Earliest texts are written in Sumerian (Early Dynastic), not Akkadian.
The “Sumerian Problem”
Scholars believed that language corresponds with race, but Sumerian is not related to Akkadian (Semitic language). So… what race are the “sumerians?”
What was the problems with using language as a racial distinction?
Language is NOT always perfectly corresponded with descent/ethnicity. Mespotamian society is BILINGUAL — so to seperate the same people as either or is… insane.
T or F, Mespotamian populations used language as a dividing point.
FALSE! There was zero indication that was a division. Rather, they used determinants like clothing and whether if they were mobile vs sedentary.
The Marriage of Martu (1800 BCE, old babylonian)
Myth about a god named “Martu” (Mr. West), which was a personification of non-sedentary, nomadic outsider people. Wants to get married to a goddess, yet her friends try to dissuade her.
This narrative reflects the culutral contact and relationship between nomadic and settled communities, and a universal acceptance of the god, even if they are viewed differently from an urban perspective.

The Ur III Period (2100 - 2000 BCE)
Main center of power around the City of Ur, with indirect rule surrounding the city, and close contact outside of that. Characteristics include extensive economic documentation, Sumerian dying out as a spoken language (still used as a literary).
Who are the Armorites?
An outsider, “westerner.” Not necessarily an official group, moreso a stereotype name deemed from Mespotamian king to describe foreigners (used as an exonym).
The end of the Ur III Period (2000 BCE)
Collapses due to overpopulation, as well as environmental and political factors. The armorites are blamed in new literature, which also brings the Marriage of Martu to light in this context. Blame outsiders for failures.
The idea of race into Mesopotamian society & true alterity
Scholars assumed mesopotamians racialized based on language, wheras they distinguished themselves based on sedentary vs mobile lifestyles. However, the stereotypes assumed are similar to how we racialize people today.
Old Babylonian Period (Mespotamia) (2000 - 1600 BCE)
During this period, the city of Babylon increased in political prominence.
Under the reign of Hammurabi (1792–1750 BCE), Babylon controlled a region from the Persian Gulf in the south to the Middle Euphrates and upper Tigris regions, including Assyria
Orrientalism
A series of interrelated assumptions and stereotypes about the culture of the middle east that reflect uneven power relations, especially in the context of imperialism & colonialism. Style of thought upon ontological (ways of being) and epistemological (ways of knowing) distinctions between the orrient (east) and the occident (west).
Discourse tends to be “stuck in time.” No matter if the middle east is portrayed 1000 years ago or only 20, its viewed as mysterious, exotic, and stuck in a pre-modern era.
Who played a major role in stopping the usage of the “orrient?”
Edward Said. Described the term as the corporate institution for “dealing” with the orrient by making statements, describing, authorizng views, and ruling over it. Western style for dominating and restructuring them.
Hegemony
Said: “Soft” forms of power mediated through culture.
Binaries in the Portrayal of the East
WEST vs EAST: Democratic vs Despotic, Gender Equality vs Repression of Women, Evolving vs Static. Inconsistencies in reality.
Forcing a cradle problem
The orient is the source of Europe’s richest colonies, origins of civilization in language, etc. Europe tries to force themselves as the cradle of civilization, and/or force the idea that civilization started in areas that have a direct correspondent to Europe (fertile crescent, Egypt, etc.)
Israel & the Middle East idea
Even though seen as Western now, they were subject to 19th century orrientalism constructions — especially Arab (Mizrahi) Jews. Antisemitism and orrientalism tied together in this way.
European Judaism: the orriental “other” at home.
King Hammurami of Babylon (1792 - 1750 BCE)
Created steels with “legal cases” set up in temples. Myth that these laws were rigid and strictly enforced.
2 Types of Legal Texts
Records of legal cases (not chisled into stone)
Royal monumens of “if, then” statements
What were legal texts typically depicting in Mespotamia?
Contracts, records of court proceedings, royal editcts (cancellation of debts, remission).
Law Codes
NOT LAW. Glorifies king as a “just” ruler. Doesn’t reflect actual practice, rather, lists “cases” that reflects idealized justice. Even when the codes are applicable, there is little to no evidence they were actually used in a ruling. (Used normal imprisonment and fines).
Hammurabi’s Code reflects this idea rather than actual law.
Poetic Justice
A literary device in which bad deeds are punished in a fitting way. “eye for an eye.”
Royal Law Codes
First known example from the UR III period (2100 BCE), Hammurabi joins the list of kings expressing this idealized justice by issuing binding legal proclamations (NOT in the steele) and sponsoring monuments that reflect idealized justice (like the steele).
Hammurabi’s Steele (1754 BCE, Babylon)
Apperance of Shamash (mespotamian god of Justice) and the symbol of kingship, but he isn’t taking the symbol from the god. Rather, he already has the cap on showing that he already comes from an ancient line of kings. Horned helmet and rays of light.
Shows the king as an agent of divine justice — using it as a tool for propaganda to justify his rule.
Tens of thousands of clay tablets from this time survived, none of which mention the importance or use of the steele.
Elaborates the principle of poetic justice.

