1/15
Flashcards created from Chapter 3 of Understanding Criminal Procedure (8th Edition by Dressler, Michaels, and Simmons) covering the history, theories, and application of Bill of Rights incorporation.
What is incorporation in American constitutional law?
The process by which most Bill of Rights protections have been made applicable to state governments through the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause.
What was the original scope of the Bill of Rights when ratified in 1791?
It was understood to restrict and limit only the federal government, leaving states with broad freedom over their own criminal legal systems.
Which landmark Supreme Court case held that the Bill of Rights applied only to the federal government and not to the states?
Barron v. Baltimore, 32 U.S. 243 (1833).
Which constitutional amendment and clause serves as the vehicle for incorporating the Bill of Rights against the states?
The Fourteenth Amendment (1868), specifically its Due Process Clause: "…nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law."
Why is incorporation critically important to modern criminal justice?
Because the vast majority of criminal cases in the United States are prosecuted in state courts rather than federal courts.
What are the two competing constitutional values central to the incorporation debate?
Federalism (preserving state legal independence, experimentation, and local control) versus National Uniformity (ensuring equal constitutional rights regardless of geography).
What is the main idea of the Full Incorporation theory, and who was its chief advocate?
The main idea is that every provision of the Bill of Rights automatically applies to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment. Its chief advocate was Justice Hugo Black.
How does the Fundamental Rights Theory determine which protections apply to state criminal proceedings?
Only rights considered fundamental to liberty and justice apply to the states, with courts determining on a case-by-case basis whether each right is essential to due process.
What distinguishes the Full-Incorporation-Plus theory from standard Full Incorporation?
Full-Incorporation-Plus applies all enumerated rights of the Bill of Rights to the states AND protects additional unenumerated fundamental rights under the Due Process Clause.
How does Selective Incorporation function in practice?
Each constitutional right is examined individually on its own merits; if it is fundamental to the American system of justice, it is incorporated against the states.
Which theory of incorporation has been adopted and overwhelmingly used by the U.S. Supreme Court?
Selective Incorporation.
What key question does the Supreme Court ask under Selective Incorporation?
"Is this right fundamental to the American system of ordered liberty and justice?"
What is the narrow interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause?
The view that due process guarantees only procedural fairness (such as notice, a hearing, and an impartial decision-maker), but does not mandate substantive Bill of Rights protections.
What is the broad interpretation of the Due Process Clause adopted by the Supreme Court?
The view that due process protects substantive constitutional rights, including many Bill of Rights provisions, making it the vehicle for incorporation.
What four key constitutional values explain why Selective Incorporation prevails?
Which Bill of Rights guarantees in the 4th, 5th, 6th, and 8th Amendments are incorporated against the states?
4th: Protection against unreasonable searches and seizures 5th: Privilege against self-incrimination 6th: Right to counsel and right to a jury trial 8th: Protection against cruel and unusual punishment