Torts Final

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/141

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

142 Terms

1
New cards

what is an intentional tort?

generally involve the worst, most reprehensible misconduct, but this doesn’t apply to every case. It’s referred to as “intentional” because the tortfeasor must intend something specific, subjectively, to trigger liability

2
New cards

what are the elements of an intentional tort?


a.     Act – requires voluntary act of defendant
b.     Intent – defendant has a certain mental state when they perform wrongful act

                            i.      Established if defendant desires that act will cause; or knowns that it is substantially certain the result will occur

1.     Actor does not need to intend the injury/consequence

                           ii.      Causation: defendant’s act or force set in motion by act causes plaintiff’s injury

Result must have been legally caused by the defendant’s act

3
New cards

what are the five intentional torts?

battery, assault, false imprisonment, trespass, and Intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED)

4
New cards

Battery

this is designed to protect our bodily integrity or our right to be free from certain unwanted physical contacts. It recognizes that we are entitled to some level of autonomy over our own bodies and provides redress where that autonomy is violated in certain ways.

5
New cards

Battery elements

1.     Intend the contact or act (intent)
2.     Harmful or offensive contact does occur
a.     Harmful results in physical injury, pain, or disfigurement
b.     Offensive: something a reasonable person would deem offensive
3.     With P body or something physically, intimately connected
a.     EX: D kicks P in the shin and P losses muscle mass and bone. D ordered to pay damages. Ct held b/c D intended to kick P, D was liable. They were in school and under school rules D was liable, they were not playing on playground or it would be different


6
New cards

Assault

requires someone to know about it; if you see it coming its assault & battery

7
New cards

Assault elements

1.     Intent (Desire/purpose or substantial certainty)
2.     Apprehension (or battery) – apprehension is NOT fear
3.     Imminent threat


8
New cards

Apprehension - Assault element

a.     You don’t have to see it; you can hear it. If the person is aware

                            i.      Assault requires the defendant’s voluntary action, an intent (desire or substantial certainty) to cause the victim to suffer apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact, and the victim must experience the reasonable or imminent apprehension of such contact. Assault occurs when the defendant intends to cause the plaintiff to believe he is about to be battered.

                           ii.      There must be REASONABLE apprehension

9
New cards

Imminent Threat - Assault Element

a.     A threat must be something that appears to be immediate (happening right now; has to be immediate contact)

                            i.      The D intended to cause apprehension of an imminent threat to the P

                           ii.      Looks at words and context; just words and no contact is not assault

Be coupled with overt action that is happening right then

10
New cards

Transfer of Intent

1.     Occurs when Defendant intends to commit a tort to one person, or one kind of tort, but ends up committing the tort, but ends up committing the tort against another person or a different type of tort


11
New cards

False Imprisonment elements

                i.         The Elements

1.     Intent (to confine)
2.     Confinement to bounded area
3.     Against Plaintiff’s will, AND
4.     Plaintiff is aware or injured


12
New cards

Confinement to bounded area - false imprisonment element

a.     Bounded in all directions
b.     Wrinkle - Reasonable means to escape does not constitute false imprisonment unless the victim must be heroic, endure excessive harassment, discomfort, or is unaware of confinement

Confinement, physical barriers, physical force threats (direct and indirect), duress, failure to provide means of escape, invalid use

13
New cards

Shopkeeper’s Privilege

1.     Owner or employee who honestly and reasonably believes someone stole can detain for a reasonable time to conduct a reasonable investigation


14
New cards

Shopkeeper’s Privilege “Elements”

a.     Honest and Reasonable Belief
b.     Reasonable Time
c.     Reasonable Investigation


15
New cards

Trespass

actionable invasion of interest in exclusive possession of land

16
New cards

Trespass to Land (Instrusion) Elements: D intentionally….

a.     Defendant enters land belonging to the Plaintiff, OR
b.     defendant intentionally causes something (or another person) to enter plaintiff’s land


