UNIT SIX Contract Law

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/68

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

frustration of a contract, doctrine of certainty

69 Terms

1
New cards

What is frustration of a contract?

A contract is frustrated if an event occurs after formation which makes performance impossible or radically different, and the event is outside the control of the parties.

2
New cards

What 3 things must be true of the event for frustration?

1) It makes performance impossible or radically different.

2) It is beyond the ordinary risks the parties took on at formation.

3) It is beyond the control of either party.

3
New cards

Give examples of events that may frustrate a contract.

Government intervention, illegality, destruction of the subject matter, non-occurrence of a fundamental event, unavailability of a specific person or thing vital to the contract.

4
New cards

Is frustration a breach of contract? What follows from that?

No. Neither party is in breach, so breach remedies such as damages are not available.

5
New cards

Does the non-defaulting party get to choose whether to terminate a frustrated contract?

No. Discharge happens automatically as a matter of law.

6
New cards

What 3 factors do the courts consider when a specific person or thing becomes unavailable?

1) The length of the contract.

2) The length of the period of absence.

3) Whether the contract must be performed by that particular individual or a substitute can do the work. Condor v Barron Knights [1966] 1 WLR 87.

7
New cards

How can the non-occurrence of a fundamental event frustrate a contract? Which case?

If a particular event is essential to the contract and is cancelled, the contract may be frustrated. Krell v Henry [1903].

8
New cards

Does all government intervention frustrate a contract? Which case?

No. Not every form does, but some can. Metropolitan Water Board v Dick Kerr [1918] AC 119.

9
New cards

How can illegality frustrate a contract? Which case?

A change in the law (e.g. in wartime) can make performance illegal. Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna v Fairbairn Lawson Combe Barbour Ltd [1943] AC 32 (HL).

10
New cards

Does delay frustrate a contract?

Delay alone does not. If a contract requires delivery by a date and D is late, that is breach of an express term, not frustration.

11
New cards

What factors decide whether delay frustrates a contract?

1) Whether the contract provides for the consequences of delay.

2) The likely length of the delay.

3) Any time set in the contract for performance.

4) If the contract resumes after the delay, whether it is radically different from the original.

12
New cards

How do the specificity of the contract and the availability of alternative performance affect frustration by delay? Which case?

If the contract is very specific (time, route, goods), it is more likely to be radically different, so frustration is more likely. If performance is still possible in another way, there is likely no frustration. Tsakiroglou & Co Ltd v Noblee Thorl [1962] AC 93 (Suez Canal).

13
New cards

Does making performance more difficult or more expensive frustrate a contract? Why?

No. Otherwise it would open the floodgates of litigation. A party wanting protection should include an express provision, e.g. a price escalation clause.

14
New cards

What are the 3 limitations on the doctrine of frustration?

1) Without default (the event must not be self-induced). 2) Foreseeability (it must be an unexpected event).

3) Whether either party assumed the risk of the event.

15
New cards

Can a party rely on frustration if they caused the event? Which cases?

No. Self-induced frustration is not allowed. Maritime National Fish Ltd v Ocean Trawlers Ltd [1935] and The Super Servant Two [1990]. Any act by a party that contributes to the event prevents frustration.

16
New cards

What did The Super Servant Two (Bingham LJ) say about the essence of frustration?

Frustration should not be due to the act or election of the party relying on it. It must be an outside event or extraneous change of situation. A party who has a choice (whether to breach) or is negligent cannot rely on it.

17
New cards

What is the rationale for refusing self-induced frustration?

A party should not be excused from the consequences of their own fault. (Your notes cite Taylor v Caldwell here; see the checks below.)

18
New cards

How does foreseeability affect frustration? Which cases?

A foreseen event will generally exclude frustration (The Sea Angel). An event that was foreseeable but not in fact foreseen may still frustrate, depending on how foreseeable it was. Davis Contractors v Fareham: a road closure delaying delivery is the kind of event you could foresee, so no frustration.

