1/53
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Street v Mountford
Facts:
Wendy Mountford and her husband lived on the top floor of a house in Poole divided into flatlets- Owned by Roger Street, a solicitor.
An agreement was signed in 1983
Payment of £37 a week
Ban on anyone but them occupying the rooms without prior permission
Right on owner's right to enter rooms for inspection
Clean and tidy
Agreement terminable on 14 days notice.
The agreement was titled 'license' agreement- didn’t give them tenancy.
Tenacy was protected under Rent Acts- security of tenure (right to stay as long as you occupy), fair rent without being affected by conditions of scarcity.
Under the Rent Act 1977 s1- tenancy under a dwelling which is let as a separate dwelling is a protected tenancy.
Issue: did the agreement create a lease?
Two opposing arguments:
Street- subjective intention is paramount- intent of license by signing contract
Mountford- objective test- once certain qualities are present, there is a lease
The decision: they decided that a lease is an arrangement which confers exclusive possession, for a term, at a rent. They adopted the objective test.
What is a lease?
A lease is distinct from a freehold, which is indefinite in length but a lease is time limited.
Leasehold estate- control of property is defined by the time of the lease. Carved out for a set period of time.
License- permission. Gives no property interest by itself.
Aslan v Murphy [1989]
Facts:
Murphy occupied small basement room owned by Aslan
Contract stated it was a 'license fee'- owner retained keys, occupant must vacate room for 90 mins each day and the owner permitted others to use the space. Essentially stating that Murphy did not have exclusive possession.
In practice, no other people were permitted to use the room and the daily exclusion rule was never enforced.
Held:
Applied substance over form approach (Lord Templeman)
Daily exclusion and sharing terms were not exercised
Retaining a key is not determinative, it depends on how it is used
Thus, Murphy was a tenant with exclusive possession. Not a lodger or a licensee.
Antoniades v Villiers [1990]
Antoniades owned a one bedroom flat in a loft conversion occupied by an unmarried couple- Villiers and Bridger
The owner waned them to sign separate but identical agreements, described as a license.
Question was asked whether it was a lease or license.
Templeman's substance over form was followed
Title is not determinative
The agreements were not separate, they were interdependent and read together.
Clause 16 was a pretense- never intended to be used.
Looking to the reality: a couple were sharing a small one bed flat as joint tenants with executive possession.
AG securities v Vaughan [1989]
HMO
Parties moved in at different times
AG retained the right to introduce a new occupier when someone left.
Lease or license?
Court held that they were licensees, not joint tenants
The separate agreements were genuine and reflected the real arrangement between the parties
They were not joint tenants (moved in at different times)
Clause allowed landlord to replace tenants- they did not have executive possession
Certainty of term
Leases must be of a certain term- Lace v Chantler [1944]
Special rules apply to convert any attempt to create a lease for life into a fixed term of 90 years- LPA s149. However, this is specific and not a general cure for any uncertainty- Mexfield Housing Cooperative Ltd v Berrisford [2011]
When will a purchaser be bound by the lease?
Unregistered title- bind whole word, irrespective of notice
Registered title:
Less than 7 years- can be overriding interest. Sch 3 para 1
More than 7 years- must have been registered
Westminster City Council v Clarke [1992] 2 AC 288
The City Council (C) owned a hostel for homeless men in which Mr. Clarke (D) occupied a room.
C and D entered into an agreement which permitted D to stay at the hostel which was headed ‘Licence to Occupy’ and clearly stated that it is not intended to create rights and obligations of a tenancy.
The agreement also stated that the occupier’s accommodation can be changed without notice as the council directs and the occupier can be required to share a room.
Following complaints by other residents the C sought to remove D from his accommodation.
D argued that the agreement was a lease and that he was entitled to statutory protection from removal as a ‘secure tenant’ under the Housing Act 1985.
The grant of exclusive possession would be inconsistent with the C’s purpose
Rights reserved by an owner over the property licensed to an occupier will not be deemed to be pretences intended to hide the appearance of a lease if they serve a genuine purpose.
Characteristics of a tenancy
Exclusive possession
For a certain term
At a rent
Priority- general rules
LRA (2002) s28(1)- priority as between interests in registered land are determined by the order of creation.
Exceptions:
LRA 2002 s29(1)- transfer of legal estate for value which is then registered.
Priority- protection of an interest
Notice is put on register
Leases of less than 7 years
Interests of persons in occupation
Legal easements
Actual occupation cases
Boland- Mrs Boland significantly financially contributed to the property but hadn't registered any legal interest. She had proprietary interests since she contributed to the purchase of the home. She had actual occupation
McCann- she contributed to the purchase price of a property, but her actual occupation did not exist prior to the creation of the legal charge. She only moved her furniture in 25 minutes before the legal transfer.