17
New cards

Trespass to land info

                            i.      wrinkle - requisite intent is to enter the land (NOT to trespass)

1.     Good faith mistake is still tortious, doesn’t matter that you didn’t know

                           ii.      Even if you do not cause any damage at all, that is enough to say it is trespass and you can get nominal (symbolic damages saying the defendant didn’t follow the P’s rights) damages

2.     Protects possession of land & fixtures (real estate), so extends to leasehold interest, so is sufficient for a cause to action for trespass


18
New cards

Scope of Liability for Trespass to Land

a.     No foreseeability limitation
b.     Trespasser subject to liability for physical harm to possessor, his land, his things, to members of household, or their things, caused by act or condition created by trespasser
c.     Limits

                            i.      Harm must be caused by trespass, must occur during continuous of trespass

19
New cards

what are the two types of personal property intentional torts

Trespass to chattels and Conversion

20
New cards

Trespass to Chattels

A defendant commits a trespass to chattels (tangible personal property) if she intentionally interferes with the plaintiff’s right of possession by dispossessing the plaintiff of the chattel; OR using or intermeddling with the plaintiff’s chattel


21
New cards

Trespass to Chattels Elements

Intentionally interfered with property AND harmed the property

22
New cards

Intentionally Interfered with Property - Trespass to Chattels Element

                            i.      Intentional interference is some intended interaction with the property (“intermeddling”)

                           ii.      Good faith and mistaken identity is no excuse

                          iii.      Interfering with the right of possession or use of the chattel

1.     Can be disruption of service or functionality

2.     Can also be dispossession, physical contact, or unauthorized use

3.     Unauthorized digital contact or data interference

23
New cards

Harmed the Property - Trespass to Chattels Element

                            i.      Can be physical damage, deprivation of use for a substantial period of time, or impairment of the condition or quality of the chattel

1.     Not complete destruction

24
New cards

what are the 2 types of trespass to chattels?

dispossession and intermeddling

25
New cards

Dispossession - type of Trespass to Chattel

                            i.      Taking a chattel from the possession of another w/o the other’s consent, or

                           ii.      Obtaining possession of a chattel from another by fraud or duress, or

                          iii.      Barring the possessor’s access to a chattel, or

                          iv.      Destroying a chattel while it is in another’s possession

26
New cards

Intermeddling - type of Trespass to Chattel

                            i.      Meanings intentionally brining about a physical contact with the chattel, or

                           ii.      Acting on a chattel as intentionally to cause it to come in contact with some other object

1.     A chattel is impaired as to its condition, quality, or value, or

2.     The possessor is deprived of the use of the chattel for a substantial time, or

3.     Bodily harm is thereby caused to the possessor, or harm is caused to some person or thing in which the possessor has a legally protected interest

27
New cards

is dispossession higher than intermeddling?

yes

28
New cards

Conversion elements

Intentionally exercises dominion and control over the property AND

(Limited to tangible property unless it has scientific, literary, or artistic value

29
New cards

Conversion Info

1.     Good faith mistake can still result in liability
2.     Dominion and control and serious interference words
3.     Results in destruction or permanent dispossession
4.     “Forced sale” – damages = full value
5.     Judgment can be made with only nominal damages
6.     Where facts don’t justify requiring the D to pay full value, trespass to chattel is the proper claim


30
New cards

Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED) Elements

intentionally or recklessly engaged in extreme and outrageous behavior causing P to suffer severe emotional distress

31
New cards

Extreme and outrageous behavior - element to IIED

a.     To be outrageous, conduct must be so extreme as to go beyond all bounds of human decency
b.     Outrageous can come down to the subjectiveness of a community as it is circumstantial
c.     A pattern of behavior can bolster a claim of outrageous conduct

                            i.      Constant harassment and it is on-going

d.     The vulnerability of the victim and the relationship of the victim to the defendant is important

