1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
define what human rights are
human rights are the universal claims to certain freedoms and entitlements that ensure the dignity and equality of each person
define negative rights
-rights that require constitutional limits to the power of government. it also requires the rule of law to be upheld by the judiciary.
- Constitutionalism and rule of law prevents government from intruding unjustly upon a person’s life, liberty or freedom to live as they choose
define positive rights
rights that oblige governments to provide public goods and services
define how the Constitution protects human rights
The Australian Constitution protects human rights through it’s specification of a few express rights and the High Court’s discovery of implied rights.
Define with an example how the Constitution protects express rights
Express rights are specified directly within the Const.
e.g s116 specifies the freedom of and from religion, preventing the government from impeding or enforcing religion
(link to negative rights)
-limited adaptive capacity can lead rights to become outdated
Define with an example how Constitution protects implied rights
through Constitutional interpretation, the High Court of Australia has discovered implied rights.
. In Australian Capital Television Pty Ltd v Cwth(1992), the HC held that although the Constitution does not expressly mention freedom of political communication, an implied right exists because representative government under s 7 and 24 requires voters to communicate and receive political information freely.
(prevents govt from impeding ppl’s freedom to communicate political info)
- gives power to unelected judges to create political rights.
Define how statutes protect human rights
Australia protects rights through statutes passed by Parliament.
elected representatives can respond to community concerns by enacting laws that establish rights protection.
How does the Racial Discrimination Act (1975)(Cth) protects rights
The Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cwth) makes racial discrimination unlawful, giving individuals an enforceable legal mechanism against racial discrimination.
- protects civil right to equality in areas such as employment, housing and access to services, thereby ensuring individuals can live in security
pos and neg of statutes in promoting human rights
+Because Parliaments are democratically elected, statutory rights are adaptable to represent the will of the majority
-statutes can be easily changed by an executive dominated Parliament, risking of govt comprimising the rights of the minority
How does the Human Rights Act (2004) protect civil rights
Furthermore, while Australia does not have a national bill of rights, it posses several at a State and Territory level.
the Human Rights Act (2004) (ACT) protects civil rights that ensure freedom from government outreach, like the right to life.
+ strongly focus on prevention, forcing public servants to use these statutes as guidelines for protecting human rights.
-do not provide remedy for the breach of a right.
Define how common law protects human rights
Australian judges protect political rights using the principle of legality.
How does common law protect civil rights
For instance, the courts created the right to silence through centuries of case law to stop torture and forced confessions. Today, Australian common law protects the accused’s the right to silence, disallowing silence to be used as evidence for guilt during an investigation or trial.
(upholds rule of law by limiting potential abuse of police power)
+adaptability of common law ensure rights stay up to date
-courts can only protect right after its been violated
how does the principle of legality protect human rights
The principle of legality is a common law rule of statutory interpretation that assumes Parliament doesn’t intend to infringe rights and liberties. If it does, it must express this intention clearly
when interpreting vague legislation designed to curb anti-bike laws, courts may favour an interpretation that avoids unnecessarily restricting freedom of association for regular work meetings.
(prevents govt from limiting people’s right to freedom)
- limited protection as common law cannot prevent deliberate legislative infringements of human rights.
+Parliament’s sovereignty over common law can be positive as they are held accountable through elections.
Define how international law protects human rights in Australia
-Executives can agree to international treaties and optional protocols and legislatures may pass legislation so that they are enforceable in domestic law.
-It can influence judges if there are gaps in common law or where Australia statutes are unclear.
-can be adopted into State and Territory Law
How can international law protect rights through statutes
For instance, in 1966, the Australian govt signed the UN’s International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. However it was only after Cwth Parliament passed the Racial Discrimination Act 1975, the UN treaty became enforceable by the courts.
what does this show
+international law can provide a universal framework for rights protection
-not legally enforceable in sovereign country until legislated
how can international law protect rights through courts
The High Court can consider international human rights jurisprudence as a persuasive influence when developing the common law or interpreting legislation. The influence of international law can be seen in Mabo V Queensland (No 2) (1992) where the High Court rejected terra nullius as discriminatory and inconsistent with the principle of equality recognised in the ICCPR.(int covenant on Civil and Political Rights)
what does this show
+courts can consider international human-rights jurisprudence when addressing human-rights issues.
how does international law protect rights through bills of rights
Finally, international law can be adopted into State and Territory law. For example, the Human Rights Act 2004 (ACT) protects civil rights from the ICCPR, such as freedom of speech
+provide a universal framework for rights protection.
-general: aus govt have been reluctant to embrace some international rights.
How does the US Constitution protect human rights
The US Const codifies the bill of rights, the first 10 amendments, which provide strong constitutional protection for individual rights against government power.
e.g The Fifth Amendment protects civil rights by requiring due process, limiting the government’s ability to deprive individuals of life, liberty or property unlawfully.
--limited adaptive capacity
How does US statutes protect human rights
Various federal law provide explicit protections for Human Rights in the USA
The Civil Rights Act 1964 grants equal rights to all citizens regardless of their race.
How does US common law protect human rights
-In A.A.R.P.V v Trump (2025), the Supreme Court upheld the common law principle of procedural fairness by requiring detainees to receive an opportunity to challenge their deportation before a court, thereby protecting the detainees due process rights.
=Supreme Court’s rulings shaped by common law principles protect civil rights of people, ensuring govt cannot unjustly limit a person’s individual freedom.
-unelected judges take on activist role in protecting civil rights
How can statutes limit civil rights
-In 2025, Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act 1798 to rapidly deport alleged gang members. The rapid deportation disallowed them from contesting the government’s claim in court, thereby restricting their due process rights.
=statute laws can restrict individuals’ civil rights, allowing government to undermine personal freedom
How does US use international law to protect human rights
While the US supports the UN, it’s refrained from ratifying several international human rights agreements.
As of 2026, the US remains the only UN member having signed but not ratified the Convention of the Rights of a Child (1989), demonstrating that the US has selectively resisted the ratification of international law.
=limits effectiveness of international law in upholding rights in the US
define the difference of human rights protection between AUS and the US
While the US relies heavily on constitutional law, Australia relies more heavily on statutory law for rights protection.
The US shuns international human right treaties whereas Australia uses them as a basis for much of its human rights law.
civil rights
rights that protect individual freedom and security
political rights
rights that enable political participation
economic rights
relate to work and economic security
social rights
relate to wellbeing and living standards
cultural
allow people to maintain and practise their culture