1/141
what is an intentional tort?
generally involve the worst, most reprehensible misconduct, but this doesn’t apply to every case. It’s referred to as “intentional” because the tortfeasor must intend something specific, subjectively, to trigger liability
what are the elements of an intentional tort?
i. Established if defendant desires that act will cause; or knowns that it is substantially certain the result will occur
1. Actor does not need to intend the injury/consequence
ii. Causation: defendant’s act or force set in motion by act causes plaintiff’s injury
Result must have been legally caused by the defendant’s act
what are the five intentional torts?
battery, assault, false imprisonment, trespass, and Intentional infliction of emotional distress (IIED)
Battery
this is designed to protect our bodily integrity or our right to be free from certain unwanted physical contacts. It recognizes that we are entitled to some level of autonomy over our own bodies and provides redress where that autonomy is violated in certain ways.
Battery elements
Assault
requires someone to know about it; if you see it coming its assault & battery
Assault elements
Apprehension - Assault element
i. Assault requires the defendant’s voluntary action, an intent (desire or substantial certainty) to cause the victim to suffer apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact, and the victim must experience the reasonable or imminent apprehension of such contact. Assault occurs when the defendant intends to cause the plaintiff to believe he is about to be battered.
ii. There must be REASONABLE apprehension
Imminent Threat - Assault Element
i. The D intended to cause apprehension of an imminent threat to the P
ii. Looks at words and context; just words and no contact is not assault
Be coupled with overt action that is happening right then
Transfer of Intent
False Imprisonment elements
Confinement to bounded area - false imprisonment element
Confinement, physical barriers, physical force threats (direct and indirect), duress, failure to provide means of escape, invalid use
Shopkeeper’s Privilege
Shopkeeper’s Privilege “Elements”
Trespass
actionable invasion of interest in exclusive possession of land
Trespass to Land (Instrusion) Elements: D intentionally….
Trespass to land info
i. wrinkle - requisite intent is to enter the land (NOT to trespass)
1. Good faith mistake is still tortious, doesn’t matter that you didn’t know
ii. Even if you do not cause any damage at all, that is enough to say it is trespass and you can get nominal (symbolic damages saying the defendant didn’t follow the P’s rights) damages
Scope of Liability for Trespass to Land
i. Harm must be caused by trespass, must occur during continuous of trespass
what are the two types of personal property intentional torts
Trespass to chattels and Conversion
Trespass to Chattels
Trespass to Chattels Elements
Intentionally interfered with property AND harmed the property
Intentionally Interfered with Property - Trespass to Chattels Element
i. Intentional interference is some intended interaction with the property (“intermeddling”)
ii. Good faith and mistaken identity is no excuse
iii. Interfering with the right of possession or use of the chattel
1. Can be disruption of service or functionality
2. Can also be dispossession, physical contact, or unauthorized use
3. Unauthorized digital contact or data interference
Harmed the Property - Trespass to Chattels Element
i. Can be physical damage, deprivation of use for a substantial period of time, or impairment of the condition or quality of the chattel
1. Not complete destruction
what are the 2 types of trespass to chattels?
dispossession and intermeddling
Dispossession - type of Trespass to Chattel
i. Taking a chattel from the possession of another w/o the other’s consent, or
ii. Obtaining possession of a chattel from another by fraud or duress, or
iii. Barring the possessor’s access to a chattel, or
iv. Destroying a chattel while it is in another’s possession
Intermeddling - type of Trespass to Chattel
i. Meanings intentionally brining about a physical contact with the chattel, or
ii. Acting on a chattel as intentionally to cause it to come in contact with some other object
1. A chattel is impaired as to its condition, quality, or value, or
2. The possessor is deprived of the use of the chattel for a substantial time, or
3. Bodily harm is thereby caused to the possessor, or harm is caused to some person or thing in which the possessor has a legally protected interest
is dispossession higher than intermeddling?