                            i.      Lower threshold where D knew P’s susceptibility and abuses it

                           ii.      Superior-subordinate relationship can be important

32
New cards

Severe emotional distress - element to IIED

a.     Based on the standard that it has to be so severe that no reasonable person could be expected to endure it
b.     Also has to be long-lasting and not fleeting


33
New cards

Restatement 2nd approach to IIED

bystander who witnesses must be present at the time, and must be immediate family member to recover if you do not have physical symptoms

34
New cards

Restatement 3nd approach to IIED

bystander must be family member who witnessed contemporaneously to recover (non-relatives cannot recover)

35
New cards

3rd party recovery for IIED requires P to show:

1.     Close relative of the victim
2.     Present at the scene of the outrageous conduct
3.     D knows the close relative is present and it a close relative


36
New cards

Defenses to Intentional Torts

A defendant has a privilege to use force against the plaintiff for the purpose of defending himself against the plaintiff’s unprivileged use of force if the defendant reasonably believes that the force is both necessary and proportionate to the force that the plaintiff is intentionally inflicting or about to inflict


37
New cards

what are the defenses to intentional torts?

consent, defense to self, other, and property

38
New cards

Consent defintion - Defense to Intentional Tort

Willingness in fact for conduct to occur

39
New cards

Consent info - Defense to Intentional Tort

                i.         It can be by action or inaction and does not need to be communicated to the actor

              ii.         Many courts see consent as an affirmative defense

             iii.         Applies to any intentional torts

             iv.         Even though the consent to contact results in injury, it does not invalidate consent (cause the D has to prove the defense)


40
New cards

what are the two types of consent?

express and implied

41
New cards

Express Consent - Defense to Intentional Tort

states in written or spoken words

42
New cards

Implied Consent - Defense to Intentional Tort

manifested through conduct/behavior

a.     Can be implied when under the circumstances the conduct of the individual reasonably conveys consent
b.     Consent is assumed to all ordinary contacts which are customary and reasonably necessary to the common intercourse of life, like a tap on the shoulder to get attention or a causal jostling to make passage


43
New cards

Actual v. Apparent Consent (2nd Restatement) - Defense to Intentional Tort

Actual consent – willingness manifested by action or inaction

Apparent consent – words or conduct reasonably understood by another to be intended as consent

44
New cards

Limitations to Consent - Defense to Intentional Tort

1.     P must have capacity to consent, consent must be voluntary, no action beyond scope of consent, cannot be by fraud or duress
a.     capacity (minors
b.     scope and conditional/restricted forms of consent


45
New cards

Mental Illness - defense for Intentional Tort

1.     NOT a defense; general rule that they are liable for intentional torts
2.     Policy justifications encourage caretakers to take responsibility and compensate innocent parties
3.     Consistent with infant liability
4.     A person must be capable of intent to commit an act


46
New cards

Self Defense - defense for Intentional Tort

1.     May occur when another’s misconduct constitutes a legitimate threat of harm to one’s body, and the law permits the use to cause harmful contacts to the source of our threat
2.     The basic test is whether the defendants use of force was necessary given all the attendant facts and circumstances
a.     It can be used for other intentional torts like assault, trespass, or false imprisonment
3.     Deadly force can be used if reasonable, but other actor must have threatened deadly force first


47
New cards

Elements to Self Defense - defense to intentional tort

a.     Defendant must honestly and reasonably believe there is a threat of imminent harm, AND
b.     Response must be proportionate/reasonable


48
New cards

Retreat to the wall v. Stand your ground for Self Defense - defense to intentional tort

Retreat to the wall – retreat where serious bodily injury or death would be otherwise required (modern approach)

Stand your ground – no requirement of retreat with assumption there is a legal to be present or proceed; may use deadly force

49
New cards

Defense to others - defense to intentional tort

1.     A person can reasonably use force to protect a 3rd person from immediate harm; exists only when the other person has the privilege; can only use force proportionate to what they can use
a.     If someone is intervening and helping the aggressor, if the person reasonably believes they needed help that can be a defense
2.     More of a shift to a reasonable belief standard


50
New cards

Defense to Property - defense to intentional tort

Defendant may use reasonable force, deadly force is never reasonable unless when protecting home, but most likely privileged only to protect personal safety

51
New cards

Necessity - Defense to intentional tort

commits trespass for public good/or to protect life/property (this defense allows the D to interfere with the property interests of an innocent party to avoid a great injury)

52
New cards

what are the two types of necessity?