19
New cards

What does "risk assumed" mean for frustration? Give the chocolate example.

If a party has taken on a risk, the event will not frustrate. Delivering chocolate London to Sheffield: a 35 degree heatwave probably frustrates the contract (risk not assumed). Ghana to Ivory Coast: the heat is probably a risk the party assumed, so no frustration.

20
New cards

Can a lease of land be frustrated?

In principle yes, but only in rare and exceptional circumstances, e.g. National Carriers v Panalpina.

21
New cards

What is a force majeure clause?

An express term covering events outside the parties' control, setting out what happens if they occur, so that the party who cannot perform is not liable.

22
New cards

What are the advantages of force majeure clauses?

They make frustration more flexible (they can cover things frustration normally does not, e.g. shortages of labour and materials). They give stability, because the parties specify what happens and how loss falls. Most commercial contracts include them.

23
New cards

What process do force majeure clauses usually include?

A notice process: one party informs the other of the facts it considers trigger the clause. The clause should set out the consequences, often suspension of the contract until circumstances return to normal rather than termination.

24
New cards

What control applies to force majeure clauses in B2B contracts?

s 3 UCTA 1977. The clause must be reasonable or it is not valid

25
New cards

Do force majeure clauses always work?

No. They must be airtight and specific (see Tsakiroglou & Co, 1962). Acts of a party that contribute to the event can also stop reliance on them.

26
New cards

Why do commercial parties prefer force majeure clauses to the 1943 Act?

The 1943 Act is unpredictable and can leave workers with nothing. A clause lets the parties decide in advance what happens to their money and work.

27
New cards

What are the effects of frustration at common law?

1) The contract terminates automatically at the time of the frustrating event.

2) Both parties are released from all future obligations. 3) Neither party is in breach.

28
New cards

Think of frustration as what button on the contract?

The "stop" button. Future performance ends, as with termination for breach, but without breach.

29
New cards

What is the aim of the Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943?

To split financial losses and obligations fairly when a contract suddenly stops.

30
New cards

What are the 3 key points of s 1(2)?

1) Money paid before the event can be recovered.

2) Money that should have been paid before the event need not be paid.

3) By the proviso, the court has discretion to let the payee recover expenses incurred in performing the contract out of the sums paid or payable before the event.


31
New cards

What is the cap on expenses recovered under the s 1(2) proviso?

The sums paid or payable before the frustrating event. If expenses are less than that pot, only the expenses can be recovered. If nothing was paid or payable before the event, nothing can be recovered under s 1(2).

32
New cards

How much discretion does the court have over expenses under the s 1(2) proviso? Which case?

Very wide discretion. It is not mandatory or implied that the court will award anything. Gamerco SA v ICM/Fair Warning (Agency) Ltd [1995] 1 WLR 1226.

33
New cards

What does s 1(3) cover?

Where one party has obtained a valuable benefit (before discharge) from the other's performance, the court has discretion to order them to pay a "just sum".

34
New cards

What is the two-stage test for s 1(3)? Which case?

BP Exploration Co (Libya) Ltd v Hunt [1979] (Goff J).

1) Identify and value the benefit (the end product, minus any expenses the receiving party already spent).

2) Assess a "just sum", which cannot be more than the value of the benefit, looking at the contract terms for what the work was worth.

35
New cards

In BP v Hunt, what is a "valuable benefit"?

The end product or result, not the time and labour spent. If the frustrating event (e.g. fire) destroys the work, the benefit may be zero.

36
New cards

Why is s 1(3) criticised?

It is highly unpredictable, as nobody knows how much a judge will award.

37
New cards

Julie hires a cottage for August (£2,000). She pays £200 upfront, with £1,800 due on 31 August. Holiday Letts spends £250 on window locks. The cottage burns down on 5 August. What happens under s 1(2)?

Julie can recover the £200 and need not pay the £1,800. Under the proviso, the court has a discretion to let Holiday Letts keep some or all of the £200 against its £250 expenses, capped at the £200 paid.

