1/90
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What qualifies as an NIL activity under Bylaw 22.02.3?
Using NIL to advertise commercial products, support nonprofits, or participate in activities incidental to athletics
Give 3 examples of permissible NIL activities
Commercial endorsements, charitable promotions, and activities incidental to athletics
What are the main concerns with student-athlete NIL involvement?
Compensation being used to pay for athletic participation or achievement rather than actual NIL activity
Can a student-athlete use an agent to negotiate a professional playing contract?
Yes, for negotiating employment terms with a professional team or league
Can a student-athlete use an agent to locate and negotiate NIL deals?
Yes. Bylaw 22.3.1 permits professional services and agent representation for NIL activities
T/F: NIL compensation may be based partly on athletic skill or reputation
True. Bylaw 22.01.1 permits this
Can an NIL deal pay a softball player extra for every home run?
No. That compensates athletic achievement, not NIL activity
Why does NIL contract wording matter?
Terms rewarding athletic participation or achievement can make an otherwise permissible deal impermissible
Can a university enter an NIL agreement with and pay a student-athlete?
Yes. Bylaw 22.1.1 permits institutional licensing and endorsement agreements
Can athletics staff facilitate an NIL deal between a student-athlete and a local business?
Yes. Institutional involvement in NIL activities is permitted
What are two NIL activities institutions may perform under 22.1.1?
Enter written NIL licensing/endorsement agreements and act as marketing agents for noninstitutional NIL contracts
How long can an institutional NIL licensing agreement generally last?
No longer than the student-athlete's period of eligibility
Can a university continue using previously created NIL content after eligibility expires?
Yes, if agreed upon, to promote its academic or athletics programs
Can a university pay a student-athlete for NIL rights in game broadcasts?
No. Bylaw 22.1.1 prohibits this
Can an institutional NIL agreement provide payments to a third party on the athlete's behalf?
No
Who may assist an athlete with NIL agreement discussions?
A parent, guardian, lawyer, or other competent representative unless waived in writing
Can a university guarantee a third party will pay a student-athlete for NIL?
No. Bylaw 22.1.1.1 prohibits institutional guarantees
What is an example of an impermissible institutional NIL guarantee?
A university promising to cover a brand's payment if the brand fails to pay
What is the exception for third-party NIL guarantees made before July 1, 2025?
They may apply during 2025–26; guaranteed amounts count toward the benefits cap until third-party payments are received
Do actual and necessary NIL activity expenses count toward the benefits cap?
No. Institutions may cover these expenses, and they are not NIL compensation
Can student-athletes receive NIL compensation from outside businesses?
Yes. Noninstitutional NIL activities are permitted subject to reporting and review requirements
What is an associated entity under Bylaw 22.02.1?
An organization supporting athletics, creating NIL opportunities exclusively for a school's athletes, or assisting with recruiting or retention
What are examples of associated entities?
NIL collectives and organizations such as Learfield when they meet the bylaw definition
What makes an individual an associated individual under 22.02.2?
Connection to an associated entity, lifetime contributions over $50,000, or assisting with recruiting or retention
Does donating exactly $50,000 make someone an associated individual under the donor provision?
No. The bylaw requires more than $50,000
Can contributions through family members or affiliated entities count toward the $50,000 threshold?
Yes. Direct and indirect lifetime contributions count
T/F: Athletes cannot enter NIL agreements with associated entities or individuals
False. They can, but the agreements must satisfy valid business purpose requirements
What must an associated entity's or individual's NIL deal demonstrate?
A valid business purpose and compensation comparable to similarly situated individuals with similar NIL value
What is NOT a valid business purpose for an associated entity NIL payment?
Raising money to induce a student-athlete to attend or participate at a particular institution
What may the CSC request to verify an NIL deal's valid business purpose?
Information and documentation from the student-athlete or entities involved
What does an NIL agreement need to show about activation of NIL rights?
Actual use of the NIL rights, including the planned use, obligations, timing, and ultimate use
Can a nonprofit NIL agreement qualify as having a valid business purpose?
Yes, if funding comes from the nonprofit and the athlete primarily raises funds for its legitimate charitable mission
What happens if an athlete does not provide requested information to the CSC?
The deal may not be cleared
What is CAPS used for?
Managing institutional revenue-sharing payments, allocating cap funds, and monitoring payments against the benefits cap
What does the institution report through the benefits cap management system?
Institutional NIL payments
What is the reporting threshold for noninstitutional NIL deals?
$600 or more in aggregate from the same or substantially similar third party
When must an athlete report a noninstitutional NIL deal?
Within 5 business days of executing the contract or agreeing to payment terms
What documentation must an athlete submit for an NIL deal?
Written documentation showing both the athlete and payor agreed to the terms
What happens if an athlete fails to report a required NIL deal?
They may face discipline, including future practice or competition ineligibility
How long does an institution have to review a potentially unreported NIL deal after discovering it?
2 business days
What happens if an athlete still has not reported the deal after the institution's 2-business-day review period?
The CSC makes the athlete immediately ineligible for practice and competition until reported
How much notice must the CSC provide before denying a deal for insufficient information?
14 calendar days
When do high school athletes begin reporting NIL deals?
The first day of classes of their junior year
When do two-year college athletes begin reporting NIL deals?
Upon initial enrollment
When must four-year transfers report qualifying NIL deals?
Deals executed after officially entering the Transfer Portal
When must prospective athletes report deals after initial full-time enrollment at a Division I school?
By the earlier of 14 days after enrollment or before their first scheduled outside contest
Who is responsible for accurately reporting an NIL deal?
The student-athlete
What must a payor attest to when submitting an NIL deal?
