Philosophy Ethics SAC responses

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/8

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

9 Terms

1
New cards

Explain Aristotle’s account of how moral character develops. In your response, show how action, habit, pleasure, and pain contribute to the development of virtue.

Aristotle emphasises the importance of habituation in the development of a virtuous character. He suggests that no one has an innate moral sense, and instead, virtuous actions must be habituated to develop a virtuous state of character. He argues it is important that people learn to take pleasure in good actions and pain in bad ones, so that they can develop virtues, and when people automatically feel a sense of happiness or pleasure from committing good acts, it is the ultimate indicator that they have developed this virtue as part of their character. Imagine if a child is told by their parent to give a coin to a homeless person, but refuses because they are too scared. Then, after they repeatedly are courageous by talking to new people in public, the next time they see this person, they give them a coin and approach them as well as feeling pleasure. Aristotle would argue that this emotional response reflects the child’s character and by habituating this act, this virtue has been ‘made perfect by habit.’

2
New cards

How might another philosophical account of moral motivation challenge of qualify Aristotle’s emphasis on habituation?

Though both Kant and Aristotle argue that morality is grounded in reason, Kant would contend that all rational beings have the capacity to recognise universal moral duties, which are binding to all rational beings. He also suggests that all of these beings have an internal sense of duty. Imagine that there s someone at the pool who has completed lifeguard training, and they see another person drowning. Aristotle may say that this person should act in a balance between recklessness and cowardice, and save the person. However, Kant would argue that having a habituated virtue such as courage is not enough to act upon, and instead, this person must question whether they can rationally will the ‘maxim’ of refusing assistance becoming a universal law. Thus, Kant would challenge Aristotle’s emphasis on habituation by arguing that virtuous characters are not sufficient to know how to morally act right, and universal laws and moral duties should be considered too. He would also argue that by Aristotle treating experiences as things that lead to the development of a virtuous character, and potentially justifying actions of this, his ‘habituation’ risks treating people as means to an end.

3
New cards

After considering Aristotle and Kant, is the cultivation of a virtuous character sufficient to guide action when moral values conflict or when doing the right thing carries a significant personal cost? Defend your position and test it with a relevant example, case study, or thought experiment.

No, I do not think having a virtuous character is sufficient to guide moral actions when moral values or personal costs conflict. There can be conflating duties and people can have a compulsion to act in a certain way yet still act differently, because of temporary lapses in judgement known as ‘akrasia’. Consider if there was someone hiding in your house, and the law enforcement demanded you tell them if the person is there. You can either lie to save them or tell the truth and risk harming them. These are two conflating virtues— honesty and responsibility, thus creating tension. Though Aristotle would offer ‘phronesis’ as a way to evaluate these actions, I believe that it does not settle the conflict between morals, instead only providing a way to consider them.

4
New cards

Explain how Kant applies the categorical imperative to the false promise of someone forced by necessity to borrow money knowing that they cannot repay it. Why does he conclude that the action is morally wrong?

Kant argues that this action is morally wrong, as the maxim cannot be successfully universalised. kant suggests that, though this maxim may increase one’s own feelings of pleasure and wellbeing, it is immoral, as the person cannot rationally will their ‘maxim’ becoming a universal law. Kant would also argue that the feeling of self-love is designed to promote wellbeing, positivity, and flourishing, so if it then leads to lying, it is contradictory to its purpose. Even if lying can sometimes lead to more positive outcomes, such as telling someone that you forgot to throw them a birthday party in order to give them a great surprise party at the end of the day, Kant simply suggests that people not being able to lie is an absolute duty, meaning that it can never be broken and not be considered immoral.

5
New cards

How might another philosophical perspective challenge or qualify Kant’s approach to determine whether the false promise is morally right or wrong?

