1/191
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Substantial evidence
What quantum of evidence is required in administrative proceedings involving physicians?
Preponderance of evidence
What quantum of evidence is required in civil cases against physicians?
Proof beyond reasonable doubt
What quantum of evidence is required in criminal prosecutions of physicians?
Concurrent or successive legal actions without violating double jeopardy
How can administrative, civil, and criminal proceedings be pursued for a single wrongful medical act?
Safeguard public health and preserve professional integrity of the medical discipline
What is the primary societal purpose of administrative liability for physicians?
Compensate the private patient for personal injury, economic loss, or contractual breach through monetary indemnification
What is the primary societal purpose of civil liability in medical practice?
Enforce social order by penalizing public wrongs committed against the State
What is the primary societal purpose of criminal liability?
Board of Medicine under oversight of the Professional Regulation Commission
Which administrative body exercises primary quasi-judicial jurisdiction over physician licensing?
Regular Courts such as Municipal Trial Courts or Regional Trial Courts
Which judicial forum hears civil claims for medical damages?
Regular Courts such as Municipal Trial Courts or Regional Trial Courts
Which judicial forum tries criminal offenses committed by physicians?
Reprimand, suspension, or revocation of medical license
What are the primary penalties imposed in administrative proceedings against physicians?
Monetary damages
What is the primary sanction awarded in civil medical malpractice suits?
Imprisonment, fine, both, or disqualification
What are the principal penalties imposed in criminal prosecutions of physicians?
Medical Act of 1959 or Republic Act 2382
Which primary statute governs administrative disciplinary grounds for Philippine physicians?
New Civil Code of the Philippines
Which codal body governs civil liability and the system of damages for medical malpractice?
Revocable privilege granted by the State
What is the legal nature of the entitlement to practice medicine in the Philippines?
Police power
Which inherent power of the State justifies regulating, suspending, or revoking a medical license?
Quasi-judicial
How are administrative proceedings against medical practitioners legally categorized?
Section 5, Rule 133 of the Rules of Court
Where is substantial evidence statutorily defined?
Relevant evidence that a reasonable mind might accept as adequate to justify a conclusion
How is substantial evidence defined under Section 5, Rule 133?
Professional Regulation Commission
Which commission oversees the Board of Medicine and exercises quasi-judicial authority over licensed professionals?
Regional Trial Court
At what level of court authority do decisions of the Professional Regulation Commission operate?
Expiration of the statutory appeal period
When do decisions of the Professional Regulation Commission become final and executory?
Conviction by final judgment of a criminal offense involving moral turpitude
Which criminal ground under Section 24 of the Medical Act involves a court conviction?
Fraud in acquiring the certificate of registration
Which administrative ground penalizes dishonesty in obtaining a medical license?
Performance of or aiding in any criminal abortion
Which medical procedure constitutes a statutory criminal ground for license revocation under Section 24?
Knowingly issuing any false medical certificate
Which document issuance constitutes a specific criminal ground for license revocation under Section 24?
Aiding or acting as a dummy of an unqualified or unregistered person
Which act of assisting an unlicensed individual practice medicine grounds license revocation?
Immoral or dishonorable conduct
Which personal conduct ground under Section 24 penalizes moral depravity?
Insanity
Which mental condition serves as a statutory personal ground for license suspension or revocation under Section 24?
Gross negligence, ignorance, or incompetence in practice resulting in injury or death
Which clinical failure serves as a personal ground for license revocation under Section 24?
Addiction to alcoholic beverages, habit-forming drugs, or any form of gambling
Which addictive behaviors rendering a physician incompetent ground administrative action under Section 24?
False, extravagant, or unethical advertisements
Which advertising practice constitutes unprofessional conduct under Section 24?
Name, profession, limitation of practice, clinic hours, office address, and home address
What six specific details are strictly permitted in physician advertisements under Section 24?
Issuing statements or spreading derogatory rumors against another physician without justifiable motive
Which interpersonal act against a colleague constitutes unprofessional conduct under Section 24?
