1/379
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Meaning of Production — Majority vs. Minority Rule (x)
(x)
Majority Rule →
Requires actual production that is marketed (produced and sold).
Followed by
Texas → Stanolind v. Barnhill.
Minority Rule →
A well capable of producing may be sufficient, even if oil or gas is not actually being sold.
Followed by
· Oklahoma → Pack v. Santa Fe Minerals.
The habendum clause may be satisfied through
different production requirements depending on the jurisdiction:
Oklahoma — Discovery →
1. A well must actually discover oil or gas, but it does not necessarily have to produce and sell it.
Mixed Approach — Oil vs. Gas →
1. Oil must be produced and sold, but a gas well may only need to be capable of producing.
Texas — Actual Production →
1. Both oil and gas must be produced and sold. Having a well capable of producing is not enough unless a shut-in royalty clause or another exception applies.
Discovery →
A well has actually been drilled and oil or gas discovered, not merely geological evidence suggesting minerals might exist.
Shut-in well →
A well capable of producing in paying quantities but temporarily not producing.
The well must be turnkey →
Capable of producing immediately, essentially by turning it on.
A well cannot qualify merely because it might become
productive after additional drilling, installation of casing, or other substantial work.
Both majority and minority approaches require a genuinely
capable well when relying on shut-in production.
Texas → Generally requires
actual production and marketing unless a shut-in royalty clause or other exception applies.
Oklahoma → May allow the lease to continue based on
the well's present capability to produce, even when it is shut in.
Example → A Texas lease has a 5-year primary term. Before it expires, the lessee drills a gas well capable of producing in paying quantities but shuts it in because no pipeline exists. (x)
(x)
If the well is turnkey and the lessee satisfies the shut-in royalty clause, the lease
· continues into the secondary term through constructive production.
Otherwise, it generally
· expires absent another applicable exception.
Important Distinction — Cessation of Production vs. Production in Paying Quantities (x)
(x)
These are two different questions about maintaining a lease during
the secondary term.
Cessation of Production (Stanolind and Pack) → What happens when production stops?
· Texas generally enforces the production requirement, subject to applicable exceptions, while Oklahoma may consider whether the interruption was justified.
Production in Paying Quantities (Clifton v. Koontz) → What happens when a well produces but makes little money or loses money?
· Texas applies the two-step test to determine whether production is sufficient to maintain the lease.
No production raises a
cessation-of-production issue;
marginal or unprofitable production raises a
production-in-paying-quantities issue.
. These concepts can overlap but are separate legal questions. (x)
(x)
Habendum clause → May expressly require production in
paying quantities.
Even when the language is absent, the requirement is implied in many states
(including Texas), but not all (e.g., Mississippi).
→ Production in paying quantities =
Production in commercial quantities.
→ A commercially meaningful quantity would be enough to
interest a purchaser in entering into a contract to take the production.
Different states have different approaches to deciding whether a well produces in paying quantities. (X)
(x)
Lessee's subjective view →
1. Whether the lessee personally considers continued production worthwhile.
Generally favors the lessee because the decision depends heavily on
the lessee's own judgment.
Objective view (most common) →
Whether continued operation would be marginally profitable to a reasonably prudent operator.
Focuses on commercial reasonableness rather than the lessee's
personal preferences (the oil company does not decide for itself).
Sufficient to compensate the lessor →
1. Whether the landowner receives enough royalties to justify keeping the lease in effect.
Calculating Production in Paying Quantities
Courts must determine three things:
1. Costs → How much does it cost to operate the well?
2. Revenues → How much money does the well generate?
3. Time → Over what period should profitability be measured?
Disputes frequently arise over which
expenses and revenues should count.
Lessee →
Wants to include more revenue and fewer costs to show the well is profitable (retain lease).
Lessor →
Emphasizes costs and challenges revenue calculations to show the well is unprofitable (terminate lease).
Operating costs may include:
· Repairs
· Wages
· Utilities
· Other direct operating expenses (x)
(x)
Disputed costs →
Courts must decide whether these expenses count when calculating how much it costs to operate the well:
· Depreciation, overhead, and abandonment expenses.
· Overriding royalties.
· Production taxes. (x)
(x)
Example → Overhead expenses are costs shared by multiple wells (e.g., 10 wells managed by one office). (x)
(x)
Courts must decide how much of those costs count when
determining whether a particular well is profitable.
Operating revenues →
Money earned from oil or gas production, not the money originally invested in drilling the well.
Take-or-Pay Contracts (x)
(x)
Take-or-pay clause →
Provision in a gas purchase contract requiring the purchaser to pay for a specified quantity of production even if the purchaser does not actually take delivery.
Example → A pipeline company cannot take 100 units of gas but must still pay for 50 under a take-or-pay clause. (x)
(x)
→ Payment arises from the purchase contract rather than
actual sale and delivery.