Though both Kant and Mill agree that morality is grounded in reason, mill would critique Kant’s ‘universal law’ by suggesting that the consequence of an action determines its morality, not the principle or intention behind it. Mill would suggest that, though lying can often be harmful, if it promotes the maximum utility, then it is justifiable. Mill would argue that given tis person’s necessity to borrow money, their action of lying cannot automatically be deemed immoral as it is likely their action will produce more utility than if they suffered from not borrowing it. If it so happened that by this person lying, the other person suffered little consequences, or there was simply maximum utility produces, then it is justifiable according to his hedonistic consequentialist theory.

6
New cards

Are universal moral rules an adequate basis for deciding what we ought to do? Defend your position using relevant philosophical reasoning and at least one example/ case study.

No, I do not think universal moral rules are always suitable for deciding right actions. Sometimes we can act according to rules that create more suffering than pleasure. Mill would argue that the principles behind actions are not sufficient when actions’ consequences will not maxim utility, of acting according to purely rules and duties. Consider the Trolley Problem thought experiment where someone has the lever to a cart which will either be pulled to kill one person, or will continue and kill five. Kant would suggest that not killing people is an absolute duty, and so this person ought to not pull the lever, and let five die. Mill would challenge this by arguing that the principle would lead to an immoral consequence, and instead, they should pull the lever as to save five and produce the maximum utility.

7
New cards

Explain how Mill distinguishes higher from lower pleasures in this extract. Why does this distinction complicate a purely quantitative account of happiness

As a hedonistic utilitarianist, Mill would argue that ‘it is better to be a human dissatissfied than a pig satisfied’ to illustrate his distinction between types of pleasures. This explains his belief that higher, intellectual pleasures (like wisdom and intellect) are superior to lower, sensual pleasures (like eating and drinking, coming from basic human instincts), as they lead to more profound happiness and flourishing. This perspective differs from a purely qualitative account of happiness, as supported by Jeremy Bentham’s hedonic utilitarianism, which uses the ‘Hedonic calculus’ to measure the amount of pleasure and pain caused by an action, as it focuses on types of pleasure instead of simply amounts.

8
New cards

How might another utilitarian approach or ethical theory challenge Mill’s claim that some pleasures have greater quality than others? Explain the point of disagreement and apply it to a relevant example.

Jeremy Bentham, a hedonic utilitarianist, would criticise Mill’s distinction between pleasures and their differences in quality, by suggesting that a ‘hedonic calculus’ is used instead. Bentham would argue that instead of treating different pleasures as having different levels of value, these are merely long-term and short-term pleasures, differing in quantity, not quality. Bentham would suggest that the morality of actions is thus judged by how they maximise pleasure and minimise pain, not considering different types of pleasure.

9
New cards

Is happiness or well-being an adequate foundation for determining what is morally right? Defend your position, testing Mill’s view against a relevamt case study/ thought experiment

I do not think happiness and wellbeing are sufficient to determine morally right actions, as other factors must be considered too. Karl Popper argued that it is not enough to maximise pleasure, instead, we should minimise suffering, as it poses a more immediate and severe impact on human wellbeing. That is not to say that happiness is not important, but simply that it is not the only thing that should be considered in moral evaluation. Consider Amantya Sen’s Colosseum thought experiment, in which one gladiator is brutally killed, and there is a mass amount of pleasure from the crowd. To classical utilitarianists who weigh pleasure and pain on an aggregate scale, the ‘hedonic calculus’, this creates tension, as the crowd’s pleasure would justify the gladiator’s intense suffering, making it appear immoral by treating people as means to an end. Mill would challenge this, arguing that one cannot compare this sadistic entertainment and ‘lower pleasure’ to the intense suffering of the gladiator. Yet, his ethical theory does not allow for these two different units of utility to be compared, making his philosophy still have tension. I would be more inclined to agree with an ideal utilitarianist such as G.E. Moore, who would argue that happiness is not the only thing that is intrinsically valuable and things like fairness, the right to live (for the gladiator), and honour must be considered too. Thus, I would argee with Moore’s critique that Mill and other classical utilitarianists’ approaches can be overly rigid and reductive, and would suggest that not only happiness, but other intrinsic goods ought to be considered too when determining what is morally right.