science & democracy final

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/13

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

prob cumulative, everything from midterm 2 onwards

14 Terms

1
New cards

merchants of doubt consideration

  • book is not just catalogue of events but BIOGRAPHY

  • biographical details of scientists that manufacture doubt

    • political beliefs, personal beliefs, why choose to do or not


2
New cards

danger of paying too much attention to biography

  • attacking character → implication on how science is perceived

  • evidence/science should be evaluated separately


3
New cards

merchants of doubt vs. reasonable skeptic

  • what are their motivations

  • motivated to get science right or not

  • does science challenge their fundamental values/beliefs

  • how to assess scientific evidence

    • not equal to saying it should be basis of public policy

  • conflicts of interest should be declared


4
New cards

merchants of doubt vs. reasonable skeptic pt 2

  • willing to accept new info

  • bankrolls work

  • critique finding vs. claim patently false

  • reasonable skeptic should help NARROW uncertainty


5
New cards

2020s example

  • toxicologist in trial about gas stoves backed by stove company

  • by time science reaches public, can become something completely different

    • threat to identity, fear of government control


6
New cards

2024 climate example

% who say human activity contributes to global climate change

  • all u.s. adults: 45%

  • rep: 20%

  • dem: 70%

climate scientists can’t assume everyone comes from same beliefs about issue


7
New cards

gaining credibility

how should conservative value climate science approach a conservative audience?

  • share relevant details about self and values, then science & why IT’S credible

  • merchants of doubt: when science conflicts with economic interests / political values, people motivated to doubt science

    • science unlikely to settle disagreements/overcome skepticism, because science itself is not source

  • oreskes: scientists have values too, should be upfront about them to persuade non-scientist audience


8
New cards

fundamentals of persuasion

  1. listener’s attention is scarce

  2. source credibility matters


9
New cards

listener’s attention is scarce

  • more likely to pay attention if clear why topic is relevant to goals, everyday life, well-being

  • fundamental cognitive limitation


10
New cards

source credibility matters

definition: knowledgeable AND trustworthy

  • knowledgeable: speaker knows more about consequences of certain decisions than listener (relative expertise)

  • trustworthy: speaker has common interests with listener (both benefit from listener’s decision)


11
New cards

perceived credibility

  • credibility not function of objective speaker attributes, granted by AUDIENCE

  • perceived credibility: whether listener perceives that speaker has relative expertise / common interests

  • so how to communicate with skeptical audience?


12
New cards

conservative scientist talking to conservative audience

  • start with credentials for COMMON interests

  • conservative geologist richard alley talks about climate change

  • introduce as republican, community member, christian, worked for oil company


13
New cards

how does science impact policy (persuasion)?:

  • deficit model:

    • policymakers not using science because they don’t know about it; scientists thus need to tell them (fill the deficit)

    • implies scientists should engage in information dissemination

  • however, Crowley et al example → collaborative relationship-building has bigger impact (why)

  • impact of information dissemination is limited


14
New cards