1/103
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Lady Justice: what does the scale mean?
Two sides to every story. Hear both sides, because you're innocent until proven guilty.
Lady Justice: what does the blindfold mean?
Justice is blind: no bias, no favoritism.
Lady Justice: what does the sword mean?
Enforcement. The power to lay down the law, including putting you in jail.
Why do business students study law? (3 reasons)
1) Builds basic legal vocabulary 2) Lets you identify potential legal liability 3) Informs business decisions. It keeps your company out of expensive litigation and helps you spot when others aren't following the law.
What 3 things does an efficient market need?
Law, Rule of Law, Property.
Definition of law
Rules established by the state and enforced and backed by formal social force. Adequate enforcement institutions are necessary to maintain order in society.
What happens without laws in place?
People spend more time protecting what they have instead of developing it.
Rule of Law
Laws that are made are generally and equally applicable. The law applies to EVERYONE the same way.
Why does the Rule of Law matter economically?
Well-functioning market and economic growth. Almost all wealthy countries embrace it.
World Justice Project: 4 principles of the Rule of Law
1) Accountability 2) Clear, publicized, stable, and just laws 3) Process for enacting, administering, and enforcing laws is accessible, fair, and efficient 4) Justice delivered in a timely manner
Property (legal definition)
A legal right that allows you to exclude others from your resources.
Why do property rights matter to business? (3 points)
Without the exclusionary right, business comes to a standstill. It is the basis for the private market and modern business. It gives incentive to develop resources you own.
Common law: what does it emphasize?
The role of judges in determining the meaning of laws and how they apply.
Which legal system does the U.S. follow, and what is the exception?
Common law. The exception is Louisiana (civil law).
Stare decisis
"Let the prior decision stand." Judges follow precedent whenever possible, which ensures certainty, stability, and predictability in the law.
Pros of common law (2)
1) Laws can be concise 2) Stare decisis
Cons of common law (4)
1) Volume of cases 2) Conflicting precedents 3) Holding vs. dicta distinction makes precedent harder to determine 4) Rejection of precedent / bad precedent
Holding vs. dicta
Holding = the part of the opinion necessary to decide the case (the real precedent). Dicta = extra comments that aren't needed to decide it.
When can a court reject precedent?
When it believes the case was wrongly decided or times have changed.
How hard is it to overturn a Supreme Court precedent?
You must persuade 5 of 9 justices that the earlier decision was wrong AND harmful. It's rare because frequent change means nobody can plan their lives.
Overturning precedent: classic example
Brown v. Board of Education overturned Plessy v. Ferguson (unanimous).
Civil law system (the legal system, not civil vs. criminal)
Relies more on legislation than judicial decisions. Judges do NOT make law and do NOT feel obligated to follow prior decisions.
Common law vs. civil law: who makes the law?
Common law = judges (precedent). Civil law = legislatures (legislation).
Public law
Regulation of society; government represents society. Includes constitutional, administrative, and criminal law.
Private law
Regulation of private resources. Includes property, contract, and tort law.
Memory trick: public vs. private law lists
Public = C.A.C. (Constitutional, Administrative, Criminal). Private = P.C.T. (Property, Contract, Tort).
Civil law (vs. criminal): who sues and what is the sanction?
An individual sues for damages or other relief. Sanction = damages. Examples: breach of contract, tort.
Criminal law: who sues and what are the sanctions?
Government brings suit to prove a wrong against society. Sanctions: death, imprisonment, fines, removal from office, disqualification from voting or holding office. Examples: robbery, conspiracy.
Civil vs. criminal: quick test
Who brings the suit? Individual = civil (damages). Government = criminal (punishment).
Substantive law
Defines the legal relationships between people, or between people and the state. Defines rights and duties.
Procedural law
The method and means by which substantive law is made and administered. Provides the machinery for enforcing rights and duties (e.g., time allowed to sue, rules of the lawsuit process).
Substantive vs. procedural: quick test
Substantive = "What are my rights and duties?" Procedural = "HOW do I enforce them?"
Texting driver hits pedestrian: substantive law?
Pedestrian's right to cross the street without being hit. Driver's duty to drive with care (not on his phone).
Texting driver hits pedestrian: procedural law?
