1/294
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Attachment
An emotional connection between individuals that is most clearly demonstrated by one individuals reaction to separation from the other
Separation distress
An emotional reaction experienced when an individual is separated from someone to whom they are attached
Importance of infant caregiver attachment
Attachment between infants and caregivers is an important developmental stage that provides a foundation for further development
Evidence for the importance of attachment
Research involving both animals and humans suggests that early attachment between infants and caregivers contributes to later development
Harry Harlow 1958
A researcher who investigated the effects of early maternal experiences on later development through experiments with infant rhesus monkeys
The Nature of Love 1958
An article by Harry Harlow exploring the importance of early maternal experiences and the role of contact comfort in attachment
Aim of Harlow 1958
To investigate the effects of early experiences with a mother or primary caregiver on later development and determine what motivates infant attachment
Traditional behaviourist explanation of attachment
Attachment was believed to develop because caregivers satisfy basic biological needs such as hunger and thirst by providing food
Behaviourist explanation of the mother infant attachment relationship
Infants become attached to their mothers because mothers provide food and infants learn to associate their presence with satisfaction of hunger and thirst
Attachment as a secondary drive
The traditional view that attachment develops as a consequence of satisfying primary biological needs such as hunger and thirst rather than being an independent need
Why behaviourists believed infants attached to mothers
Mothers provide food and nourishment so infants develop an association between their mothers and the reduction of hunger and thirst
Harlows criticism of the traditional attachment explanation
He argued that attachment could not simply be explained by the satisfaction of basic biological needs because emotional comfort and physical contact were also important
Contact comfort
The emotional security and reassurance obtained through physical contact with a soft comforting caregiver
Central argument of Harlow 1958
Attachment is not simply caused by hunger and thirst reduction because infants also seek physical comfort and emotional security from caregivers
Why Harlow used rhesus monkeys
Rhesus monkeys share important basic behaviours with human infants including nursing and clinging as well as cognitive abilities involving perception memory and learning
Developmental differences between rhesus monkeys and human infants
Rhesus monkeys are more mature at birth and develop more rapidly than human babies
Similarities between rhesus monkeys and human infants
Both display basic behaviours such as nursing and clinging and possess cognitive abilities involving perception memory and learning
Artificial surrogate mother in Harlow 1958
A constructed replacement mother designed to provide infant monkeys with different combinations of food warmth and physical comfort
Cloth surrogate mother in Harlow 1958
A surrogate mother constructed from a wooden block covered with soft cotton cloth and equipped with a heat source and a milk dispensing mechanism
Features of the cloth mother
She provided soft physical contact warmth and milk allowing infant monkeys to receive both basic biological care and contact comfort
Heat source in the cloth mother
A light bulb placed behind the surrogate mother that radiated warmth for the infant monkey
Milk dispensing mechanism in the cloth mother
A device installed in the breast area that allowed the surrogate mother to provide milk to infant monkeys
Purpose of the cloth mother
To provide an artificial caregiver offering food warmth and soft physical contact so researchers could investigate the importance of contact comfort
Wire surrogate mother in Harlow 1958
A second artificial mother constructed from wire with a heat radiator and milk dispensing mechanism but without the soft cloth covering
Features of the wire mother
She provided warmth and milk but lacked the soft comforting surface that allowed infant monkeys to experience contact comfort
Difference between the cloth and wire mothers
Both could provide warmth and milk but the cloth mother offered soft physical contact whereas the wire mother was made of uncomfortable wire
Harlows description of the wire mother
Biologically adequate but psychologically inept because she could satisfy basic biological needs without providing the same physical comfort
Purpose of comparing cloth and wire mothers
To investigate whether infant monkeys preferred contact comfort or satisfaction of basic biological needs when choosing which surrogate mother to spend time with
First experiment in Harlow 1958
Infant rhesus monkeys were placed in cages adjacent to both a cloth and a wire surrogate mother and allowed to choose freely between them
Participants in the first Harlow experiment
Eight infant rhesus monkeys divided into two groups of four
First experimental condition in Harlow 1958
Four infant monkeys received milk from the cloth mother while the wire mother did not provide milk
Second experimental condition in Harlow 1958
The other four infant monkeys received milk from the wire mother while the cloth mother did not provide milk
Independent variable in the first Harlow experiment
The type of surrogate mother available and whether the cloth or wire mother provided milk
Dependent variable in the first Harlow experiment
The amount of time infant monkeys spent with the cloth mother and the wire mother
Procedure in the first Harlow experiment
