1/97
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Capital budgeting
Planning and managing a firm's long-term investments (new products, markets, buildings, machinery, equipment); evaluates the size, timing, and risk of future cash flows.
Capital structure
Financing decisions: the mixture of debt and equity a firm uses.
Working capital management
Managing short-term assets and liabilities (cash, inventory, receivables, payables).
Goal of the financial manager
Maximize shareholders' wealth (stock price).
When is an investment worth taking?
When it creates value for the owners (shareholders).
Four investment decision rules in Ch. 8
NPV, IRR, payback period, and profitability index.
Most popular capital budgeting methods among CFOs (survey)
IRR and NPV (each used always/mostly always by about 75% of CFOs), followed by hurdle rate and payback.
Stand-alone (independent) projects
Projects whose cash flows are not affected by decisions about other projects.
Mutually exclusive projects
A set of projects where accepting one means the others cannot be accepted.
Valuation Principle (as applied to NPV)
Convert costs and benefits to the same point in time (usually cash today) to make a decision.
Net present value (NPV)
The difference between the PV of a project's benefits and the PV of its costs: NPV = PV(Benefits) − PV(Costs). Shows how much value is created.
NPV formula
NPV = CF0 + CF1/(1+r) + CF2/(1+r)^2 + … + CFn/(1+r)^n = sum of CFt/(1+r)^t from t = 0 to n.
Three steps to compute NPV
1) Estimate the project's expected cash flows. 2) Estimate the required return for projects of this risk level. 3) Find the PV of the cash flows and subtract the initial investment.
NPV decision rule (stand-alone)
Accept if NPV > 0; reject if NPV < 0.
NPV decision rule (mutually exclusive)
Select the alternative with the highest NPV.
Why a positive NPV increases firm value regardless of cash needs or preferences
You could borrow the PV of the future benefit today and use the future inflow to repay the loan, leaving you with the NPV in cash today.
NPV profile
A graph of a project's NPV over a range of discount rates; shows NPV depends on the cost of capital.
Where an NPV profile crosses zero
At the IRR. NPV is positive for discount rates below the IRR and negative above it.
Advantages of NPV
Corresponds directly to the project's impact on firm value; direct application of the Valuation Principle.
Disadvantages of NPV
Relies on an accurate estimate of the discount rate; can be time-consuming to compute.
Internal rate of return (IRR)
The discount rate that makes NPV = 0; the rate at which the PV of benefits equals the PV of costs. Interpreted as the average rate of return on the investment.
IRR decision rule
Accept the project if IRR > cost of capital (r); reject if IRR < r.
Why IRR is intuitively appealing
It is a simple return figure that is easy to communicate and is based entirely on estimated cash flows, independent of interest rates found elsewhere.
Fredrick's fertilizer project (cash flows)
-$81.6 million at year 0, then +$28 million per year for years 1–4.
Fredrick's project NPV at 10% cost of capital
+$7.2 million, so accept.
Fredrick's project NPV at 16% cost of capital
-$3.3 million, so reject.
Fredrick's project IRR
About 13.99% (≈14%); accept if cost of capital is below this.
When do NPV and IRR give different answers?
(1) Nonconventional cash flows (sign changes more than once, possibly multiple IRRs). (2) Mutually exclusive projects (timing and scale of cash flows differ).
When NPV and IRR conflict, which should you rely on?
The NPV rule.
Nonconventional cash flows
Cash flows whose signs change more than once (e.g., -$1,000, +$2,500, -$1,540); the project can have more than one IRR, making the IRR rule ambiguous.
Mutually exclusive example: Project A vs. B (10% cost of capital)
A: NPV $64.05, IRR 19.43%. B: NPV $60.74, IRR 22.17%. IRR favors B, NPV favors A, so choose A (highest NPV).
Bottom line on IRR for mutually exclusive projects
Picking the project with the largest IRR can lead to a mistake; it is dangerous to use IRR to choose between mutually exclusive projects, so always rely on NPV.
Advantages of IRR
Closely related to NPV and usually leads to the same decision; intuitive and easy to communicate; if IRR is high enough you may not need to estimate a required return.
Disadvantages of IRR
Multiple IRRs possible with nonconventional cash flows; not reliable for choosing among mutually exclusive projects.
Payback period
The length of time it takes to recover the initial investment of a project from its future cash flows (in a nominal sense, with no discounting).
Payback period decision rule
Accept if the payback period is less than a preset (target) limit: accept if PBP < target PBP.
How to compute payback period
Subtract each year's future cash flows from the initial cost until the investment is recovered; add the fraction of the final year needed.
Fredrick's project payback period
2 + 25.6/28 = about 2.91 years; rejected under a 2-year payback requirement even though NPV and IRR say accept.
Advantages of payback period
Easy to understand; adjusts for uncertainty of later cash flows; biased toward liquidity.
Disadvantages of payback period
Ignores time value of money; requires an arbitrary cutoff; ignores cash flows beyond the cutoff; biased against long-term projects; not necessarily consistent with maximizing shareholder wealth.
Payback pitfall example (Projects A and B, -$10,000 each)
B pays back in 2 years and A in 3, so payback picks B, even though A's year-4 cash flow is $1,000,000. Ignoring cash flows after the cutoff causes a huge mistake.
Profitability index (PI)
Measures benefit per unit of cost (resource consumed): PI = Value Created / Resource Consumed = NPV / Resource Consumed.
Interpreting a PI of 0.1
For every $1 of investment, the project creates an additional $0.10 in value.
PI decision rule
Accept if PI > 0.
When is the profitability index most useful?
To rank projects when capital (or another resource) is limited and not all positive-NPV projects can be accepted.
Fredrick's project PI at 10%
7.2 / 81.6 = 0.0882 (8.82%); accept.
How to use PI with a constrained resource
Rank projects by PI based on the constrained resource, then move down the list accepting value-creating projects until the resource is exhausted.
$200 million budget example (A, B, C)
PI = NPV / initial investment: A 0.500 (100/200), B 0.625 (75/120), C 0.875 (70/80). Rank C, B, A; C + B use $200M for NPV of $145M.
Advantages of profitability index
Uses NPV to measure benefit; closely related to NPV; easy to understand; ranks projects by value created per unit of resource consumed.
Disadvantages of profitability index
Cannot be used reliably to choose among mutually exclusive projects.
Summary: which rule is most reliable overall?
NPV, because it directly measures value added to the firm; IRR, payback, and PI can mislead in some situations.