Public and Private

53
New cards

Public Necessity - Defense to intentional tort

                            i.      Exists when the D appropriates or injures a private property interest to protect the community or to avoid public harm

                           ii.      Complete privilege/absolute defense/no liability

54
New cards

Private Necessity - Defense to intentional tort

                            i.      Exists when the individual appropriates or injures a private property interest to protect a private interest valued greater than the appropriated or injured property

                           ii.      Partial privilege, D is privileged to interfere, have to compensate P

1.     EX: Hiding from bear in cabin and have to pay for the damages bear that bear caused

                          iii.      Private necessity to protect life trumps necessity to protect property

55
New cards

Negligence Definition

negligence is conduct (the commission of an act or the failure to act), without wrongful intent, that falls below the minimum degree of ordinary care imposed by law to protect others against unreasonable risk of harm

56
New cards
57
New cards

Restatement 3rd for Negligence

A person acts negligently if the person does not exercise reasonable care under all the circumstances

58
New cards

Negligence Elements

duty, breach, causation, damages

59
New cards

Duty definition - element of negligence

defendant owed the plaintiff a duty to exercise care for plaintiff’s safety

60
New cards

Breach definition - element of negligence

defendant breached that duty by unreasonably risky conduct

61
New cards

Causation definition - element of negligence

defendant’s conduct in fact caused harm to the plaintiff (sine qua non, or “but for”)

62
New cards

Damages - element of negligence

existence and number of damages, resulting from harms of a legally recognized kind (e.g. physical injury)

63
New cards

The duty of reasonable care

There are two (sometimes competing) approaches for defining the basic standard of care in negligence. The traditional approach most courts define is what a reasonably prudent person under the circumstances would or would not do

64
New cards

what are the two standards for the duty of reasonable care?

the reasonable prudent person and the reasonable person under the circumstances

65
New cards

Reasonably Prudent Person Standard - Duty element for negligence

1.     Prudent – practical wisdom or intelligence of a person of ordinary common sense
a.     Defendant had a duty to use property as a reasonably prudent person so as to not injure P
b.     Measures conduct according to an external social standard
c.     Alabama: a person’s conduct is negligent when they either do something that a reasonably prudent person will not do in a similar situation if they fail to do something that a reasonably prudent person would have done in a similar situation


66
New cards

The Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence

The modern trend is to define negligence as the failure to exercise reasonable care under all the circumstances, and then use an economic or cost-benefit analysis to determine whether reasonable care has been exercised

The 3rd Restatement calls for courts, when determining whether a person has acted without reasonable care, to weight the following factors: (1) the foreseeable likelihood that the person’s conduct will result in harm; (2) the foreseeable severity of any harm that may result; and (3) the burden of precautions to eliminate or reduce the risk of harm


67
New cards

Extraordinary Knowledge and Skill for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence

1.     A person who comes to the aid of another is a foreseeable plaintiff. If the defendant negligently puts either the rescued party or the rescuer in danger, then he is liable for the rescuer’s injuries. To the extent that a rescuer’s efforts are unreasonable, comparative responsibility should be available to reduce, rather than bar, recovery by a rescuer
2.     The standard of the reasonable man needs only a minimum of attention, perception, memory, knowledge, intelligence, and judgment to realize the existence of skill. If the actor has in fact more than the minimum of these qualities, he is required to exercise the superior qualities that he has in a manner reasonable under the circumstances. The standard becomes that of a reasonable man with such superior attributes