Infant monkeys had continuous access to both surrogate mothers and researchers measured how much time they spent with each mother across different age periods
Findings of the first Harlow experiment
Infant monkeys consistently preferred spending time with the soft cloth mother rather than the wire mother
Main finding of Harlow 1958 regarding contact comfort
Infant monkeys preferred contact comfort from the cloth mother even when the wire mother was responsible for providing food
Findings when the wire mother provided milk
Infant monkeys used the wire mother to obtain milk but increasingly spent their remaining time with the cloth mother
Developmental finding in the first Harlow experiment
By approximately twenty days of age monkeys had learned to approach the wire mother primarily to obtain milk while spending increasing amounts of time with the cloth mother
Meaning of the twenty day finding
Infant monkeys distinguished between the surrogate that provided food and the surrogate that provided physical comfort demonstrating that attachment was not simply determined by food provision
Conclusion of the first Harlow experiment
Contact comfort was more important than food provision in determining which surrogate mother infant monkeys preferred to spend time with
How the first Harlow experiment challenged behaviourism
Monkeys preferred the cloth mother even when the wire mother provided milk contradicting the belief that attachment is primarily caused by hunger and thirst reduction
Evidence against attachment as a secondary drive
Infant monkeys sought the cloth mother for comfort even when their food was provided by the wire mother
Secure base hypothesis
The idea that an attached caregiver provides a source of security from which an infant can confidently explore the surrounding environment
Secure base
A trusted caregiver who provides emotional security and reassurance allowing an infant to explore unfamiliar environments and return for comfort when necessary
Purpose of the second Harlow experiment
To investigate whether the cloth surrogate mother functioned as a secure base that encouraged infant monkeys to explore their environment
Open field test in Harlow 1958
An experimental procedure in which infant monkeys were placed in a small room containing unfamiliar stimuli and researchers observed their exploratory and emotional behaviour
Environment in the open field test
A small room containing objects that monkeys typically enjoyed manipulating and exploring such as wooden blocks and blankets
Conditions in the open field test
Infant monkeys were observed in the room alone with a cloth mother or with a wire mother
Independent variable in the open field test
Whether the infant monkey was alone with a cloth surrogate mother or with a wire surrogate mother
Dependent variable in the open field test
The monkeys exploratory behaviour attachment behaviour and emotional responses within the unfamiliar environment
Procedure in the open field test
Infant monkeys were placed in a room containing toys and objects and their behaviour was observed across trials with different surrogate mother conditions
Findings when the cloth mother was present
Infant monkeys repeatedly approached and clung to the cloth mother before moving away to explore and manipulate objects in the room
Exploratory behaviour with the cloth mother
Monkeys used the cloth mother as a secure base by returning to her for reassurance before leaving again to investigate their surroundings
Attachment behaviour with the cloth mother
Monkeys rushed toward the cloth mother clutched her and manipulated her body and face before returning to exploration
Relationship between the cloth mother and exploration
The presence of the cloth mother provided security that encouraged infant monkeys to explore unfamiliar objects and environments
Findings when the wire mother was present
Infant monkeys displayed more anxious behaviour and frequently froze or remained motionless in a crouched position in the corner of the room
Findings when no mother was present
Infant monkeys also displayed anxious behaviour and struggled to explore the unfamiliar environment
Additional signs of distress in the wire mother and no mother conditions
Some monkeys screamed or cried and could not be easily calmed down
Conclusion of the open field test
The cloth mother provided a secure base that reduced anxiety and encouraged exploration whereas the wire mother did not provide equivalent emotional security
Secure base and cognitive development
Properly formed attachment may encourage exploration of the environment and thereby provide opportunities for learning and cognitive growth
Relationship between attachment and exploration
A secure attachment provides reassurance allowing infants to explore unfamiliar environments and interact with objects rather than remaining anxious and withdrawn
Overall conclusion of Harlow 1958
Contact comfort is essential to attachment and an emotionally comforting caregiver provides a secure base that supports exploration and development
First major contribution of Harlow 1958
The research challenged the traditional behaviourist explanation by demonstrating that attachment is not simply based on food provision or satisfaction of hunger and thirst
Second major contribution of Harlow 1958
The research demonstrated the importance of contact comfort and the role of a secure base in encouraging exploration
Third major contribution of Harlow 1958
The findings helped establish the importance of physical affection and emotional security in early caregiver relationships
Methodological strength of Harlow 1958
The use of two surrogate mothers allowed researchers to separate the effects of food provision from the effects of contact comfort
Another methodological strength of Harlow 1958
Researchers measured observable behaviour such as time spent with each surrogate mother and exploratory behaviour in the open field test