38
New cards

In the same facts, can the court order Julie to pay a just sum under s 1(3)?

Yes, if her 5 days of exclusive use and possession are a valuable benefit. The court has discretion to order a just sum for the benefit received before the fire.

39
New cards

What is the basic rule on certainty?

A contract must be sufficiently certain before a court can enforce it. Courts must uphold the reasonable expectations of honest commercial people.

40
New cards

Distinguish vagueness from incompleteness.

Vagueness: the contract covers the key issues but the words used are unclear.

Incompleteness: the words are clear but an important matter is missing.

41
New cards

How is certainty linked to implied terms and contractual intention?

Omissions may be remedied by implied terms. Vagueness or incompleteness may also suggest the parties had not reached a binding agreement at all, so certainty is closely linked to intention to create legal relations.

42
New cards

How do courts judge whether the parties have agreed all material terms?

Objectively, in context.

Factors: 1) whether the parties are in the same trade.

2) Trade usage.

3) Whether the agreement has been acted on for any length of time.

4) Whether there is an objective mechanism for resolving uncertainty, such as an arbitration clause

43
New cards

Give examples of vague terms from case law.

"Fair specification" (Hillas v Arcos (1932)). "Hire purchase terms" (Scammell v Ouston [1941] AC 251). Supply "at quantities and prices which in all the circumstances were reasonable" (Baird Textile Holdings v Marks & Spencer [2001] EWCA 274). "Subject to satisfactory mortgage" (Lee-Parker v Izett [1972] 1 WLR 775).

44
New cards

How do courts treat words like "reasonable" and "fair"?

They apply an objective standard where this is what the parties intended. Sometimes there is no objective standard to apply, as in Baird Textiles v Marks and Spencer.

45
New cards

What evidence do courts use to interpret vague words?

The factual background against which the terms were settled: the parties' intention, relationship, and context.

46
New cards

Can the court force the parties to arbitration to resolve a dispute over an uncertain term?

Generally no, as that would make them do something they never agreed to. But an agreed arbitration clause can be enforced if it was meant to cover the issue (a question of construction).

47
New cards

What is the bottom line on incompleteness?

The law strives to uphold contracts. The contract is enforceable unless it is unworkable, or too uncertain without the missing term being added.

48
New cards

Who decides what is "essential"? Which case?

The parties. They are "masters of their contractual fate" and their intentions matter. Pagnan v Feed Products.

49
New cards

What are the 3 ways a term can be implied?

1) By custom: the custom is notorious, certain, reasonable, and generally regarded as binding in the trade.

2) In fact: necessary for business efficacy (The Moorcock).

3) In law: what the nature of the contract itself implicitly requires.

50
New cards

How does performance of the deal affect certainty?

Unperformed deals: if nothing has been done and the terms are vague, courts are strict and there is no contract.

Performed deals: if the parties have spent time and money, courts assume they intended a contract and work hard to fill the gaps.

51
New cards

Why does performance matter?

People do not usually work for free or ship goods by accident, so acting on the deal shows intention to be bound.

52
New cards

What are interim or provisional agreements?

Parties agree the main terms but make clear they are not bound until the remaining terms are settled. Sometimes parties settle all terms and still do not intend to be bound (e.g. contracts not yet exchanged).

53
New cards

When will an interim agreement be upheld or void?

One intended to be legally binding will generally be upheld. It is void only if failure to agree further terms makes the whole contract unworkable.

54
New cards

Foley v Classique Coaches [1934] 2 KB 1: petrol supplied "at a price agreed by the parties from time to time". Enforceable?

es. The parties had acted on it for 3 years, the petrol was only part of the contract's substance, and there was an arbitration clause. They treated the agreement as binding.

55
New cards

Walford v Miles [1992] 2 AC 128: is an agreement "to continue to negotiate in good faith" enforceable?

No. A duty to negotiate in good faith is inherently repugnant to the adversarial position of negotiating parties (Lord Ackner). It is unworkable in practice and lacks certainty. "Lock-in" agreements are generally unenforceable in English law.