Violation of any provision of the Code of Ethics approved by the PMA
Which ethical breach constitutes statutory unprofessional conduct under Section 24?
Refusal to attend to a patient in danger of death when there is a risk to the physician's life
What specific refusal of care does NOT constitute a valid ground for license suspension or revocation under Section 24?
Reprimand, suspension of certificate, and revocation of certificate
What three principal administrative sanctions may the Board of Medicine impose?
At least two years
Under Section 27 of RA 2382, what is the minimum waiting period before a revoked license can be reinstated?
Acted in an exemplary manner in the community of residence and committed no illegal, immoral, or dishonorable act
What must an applicant prove to secure license reinstatement under Section 27?
Fine of P1,000 to P10,000, subsidiary imprisonment in case of insolvency, or imprisonment of 1 to 5 years, or both
What are the statutory penalties for illegal practice of medicine under Section 28 of RA 2382?
Board of Medical Examiners
Which entity may file an action to enjoin an individual illegally practicing medicine under Section 29?
Contempt of court
How is a person punished if they continue practicing medicine after being enjoined under Section 29?
No
Does an injunction proceeding under Section 29 relieve an illegal practitioner from criminal prosecution under Section 28?
Reprimand, suspension, or revocation of license
What administrative liability is incurred for failing to comply with national laws like the Sanitary Code or Fire Code?
Reprimand, suspension, or revocation of license
What administrative liability results from failing to secure local permits such as Mayor's permits or Building permits?
Bill of Rights of the 1987 Philippine Constitution
Where are the constitutional due process protections of a respondent physician codified?
Representation by counsel or in person, speedy and public hearing, and confronting or cross-examining witnesses
What procedural rights are explicitly granted to a respondent physician under Section 25 of RA 2382?
Rule 115, Section 1 of the Rules of Court
Which procedural rule enumerates the rights of the accused applicable in administrative hearings?
Presumption of innocence until the contrary is proven
Which fundamental presumption protects a respondent physician during administrative trials?
Right to testify as a witness or remain silent without prejudice
What testimonial choice is granted to a respondent physician under Rule 115?
Right against self-incrimination
Which right protects a respondent physician from being compelled to testify against oneself?
Right to compulsory process
Which right enables a respondent physician to secure the attendance of witnesses and production of evidence?
Thirty days
Within how many days after promulgation does a decision of the Board of Medicine automatically become final if unappealed?
Board of Medicine to Professional Regulation Commission to Office of the President to Court of Appeals or Supreme Court
What is the complete four-step procedural flow of administrative appeals for a physician?
Rule 43 Petition for Review or Rule 65 Petition for Certiorari
Under what procedural rules can a PRC or OP decision be appealed to the Court of Appeals or Supreme Court?
Preponderance of evidence
What quantum of evidence governs civil liability actions against physicians?
Rule 133, Section 1 of the Rules of Court
Where is preponderance of evidence statutorily defined?
Superior weight of evidence
What core concept defines preponderance of evidence?
Witness demeanor, intelligence, opportunity to observe, probability or improbability of testimony, interest or credibility, and number of witnesses
What factors do courts weigh when determining preponderance of evidence?
Breach of contract, Abuse of rights or Human relations, and Tort or Quasi-delict
What are the three primary sources of civil liability for physicians?
Contract to cure
What specific contractual agreement arises when a physician explicitly promises a successful outcome?
Article 2201 of the New Civil Code
Which Civil Code provision governs damages for breach of contract?
Legal right of plaintiff, correlative obligation of defendant, and act or omission violating the right
What are the three elements of a cause of action for breach of contract?
Natural and probable consequences foreseen or reasonably foreseeable at contract formation
What damages is a good-faith contract breaker liable for under Article 2201?
All damages reasonably attributable to non-performance
What damages is a bad-faith or fraudulent contract breaker liable for under Article 2201?
Expert testimony
What type of evidence is NOT required to prove breach of contract, unlike medical negligence?
