1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Main argument
Austen interrogated the practices and terms of the marriage market, which commodified women, and suggested alternatives to the subject positions society made available to women in her period. Her alternative to the marriage bargain is companionate marriage.
The marriage bargain vs. the companionate marriage in P&P
Marriage bargain: Lydia’s marriage to Wickham.
Companionate marriage: Elizabeth and Darcy; Jane and Bingley.
To reach this ideal, Austen overturns the traditional use of the blazon in the courtship novel.
Michie’s (2011) two key arguments (slide 9)
The 19th-century 1) marriage plot of the novel of manners argues about the private and personal realms but also the social, economic and political realms.
The novel has traces of two disciplines-discourses that emerged at the time (and separated from aesthetics in the 18th century): political economy and anthropology.
Political economy vs. anthropology in novels of manners
Political economy shows up as money, inheritance, and marriage as an economic transaction.
Anthropology shows up as marriage rules, gift-giving, and the social meaning of exchange.
Marriage bargain
marriage as a financial arrangement. In P&P, Lydia’s marriage to Wickham.
Companionate marriage
marriage based on a partnership of equals, as in Elizabeth and Darcy and Jane and Bingley.
Marriage plot (19th-century English novel)
the most common plot in the novel of manners: a hero positioned between a wealthy, materialistic, status-conscious woman who might enhance his social position and a poorer, more altruistic, psychologically independent woman. It emerges in P&P.
The rich woman (heiress) in novels
The heiress isn’t a real character but a symbol of showy, worrying new money, which the hero must reject so the novel can seem like it’s about virtue and not wealth.
Novel of manners:
the type of 19th-century novel Michie analyzes, built around social behavior, marriage and money. (p&p)
Patrilineage
lineage based on descent on the paternal line.
Exogamy
marrying outside your group.
Endogamy
marrying within your group. The heiress had to be exchanged endogamously to keep property in the group.
Engrossment
accumulating and concentrating wealth. the heiress shows that capitalism is aimed at amassing, not exchanging or circulating property.
1. Austen’s alternative: from the marriage bargain to companionate marriage (P&P, 1813)
Austen questions the commodification of women in the marriage market.
Contrast: Lydia and Wickham (bargain) vs. Elizabeth and Darcy, Jane and Bingley (companionate).
Method: she overturns the traditional use of the blazon.
2. The blazon overturned: Lady Catherine confronts Elizabeth
Elizabeth withstands the demands of patriarchy expressed by two women who are the agents of the exchange: Lady Catherine and Darcy’s mother.
Lady Catherine retorts with the “normative taxonomy of the blazon” (family, fortune, rank).
Elizabeth’s radical argument: she rejects Lady Catherine’s arguments for class endogamy and insists that, as a gentleman’s daughter, she is Darcy’s equal.
The blazon overturned: Elizabeth’s rejection of patriarchal courtship
She recommends a new ethic for female behavior and a new subject position from which to consider societal wisdom about equal marriages.
The blazon overturned: Darcy humbled
Darcy is eventually grateful for the humbling experience of his first proposal. “Darcy humbled is the patriarchy humbled.”
Lizzy taught him the measure for marriage is no longer his blazon (fortune and class prestige) but his “pleasing,” assessed only from her subjective point of view.
In the new system of companionate marriage, the terms of the blazon are emptied of value.
P&P’s critique of endogamy and engrossment
P&P opposes endogamy: Elizabeth doesn’t marry her cousin Mr Collins, and Darcy doesn’t marry his cousin Miss de Bourgh.
Novel uses exogamous marriage to critique engrossment and lack of social mobility.
P&P marriage between a rich man (Darcy) and a poorer woman (Elizabeth) is a form of spiritual, emotional or psychological exogamy, bringing nonmaterialist values into story
What alternative to the marriage bargain does Austen offer in P&P?
Companionate marriage. The marriage bargain is Lydia’s marriage to Wickham. The companionate marriages are Elizabeth and Darcy and Jane and Bingley. To reach this, Austen overturns the traditional use of the blazon in the courtship novel. She also interrogates the commodification of women and offers different subject positions.
How does Elizabeth respond to Lady Catherine, and why does it matter?
Lady Catherine speaks for patriarchy, as one of two women who are the agents of the exchange (with Darcy’s mother). She retorts with the normative taxonomy of the blazon. Elizabeth rejects class endogamy and says that, as a gentleman’s daughter, she is Darcy’s equal. This withstands patriarchal demands and models a new ethic for female behavior.
What does “Darcy humbled is the patriarchy humbled” mean?
After Elizabeth’s refusal, Darcy is grateful for the humbling experience of his first proposal. Lizzy taught him that the measure of a marriage is no longer his blazon (fortune and class prestige) but his “pleasing,” which only she can judge. Under companionate marriage, the terms of the blazon are emptied of value.
What is the “marriage plot” Michie describes?
In the 19th-century novel of manners, a hero is positioned between a wealthy, materialistic, status-conscious woman who could advance his position and a poorer, more altruistic, psychologically independent woman. It emerges in P&P. The rich woman is the vulgarity and wealth the hero must avoid, and she carries cultural anxieties about changing forms of money.
Why is the heiress a “block to exogamy and progress”?
For anthropologists, modernity meant freedom to marry whom you wanted and individual ownership. But under patrilineage, heiresses could inherit, and if she married outside the group, the property went with her. So she had to marry endogamously, while all others could marry exogamously. This reveals the limits behind the freedoms.
How does P&P critique endogamy and engrossment?
Miss Bingley wants to join commercial wealth with Darcy’s landed estate, and Lady Catherine wants two cousins’ properties to become one. Both endorse endogamy and engrossment. Elizabeth doesn’t marry Mr Collins and Darcy doesn’t marry Miss de Bourgh, so the novel opposes endogamy. Austen uses exogamous marriage to critique engrossment and lack of social mobility. Darcy marrying poorer Elizabeth is “spiritual, emotional or psychological exogamy” that brings nonmaterialist values into the Darcys.
How does Pride and Prejudice (1813) overturn the blazon and move from the marriage bargain to companionate marriage?
Setup: Austen interrogates the marriage market’s commodification of women.
The bargain: Lydia and Wickham.
Lady Catherine’s confrontation: two female agents of patriarchy, the normative taxonomy of the blazon, Elizabeth’s radical argument (gentleman’s daughter, Darcy’s equal, rejects class endogamy).
Elizabeth’s rejection of patriarchal courtship: she recommends a new ethic and subject position.
Darcy humbled: “Darcy humbled is the patriarchy humbled”, and “pleasing” replaces the blazon.
Result: companionate marriage (Elizabeth and Darcy; Jane and Bingley), and the blazon’s terms are emptied of value.