68
New cards

Children for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence

1.     The standard of care imposed on a child is that of a reasonable child of similar age, intelligence, and experience. Unlike the objective standard applied to adult defendants in negligence actions, the standard applicable to minors is more subjective in nature because children are unable to appreciate the same risks as adult
2.     However, a child engaged in an adult activity, such as driving a car, is held to the same standard as an adult. Courts regard children of a particularly young age as incapable of negligent conduct. Under the 3rd Restatement, children under the age of 5 are generally incapable of negligent conduct
3.     Restatement 3rd: children under 5 are not capable of negligence
4.     Individual characteristics matter for the reasonably prudent person standard, but there is an exception when the child is engaging in adult activates or inherently dangerous activities


69
New cards

Mental Illness for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence

Individual characteristics do not matter for the reasonably prudent person standard, but there is a possibility of limited exception if they have sudden onset characteristics of it and they didn’t know about it


70
New cards

Disability for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence

1.     Individual characteristics matter for the reasonably prudent person standard
2.     Restatement 3rd: the conduct of an actor with a physical disability is negligent only if the conduct does not conform to that of a reasonably careful person with the same disability


71
New cards

Breach definition - element of negligence

failure to meet the standard of care

72
New cards

what are the four ways to prove breach for negligence?

learned hand formula, negligence per se, custom, and res ipsa loquitor

73
New cards

learned hand formula for how to prove breach for negligence

1.     Defendant is negligent (liable) where the burden/cost of prevention (B) is less than the social benefit gained from prevention (PxL)
a.     B – cost of preventing a particular harm from happening; weight it against the probability that something is going to go wrong
b.     L – harm or injury; gravity/severity of harm/injury
c.     P – probability of harm/injury
d.     B<(P x L)
2.     If the burden is less than the right side, then you should spend $ to prevent it from happening
3.     If the right side is less than the Burden, then we will keep taking the risk
a.     If cost to fix is less then fix that shit
b.     If more than let that shit ride


74
New cards

Negligence Per Se for how to prove breach for negligence

The standard of care can sometimes be determined by statute. In most jurisdictions, the violation of such a statute established negligence as a matter of law (a conclusive presumption as a duty to breach). A minority of jurisdictions hold that violation of the statute is merely evidence of negligence (a rebuttable presumption as to duty and breach)


75
New cards

Origins and Rationale for Negligence per se for how to prove breach for negligence

a.     A criminal or regulatory statute (or an administrative regulation or municipal ordinance) imposes a penalty for violation of a specific duty;
b.     The defendant violates the statute by failing to perform that duty;
c.     The plaintiff is in the same class of people intended to be protected by the statute; and
d.     The harm is of the type of the statute was intended to protect against


76
New cards

Type of Harm and Membership in Protected Class for Negligence Per se for how to prove breach for negligence

The doctrine of negligence per se does not apply even though a statute has been violated if the plaintiff was not in the class of persons designed to be protected or the type of harm that occurred was not one which the statute was designed to protect

77
New cards

Excuse for Negligence Per se for how to prove breach for negligence

a.     Restatement 2nd: the unexcused violation of a legislative enactment which is adopted by the court as defining the standard of conduct of a reasonable man, is negligence in itself. But an excused violation of a legislative enactment is not negligence
b.     This excuse applies where “the actor neither knows nor should know of any occasion or necessity for action in compliance with the legislation or regulation
c.     The issue with excuse becomes whether a “reasonable prudent person under the circumstances” would have likewise been in violation of the statute


78
New cards

Unless such enactment or regulation is construed not to permit such excuse, its violation is excused when:

