1/85
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the purpose of the rules on fraudulent and wrongful trading?
To prevent directors continuing to trade and incur further debts when a company is in financial difficulty, thereby minimising losses to creditors.
Who can bring fraudulent trading proceedings under ss 213/246ZA Insolvency Act 1986?
The liquidator or administrator.
Against whom can a fraudulent trading claim be brought?
Any person knowingly party to carrying on the company's business with intent to defraud creditors or for any fraudulent purpose.
Can a bank be liable for fraudulent trading?
Yes. Any person can be liable, including a bank through the knowledge of its employees.
What does 'blind eye' knowledge mean in fraudulent trading?
Suspicion of relevant facts combined with a deliberate decision to avoid confirming them.
What level of dishonesty is required for fraudulent trading?
Actual dishonesty involving real moral blame; only one creditor needs to be defrauded.
How is dishonesty assessed for fraudulent trading under Ivey v Genting Casinos?
First establish the person's subjective state of knowledge or belief; then assess whether their conduct was dishonest by the objective standards of ordinary decent people.
What civil remedy is available for fraudulent trading?
The court can order the liable person to contribute such amount to the company's assets as it considers proper. The amount is compensatory, not punitive.
Who benefits from a contribution ordered for fraudulent trading?
The funds are held for unsecured creditors generally, not necessarily just the creditor who was defrauded.
What other consequences may follow a fraudulent trading finding against a director?
The court is likely to make a disqualification order under s 10 Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986.
What criminal sanctions apply to fraudulent trading under s 993 Companies Act 2006?
Criminal liability applies whether or not the company is being wound up; the maximum sentence on indictment is 10 years' imprisonment, and fines may also be imposed.
What is wrongful trading?
Where directors continue trading after they knew or ought to have concluded that insolvent liquidation or administration was reasonably inevitable, without taking every step to minimise potential losses to creditors.
Who can bring wrongful trading proceedings under ss 214/246ZB Insolvency Act 1986?
The liquidator or administrator.
Can wrongful trading claims be assigned to a third party?
Yes. Under the Small Business, Enterprise and Employment Act 2015, claims can be assigned to raise funds for the insolvent estate without the estate bearing the litigation costs and risks.
Against whom can a wrongful trading claim be brought?
Any person who was a director (of any type) at the relevant time.
What are the two limbs of the wrongful trading test?
(1) The director knew or ought to have concluded there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation or administration, and continued trading which worsened the company's position; (2) the director failed to take every step to minimise potential losses to creditors.
What must be established under the first limb of wrongful trading?
The company entered insolvent liquidation or administration; before commencement of winding up or insolvent administration, the director knew or ought to have concluded there was no reasonable prospect of avoiding it; and the director allowed trading to continue, worsening the company's position.
What does 'point of no return' mean in wrongful trading?
The point before commencement of winding up or insolvent administration when there was no reasonable prospect of the company avoiding insolvent liquidation or administration.
What insolvency test must the company satisfy for wrongful trading?
The company must have gone into insolvent liquidation or administration on the balance sheet test.
What is the defence to wrongful trading under the second limb?
The director must show they took every step with a view to minimising potential losses to the company's creditors.
What practical steps may demonstrate that a director took every step to minimise creditor losses?
Voicing concerns at board meetings; seeking independent financial and legal advice; maintaining up-to-date financial information; proposing cost reductions; avoiding new creditors or increased credit from existing creditors; taking advice on insolvency procedures; and negotiating with creditors to restructure liabilities.
What standard of care applies when assessing a director's conduct in wrongful trading?
The reasonably diligent person test, considering both the general knowledge, skill and experience reasonably expected of someone performing the same functions (objective) and the director's actual knowledge, skill and experience (subjective). The higher standard applies.
What does the reasonably diligent person test establish in wrongful trading?
What facts, conclusions and steps the director ought to have recognised or taken.
What practical advice should be given to directors concerned about wrongful trading?
Hold frequent board meetings, review the company's financial position, keep detailed minutes recording steps taken, obtain professional advice promptly and maintain up-to-date financial information.
Why should directors keep detailed board minutes when financial difficulties arise?
To evidence their concerns, decisions and the steps taken to minimise losses to creditors.
Can a director avoid wrongful trading liability by resigning?