yes
Conversion elements
Intentionally exercises dominion and control over the property AND
(Limited to tangible property unless it has scientific, literary, or artistic value
Conversion Info
Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress (IIED) Elements
intentionally or recklessly engaged in extreme and outrageous behavior causing P to suffer severe emotional distress
Extreme and outrageous behavior - element to IIED
i. Constant harassment and it is on-going
i. Lower threshold where D knew P’s susceptibility and abuses it
ii. Superior-subordinate relationship can be important
Severe emotional distress - element to IIED
Restatement 2nd approach to IIED
bystander who witnesses must be present at the time, and must be immediate family member to recover if you do not have physical symptoms
Restatement 3nd approach to IIED
bystander must be family member who witnessed contemporaneously to recover (non-relatives cannot recover)
3rd party recovery for IIED requires P to show:
Defenses to Intentional Torts
what are the defenses to intentional torts?
consent, defense to self, other, and property
Consent defintion - Defense to Intentional Tort
Willingness in fact for conduct to occur
Consent info - Defense to Intentional Tort
what are the two types of consent?
express and implied
Express Consent - Defense to Intentional Tort
states in written or spoken words
Implied Consent - Defense to Intentional Tort
manifested through conduct/behavior
Actual v. Apparent Consent (2nd Restatement) - Defense to Intentional Tort
Actual consent – willingness manifested by action or inaction
Apparent consent – words or conduct reasonably understood by another to be intended as consent
Limitations to Consent - Defense to Intentional Tort
Mental Illness - defense for Intentional Tort
Self Defense - defense for Intentional Tort
Elements to Self Defense - defense to intentional tort
Retreat to the wall v. Stand your ground for Self Defense - defense to intentional tort
Retreat to the wall – retreat where serious bodily injury or death would be otherwise required (modern approach)
Stand your ground – no requirement of retreat with assumption there is a legal to be present or proceed; may use deadly force
Defense to others - defense to intentional tort
Defense to Property - defense to intentional tort
Defendant may use reasonable force, deadly force is never reasonable unless when protecting home, but most likely privileged only to protect personal safety
Necessity - Defense to intentional tort
commits trespass for public good/or to protect life/property (this defense allows the D to interfere with the property interests of an innocent party to avoid a great injury)
what are the two types of necessity?
Public and Private
Public Necessity - Defense to intentional tort
i. Exists when the D appropriates or injures a private property interest to protect the community or to avoid public harm
ii. Complete privilege/absolute defense/no liability
Private Necessity - Defense to intentional tort
i. Exists when the individual appropriates or injures a private property interest to protect a private interest valued greater than the appropriated or injured property
ii. Partial privilege, D is privileged to interfere, have to compensate P
1. EX: Hiding from bear in cabin and have to pay for the damages bear that bear caused
iii. Private necessity to protect life trumps necessity to protect property
Negligence Definition
negligence is conduct (the commission of an act or the failure to act), without wrongful intent, that falls below the minimum degree of ordinary care imposed by law to protect others against unreasonable risk of harm
Restatement 3rd for Negligence
A person acts negligently if the person does not exercise reasonable care under all the circumstances
Negligence Elements
duty, breach, causation, damages
Duty definition - element of negligence
defendant owed the plaintiff a duty to exercise care for plaintiff’s safety
Breach definition - element of negligence
defendant breached that duty by unreasonably risky conduct
Causation definition - element of negligence
defendant’s conduct in fact caused harm to the plaintiff (sine qua non, or “but for”)
Damages - element of negligence
existence and number of damages, resulting from harms of a legally recognized kind (e.g. physical injury)
The duty of reasonable care
There are two (sometimes competing) approaches for defining the basic standard of care in negligence. The traditional approach most courts define is what a reasonably prudent person under the circumstances would or would not do
what are the two standards for the duty of reasonable care?
the reasonable prudent person and the reasonable person under the circumstances
Reasonably Prudent Person Standard - Duty element for negligence
The Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence
Extraordinary Knowledge and Skill for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence
Children for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence
Mental Illness for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence
Disability for Reasonable Person Under the Circumstances - Duty element for negligence
Breach definition - element of negligence
failure to meet the standard of care
what are the four ways to prove breach for negligence?