Legal question → Should that contractual payment count as
revenue when determining whether the well produces in paying quantities?
Lessee →
Yes, because it increases the company's income (higher revenue makes the well look profitable).
Lessor →
· No, because it is contractual compensation rather than revenue generated by actual production.
Another example → A purchaser may pay a producer to terminate a gas purchase contract. Courts must decide whether this counts as production revenue, even though no gas was sold.
· Oil company earns $5,000 selling gas.
· Pipeline company pays another $10,000 to cancel the contract.
· Oil company wants to count $15,000 as revenue to prove the well produces in paying quantities and keep the lease alive. (x)
(x)
Reasonable time period →
Generally one year, but not a rigid requirement. The period may be longer or shorter.
Step 1 —
Financial Test (Litmus Test)
Rule →
Have operating revenues exceeded operating costs over a reasonable period of time?
Operating Costs < Operating Revenues (x)
(x)
If yes → The well produces in paying quantities and
the lease is maintained.
If no →
· Proceed to Step 2 (reasonably prudent operator test).
In the black" →
· Revenues exceed costs; the well is profitable.
"In the red" →
· Costs exceed revenues; the well is unprofitable.
Determining the correct revenues and expenses can be complicated. (x)
(x)
Even a small profit may satisfy
step 1
A profit of half a penny is
sufficient
there is no requirement that the lessee make a
substantial profit
Step 2 — Reasonably Prudent Operator Test (Texas) (x)
(x)
If the well fails Step 1, the lease does not necessarily
terminate
Court applies →
Reasonably prudent operator (RPO) standard.
Rule →
Would a reasonable and prudent operator, motivated by profit rather than speculation, nevertheless continue operating the lease in the manner in which it is being operated?
Lessee may continue operating an unprofitable well if there is a
reasonable expectation of future profitability.
However, the lessee cannot justify continued operation merely by
· wanting to hold the lease for speculative purposes.
If the well fails both Step 1 and Step 2, it is not producing in
paying quantities, and the lease generally terminates during the secondary term unless an applicable exception exists.
The two-step test generally favors lessees because
it allows marginal wells to continue operating rather than forcing abandonment.
Stripper wells →
Wells that produce very small quantities of oil or gas, sometimes only a few barrels per week.
A stripper well CAN produce in paying quantities →
· If profitable, even by one cent.
Not all stripper wells produce in paying quantities →
· Some lose money and may fail both steps.
If the lease terminates, the well may be
· plugged and abandoned (P&A).
Once plugged and abandoned the well is rarely
reopened or re-drilled.
Sunk Costs Example:
· Company spends $10 million drilling a well, expecting $100 million in production.
· Well only contains $5 million worth of recoverable oil or gas.
· Sunk cost → Money already spent that cannot be recovered (the $10 million spent drilling).
· Company may still reasonably produce the $5 million rather than abandon the well. (x)
(x)
A reasonable operator may continue producing despite
an unsuccessful initial investment because it can still recover some money.
Clifton v. Koontz (Texas). Facts:
Facts:
· Lessors sought to cancel the lease for lack of production in paying quantities.
· Income: $3,250; expenses: $3,466 → Loss of $216.
· Lessee reworked the well (operations to improve production), increasing production by 1,800%.
· Lease contained a 60-day cessation-of-production clause, but the interruption exceeded 60 days.
Court's Analysis:
Step 1:
Step 2:
→ Failed because operating expenses exceeded revenues.
→ Satisfied because the lessee took reasonable steps to improve production and had a reasonable basis to expect profitable returns.
The court examined the well's revenues and operating costs over more than one year because the lessee needed
time to plan and rework the well to improve production.
→ Rule: A well that fails the financial test may nevertheless
satisfy production in paying quantities if a reasonably prudent operator, motivated by profit rather than speculation, would continue operating it.
Shut-in royalty →
Another method of achieving constructive production during the secondary term (the other method discussed was the cessation-of-production clause).
Allows the lease to remain effective when a well is capable of producing in paying quantities but is
· shut in rather than actively producing.
Clause typically requires payment to
the lessor
Usually paid annually (some clauses require seasonal or
monthly payments
Often nominal in amount, depending on
the lease
Wording of the shut-in royalty clause is
extremely important
Whether failure to pay shut-in royalties terminates the lease depends on what the lease defines as
constructive production.
Shut-In Well =
Constructive Production (Payment Is a Covenant)
A well capable of producing in paying quantities keeps
the lease alive
Payment is a separate
promise (covenant)
Failure to pay →
Breach of covenant, but lease does not automatically terminate.
Proper Payment =
Constructive Production (Payment Is a Condition)
Paying the shut-in royalty is what keeps the
lease alive
Failure to pay properly or on time →
Lease may automatically terminate.
Similar to an
unless" delay rental clause.