No. Resignation does not necessarily avoid liability and may itself amount to wrongful trading. Resignation should only be considered where the director is constantly outvoted by other directors.
Is relief available for wrongful trading?
No relief is available.
What civil remedy is available for wrongful trading?
The court can order the director to contribute an amount to the insolvent estate as it considers fit.
How is compensation for wrongful trading normally calculated?
By reference to the additional depletion of the company's assets from the point of no return.
Who benefits from a contribution ordered for wrongful trading?
The general body of unsecured creditors.
Can directors be jointly and severally liable for wrongful trading?
Yes. The court may impose joint and several liability or apportion liability according to culpability.
What director disqualification order may follow wrongful trading?
A disqualification order of up to 15 years.
Are there criminal sanctions for wrongful trading?
No. Wrongful trading gives rise to civil liability only.
What is misfeasance?
The improper, careless or negligent performance of a lawful duty.
What is the purpose of the misfeasance procedure?
It provides a procedure for pursuing claims against directors, secretaries, liquidators or administrators who have breached their duties; it does not create a new substantive liability.
Against whom can misfeasance proceedings be brought?
Directors, secretaries, liquidators or administrators, including former directors and secretaries.
Who can bring misfeasance proceedings?
The liquidator, official receiver, or any creditor or contributory.
Can a company's shareholders ratify a breach of duty where there is a reasonable prospect of insolvent liquidation or administration?
No. Ratification is not possible in those circumstances.
What order can the court make for misfeasance?
It may order the director to compensate the company for money or property misapplied as a result of the misfeasance.
What is the purpose of the transaction at undervalue provisions under s 238 Insolvency Act 1986?
To reverse transactions that improperly reduce the company's assets for the benefit of creditors. The claim targets the counterparty to the transaction rather than the directors responsible.
What constitutes a transaction at undervalue under s 238?
A gift, or a transaction for consideration significantly less in value than the money or money's worth provided by the company.
What transactions may potentially constitute a transaction at undervalue?
Granting security (e.g. where the main purpose is to put assets beyond HMRC's reach, as in Hill) and payment of a dividend.
What is the relevant time period for a transaction at undervalue under s 238?
The two-year period ending with the onset of insolvency.
When does the relevant time period end for a transaction at undervalue in administration?
Onset of administration is the date of filing the application (for a court appointment), or the date of the notice of intention to appoint or appointment (for an out-of-court appointment).
When does the relevant time period end for a transaction at undervalue in liquidation?
Onset of liquidation is the commencement of winding up: the resolution for voluntary winding up or presentation of the petition for compulsory winding up.
What must be proved about the company's solvency for a s 238 transaction at undervalue claim?
The company was insolvent at the time of the transaction or became insolvent as a result, using either the cash-flow or balance-sheet test.
What presumption applies to insolvency in a s 238 transaction at undervalue involving a connected person?
Insolvency is presumed unless the connected person proves otherwise.
Who is a connected person for the purposes of a transaction at undervalue?
Directors, associates of directors and associates of the company.
Who may be an associate for insolvency transaction purposes?
A spouse, business partner, employee, relative, certain trustees, a company controlled by a director, or a company associated with the company in question through mutual control.
What defence is available to a transaction at undervalue claim under s 238?
The court must be satisfied that the company entered into the transaction in good faith for the purpose of carrying on its business and that there were reasonable grounds for believing the transaction would benefit the company.
What is an example of a defence to a transaction at undervalue claim?
Granting new security to prevent a genuine threat by an unsecured bank to terminate facilities and commence winding-up proceedings.
What orders can the court make for a transaction at undervalue?
Any order it considers appropriate to restore the company to the position it would have been in had the transaction not occurred, including requiring the counterparty to pay the amount of the undervalue.
Can orders for a transaction at undervalue affect subsequent purchasers?
Yes. The court can make orders against subsequent purchasers, although innocent third parties may be protected.
What is the purpose of s 423 Insolvency Act 1986 (transactions defrauding creditors)?
To reverse transactions at an undervalue entered into with the purpose of putting assets beyond creditors' reach or otherwise prejudicing their interests.
Who can apply under s 423?
A liquidator, administrator, supervisor of a voluntary arrangement, or a victim of the transaction.
What are the requirements for a transaction defrauding creditors claim under s 423?