Proof of non-performance of express contractual terms
What proof is sufficient to establish civil liability in a breach of contract action?
Article 19 of the New Civil Code
Which article mandates acting with justice, giving everyone their due, and observing honesty and good faith?
Honeste vivere, alterum non laedere, and jus suum quique tribuere
What three Latin maxims are embodied in Article 19 of the New Civil Code?
Article 20 of the New Civil Code
Which article mandates indemnification for willful or negligent acts contrary to law causing damage?
Article 21 of the New Civil Code
Which article mandates compensation for willfully causing loss or injury contrary to morals, good customs, or public policy?
Article 2176 of the New Civil Code
Which Civil Code article defines tort or quasi-delict?
Act or omission causing damage with fault or negligence present without a pre-existing contract
How is quasi-delict defined under Article 2176?
Unwarranted departure from accepted standards of medical practice resulting in patient injury
How is medical negligence defined under tort law?
Six categories
Into how many distinct categories are civil damages classified under Article 2197 NCC?
Actual or compensatory, Moral, Nominal, Temperate or moderate, Liquidated, and Exemplary or corrective
What are the six kinds of civil damages under Article 2197?
Adequate compensation for duly proven pecuniary loss and lost profits
What do actual or compensatory damages cover under Articles 2199 and 2200?
Daño emergente
What Latin term describes actual pecuniary loss suffered?
Lucro cesante
What Latin term describes unrealized lost profits?
All damages that are natural and probable consequences of the act or omission, whether foreseen or unforeseen
What damages are recoverable in crimes and quasi-delicts under Article 2202?
Diligence of a good father of a family
What degree of diligence must an aggrieved party exercise to mitigate damages under Article 2203?
P50,000.00
What is the baseline statutory civil indemnity for death caused by a crime or quasi-delict under prevailing jurisprudence?
Loss of earning capacity, support under Article 291 for up to 5 years, and moral damages for mental anguish
What three additional recoveries are granted to heirs upon death under Article 2206?
Spouse, legitimate and illegitimate descendants, and ascendants
Who may recover moral damages for mental anguish caused by a patient's death under Article 2206?
Express stipulation
What is generally required to recover attorney's fees under Article 2208?
Award of exemplary damages, compelled litigation with third persons, malicious prosecution, unfounded civil actions, gross bad faith, or equity
In what circumstances may attorney's fees be awarded without express stipulation?
Contributory negligence of the plaintiff
What circumstance mitigates civil recovery in quasi-delict actions under Article 2214?
Contravening contract terms, deriving benefit, inevitable loss, or attempting to minimize harm
What factors allow courts to equitably mitigate contractual or tort damages under Article 2215?
Physical suffering, mental anguish, fright, serious anxiety, besmirched reputation, wounded feelings, moral shock, and social humiliation
What injuries are included under moral damages under Article 2217?
Crimes or quasi-delicts causing physical injuries, defamation, and bad-faith breach of contract
In what actions are moral damages recoverable under Articles 2219 and 2220?
Vindicate or recognize a violated legal right
What is the purpose of awarding nominal damages under Article 2221?
Bars further contest regarding the right involved
What is the legal effect of awarding nominal damages under Article 2223?
Granted when pecuniary loss has been suffered but its exact monetary amount cannot be proven with certainty
When are temperate or moderate damages awarded under Article 2224?
Chronic or continuing injuries requiring long-term care
In what medical scenarios are temperate damages particularly applicable?
Exceeds nominal damages but falls below compensatory damages
How does the monetary value of temperate damages relate to nominal and actual damages?
Pre-agreed damages stipulated by contracting parties in advance
What are liquidated damages under Article 2226?
When found iniquitous or unconscionable
When may courts equitably reduce liquidated damages under Article 2227?
Imposed by way of example or correction for the public good
What is the purpose of exemplary or corrective damages under Article 2229?
Gross negligence
What must be established to award exemplary damages in quasi-delicts under Article 2231?