Suing on time (statute of limitations), what evidence is allowed at trial, which court has jurisdiction.
Sources of federal law (3)
U.S. Constitution, legislation passed by Congress, administrative law.
Supremacy of the U.S. Constitution
It is the supreme law of the nation. Any federal or state law that conflicts with it is void and has no legal effect.
Sources of state law (3)
State constitution; statutes or acts adopted by the state legislature (e.g., Commercial Code / UCC); regulations of state administrative agencies.
Case law (judicial decisions)
Decisions of judges.
Opinion
A judge's written decision. It becomes precedent for future cases.
Precedent
A prior judicial decision relied upon as an example of a rule of law.
Citation
The reference identifying how to find a case.
Decode: 675 F.3d 23 (2014)
Volume 675 of the Federal Reporter, 3rd edition, page 23, decided in 2014.
Decode: Brown v. Board of Education, 347 U.S. 483 (1954)
347 = volume number. U.S. = reporter abbreviation. 483 = page where the case begins. 1954 = year decided.
Sources of law hierarchy (top to bottom)
1) U.S. Constitution 2) Statutes of Congress 3) Federal administrative regulation 4) State constitutions 5) State statutes 6) State administrative regulation 7) Local ordinances 8) Case law
Memory trick for the hierarchy
Federal, then State, then Local, then Case law. Within each level the order is Constitution > Statute > Regulation.
3 groups of court personnel
Judges and Justices, Jurors, Lawyers.
Judge vs. Justice
People who operate courts are Judges. Members of the U.S. Supreme Court are Justices (there are 9).
Current U.S. Supreme Court Justices (9)
Roberts (Chief), Thomas, Alito, Sotomayor, Kagan, Gorsuch, Kavanaugh, Barrett, Jackson.
Most recently sworn-in Justice
Ketanji Brown Jackson.
Justice Clarence Thomas: Georgia fact
Born in Georgia.
How is a Supreme Court Justice chosen?
The President appoints federal judges, including Justices, subject to the advice and consent of the U.S. Senate.
Business and Chief Justice Roberts (per class notes)
Class takeaway: businesses should feel confident, because the numbers are steadily declining in favor of the companies.
Trial court judge: role (5 duties)
Determine applicable rules of law; observe; apply constitutional limitations and guarantees; determine what evidence is admissible; find facts when a jury trial is waived.
Appellate judge/justice: role
Decide an appeal and give reasons. The decision becomes precedent. Must consider how it affects the law as a whole. Studies briefs, the record of proceedings, and the law.
Issue of fact vs. issue of law
Fact = what actually happened ("Did X occur?"). Law = how the law is interpreted or applied (e.g., if Joe killed Sarah, is he liable? Self-defense?).
Trial court vs. appellate court: what do they decide?
Trial court = issues of FACT and LAW. Appellate court = ONLY issues of LAW.
Georgia jury duty eligibility (8 requirements)
U.S. citizen; 18 years old; proficient in English; resident of the summoning county; no jury service in the last 12 months; not on a grand jury or another trial jury; not under conservatorship; civil rights restored if convicted of a felony.
Jury: role
Fact-finding body. Trial by jury is guaranteed by the Bill of Rights.
Petit jury
Trial jury that returns a verdict in criminal and civil cases. Consists of 12 persons, but smaller juries are acceptable (many are 6). Normally requires a unanimous decision.
Ramos v. Louisiana
Supreme Court: the verdict must be unanimous in SERIOUS CRIMINAL cases (even though the textbook says some states dropped unanimity).
Lawyers: role
Representative advocates in the court system. Present evidence, points of law, and arguments. Help juries and judges decide. Primary duty is to the administration and promotion of justice.
Attorney-client privilege
Forbids a lawyer from revealing confidential facts and from testifying against a client. Extends to the lawyer's employees.
Court system organization (3 levels)
Supreme Court, Appellate Court, Trial Court.
Jurisdiction
The power of a court (state or federal) to hear a case.
Subject matter jurisdiction
Power over the ISSUES involved in a case. Any court MUST have it to hear a case.
General vs. limited jurisdiction
General = power to hear ANY type of case. Limited = power to hear only certain types of cases.