There must be a transaction at an undervalue and an intention or purpose to put assets beyond creditors' reach or otherwise prejudice their interests.
What is the relevant time period for a s 423 transaction defrauding creditors claim?
There is no two-year restriction; the transaction can have occurred at any time in the past.
How does the intention requirement under s 423 differ from a s 238 transaction at undervalue claim?
It requires the purpose of putting assets beyond creditors' reach or otherwise prejudicing their interests, a higher standard than for a s 238 claim.
Can s 423 protect future creditors?
Yes. The provision includes future creditors who were unknown at the time of the transaction.
What remedy is available for a transaction defrauding creditors under s 423?
The court may make any order it considers appropriate to restore the position to what it would have been but for the transaction.
What is the purpose of the preference provisions under s 239 Insolvency Act 1986?
To prevent a creditor obtaining an improper advantage over other creditors during insolvency.
When does a company give a preference under s 239?
Where the recipient is a creditor, surety or guarantor of the company's debts or liabilities, and the company does something which puts them in a better position in an insolvent liquidation than they would otherwise have been.
What is an example of a preference?
Granting security to an unsecured creditor.
Who can bring a claim to avoid a preference?
The liquidator or administrator.
What is the relevant time period for a preference under s 239?
Six months ending with the onset of insolvency, extended to two years where a connected person is involved.
What must be established about the company's solvency for a preference claim?
The company was insolvent at the time of the transaction or became insolvent as a result, applying the cash-flow or balance-sheet test.
Is insolvency presumed for a preference involving a connected person?
No. There is no presumption of insolvency, even where a connected person is involved.
What intention must be established for a preference to be voidable?
The company must have been influenced by a desire to prefer the creditor. This is a subjective test.
What presumption applies to the desire to prefer where a connected person is involved?
There is a rebuttable presumption that the company was influenced by a desire to prefer; the preferred person must prove otherwise.
How can a company defend a preference claim based on the desire to prefer requirement?
It can show that, although it intended to prefer the creditor, it did not have a desire to do so; for example, it acted under genuine commercial pressure to continue trading.
What happens where a company acts from mixed desires when making a preference?
The defence that it lacked a desire to prefer is defeated.
What orders can the court make where a preference is established?
Any order it considers appropriate to restore the position as if the preference had not been given.
What is a common restoration order for a preference?
Requiring the preferred creditor to pay money it received to the liquidator or administrator.
Can a restoration order for a preference be made against a guarantor?
Yes. The court can order a guarantor to contribute even if they received no money, for example where they were released from liability.
Can preference restoration orders affect third parties?
Yes. Orders can be made against third parties, subject to similar protections for innocent third parties.
What is the purpose of s 245 Insolvency Act 1986 (avoidance of floating charges)?
To prevent a creditor obtaining a floating charge for an existing debt without providing new consideration during the relevant period before insolvency.
What is the relevant time period for avoiding a floating charge under s 245?
12 months ending with the onset of insolvency, extended to two years if the charge is granted to a connected person.
What insolvency requirement applies to avoidance of a floating charge under s 245?
The company must have been insolvent when the charge was created or become insolvent as a result, applying the cash-flow or balance-sheet test.
Is insolvency required where a floating charge is granted to a connected person under s 245?
No. There is no insolvency requirement where the charge is granted to a connected person.
What consideration must be given for a floating charge to avoid being void under s 245?
New consideration must be provided. This can include money, goods or services.
What is the effect of granting a floating charge to secure an existing debt without new consideration?
The floating charge is void under s 245 if the relevant time and insolvency conditions are satisfied.
How can a floating charge securing an existing overdraft potentially be valid?
Each further use of the overdraft facility may constitute new money advanced by the bank and therefore new consideration.
How can payments into an overdraft account after creation of a floating charge affect its validity?
If the company pays in more than the pre-charge overdraft balance, the pre-charge debt may be treated as repaid and the later advances as new money; the charge is valid only to the extent of the new money.
What happens if there is a dispute over whether a floating charge is avoidable under s 245?
Court proceedings may be necessary between the floating charge holder and the liquidator or administrator.
What is the effect of a floating charge being void under s 245?
Only the security is void; the underlying debt remains payable.
What is the effect of failing to register a floating charge with Companies House?
The charge is void against a liquidator, administrator and other creditors in any event.