1/31
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What does Descartes seek to solve in reference to Epistemology?
Can we know anything with 100% certainty?
According to Descartes, what are sense reports?
Anything sensory and immediate, such as the feeling on his hand or what he sees in front of him
What does Descartes deduce about sensory reports and our certainty about them?
We can’t be 100% certain, as what is given immediately is not yet unproblematically certain knowledge. An oar can look bent in water, but out of it, it is back to normal.
According to Descartes, what are sense experience?
It is how the mind processes the sense report. Two people can see the same thing but come with different conclusions.
What does Descartes deduce about sensory experience and our certainty about them?
They are not certain. The mind can simulate itself and the sensory experiences.
What does Descartes say about dreams to support his arguement on sensory experience?
The mind itself can simulate itself through dreams, and we can’t differentiate between dreams and reality.
What does Descartes argue about math and our certainty of it?
It doesn’t seem to be certain. What if there are two swallows that fly in a barn, and another two fly in. 2+2=4. You board up everything, the doors, the windows, and even encase it in impenetrable steel. You open the barn tomorrow to see there are 5 swallows, instead of four. You’d go through every possible condition before deducing that 2+2=5
What arguement does Descartes say about faulty thinking?
That there is possibly an evil spirit or demon that can warp his brain into thinking that 2+2=4, when it is really 5.
Despite the possibility that an evil demon is controlling his mind, what can he be absolutely certain of?
That he is thinking, and that when he is thinking, he exists. Coginto ergo sum. I think, therefore I am.
What does Descartes deduce from god’s existance and certainty in general?
If god exists, then he wouldn’t hand control of the world to a demon. Which means he can be sure of math and other aspects of the world despite the errors.
What is occasionalism?
Every god is caused directly by god. Our lives are dictated by a god, not by us.
Why does Malebranche deny that matter does anything?
Its only a physical extention that wouldn’t allow something to act on their own, a casual agent that makes an effect.
What does Malebranche say about sense preception
We aren’t aware of objects, but instead their “ideas”, or the images of the objects.
What does Malebranche say about our ideas?
The ideas we encounter are not imprinted or deposited in us by objects, but exist in the mind of god.
What do the empiricists hold about knowledge
Primary source of knowledge is sense experience
What does Locke try to draw between objects?
The distinction between the idea or representation of an object that the base object represents.
What does Locke emphasize about the object before us?
That it is a representation of all the sensory inputs turned into a idea. Simply put, the idea of the actual object.
What are primary qualities according to locke?
Objective, mind-independent properties that derive from physical objects. One such thing is the solidity of a wall
What are secondary qualities according to locke?
The subjective properties that come from the senses. Color, size or sound.
What does berkeley conclude about our ideas?
The idea is the object
How does berkeley support that the idea is the object?
We can only directly precieve our mental conents, where all the sensory data we collect is what we call the object
How does the concept of objects between locke and berkeley contrast
Locke sees what we precieve of as objects as ideas, which means there must be an external world. Berkely sees that it all exists in the mind, and that the world presents itself objective because god’s mind is constantly thinking.
What is metaphysics?
How the world really is like
What does Hume discover?
Empirical science implies meta phyiscs. “Water boiling at 212 degrees” is a statement that links two events in nature, where one necessarily produces the other
How is causality defined by Hume?
It is a habit of mind, where we express our expectations on what would happen in the world around us. This would mean that the necessity of an action to happen isn’t objective, but comes from our own expectations of the mind.
Why is necessity key in causality
Without any necessity of the causes of events, we would not be able to predict the course of nature or the effects. There is always are reason behind the causes, and there needs to be a necessaru condition for it
What is causality?
Things happen because other things happen, where the effects determine how the causes will be.
How is necessity defined by hume?
It is a mental habit we gather from repeated observation, or empirical data. We expect big heavy thing to crush small thing without even needing to look because we have seen it happen so many times.
How does hume and Kant contrast in their beliefs about cognition and observation?
Hume thins our coginition is passive, where ideas have to conform to what is being seen physically
What does Kant say about causal connections?
They are found in the mind and not nature, but causality is a necessary condition where we rely on observations to have predictable regularity
How does kant answer hume’s skeptisism of causality?
That causality is not given through observation, a priori, and that it isn’t formed through repreated observation. He draws the line and states that cause and effect are natural, where people are born with the understanding of the skill rather than have it develop and learn as a skill.
What does Kant say about there being a necessary rule?
There must be a necessary rule that makes everything coherent in the first place. He imposes that our minds place rules on appearances