Facchini v Bryson [1952]
Service occupancy- lease was created
Lack of intention to create legal relations
Family- Errington v Errington
Formalities not complied with tends to create an equitable lease
Walsh v Lonsdale and s2 Law of Property- Misc Provisions Act 1989.
Elitestone test for determining whether a structure is part of the land?
The test was reiterated in Elitestone, originating from Holland v Hogson, and makes it so that the degree of annexation and the object of the annexation are considered.
Many different tests have been suggested, such as whether the object which has been fixed to the property has been so fixed for the better enjoyment of the object as a chattel, or whether it has been fixed with a view to effecting a permanent improvement of the freehold.
Can a chattel be connected to water and electricity?
Yes
Distinction between a house and chattel.
A house which is constructed in such a way that it cannot be removed at all, save by destruction, cannot have been intended to remain as a chattel. It was made clear in Elitestone that the physical object is a fixture if it merges with the land.
What happened in Elitestone Ltd v Morris?
The predecessor of Morris had constructed a wooden bungalow. It rested on concrete pillars, and the pillars were attached to Elitestone’s land. The structure could only be used when on the land; removing the bungalow would have required demolition and reconstruction of the structure. The House of Lords held, unanimously, that the structure was not a fixture per se, however it must be intended to form part of the land, to have become ‘part and parcel’ of the land, because of the difficulty of its removal and the magnitude of its affixing to the land.
Chelsea Yacht & Boat Co v Pope
A houseboat was held not to be part of the land because it was not permanently affixed, affirmed in Tristmire v Mew [2011]
Botham v TSB Bank [1996]
White goods were chattels because, although they were required for the use of the kitchen, they were not sufficiently annexed or permanent enough to be considered a fixture.
Tower Hamlets LBC v Bromley LBC [2015]
Ownership of statue not passed on but they had asserted rights of dominion over the statue. Better enjoyment.
Leigh v Taylor
Artworks affixed for displays remain chattels.
Legal interests
Must comply with rules for legal interest
Be created using formalities/registered
Binding on third parties
Equitable interests
Formalities less significant
May bind third parties
The insurance principle
The state guarantees that any loss incurred by a land purchaser resulting from reliance on the conclusiveness of the Land Register will be compensated through a statutory indemnity system.
The curtain principle
The concept that land registration may allow certain equitable interests attached to the land to be hidden from a purchaser's view. Records the things the state wants it to record.
The mirror principle
Registration of a land title must reflect all the important and significant details that a purchaser must know before buying the land.
LRA (2002) s28(1)
Priority of an interest affecting a registered estate is not affected by a disposition of the estate
Thus, priority as between interests in registered land are determined by the order of creation.
LRA 2002 s29(1)
Registered disposition- the transfer of the legal estate or creation of a mortgage.
For value- money has changed hands (doesn’t have to be sufficient)
Search of register is required, but no further diligence
Essentially, if a person buys the land for money and register it, they can take priority.
How to protect a property interest
Put a notice on the register
Falls within schedule 3 as an overriding interest
The most important are:
Leases of less than 7 years
Interests of persons in occupation
Legal easements
They don’t have to be registered to have priority to a subsequent purchaser.
Impact of overriding interests
They represent a major exception to the mirror principle i.e. the register should reflect all interests affecting an estate.
What constitutes an overriding interest?
[1] Interest + [2] actual occupation = overriding interest
Both must be present, do NOT fall into the trap of just considering actual occupation!
Licenses and interests
Licences Do NOT generally bind a purchaser and in any event can be revoked on reasonable notice. However, see Binions v Evans [1972]- a new obligation to observe Mrs Evans licence was directly imposed on him.
Occupation- Boland
Mrs Boland significantly financially contributed to the property but hadn't registered any legal interest. She had proprietary interests since she contributed to the purchase of the home. She had actual occupation
Occupation- Abbey National BS v Cann
She contributed to the purchase price of a property, but her actual occupation did not exist prior to the creation of the legal charge. She only moved her furniture in 25 minutes before the legal transfer.
The Rent Act 1977 (preceding the 1988 Housing Act
Fair rent, ignoring scarcity. This no longer applies to tenancies- however, some people retain their protections if they signed the lease before the Housing Act.
Housing Act 1988
Provided that all tenancies would be at the 'market rent'- the rent a property could reasonable achieve on the open market from a willing landlord, or comparable tenancy terms.
Limited rights to challenge excessive rent increases.
McCann v UK [2008]
Local authority landlord took possession proceedings against a former joint tenant.
