1/25
Looks like no tags are added yet.
If the fact pattern shows…
Federal law conflicting with state law
Limits on state power —> Preemption/Supremacy Clause
Federal Preemption (express vs. implied)
Express
When congress has legislated in the area, federal law may preempt state. (United v. Camden, PG&E)
Implied
Field (federal gov occupies the field)
Conflict (physically impossible to comply with both state and federal law)
If the fact pattern shows…
Judicial review
Judicial power —> Article III / Supremacy Clause
Judicial Review (federal vs. state)
Federal
The supreme court has the power to review/overrule federal courts, and declare federal laws unconstitutional
Marbury v madison
State
Federal courts have the power to review/overrule state court decisions, and declare state laws unconstitutional
Martin v hunters lessee
If the fact pattern shows…
State law favoring its own residents/businesses
Dormant Commerce Clause Art. I, § 8, cl. 3
Dormant Commerce Power
“Congress has not acted, but can.” Congress has the power to step in when state laws interfere with interstate commerce. The court has determined that the court’s power to do this can be either economic or political.
Discriminatory
Neutral/protectionist
Disproportionate Adversity
If the fact pattern shows…
State treating out-of-state citizens differently
Privileges & Immunities Art. IV, § 2
Privileges & Immunities Clause
States cannot discriminate against (1) Out of state (2) Citizens.
Three step test to determine whether a state is liable for violating this rule
Three-step P&I Test
(1) whether discrimination existed
Does the state treat citizens of other states worse than its own citizens?
(2) whether the discrimination was reasonable
Does the discrimination reach a right bearing on interstate harmony and the nation as a single entity?
(3) whether there was a substantial relationship between the discrimination and the state’s objective
Does the state have a substantial relationship between the discrimination and objective? (considering the least restrictive means)
If the fact pattern shows…
Congress directing a state legislature to enact legislation
Limits on state power —> State regulation of house & Senate —> Anti-commandeering, 10th Amendment state immunity/ federal structure
State regulation of house & senate
States cannot add extra qualifications over federal offices
If the fact pattern shows…
Congress attaching conditions to federal funds
Legislative Power —> Taxing/Spending Clause Art. I, § 8, cl. 1 AND Necessary & Proper Clause Art. I, § 8, cl. 18
If the fact pattern shows…
Congress regulating private activity
Legislative Power —> Commerce —> Art. I, § 8, cl. 3
If the fact pattern shows…
President acting without clear congressional authorization
Executive Power —> Domestic Affairs(?) —> Separation of powers /Youngstown (Art. II)
Unitary Executive Theory
Art. 2 vests executive power in the president alone, so he must be allowed to appoint, direct, and remove the people who carry it out.
If the fact pattern shows…
President claiming immunity from prosecution
Executive Power —> Presidential immunity —> Four Protections
Four Protections (Presidential Immunity)
Core powers (absolute)
Other official acts
Unofficial conduct
Subpoena for president’s papers
to determine if an executive act is official or unofficial…
look at the nature of the act itself
If the fact pattern shows…
Bicameralism & Presentment
Limits on Executive Power —> Art. I, § 7
bicameralism context
bill passes thru both chambers of congress
presentment
after being passed by congress, bill is presented to President to either sign or veto (send back with revisions)
Clinton v. City of NY.
It’s unconstitutional for the president to “veto parts of the whole” bill/ line item veto (applies only to specific financial/tax/etc)
If the fact pattern shows…
Congress controlling how executive officials are appointed or removed
Limits on Executive Power —> Executive Officials —> Appointments Clause / removal power (Art. II, § 2)
Executive Official appointment/removal: Three-part test
Is it an executive officer, or just an employee?
Principal or inferior officer? (Morrisson)
Who may remove the officer? (Myers, Slaughter)
executive officer context
Officer position = outlined in law for set period (Lucia)
(In Lucia, ALJs were doing inferior executive officer activities but were not actually executive officers)
Function decides whether the power is executive or not (even if congress calls it an agent) (Bowsher)
Federal Reserve is an exception
Non-Article III courts are open
Principal/inferior officer context
Principal officer = appointed by president, consented by senate
Inferior officer = can be appointed by president alone, court, or dept. head