1/52
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is law?
Law is all around and applies to both small and large parts of life beyond codes, defines privileges and obligations
What is law compared to?
A tree with a defined functionality and predictability
Sources of law?
Legislation, common law, other sources like Indigenous
Rule of law?
Nobody is above the law and the law must not be arbitrary, this is the laws foundation
Public vs private law?
Public is individual vs society, private is torts or civil law
Common misconception about illegality?
Though it is criminal activity, it doesn’t necessarily equate to immortality
Constitution?
The legal claim on which a state is founded and operates, it grants the authority of a state to make/enforce laws, creates structures and outlines ideals of a nation
Relevant acts to Canada’s constitution?
Constitution Act of 1867, 1982 Amendment
Constitution Act of 1982?
Included the Charter of Rights and Freedoms which prevents the government from breaching the rights of individuals, recognized treaty rights of Indigenous people, process to amend the written constitution
Purpose of unwritten principles?
Allows certain problems that aren’t outlined in the constitution to be dealt with and endure through world changes (ex. democracy, rule of law, judicial independence)
Democracy?
The sovereign will of the people that is represented by representatives, can also exist outside of government
Judicial independence?
Judiciary’s freedom to act without political interference, acts as a shield for individuals against the state and protects the constitution
Constitutional supremacy?
The constitution is the supreme law of Canada, any law in conflict with it is of no force or effect
Procedure for inconsistent legislation?
Not automatically invalid, courts issue remedies like reading-in (rewrite) or reading-down (narrow down)
Parliamentary supremacy?
Where the government can overrule the constitution, before the charter Canada was this
What is outlined in the charter?
Fundamental freedoms, democratic rights, legal rights, equality rights
Section 1 of the Charter?
It is subject to reasonable limits that can be justified in a democratic society
Section 33 of the Charter?
Notwithstanding clause, which allows the government to exempt laws from sections of the charter
Limit of freedom of expression?
Acts of violence is not protected under the charter and physical acts can count as expression
R v. Keegstra?
A landmark case that shows that while banning hate speech is limiting freedom of expression, it is a reasonable limit justified under section 1
Federalism?
Division of legislative power within a state where the provincial is not subordinate to federal, areas of power outlined by the constitution
Heads of power in federal vs provincial?
28 powers in federal, including criminal law while provincial deals with property, civil rights, OHS, drivers licenses, etc
Jurisdiction?
What the government has power over
Intra vires?
When legislation falls within a governments power
Ultra vires?
When legislation falls outside a governments power (unconstitutional)
Asymmetrical federalism?
When different provinces are treated differently based on relational differences like population and history
Dominant tide of federalism?
Powers between levels of government overlap
Federal paramountcy?
When federal and provincial laws conflict and are both intra vires, the federal law prevails
Division of powers analysis?
Determine the pith and substance of a law (characterization), then classify the law based on which head of power it belongs under
National concern doctrine?
Show the matter is of sufficient concern to the whole country, the specifics of the matter (singleness), provincial inability to deal with it (distinctive) and scale of impact (indivisibility)
Federal Peace Order and Good Governance?
Says that the federal government has powers over national concern
How does constitutional change come about?
Interpretation of laws through the judiciary most often but there is an amending formula that requires unanimous consent. Written constitutional laws are harder to amend
How was the federations resolution brought about?
By an act of British parliament, talked about amendment of the constitution only
How does the federal government have power over provincial acts?
Can disallow provincial acts one year within their passing
Which Canadian province has a distinct civil law?
Quebec
Amending changes made in the 1982 Act?
Established legal formulas for amending the constitution (Queen amendments = unanimous, general amending = 2/3 provinces and ½ population, multiple province amending, change in executive government), said first 3 amending formulas entrench parts of the written constitution
Patriation and its relation to equality?
Refers to the power to amend the constitution being brought home, equality rights came into effect 3 years after patriation to allow time for revision
How do municipalities derive their authority?
Authority is transferred to them by the provincial government
Life cycle of legislation?
Begins as a bill (proposal) and goes through first reading where it can be changed, then goes through second and third reading and if passed, goes through the other half of parliament (bicameral system only for federal), if passed must receive royal assent and becomes an act
Regulations?
Process for creating is much quicker, includes the fine details of an act and the act is its enabling statute
SA vs RSA?
SA is all statutes passed in a year and RSA is all statutes/amendments passed up until a specific point (10-20 years), A = Alberta but also applies to Canada = C
Adversarial system?
A court case is always a dispute between 2 or more parties
Ratio descendi?
The idea that when a rule emerges in a upper court, that decision is binding on all lower courts
Obiter dictum?
Something a judge says that is not binding because it isn’t part of the ruling but still has persuasive authority
Written vs oral decision?
Appeal courts always use written but straight forward decisions in lower courts can be given orally
Trial courts vs appellate courts?
Trial courts are courts of first instance because they receive all evidence and written statements with one judge, appellate courts don’t receive new evidence and uses a panel
Issues of fact?
Disputed points about what actually happened in the case, usually has more judge deference
Issues of law?
Where one argues that the wrong legal test or legislature was applied, gets less judge deference
3 elements of judicial independence?
Security of tenure (cannot be fired), financial security, institutional independence from other branches
How do courts ensure accountability of judges?
Judges must be apolitical at all times, open court principle, reasons for judgements provided, right of appeal, committees recommend appointees
Why does legislation trump the common law?
Because the legislative body is elected and judges aren’t
Binding vs persuasive?
Courts below a higher court are binding to a ruling while courts between provinces of the same level are persuasive
Why might a binding precedent not be applied?
Because a case is distinguishable based on its fact