1.     The violation is reasonable because of the actor’s incapacity;

2.     He neither knows nor should know of the occasion for compliance;

3.     He is unable after reasonable diligence or care to comply;

4.     He is confronted by an emergency not due to his own misconduct;

5.     Compliance would involve a greater risk of harm to the actor or to others

79
New cards

Custom for how to prove breach for negligence

Restatement 3rd 13: Compliance with custom is evidence that an actor’s conduct is not negligence but does not preclude a finding of negligence; departure from custom in a way that increases the risk is evidence of negligence. Basically, if there is a custom and you fail to adhere to it, it doesn’t automatically mean you are negligent, but if you complied with it, it doesn’t mean you’re free from liability.

it is going to inform our standard of care and is a type of evidence

80
New cards

what are the two types of custom for proving breach for negligence?

Industry custom and Personal custom

81
New cards

Industry Custom for how to prove breach for negligence

Evidence of a custom in a community or industry is admissible as evidence to establish the proper standard of care, but such evidence is not conclusive. The entire community or industry may be negligent

Main Takeaway: Custom - a pattern of general practice that is definite and fixed enough to be recognized and known as a rule or norm of behavior.

82
New cards

Personal Custom for how to prove breach for negligence

                            i.      The rule does not set the standard for conduct establishing what the law requires of a reasonable person under the circumstances.

                           ii.      A company’s internal policies or procedures do not set the legal standard of ordinary or reasonable care in a negligence case.

                          iii.      The standard of care remains an objective one – what a reasonably careful and prudent person would do under similar circumstances – not what the company itself subjectively considers to be ordinary care. Such procedures do not establish the legal duty or standard required by law.

83
New cards

Res Ipsa Loquitur definition

the thing speaks for itself

84
New cards

What evidence does Res Ipsa Loquitur require?

a.     The nature of a particular accident suggests that it was probably due to negligence
b.     The defendant had exclusive control over whatever caused the accident (such that it was the defendant’s negligence); AND
c.     The plaintiff lacks direct evidence of the event relative to the information available to the defendant


85
New cards

Res Ipsa Loquitur info for proving breach for negligence

a.     Restatement 3rd – the factfinder may infer negligence when the accident is a type that ordinary care happens because of negligence by defendant’s class of actors

                            i.      “Circumstantial evidence of a quite distinctive form” – the doctrine implies that the court does not know, and cannot find out, what happened

2.     If a fact finder can reasonably conclude that the accident could have happened without defendant’s negligence, the res ipsa presumption does not apply
3.     Based on the occurrence of the accident itself, and because of the defendant’s relationship to it, plaintiff seeks to show that:
a.     1) the harm-causing event was probably due to negligence, AND
b.     The defendant was probably the culpable party


86
New cards

Causation - element for negligence

Tort law demands a link between the defendant’s misconduct and the plaintiff’s harm. Causation is that missing link. The plaintiff must prove that the defendant’s actions were both the actual cause (also known as the factual cause or “cause-in-fact”) and the proximate cause (within the scope of liability) of the plaintiff’s injury)


87
New cards

what are the two ways to prove causation for negligence?

cause-in-fact (actual cause) and Proximate (legal) cause

88
New cards

what is the main test for cause-in-fact (actual cause) for causation?

the ‘But-For” Test - but for the existence of X, would Y have occurred?

89
New cards

‘But-For” Test for proving causation info

1.     If the plaintiff’s injury would not have occurred but for the defendant’s tortious act or omission, then the defendant’s conduct is a factual cause of the harm. If the injury would have occurred despite the defendant’s conduct, then there is no factual cause. The “but-For” cause is not a search for a lone cause – there is no such thing.
2.     If we can’t say that this change would have prevented the negligence and the injury, then there’s no liability for the defendant
3.     Plaintiff must establish that, more likely than not (preponderance standard), but for defendant’s conduct (in the specific way D was negligent), plaintiff would not have been injured in this way (in the specific way P was injured)


90
New cards

Steps for ‘But-For” Test for proving causation

a.     Step 1 – identify the specific way the D was negligent (breached standard of care)
b.     Step 2 – ask the question – in a counterfactual world in which D was NOT negligent, would P have been injured in this specific way?

