1/11
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the two common views of morality and friendship?
the “moral danger” view, and the “overly moralized” view.
The “moral danger” view
friendship has no moral limits; you will do anything for a friend no matter what.
The “overly moralized” view
a friend will only help when helping is compatible with morality.
Practical deference
you act, in a way that you think isn’t optimal, on a friend’s judgment because it is theirs.
How can we respect a friend’s wishes?
your sharing of it must be done in a way that acknowledges it as theirs in a more robust sense; their goal remains theirs.
Under what two conditions should we so defer to our friends?
particular agency interest, and reasonable judgement.
Particular agency interest
only your friend has a particular interest in exercising their agency, so the goal is theirs and theirs alone.
Reasonable judgement
your friend has a reasonable sense of judgement in their decisions and goals.
What is Koltonski’s argument?
when a friend has a particular agency interest in the matter at hand (and you do not) and their judgment of the matter is reasonable, sharing their end in the right way requires deferring to their judgment about how jointly to pursue that end. if you don’t do this then you failed friendship and morality.
What can you not be doing during moral disagreements with your friend?
humoring or pleasing them, or giving them agency.
Why should we not humor or give our friends agency?
because it is quite condescending; it assumes that you think your friend is unreasonable and lacks responsibility in their decision making.
What should deference be like in friendships according to Koltonski?
mutually shared, depending on who has the particular agency interest.