How does Hammurabi’s Steele use Poetic Justice to work on multiple levels?
Academic — Scribes comes up with extreme cases, which are copied by scribes for 1.5k years
Religious — Impress gods with the justice, as the main audience IS the gods
Social — If displayed in public, shows hammurabi as a just ruler with fair punishments.
True or False: Hammurabi’s Steele reflects a development of civilization as the world’s first comprehensive set of laws.
FALSE. Not laws and not the first.
Why does the myth of Hammurabi’s Steele still exist?
Feels true because of the orrientalist narrative.
Fits into other negative stereotypes aout the middle east. Direct literary tradition from Hammurabi to “legal” texts in the Jewish bible. Similar themes of poetic justice (idealized). Raises questions about whether all legal texts from this time were real or idealized. Creates characterizations about Judiasm as a brutal god vs christian as a positive god. Thus, the brutal nature of hammurabi’s laws feel true bc they reflect antisemitic beliefs engrained in society.
Long tradition of islamiphobia and antisemitism through orrientalist discourse.
General Trends of Eras in Ancient Egypt
Alternation of kingdoms to periods. Intermediate periods are reflected by decentralization, multiple claimed kings. Old, middle, new kingdoms are dominate centralized power.
Old Kingdom Egypt (2600 - 2100 BCE)
Hieroglyphic writing was already well-developed, and the pyramids at Giza were constructed in this period, including pyramids for Pharaohs Sneferu (grandfather), Khufu (father) and Khafre (son). Overlaps with Early Dynastic Period (2900 - 2350).
Environment & The “Two Lands”
Monsoon rains drench Ethopian highlands, which floods egypt annually, depositng a fertile nutrient-rich soil. If too high, the settlement is flooded, but too low means not enough cultivated land — not enough food.
Upper Egypt: Nile (rich) valley surrounded by desert (red land). More south.
Lower Egypt: Delta = marshy, changing environment (black land = egypt). More north.
How was the material transported to build the pyramids?
Cut limestone with sand, using the copper saw as a guide to move the quartz sand to cut the stone.
Limestone blocks were moved by pouring water on the ground, allowing them to be dragged through the sand.
Tiers of people in the Pyramid Town of Giza (Old Kingdom)
Unskilled Brute Labor (regular egyptians)
Corvee Labor - Required by the state to work for 2-3 months, then go home. Complusory and forced, but not technically slavery. Moreso a “tax” rather than a traditional $ tax.
Skilled Workers
Lived here full time and had families, with a population of about 150k total people, 20-25k of them being the working pop.
Evidence of higher social status people (such as priests) getting out (negotiating) of service, arguing that they’re needed elsewhere for the betterment of the general population.
Workers.. well fed?
Bread and beer formed the basis of the workers diet. However, strong evidence of mass slaughtering of animals, suggesting an inclusion of meat in the diet as well… even though its considered a luxury good (ususally).
True or False: There was a large focus on administration at Giza.
TRUE! People were hired specifically to keep track of rations (payment for work with food) and progress of the pyramid construction.
Pyramid of Khufu
Old Kingdom, Giza (2550 BCE)
Constructed as a royal tomb, covered in smooth limestone to reflect the Pharoh’s power and connection to the gods.
Includes boat chambers at the sides, so the king can go travel in the afterlife.
Pyramid demonstrates advanced engineering, centralized government, and religious beliefs about death during the height of the Old Kingdom power.

New Kingdom Egypt (1600 - 1100 BCE)
Egypt at the height of its prosperity, becoming a superpower in the international system of the period, and at the peak, controlled as far north as the syrian coast.
Akhenaten and the city of Armana (1352 - 1336 BCE)
New kingdom leader, want to expand egypt and create vassal states — earning incredible wealth.
Aten, The Sun Disk
Introduces new religous ideas, seemingly coming from Akhenaten himself. Abandonment of traditional religious beliefs and polytheistic god system.
Doesn’t come from the people, leading them to completely scratch Amarna from Egyptian history post-Akhenaten
Political Context of Thebes
Current central city filled with priests to another god. Religious and political capital against king, so he builds Amarna.
What changes (other than introduction of monotheism) does Akhenaten bring to Egypt?
Changes his name TO Akhenaten (names extremely important)
Changes the style of statues to represent a new era. Common practice to represent change through art. Elongated face, narrow shoulders, wider hips, blend of masculine and feminine ideals.
Changes royal residence to Amarna over Thebes

