1/5
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Rule 18 Baseline rule for joinder
You can join as many claims as you want against the opposing party regardless if they’re related.
Rule 13 When D files a counterclaim or crossclaim
Definition of counterclaim
two types of counterclaims
Definition of crossclaim
mandatory or permissive?
Must _____ or _____
Counterclaims are brought from one side to another
if the counterclaim arises from the same t/o as the original claim —> compulsory
if the counterclaim does not arise from the same t/o as the original claim —> permissive
Crossclaims are brought against co-parties
must arise from the same t/o, or relate to property that is the subject of the action.
crossclaims are always permissive.
Rule 14 When D can implead a third party
D must show that ___
Two times when D can join a third party:
TPD files a counterclaim against TPP
Two types
TPD files a claim against original P.
requirement
mandatory or permissive?
Original P files a claim against TPD
requirement
mandatory or permissive?
D can only join an absentee party in limited circumstances: indemnity or contribution
D must show the absentee party may be liable for all or part of the claim against D
TPD files a counterclaim against TPP | Same T/O = compulsory counterclaim Not same T/O = permissive counterclaim |
TPD files a claim against the original P. | Must arise from the same T/O. Permissive. |
The original P files a claim against TPD. | Must arise from the same T/O. Permissive. |
Rule 19 If the absentee party is required
Required party definition
If joinder is not feasible (meaning what?) should we dismiss, or do we proceed without them?
Required party definition:
The court can not give complete relief without them.
Continuing without them would harm their interest.
Continuing without them will create inconsistent obligations.
If joinder is not feasible (no PJ or SMJ), should we dismiss the case or do we proceed without them? Four factors:
Extent of prejudice to a party or the absentee party if the court rendered a judgment without them.
Whether the court can minimize prejudice.
Whether the harm can be resolved if the case proceeds without them.
Whether the plaintiff can sue in an alternative forum and join all parties plus the absentee party there.
Rule 20 If P can add a new party
mandatory or permissive?
If P wants to add a new P requirements:
If P wants to add a new D requirements:
Permissive
If P wants to join a new P. | Must arise from same T/O A common question of law or fact to all P’s will arise in the action. |
If P wants to join a new D. | Must arise from same T/O A common question of law or fact will link all Ds. |
Rule 24 Intervening rules
Two types of intervention
Two ways to get intervention of right
to get permissive intervention you just need:
Two types of intervention: intervention of right, permissive intervention.
Two ways to get intervention of right.
A federal statute gives you unconditional right to intervene (rare).
Your motion to intervene must be:
Timely
You claim an interest in the central property/transaction of the suit.
If the case goes on without you, your ability to protect that interest is impaired.
The existing parties don’t adequately represent your interest.
To get permissive intervention you just need a timely motion plus either of these:
A statute gives you conditional right to intervene
Your claim/defense has a common question of law or fact with the main claim.