1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Who studied obidence in 1963?
Milgram
What did Milgram study
Obediance
The method of Milgrams experiment
Ps believed they were taking part in a study on the role of punishment in learning and memory
Two Ps drew straws for who is a learner (confederant) and who is a teacher
They are given a 15 volt shock to see how it feels
Teacher is instructed to shock the participant every time they make a mistake
Condeferates complain about heart trouble
Every time they make a mistake the shock goes up by 15V
Role of the expirementer during Milgrams
Wearing a white coat → authority
Prods are used: eg please continue
Results of Milgrams experiment
65% of participants went up to 450V
14/40 laughed nervously
Ps showed visible signs of distress
All ps went to 300V
Most dissented verbally
Features that lead to high obedience (include: place, authority, proximity, and more)
Place: Yale was well respecte
Authority: legitamate in a white coat
Proximity: they were unable to see the leaner
Agentic state
Gradual commitment of 15V
Verbal prods
In the Milgrim experiment how did they sample and what type of person was sampled
Vollunteering sampling - through a newpaper adverts
40 men between 20 and 50 years old
What is it called when there are only male participants
Androcentric sample
Evaluation of internal validity Milgrims study
Low internal validity:
Ps were getting paid for the experiment
Ps didnt believe that they were giving ‘real’ shocks to the learner
High internal validity:
70% of the participants believed the shock was real
The Sheridan and King experiment (shocking puppies) observs similar behavior
The experiment has been replicated many times
What was the Sheridan and King obedience experiment (1972)? Method? Results? Expanation of high is proves the milgram experiment has high internal validity?
Ps gave real shocks to puppies in the room. There was non harm but there was visible distress.
54% of men and 100% of women gave a fatal shock.
Shows that the reactions from milgrims study was real as the Ps behaved similarly
How were the demand characteristics of the Milgrim experiments removed in another experiment?
The Hofling hospital experiment of obedience
Hofling experiment of obedience. Method? Outcome? How does this support Milgrims study?
Method: Nurses were told by a doctor over the phone to admisiter the fatal amount of an unknown drug to a patient. The doctor said that they would sign the paperwork later (illegal)
Outcome: 21 out of 22 nurses obeyed
Support: Without the demand characteristics we see that there are still high levels of obedience
Evaluation of ecological validity Milgrims study
Pros: the relationship between the experimenter and the P is a dynamic that doesnt realistically exist
Cons: The stimuli was artifical and didnt reflect real life
Evaluation of population validity Milgrims study
Low population validity
Androcentric sample (only men) → women were equally likely to obey but reported higher feeling of tension
Ethnocentric sample (only one culture - American) → Smith and Bond found cultural differences between Jordon and India but similar results in other countries with similar cultures
Ethical issues with the Milgrim experiment arugments (was ethical vs wasnt ethical)
Wasnt ethical:
decieved participants
Verbal prods made Ps feel they couldnt leave
Didnt protect them from harm
Should have stopped in sooner
Didnt respect their right as Ps
Was ethical:
The Ps couldnt be told the true meaning to the experiment to prevent demand characteristics
They had the right to withdraw
They were debried after and a year after
Didnt reliase how they would react
80% of Ps said they learnt something
What are the three situtational variables with Milgrims experiment
PUL
P - Proximity
U - Uniform
L - location
What % of Ps obeyed from milgrims study with proximity as a situational variable
Proximity of victim: 40%
Touch proximity: 30%
Romote authority: 21%
What % of Ps obeyed from milgrims study with uniform as a situational variable
20%
What % of Ps obeyed from milgrims study with location as a situational variable
47.5%
Explanation fo why proximity, uniform and location decrease the % if Ps who obeyed in the Milgrim study
Proximity: the Ps returned to a more agenic state as there was reduced responsibility
Uniform: there was no symbol or legitimcy of authority
Location: there was no prostigous and legitamate Yale
Why was there a lack internal validty in the Milgrim experiment
Orne and Holland believed that there was demand characteristics due to the Ps working out that the procedures were fake
What are examples of binding factors in Milgrims research
Shifting responsibilty of the victum
Denying damage there were doing to the victums
Prods shifting responsibilty onto the experimenter
Evaluation of the situional variables in the Milgrim experiment
Pros: Most Ps resisted giving the shocks at some point and when the experimenter replied the P usally completed the tasks → Ps were more willing if they didnt have responsibility
Cons: Doesnt account of individual personalities (authoritarian personality). And obedience is a product of the situations rather than the need to obey.
How does Megan Birney et al (2024) show and explanation of the negative evualtion of the situational factors of Milgrims experiment
The many different types of situations in Milgrims experiment leads to a change in obedency therefore obidence is a product of the situation. Otherwise obedience would be predicted as very high in every senario.
What is legitimate authority
We recognise societies hierarchial authority which means that some have authority over use and we feel obligated to those in power and they are usally given a symbol of power
What factors contributed to a sense of legiimate authority in Milgrims study
Lab coat
Yale
The Ps entered the experiment expecting someonet to be incharge and the experimenter forfilled that role
What is destructive authority and how is it applied in Milgrims study
When the experimener used prods to order Ps to behave in ways which is against their concious
What is the explanations for obedience in Milgrims study
Agentic state
Legitamate authority
Despositional (authoritarian personality)