Critically Reviewing Literature

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/20

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

A set of 21 vocabulary flashcards covering literature review concepts, study validity, research methodologies, qualitative appraisal, and annotated bibliographies.

21 Terms

1
New cards

Reliability

The consistency and dependability of a measurement tool or method: does it produce stable, repeatable results under the same conditions?

2
New cards

Validity

How accurately a study measures what it claims to measure and how applicable its findings are: internal validity (accuracy of the study) and external validity (applicability to the real world).

3
New cards

Test-retest reliability

Taking the same test/measurement and retesting later, expecting similar results.

4
New cards

Alternate / parallel reliability

Two different versions of the same tool produce comparable results.

5
New cards

Inter-rater reliability

The correlation between two people independently assessing the same thing.

6
New cards

Internal validity

Whether a study's results are truly caused by the tested factors and not other influences; depends on controlling extraneous variables and eliminating alternative explanations.

7
New cards

External validity

Whether study results apply to other people, settings, and times in the real world.

8
New cards

Attrition (as a threat)

Participant dropout during a study, which can bias results if those who leave differ systematically from those who stay.

9
New cards

Regression to the mean

Extreme scores at baseline tend to drift closer to average on retesting, independent of any intervention.

10
New cards

Confounding variable

An outside factor related to both the exposure and outcome that can distort the apparent relationship between them.

11
New cards

Self-selection bias

Participants who choose to enroll (e.g., volunteers) differ systematically from those who don't, limiting generalizability.

12
New cards

The Evidence Pyramid (low to high quality)

Background info/expert opinion → case reports → case series → cohort studies → non-randomized trials → RCTs → critically appraised literature/guidelines → systematic reviews → meta-analyses.

13
New cards

M.A.A.R.I.E. Framework

Method, Assignment, Assessment, Results, Interpretation, Extrapolation — a structured way to walk through a study from population to conclusions. (Interpretation = conclusions for study participants; Extrapolation = conclusions for other populations.)

14
New cards

Research Design vs. Methodology vs. Methods

Design = the overall plan/structure (the "what"); Methodology = the underlying rationale/philosophy (the "why"); Methods = the actual tools used (surveys, interviews, lab tests).

15
New cards

The 3-pass reading strategy

Pass 1: Orient (question, design, main finding, ~5–10 min). Pass 2: Understand (methods, figures/tables, key evidence). Pass 3: Critique & connect (assumptions, limitations, implications) — for key papers.

16
New cards

Three questions to ask at each figure/table

What am I looking at? What is the pattern? Does it support the authors' claim?

17
New cards

Qualitative research strengths

Flexible/adaptable, participants' own words, examines individual variation, open-ended (can pursue new data), smaller samples, compelling content.

18
New cards

Saturation (in qualitative research)

Adding new cases/participants until no new themes emerge.

19
New cards

Key concepts for reviewing qualitative research

Trustworthiness, coherence, representativeness of results, testimonial validity, applicability/transferability, replicability — plus structured vs. unstructured interviews, research team training, and appropriate limitations.

20
New cards

Abstract vs. Annotation

Abstract: written by the authors, describes purpose/methods/results/conclusions. Annotation: written by you, adds evaluation, relevance to your question, and connection to other literature — copying the abstract is NOT an annotation.

21
New cards

Annotated bibliography structure

Summary (question/methods/findings) → Evaluation (strengths/limitations) → Relevance (why it matters to your question) → Connection (how it relates to other literature).