Limitation of Harlow 1958 regarding generalizability
Rhesus monkeys are not humans and although they share basic behaviours with human infants their attachment processes develop much more rapidly
Why Harlow 1958 may not fully generalize to humans
Attachment develops more slowly in human infants so the timing and nature of attachment development may differ from those observed in rhesus monkeys
Ethical issue in Harlow 1958
Infant monkeys were deliberately raised in conditions that deprived them of appropriate mother infant contact and potentially disrupted their cognitive and emotional development
Why Harlow 1958 raises animal welfare concerns
The experimental conditions exposed infant monkeys to emotional distress and prevented them from experiencing normal maternal relationships
Potential long term consequences of Harlow 1958 for the monkeys
Early deprivation of appropriate maternal contact may have negatively affected their emotional social and cognitive development
Ethical justification sometimes offered for Harlow 1958
The research produced findings that changed understanding of infant care and highlighted the importance of human contact for healthy development
Societal contribution of Harlow 1958
The findings helped change understanding of basic care in institutions such as orphanages by demonstrating that providing food and warmth alone is insufficient without human contact
Implications for orphanage care
Infants require human contact and emotional comfort in addition to food warmth and other basic biological necessities for successful development
Importance of human contact in infancy
Physical and emotional contact with caregivers is an essential component of healthy infant development
Ethical evaluation of Harlow 1958
Although the findings provided important insights into attachment and influenced human childcare practices the deliberate deprivation and distress experienced by infant monkeys raise serious ethical concerns
Overall significance of Harlow 1958
The research demonstrated that attachment is driven importantly by contact comfort and emotional security rather than simply by the satisfaction of hunger and thirst
John Bowlby 1958 to 1960
A psychologist who proposed a theory of attachment combining biological and cognitive factors to explain how attachment develops and influences later relationships
Bowlbys theory of attachment
A theory proposing that attachment involves two interconnected components the biologically based attachment behavioural system and the cognitively based internal working model
Two components of Bowlbys attachment theory
The attachment behavioural system and the internal working model
Attachment behavioural system
An instinctive biologically based sequence of behaviours activated by environmental cues that encourage an infant to seek and maintain physical proximity to their caregiver
Biological basis of the attachment behavioural system
Attachment behaviours are instinctive responses triggered by environmental cues associated with danger fear or discomfort
Purpose of the attachment behavioural system
To encourage infants to seek and maintain physical proximity to their caregivers when they experience or anticipate danger fear or discomfort
Environmental cues activating the attachment behavioural system
Signals or situations that suggest danger fear or discomfort and trigger attachment related behaviours
Alarm in Bowlbys attachment theory
A mode of the attachment behavioural system activated when an individual senses danger
Anxiety in Bowlbys attachment theory
A mode of the attachment behavioural system triggered when an individual anticipates fear or discomfort
Difference between alarm and anxiety
Alarm occurs when an individual senses danger whereas anxiety occurs when an individual anticipates fear or discomfort
Behaviour associated with alarm and anxiety
Both states encourage infants to seek and maintain physical proximity to their caregiver
Physical proximity seeking
An attachment behaviour in which an infant attempts to remain close to their caregiver for protection reassurance and security
Internal working model
The cognitive component of Bowlbys attachment theory consisting of mental representations and beliefs about attachment figures the self and relationships with other people
Three components of the internal working model
Beliefs about attachment figures beliefs about the self and beliefs about relationships with other people
Cognitive basis of the internal working model
It consists of mental representations developed through experiences with caregivers that influence how individuals understand themselves and their relationships
Beliefs about attachment figures in the internal working model
Mental representations concerning whether caregivers are available responsive reliable and willing to provide attention and comfort
Beliefs about the self in the internal working model
Mental representations concerning an individuals own worthiness of attention affection and care
Beliefs about relationships in the internal working model
Expectations about how other people behave and how responsive relationships are likely to be
How the internal working model develops
Repeated experiences with caregivers contribute to beliefs about the self attachment figures and the nature of relationships
Example of neglect influencing the internal working model
A child who repeatedly seeks closeness and expresses distress but receives little attention may develop the belief that they are not worthy of attention or care
Effect of consistent parental neglect in Bowlbys theory
Repeated rejection or lack of responsiveness may contribute to a negative internal working model in which the child expects others to be unavailable and believes they are unworthy of attention