1/17
Looks like no tags are added yet.
central argument
The Navajo Nation must incorporate traditional Diné values, laws, and legal principles into its contemporary government and judicial system to preserve its identity, sovereignty, and culture.
imbalance in navajo law
the Navajo Nation's legal system became heavily influenced by Anglo-American law.
Problems included:
Much of the Navajo Nation Code was based on Western legal models.
Navajo customs, traditions, language, and culture were rarely incorporated into written legislation.
Why was this a problem?
Western-style litigation was often incompatible with traditional Navajo approaches to justice.
4 main concerns identified
The adversarial system could not resolve certain community problems.
Western adjudication was expensive and time-consuming.
Navajo litigants found Western procedures confusing and frustrating.
Confrontational litigation contradicted traditional approaches based on talking things out and reaching consensus.
solution
Traditional Diné values and legal principles needed to play a greater role in Navajo government and courts.
Diné Bibee Haz'áanii and Fundamental Laws
refers to traditional Navajo values, norms, customs, and traditions passed down orally through generations.
Austin explains that Navajo common law can be found through:
Navajo Nation court decisions.
The Navajo Reporter.
The Indian Law Reporter.
Legal and non-legal literature about Navajo culture.
Oral teachings and traditional knowledge.
Important case: Ben v. Burbank
The Navajo Nation Supreme Court used the doctrine of k'é to reject the argument that the limitation period had expired on an oral contract claim.
This demonstrates that Navajo common law can change or override the outcome that might otherwise be expected under Anglo-American law.
Important case: In re Estate of Belone
The Supreme Court established requirements for using Navajo custom in court.
3 important principles
Pleading: The party relying on Navajo custom must identify the custom and explain how it supports their claim.
Sources: Navajo common law can be established through oral sources, court decisions, legal opinions, and literature about Navajo culture.
Expert witnesses: Custom can be proven through qualified expert witnesses.
K'é is an important principle connected to kinship and relationships.
The Navajo judicial system encourages judges to treat litigants as relatives.
This means the justice system should emphasize:
Respect.
Maintaining harmony.
Establishing order.
Bilagáana law
refers to Anglo-American or non-Navajo law.
The rule
Anglo-American law can only be adopted when it is compatible with fundamental Navajo values.
This means:
Navajo courts must consider traditional Diné principles first.
Outside legal principles are not automatically accepted.
Foreign laws must be evaluated to determine whether they fit Navajo values and community needs.
Naat'ááh Nabik'íyáti' – Participatory democracy
The principle that people as a whole have the ability and right to participate in making laws and decisions affecting their communities.
Case: Rough Rock Community School v. Navajo Nation
The court considered whether the Education Committee had properly consulted local school boards before preparing an election apportionment plan.
The court found that the committee had failed to follow the requirements of k'é and participatory democracy.
Community free speech
Introduced in Judy v. White.
Focuses on the community's collective voice.
Recognizes that the community has an interest in expressing its views.
Can give citizens legal standing to challenge government decisions.
individual free speech
Discussed in Navajo Nation v. Crockett.
Three employees were fired after disclosing confidential business records and raising concerns about misconduct.
They argued that their free speech rights had been violated.
The court found that their rights were violated under the circumstances because they raised concerns about safety, interference, and misconduct.