Why is Amarna perfect to analyze?
The city was built on previously untouched land, allowing us to analyze it perfectly with that time only as it was abandoned only a few years after death of Akhenaten.
True or False: Temples for Aten didn’t have roofs
TRUE! Not represented by a statue, offerings just piled up. Other gods were physically chisled out of art.
Difference of workers in Amarna vs Giza
Workers in Amarna relied on a child labor force, extemely malnourished. Inconsiderate, not traditional burial practices go against honor.
What was the purpose of Egyptian Monumental Architecture (Pyramids)? (Giza, 2600 BCE)
Served as royal tombs and formed as part of a larger religious and economic complex connecting dead king to living society. For example, boats were buried on the sides of the pyramids to allow for the king to travel in the afterlife.
In Amarna, Akhenate used architecture to express his vision centered on Aten and establish his city based on his authority.

Plaque showing Akhenaten and Nefertiti under the Aten
New Kingdom Egypt, at Armana (around 1350 BCE)
Aten, the sun disk, gives sun rays highlighting how Aten is the “giver of life” to the royal family and reflects the overall shift in Amarna to worshipping Aten.
Represents the interconnectedness with religion and Egypt, and how engrained it is in society.

Old Assyrian Period (2000 - 1700 BCE)
Originally a city-state, closest place that approached a democracy in Mespotamia. City council drew lotts for symbolic 1 year term presidential role.
Middle Assyrian Period (1550 - 1000 BCE)
As they grew and developed, they saw other places and decided to build an empire for better trade potential.
Neo-Assyrian Period (900 - 600 BCE)
Became the first state to rule the area extending from the gulf to the mediteranian sea. Three main leaders.
Assur: The patron deity of Assyria and its historical capital.
Ashurnasirpal II (883–859 BCE)
First Neo-Assyrian king to reach the Mediterranean.
○ Moved palace from Assur to Nimrud (Kalhu)
Establishes a legacy for the Assyrians in centuries future, building a new Assyrian capital.
Shalmaneser III (858–824 BCE)
○ Continues expansion of empire
○ Receives tribute from kings of Ancient Israel, Damascus, and kings of the “Land of the Arabs”
Tribute
Comes in two forms. One, being typially raw materials as a form of tax to a dominant power. Second, a luxury item as a cermonial gift to express allegiance.
Ashurbanipal (668–631 BCE)
Famous for collection of tablets (“library”) at 7th-century capital, Nineveh
Provinces vs Clients (“Vassals”)
Direct Assyrian rule after conquered, reorganize gov. and deport people vs Taxes paid to Assyria with an annual visit from local emissaries to capital, otherwise completely independent (hands off approach).
Assyrians prefer to start with client style because its a lot cheaper. Provinces can take up to 10 years and 3 rebellions to finally throw over.
True or False: There was an extreme importance of infrastructure development
TRUE! The royal road development was crucial infrastructure. Building towns along the road allows for going full speed all day and switching out horses.
The Importance of the Capital Nimrud (Ashurnarsipal II, 850 BCE)
Host foreign emissaries annually as part of tribute ceremonies with lavish parties with gifts for foreigners, as well as palace and art tours.
Specifically designed to cultivate feelings of awe for submission to Assyria
How was the palace used as propaganda technique?
The palace was built with cedae and other far away foreign materials, which would only be found where the foreign emissaries live, which makes them feel at home, invited, and impressed.
During the ceremonies, they will also scent the palace like home, wear their traditional clothing, and eat things like their home all for tribute to them.. while they’re here for tribute to Assyria
Banquet Steele (850 BCE)
Depictions of diverse foreigners and tribute in palace reliefs and monuments — exotic animals, clothing, precious metals. Annual tribute delievering ceremony, as well as imagery of the local gods giving to Assur (main patron deity).

What was the significance of Babylon to the Assyrian Empire?
Despite the lack of interntional prominence at this time, the city still remained a cruicial cultural center and was incorporated into the Assyrian empire.
In 610 BCE, they revolted and retook the city, which created the start of the Neo-Babylonian Empire (610 - 540 BCE)
The Dead Sea Scrolls (200 BCE - 100 CE)
The oldest copies of stories that exist in the Jewish bible, found in 1947 in caves above the dead sea. Contains about 15,000 writings from early Jewish groups, with a mix of some stories that were eventually included in the Bible, in addition to many other religious writings.

Kuntillet Ajrud (800 BCE)
First time the Hebrew language was first documented in record. Controlled by ancient Israel. Shows that at the time, Israel was NOT monotheistic, with mutiple gods such as YHWH (patron god of Judah & Israel) and Baal.

The Takeway from Israel (circa 800 BCE)
Earliest mention isn’t until 1200 BCE (2,000 years AFTER invention of writing), and Hebrew wasn’t a written language until 800 BCE. Ancient Israel and Judah have patron god YHWH, and they’re polytheistic.