What can limit a court's jurisdiction? Examples?
Subject matter, amount in controversy, or where the parties live. Examples: probate court, traffic court, juvenile court.
3 types of state courts
Supreme Court, Court of Appeals, Trial Courts.
What creates and governs state court systems?
State constitutions, the state legislature, other legislation.
State trial courts
Initial court for filing lawsuits to protect property rights or redress a wrong. Also called Superior, Circuit, or District Court. Determines both facts and law.
State appellate courts
Review results of lower courts. Procedural law must be followed to be granted an appeal. Concerned with questions of law. Some states have 1 appellate court; others have 2 (intermediate Court of Appeals and court of final resort, the Supreme Court).
Writ of certiorari
Procedure for requesting Supreme Court review. It is a 2nd review, and less than 5% of requests are granted.
3 types of federal courts
U.S. Supreme Court, Courts of Appeals (12 circuits), District Courts.
Article III: what federal cases have subject matter jurisdiction? (4)
1) Federal question cases (Constitution or federal statutes) 2) Cases where the U.S. is a party 3) Controversies among the states 4) Diversity of citizenship
Federal question cases
Cases involving U.S. Constitution issues or federal statutes. No dollar limit.
Diversity of citizenship: requirements
Plaintiffs and defendants are citizens of DIFFERENT states AND each claim is for MORE than $75,000.
Why does diversity jurisdiction exist?
To guard against state court bias against the non-resident party.
Diversity: corporation's citizenship
Citizen of BOTH its state of incorporation AND the state of its principal place of business.
Diversity: partnership's citizenship
Based on the citizenship of ALL of its members.
Class example: Mark (hit by company car) sues David and David's employer for $500,000. Federal subject matter jurisdiction?
NO. Plaintiff and defendant are from the same state (the employer's principal place of business matches Mark's state). Mark could sue David alone, since their citizenships differ.
Scenario: GA plaintiff sues FL defendant for $60,000, no federal law involved. Federal court?
NO. Different states, but the claim doesn't exceed $75,000.
Scenario: GA plaintiff sues FL defendant for $5,000 under a federal statute. Federal court?
YES. It's a federal question case, which has no dollar limit.
Federal district courts
Trial courts of the federal system. At least one in every state and D.C. The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure give the details of federal litigation procedure.
Federal appellate courts: how many?
13 Courts of Appeal: 12 U.S. Courts of Appeals plus 1 Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit hears appeals from…
Special courts and administrative decisions (per your notes).
Special courts
Created to handle special subject matter. Example: Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces.
3 levels of the court system
Trial Court, Appellate Court, Supreme Court.
How does the U.S. Supreme Court take a case?
Petition for a Writ of Certiorari. Discretionary, NOT a matter of right. Granted primarily for cases of substantial federal importance (major constitutional issues or interpretation of federal law).
Rule of 4
4 out of 9 Justices must agree to take a case.
Supreme Court review volume
More than 7,000 requests for review per year.
Can the U.S. Supreme Court review a state supreme court decision?
Yes, final judgments of the highest state court are reviewed ONLY by the U.S. Supreme Court, and it must involve a federal question.
Example: Susan loses in the Illinois Supreme Court and petitions the U.S. Supreme Court
She files a petition for a writ of certiorari. The Court can hear it only if a federal question is involved, and it has discretion to say no.
Judicial review
The ultimate power of the courts to invalidate actions by the executive branch (President) or the legislative branch (Congress).
Case that announced judicial review
Marbury v. Madison (1803).
Marbury v. Madison famous line
"It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is."
Judicial restraint (conservative)
Use judicial review only in unusual cases. Follow precedent. Also called strict constructionism or judicial abstention. Look to original intent. Change should come from the political process, not courts. Historically the dominant philosophy.
Judicial activism (liberal)
Use judicial review when society's needs justify it. Courts should play a major role in correcting societal ills. Political process is too slow. Less reliance on precedent. Value oriented and policy directed. Constitution's meaning is relative to the times. 1950s/60s Supreme Court had an activist majority.
Restraint vs. activism: memory trick
Restraint = "Rein it in" (precedent, original intent, let legislators fix things). Activism = "Act now" (courts fix society, times change, precedent matters less).