                            i.      If not persuaded (more likely than not), the answer is no; D is not the factual cause

91
New cards

what are the alternatives to But-For causation?

multiple sufficient independent causes, alternative liability, and modified alternative liability: Market Share

92
New cards

multiple sufficient independent causes info

a.     The but-for test of causation will not work if:

                            i.      there are multiple tortfeasors, and it cannot be said that the defendant’s tortious conduct necessarily was required to produce the harm;

                           ii.      there are multiple possible causes

b.     When two or more people are negligent, and their actions combine to cause someone’s injury, each person can be held responsible for the entire injury – even if either person’s actions alone would have been enough to cause the injury
c.     Multiple Sufficient Independent Causes will be treated for the but-for cause


93
New cards

alternative liability

it applies in a multiple tortfeasor scenario where there is a true but-for cause associated with the tort, but the plaintiff cannot identify, as between the tortfeasors, which one is responsible for causing the harm

this applies when the plaintiff can prove that the few defendants brought before the court are tortfeasors and that either of them could have been actual cause, but that it is impossible to prove which one

94
New cards

alternative liability criteria for application

                            i.      There be more than 1 tortfeasor

                           ii.      All tortfeasors are engaged in similar conduct

                          iii.      Plaintiff was injured because of the actions of one of the tortfeasors, AND

                          iv.      Plaintiff named all the tortfeasors in the action

1.     When this doctrine applies, it acts as a burden-shifting device, which presumes that all defendants caused the plaintiff’s harm unless and until one of them proves otherwise

95
New cards

modified alternative liability: Market Share

a.     If multiple manufacturers of fungible goods are named as defendants and the manufacturer that caused the injury cannot be determined, the manufacturers will be held proportionately liable in accordance with their market share
b.     Defendants market share of sale become proxy for likelihood it caused the plaintiff’s damage.
c.     Dissent – substituting a criterion of wealth (deep pocket theory) for traditional causation
d.     Majority – complex, changing society requires legal changes


96
New cards

Loss Chance Doctrine

proof that the defendant’s conduct increased the risk of death by decreasing the chances of survival of a plaintiff is sufficient as to the issue of proximate cause

97
New cards

Proximate Cause intro – implying a cause that is close and not far away

1.     Defendant’s conduct had a legally significant relationship to the harm
2.     Negligent conduct is proximately connected to a harm if it has a causal link with the harm (it increases the risk of that (type of) harm
a.     Every person is liable for the proximate results of his acts but not for remote damages, remote consequences depend on a concurrence of accidental circumstances. Remote circumstances the defendant has no control, and it would not make sense to hold him liable


98
New cards

what are the three tests for proximate cause regarding causation for proving negligence?

the direct cause test, foreseeability test, and the substantial factor test

99
New cards

the direct cause test for proximate cause regarding causation for proving negligence

1.     Want to be able to say that there is a direct connection between the cause and the effect
2.     Once negligence established, D’s liability does not depend on being able to foresee either the extend or the type of harm (effect
3.     Given the breach of duty and the damages as a direct cause, the anticipations of the person who negligent act has produced the damage are irrelevant
4.     Liable as long as damage is “directly traceable” to the negligent act
a.     Ask yourself, was there an “independent cause” not connected to the negligent act?

                            i.      If yes, independent cause intervenes – no liability

100
New cards

the foreseeability test for proximate cause regarding causation for proving negligence

This test considers whether the nature of the harm or accident giving rise to the plaintiff’s claim was the same general type of harm or accident that was within the scope of the original risk that permitted a finding of breach of the duty of reasonable care
If the accident that hurt the plaintiff was one of those possible accident that led to the conclusion that defendant breached its duty, by failing to exercise enough care to avoid it from occurring, then the foreseeability test is satisfied