1/13
prob cumulative, everything from midterm 2 onwards
merchants of doubt consideration
book is not just catalogue of events but BIOGRAPHY
biographical details of scientists that manufacture doubt
political beliefs, personal beliefs, why choose to do or not
danger of paying too much attention to biography
attacking character → implication on how science is perceived
evidence/science should be evaluated separately
merchants of doubt vs. reasonable skeptic
what are their motivations
motivated to get science right or not
does science challenge their fundamental values/beliefs
how to assess scientific evidence
not equal to saying it should be basis of public policy
conflicts of interest should be declared
merchants of doubt vs. reasonable skeptic pt 2
willing to accept new info
bankrolls work
critique finding vs. claim patently false
reasonable skeptic should help NARROW uncertainty
2020s example
toxicologist in trial about gas stoves backed by stove company
by time science reaches public, can become something completely different
threat to identity, fear of government control
2024 climate example
% who say human activity contributes to global climate change
all u.s. adults: 45%
rep: 20%
dem: 70%
climate scientists can’t assume everyone comes from same beliefs about issue
gaining credibility
how should conservative value climate science approach a conservative audience?
share relevant details about self and values, then science & why IT’S credible
merchants of doubt: when science conflicts with economic interests / political values, people motivated to doubt science
science unlikely to settle disagreements/overcome skepticism, because science itself is not source
oreskes: scientists have values too, should be upfront about them to persuade non-scientist audience
fundamentals of persuasion
listener’s attention is scarce
source credibility matters
listener’s attention is scarce
more likely to pay attention if clear why topic is relevant to goals, everyday life, well-being
fundamental cognitive limitation
source credibility matters
definition: knowledgeable AND trustworthy
knowledgeable: speaker knows more about consequences of certain decisions than listener (relative expertise)
trustworthy: speaker has common interests with listener (both benefit from listener’s decision)
perceived credibility
credibility not function of objective speaker attributes, granted by AUDIENCE
perceived credibility: whether listener perceives that speaker has relative expertise / common interests
so how to communicate with skeptical audience?
conservative scientist talking to conservative audience
start with credentials for COMMON interests
conservative geologist richard alley talks about climate change
introduce as republican, community member, christian, worked for oil company
how does science impact policy (persuasion)?:
deficit model:
policymakers not using science because they don’t know about it; scientists thus need to tell them (fill the deficit)
implies scientists should engage in information dissemination
however, Crowley et al example → collaborative relationship-building has bigger impact (why)
impact of information dissemination is limited