learned hand formula, negligence per se, custom, and res ipsa loquitor
learned hand formula for how to prove breach for negligence
Negligence Per Se for how to prove breach for negligence
Origins and Rationale for Negligence per se for how to prove breach for negligence
Type of Harm and Membership in Protected Class for Negligence Per se for how to prove breach for negligence
The doctrine of negligence per se does not apply even though a statute has been violated if the plaintiff was not in the class of persons designed to be protected or the type of harm that occurred was not one which the statute was designed to protect
Excuse for Negligence Per se for how to prove breach for negligence
Unless such enactment or regulation is construed not to permit such excuse, its violation is excused when:
1. The violation is reasonable because of the actor’s incapacity;
2. He neither knows nor should know of the occasion for compliance;
3. He is unable after reasonable diligence or care to comply;
4. He is confronted by an emergency not due to his own misconduct;
5. Compliance would involve a greater risk of harm to the actor or to others
Custom for how to prove breach for negligence
it is going to inform our standard of care and is a type of evidence
what are the two types of custom for proving breach for negligence?
Industry custom and Personal custom
Industry Custom for how to prove breach for negligence
Evidence of a custom in a community or industry is admissible as evidence to establish the proper standard of care, but such evidence is not conclusive. The entire community or industry may be negligent
Main Takeaway: Custom - a pattern of general practice that is definite and fixed enough to be recognized and known as a rule or norm of behavior.
Personal Custom for how to prove breach for negligence
i. The rule does not set the standard for conduct establishing what the law requires of a reasonable person under the circumstances.
ii. A company’s internal policies or procedures do not set the legal standard of ordinary or reasonable care in a negligence case.
iii. The standard of care remains an objective one – what a reasonably careful and prudent person would do under similar circumstances – not what the company itself subjectively considers to be ordinary care. Such procedures do not establish the legal duty or standard required by law.
Res Ipsa Loquitur definition
the thing speaks for itself
What evidence does Res Ipsa Loquitur require?
Res Ipsa Loquitur info for proving breach for negligence
i. “Circumstantial evidence of a quite distinctive form” – the doctrine implies that the court does not know, and cannot find out, what happened
Causation - element for negligence
what are the two ways to prove causation for negligence?
cause-in-fact (actual cause) and Proximate (legal) cause
what is the main test for cause-in-fact (actual cause) for causation?
the ‘But-For” Test - but for the existence of X, would Y have occurred?
‘But-For” Test for proving causation info
Steps for ‘But-For” Test for proving causation
i. If not persuaded (more likely than not), the answer is no; D is not the factual cause
what are the alternatives to But-For causation?
multiple sufficient independent causes, alternative liability, and modified alternative liability: Market Share
multiple sufficient independent causes info
i. there are multiple tortfeasors, and it cannot be said that the defendant’s tortious conduct necessarily was required to produce the harm;
ii. there are multiple possible causes
alternative liability
it applies in a multiple tortfeasor scenario where there is a true but-for cause associated with the tort, but the plaintiff cannot identify, as between the tortfeasors, which one is responsible for causing the harm
this applies when the plaintiff can prove that the few defendants brought before the court are tortfeasors and that either of them could have been actual cause, but that it is impossible to prove which one
alternative liability criteria for application
i. There be more than 1 tortfeasor
ii. All tortfeasors are engaged in similar conduct
iii. Plaintiff was injured because of the actions of one of the tortfeasors, AND
iv. Plaintiff named all the tortfeasors in the action
1. When this doctrine applies, it acts as a burden-shifting device, which presumes that all defendants caused the plaintiff’s harm unless and until one of them proves otherwise
modified alternative liability: Market Share
Loss Chance Doctrine
proof that the defendant’s conduct increased the risk of death by decreasing the chances of survival of a plaintiff is sufficient as to the issue of proximate cause
Proximate Cause intro – implying a cause that is close and not far away
what are the three tests for proximate cause regarding causation for proving negligence?
the direct cause test, foreseeability test, and the substantial factor test
the direct cause test for proximate cause regarding causation for proving negligence
i. If yes, independent cause intervenes – no liability
the foreseeability test for proximate cause regarding causation for proving negligence