1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is “good” and “bad” for Nietzsche, and why is Christianity bad by that standard? (Antichrist 2–5)
Good = whatever heightens the feeling of power and the will to power; bad = whatever stems from weakness. Happiness is power increasing, a resistance overcome, not contentment. Christianity sides with the weak and the failures, wages war on the higher (strong) type of man, and turns his instincts into “evil”. Progress is a modern false idea.
Why does Nietzsche call pity “the practice of nihilism”? (7)
Pity is depressive and contagious: it multiplies suffering and preserves what is ripe for destruction, so it crosses the law of selection. It denies life. Schopenhauer was right about this effect, but he was himself hostile to life, so he made pity a virtue. Nietzsche calls the “hereafter”, “salvation” etc. disguised words for nothingness.
What is the “theological instinct” and why is the priest the enemy? (8, 9, 12, 26)
A crooked attitude to reality: faith means closing one’s eyes to oneself so as not to suffer from falsehood. The priest is a “parasite” who denies and slanders life, declares nature sinful, and invents sin as his handle of power (sin must be committed for him to live). Philosophers inherit this priestly counterfeiting.
How does Nietzsche explain the Christian God as a symptom of decline? (16–19)
A healthy people has a God that expresses its power and gratitude, and may be harmful as well as useful. When a people declines, God becomes the “good” God of the weak, a God of the sick, then pure spirit or “thing-in-itself”. God becomes “nothingness deified”, a declaration of war on life. The weak call themselves “the good”.
Compare Nietzsche’s Buddhism with his Christianity. (20–23)
Buddhism: nihilistic décadence-religion too, but more realistic and positivistic. It fights suffering, not sin; no God, no prayer, no coercion; it is hygienic and rests on exhaustion at the end of a civilization. Christianity: arises among the oppressed, uses sin, guilt, hope, faith and love as “shrewdnesses”, and aims to tame barbarians by making them sick. Truth does not matter, only being believed.
What is Nietzsche’s account of the Jewish-Christian origin of morality? (24–26)
Christianity is the logical consequence of Jewish priestly instinct. Originally Yahweh expressed a people’s power; after defeat priests turned him into a God of reward and punishment (a “moral world order”). This is ressentiment-morality (reversal of noble morality): life-affirmation becomes evil. Jesus’ rebellion negated even the priests, but the Church took over.
What is Nietzsche’s critique of Kant? (10–12)
Kant is a “cunning theologian”: his skepticism re-opened the path to the “true world” and morality as essence of the world. Duty, universality and respect for the concept of virtue are impersonal and life-denying; each should discover his own virtue (“own categorical imperative”). Practical reason is a reason invented for when one need not worry about reason.
What is enlightenment and what is the difference between public and private use of reason? (What is Enlightenment?) (Kant)
Emergence from self-incurred minority: inability to use one’s understanding without another’s guidance, caused by laziness and cowardice. Motto: Sapere aude. Needs only freedom of public use of reason (as a scholar before the world). Private use (in an office, e.g. clergyman in his post) may be restricted: one obeys on duty but may criticise publicly.
Why can a church not bind itself to an unalterable creed? How is religion central to enlightenment? (Kant)
Such a contract would stop all progress for later generations: a crime against human nature, null and void. Test: could a people impose such a law on itself? Religion is chosen as main example because minority there is the most harmful and disgraceful. We live in an age of enlightenment, not yet an enlightened age. Civil freedom is compatible with freedom of spirit (“argue, but obey”).
What is Kant’s “radical evil”? (Religion, Book 1)
Evil is not in inclinations or nature but in a maxim, i.e. the free adoption of a rule that subordinates the moral law to self-love. It is “innate” as the ground of all particular maxims, yet imputable since it is an act of freedom; its ultimate origin is inscrutable. Optimism (man steadily improves) is not supported by experience.
How does Book 2 reinterpret the struggle between good and evil principle? (Kant)
The Stoics mistook the enemy: inclinations are in themselves good; the real enemy is the wickedness of the heart (maxims), an invisible foe. The Apostle’s “evil spirits” are a practical representation of this unfathomable enemy. We are not led astray unless we are already in secret league with the seducer.
What role does Christ play in Kant’s moral religion? (Book 2)
Christ = the personified idea of humanity pleasing to God, an archetype that lies in our own reason. We ought to conform to it, so we can. No miracles are needed (wanting them shows moral unbelief); only practical faith has moral worth. A supernaturally holy being could not be an example for imitation. A good disposition counts for the imperfect deed as seen by God.