Associated status, accuracy and completeness, no institutional direction, and self-funded payment
What does the CSC evaluate when reviewing an associated-party NIL deal?
Whether there is a valid business purpose and whether compensation is comparable
Can an athlete submit a proposed NIL deal before signing it?
Yes. The proposed deal may be submitted for review before execution
What options does an athlete have if an NIL deal is not cleared?
Rescind it, revise and resubmit it, appeal through the designated process, or return impermissible compensation
What are the three possible CSC outcomes for an NIL deal?
Clear the deal, flag it for further review, or do not clear it
What is the designated enforcement entity responsible for under Article 23?
Interpreting and enforcing House settlement bylaws, investigating violations, and prescribing penalties
What is neutral arbitration?
An independent process for an institution or athlete to contest a CSC decision or penalty
What is a neutral arbitrator?
An authorized independent dispute resolver whose decision is final and binding
What is a negotiated resolution under Article 23?
An agreed resolution among the institution, involved individuals, and enforcement entity, subject to CSC CEO approval
Who has sole authority to prescribe penalties for House settlement bylaw violations?
The CSC CEO
What are examples of factors that can increase penalties?
Premeditation, serious or repeated misconduct, competitive advantage, concealment, obstruction, and failure to cooperate
What are examples of factors that can reduce penalties?
Voluntary self-disclosure, cooperation, remediation, accepting responsibility, and effective compliance programs
What eligibility penalty can the CSC impose on an athlete?
Ineligibility for athletically related activities, including practice and competition
When can a program receive a postseason ban under Article 23?
For specified serious circumstances, such as failing to implement a penalty, refusing to cooperate, intentional obstruction, or an egregious violation causing competitive advantage
How long does an arbitrator generally have to issue a written decision?
45 days, with an extension possible for good cause
Are penalties generally enforced while arbitration is pending?
No. Penalties are stayed pending arbitration unless there is good cause to lift the stay
Does an athlete have the right to counsel during arbitration?
Yes
Who pays reasonable arbitrator fees when an institution uses arbitration?
The institution
What were the two main types of NIL deals before the House settlement changes?
Organic third-party NIL deals and facilitated or arranged NIL deals
What is the newer third category of athlete compensation discussed in lecture?
Revenue sharing
Who enforces traditional NCAA rules such as recruiting, financial aid, and playing seasons?
The NCAA
Who enforces NIL, revenue-sharing, and roster-limit rules at House settlement schools?
The CSC
What did the House settlement allow institutions to do directly?
Share revenue directly with student-athletes
What happened to scholarship limits under the House settlement changes?
They were replaced by roster limits
Does revenue sharing replace scholarships and third-party NIL deals?
No. Revenue sharing is in addition to scholarships and third-party NIL
Does the NCAA or CSC mandate how much revenue-sharing money each sport receives?
No. Institutions decide how to allocate their funds
What is the key Title IX consideration for institutional revenue sharing?
Equity, not necessarily identical dollar amounts for every sport
T/F: Because institutional NIL payments are permissible, the university does not have to report them
False. Institutional NIL payments must be reported through the benefits cap management system
Application: A softball player receives $500 for an hour of autograph signing. Does this deal meet the $600 reporting threshold by itself?
No. The individual deal is below $600, assuming no other payments from the same or substantially similar payor bring the aggregate to $600
Application: A player receives $750 from an associated car dealership for one promotional social media post. What issue should the CSC review?
Whether the deal has a valid business purpose and whether the compensation is comparable to similarly situated individuals
Application: A player receives $300,000 from State Farm for two hours in a commercial. Is the amount alone enough to establish a violation?
No. The review focuses on associated-party status, valid business purpose, and comparable compensation
Application: A university promises to pay an athlete if a third-party sponsor does not follow through. Is this permissible?
No. This is an institutional guarantee of third-party NIL compensation
Application: A donor gives exactly $50,000 to an institution. Are they an associated individual under the donor provision?
No. The threshold is more than $50,000
Application: A collective pays an athlete to attend a particular school, with no real promotional activity. Is this a valid business purpose?
No. Raising money to induce attendance or participation is not a valid business purpose
Application: An athlete signs a $900 NIL deal but reports it 8 business days later. Did they meet the reporting deadline?
No. The deal must be reported within 5 business days
Application: A university discovers an athlete's unreported NIL deal. What is the institution's review window?
2 business days after discovery to review and notify the CSC if there may be a violation
Application: An athlete's NIL deal with an associated business is not cleared. Name the athlete's options.
Rescind, revise and resubmit, appeal through the designated process, or return impermissible compensation
Application: A nonprofit pays an athlete to promote a charitable fundraiser. What must be true for the deal to qualify?
Funding must originate from the nonprofit and the primary activity must raise funds for its legitimate charitable mission
Application: An athlete receives a payment for every home run hit, with no advertising or other NIL activity. Is this permissible?
No. It rewards athletic achievement rather than an actual NIL activity
Application: A university pays for an athlete's necessary travel expenses to complete an NIL activity incidental to athletics. Does this count toward the benefits cap?
No. Actual and necessary expenses may be covered and are not NIL compensation
Application: A student submits a deal, but the CSC requests additional documentation and the athlete refuses. What may happen?
The CSC may decline to clear the deal
Application: An institution self-reports a violation, cooperates fully, and promptly fixes the issue. How could this affect penalties?
These are mitigating factors that may reduce the penalty
Application: An institution conceals evidence and instructs a witness to lie. How could this affect penalties?
These are aggravating factors that may increase the penalty
Application: A student-athlete's third-party NIL deal is permissible. Does the institution still have reporting responsibilities for its own NIL payments?
Yes. Institutional NIL payments must still be reported through the benefits cap management system