Procedure allowed eviction without any court assessment of proportionality Article 8 applies.
Question- did article 8 apply and if so, did a court have to consider proportionality before ordering possession?
It was held that article 8 applied and the interference with article 8 rights was lawful.
The interference was in pursuit of a legitimate aim
But the issue was whether the interference was proportionality and here it was decided it was not.
Consequence is that any common law possession proceedings taken by a public body requires consideration of proportionality of the eviction.
McDonald v McDonald [2016]
Facts:
Fiona lived in a house bought by her parents with a mortgage, who granted her an AST.
Mortgage arrears, received appointed and served s21 notice.
Faced homelessness and serious mental health issues.
Argued: article 8 applied and court must consider proportionality of order.
She looked to Mcann to assess the proportionality.
The court rejected her argument- they distinguished McCann.
Article 8 applied vertically (between state and individuals, not between individuals)
In McCann, the public body was seeking her eviction.
In this case, the tenancy was private. Public law standards could not apply.
Housing Act 2004
Regulation of shared housing (HMOs)
Tenancy deposit schemes
Housing standards- Housing Health and Safety Rating System
This, however, was underpinned by notion that Housing Act was working well and no major changes were needed.
Renter’s Rights Act 2025
ASTs abolished, as is s21. Most are now rolling assured tenancies, giving tenants flexibility to leave.
Rent increases limited: one per year, can be challenged by tribunal.
New rights: rights to request pet, prohibition on tenancy discrimination.
More accountability- landlord database, ombudsman
Ramsey v Love
Agent can sign contract- act on behalf of someone
Conveyancing stages
Valid contract s2(1)LP(MP)A 1989)
A deed- s52, LPA 1295, s1 )LP(MP)A 1989
Registering the transfer and mortgage- LRA 2002, ss3-4, 27
Rule for contract
Law of Property (MP) Act 1989, s2(1): A contract for sale or other disposition in land [ie agreement to grant an easement, lease, mortgage] can only be made in writing, and only incorporating all the terms … in one document or, where contracts are exchange, in each [and] s2(3) signed…
Applies to executory land contracts – Keay v Morris Homes (West Midlands) Ltd [2012] 1 WLR 2855.
Non compliance- contract is void
Signature-s2(3) 'must be signed' (formalities- contract)
Green v Ireland- typed signatures
Pereira Ferandes Sa v Mehta- the courts said that a party can sign using full name, initials, pseudonym, or random letters or numbers. Intention of signature- authenticating effect. Automatically inserting email address is not sufficient.
Neocleous v Rees- email signature (solicitors case)
CNT v Cooper
There is no accident. There must be a formal process.
But the courts can be flexible.
Collateral contracts
Where parties have entered into a composite transaction
If some parts comply with s2, but some others do not (which are not about the land).
Grossman v Hooper- purchase of curtains. Sale of house must be truly independent from the sale of the curtains.
Rectification
Court can rectify contract so it reflects parties true intentions
Robert Leonard Dev Ltd v Wright
House needed to be sold with furnishings
Contract didn’t include these terms
Collateral contracts could not be relied on.
Court said contract could be rectified, as long as the term was the common intention of the parties and it was simply mistakenly left out.
What is the effect of a valid land contract after Scott?
A contract for sale of land or creation of an interest (estate contract) is binding on seller and it may bind third parties if:
(1) It is protected by a Land Registry Notice OR
(2) The purchaser of registered land is in occupation they may claim priority as an overriding interest under Schedule 3 para 2 – see second semester and may bind third parties BUT
Completion (stage 2 formalities)
Performance of the contract is completed by:
The purchaser paying the purchase price
The seller transfers ownership.
Requires a deed by s52 LPA 1925
There is an exception for leases of less than 3 years
What is a deed?
S1 Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 requires:
An intention that a document is a deed;
Is validly executed as a deed by the seller or their properly authorised agent ie by power of attorney
Signed as a deed AND witnessed eg signed as a Deed by Ms Smith in the presence of
AND delivered as a deed intended to have immediate effect i.e. not in escrow (subject to a condition)
Registration of land (stage 3 formalities)
Registration of the transfer is the final stage Different registration rules apply to:
Registered land – s27 LRA 2002
Unregistered land – ss3-4 LRA 2002
Since the Land Registration Act 2002, registration has constitutive effect – see Cowan, Great Debates, ch 5
It perfects the transfer and, until requirements are met, legal title remains with the seller while the purchaser retains equitable title.
What is the registration gap?
It takes time for the land registry entries to be made. The purchaser can guard against this by freezing the register so ownership passes from the date of application, but if the purchaser does not register within the priority period, they can lose priority.
Shown in Baker v Craggs.