56
New cards

What legal rule did Paradine v Jane establish?

The rule of absolute liability for contractual promises—a party is bound to perform their obligations even if unforeseen events make it difficult or impossible (later softened by the doctrine of frustration).

57
New cards

What is a repudiatory breach, and what are the innocent party’s options?

A major breach that deprives the innocent party of substantially all the benefit of the contract. The innocent party can choose to:

  1. Affirm the contract (keep it alive), OR

    1. Terminate the contract (end future obligations).In both cases, the innocent party can claim damages.


58
New cards

What happens to existing obligations and work already done when a contract is terminated for breach?

Termination only ends future obligations. Accrued rights and payment for work properly completed before termination remain enforceable. The breaching party may still claim sums already earned (or quantum meruit where applicable),subject to set-offs and damages owed to the innocent party.

59
New cards

What is frustration in contract law, and what is its legal effect?

When an unforeseen event occurs after contract formation that makes performance impossible, illegal, or radically different from what was agreed.

  • Effect: There is no breach; the contract is not made void ab initio, but both parties are automatically discharged from all future obligations. (Applied very narrowly by courts).


60
New cards

What is a force majeure clause?

A contractual term that expressly allocates where losses and risks will fall if specific extraordinary events occur (e.g.,pandemics, war, natural disasters), preventing the need to rely on the narrow doctrine of frustration.


61
New cards

Can a lease of land ever be frustrated under English law?

Yes. Under National Carriers Ltd v Panalpina (Northern) Ltd, leases of land are not automatically excluded from frustration, though the threshold is very high and requires an unforeseen event that makes performance radically different (e.g., a 1-year warehouse lease where fire destroys the building for 10+ months).

62
New cards

Does a severe economic downturn or inability to secure financing frustrate a contract?

No. Financial hardship, market shifts, or inability to arrange finance are ordinary commercial risks, not unforeseen events that make performance impossible or radically different.

63
New cards

What if a contract specifies an exclusive method of delivery (e.g., by rail) that becomes impossible due to a flood, even if another method (e.g., by sea) is possible?

The contract is frustrated. Because the contract expressly required delivery by rail and that specific method is now impossible, performance as agreed cannot take place (assuming no force majeure clause covers it).

64
New cards

What was the rule in Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna v Fairbairn (Common Law) regarding advance payments?

Under common law, an advance payment already made before frustration is only recoverable if there was a total failure of consideration (i.e., the payor received zero benefit).

65
New cards

How does s.1(2) of the Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943 treat advance payments already paid compared to Common Law?

  • Common Law (Fibrosa): Only recoverable if there is a total failure of consideration.

  • Statute (s.1(2)): Always recoverable by the payor, even if they received partial performance.


66
New cards

How are payments due before frustration (but not yet paid) treated under Common Law vs. the 1943 Act?

  • Common Law: Still legally owed, unless there was a total failure of consideration.

  • Statute (s.1(2)): Cease to be payable once the frustrating event occurs.


67
New cards

How are expenses incurred by the payee before frustration treated under Common Law vs. the 1943 Act?

  • Common Law: Cannot be deducted or claimed; the payee bears 100% of wasted costs.

    • Statute (s.1(2)): The court has discretion to allow the payee to retain or recover expenses incurred, capped at the amount of the advance payment paid or payable before frustration.


68
New cards

How are non-money valuable benefits conferred before frustration treated under Common Law vs. the 1943 Act?

  • Common Law: Generally no right to claim payment for partial work done.

    • Statute (s.1(3)): The court can award a "just sum" for any valuable benefit conferred before frustration (capped at the value of that benefit).


69
New cards

What principle did Gamerco SA v ICM/Fair Warning (Agency) Ltd [1995] establish regarding s.1(2) of the 1943 Act?

Courts have broad discretion under s.1(2) to decide whether a payee who received a pre-frustration payment may retain or recover expenses to do justice on the facts—there is no rigid formula or automatic 50/50 loss split.