Week 11 - Authority of Institutional Organizations

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/12

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

13 Terms

1
New cards

Hannum, "Reinvigorating Human Rights for the Twenty-First Century”: Human Rights Being Stretched Too Far

Abstract: Too Much Can Undermine Human Rights Hannum says human rights law is a major achievement since 1945, but stretching it to cover every social problem may weaken its legitimacy. He wants "human rights" to mean international human rights law, kept separate from morality and politics, because progress needs all three.

A Victim of Its Own Success Western activists pushing a European liberal model of society may set off a backlash elsewhere, especially when rights are used for domestic change or geopolitics. Ironically, this could strengthen governments that oppose human rights and favor cultural relativism.

Examples of Expanding Obligations Some scholars want human rights duties to apply to international organizations, corporations, and even individuals. One analysis claims that in South America human rights now require states to tackle inequality and even prevent media concentration.

More Examples of Stretching the Term A Mexican court called the 1968 killing of protesters "genocide," and Amnesty International has taken on arms control and sex-work decriminalization. A Chinese official called hosting the Olympics a "human right," and the UN has appointed experts on topics from toxic waste to foreign debt.

Good Causes, but Not What 1948 Intended Many of these causes are admirable, but they were not what the drafters of the 1948 Universal Declaration had in mind. Using "human rights" as an all-purpose slogan risks blowback against the whole movement.

Change Is Fine, but Not a Step Backward Our understanding of rights rightly grows over time, much as Brown v. Board of Education changed the meaning of "equal protection" in the U.S.. Calling for restraint should not become an excuse to roll back protections for women, children, and minorities.

Mixing Up State Duties and Individual Crimes A state's duty to protect rights is often confused with an individual's guilt for a crime, which harms both ideas. Labels like "human rights crimes" add little to our understanding of criminal justice or international law.

Individual Criminal Liability Is Older Than Human Rights International law punished individuals such as pirates and hijackers long before human rights law existed. Most harms are neither international crimes nor human rights violations.

Even "Serious" Crimes Have Separate Roots Activists say only grave crimes like genocide, war crimes, and torture are "human rights crimes". But the law on the first three of these grew up independently of, and before, human rights law.

Fighting Impunity in Latin America After leaders like Pinochet gave themselves amnesties, activists and victims' families campaigned to overturn them. The argument was that human rights require preventing future abuses and giving victims a remedy.

2
New cards

Hannum, "Reinvigorating Human Rights for the Twenty-First Century”: When UN should be more conservative

The UN's Stance Against Amnesties Starting in 1999, UN negotiators refused to back peace deals that granted amnesty for war crimes and crimes against humanity. This led to clashes, such as over East Timor, and to friction in Uganda, where many victims preferred reconciliation to prosecution.

No Universal Rule Against Amnesty Hannum says a blanket ban on amnesty is not supported by state practice or customary international law. The 2013 Belfast Guidelines confirm that regional courts take different approaches.

Let Domestic Authorities Decide Decisions about amnesty are better left to national authorities, who can judge what will build a stable society that respects rights. The real goal is changing how governments behave, and jailing every violator may or may not help with that.

Rights Language in Crime Fighting The UN asked for documentation of Boko Haram abuses, and the U.S. created a "Human Rights Violators and War Crimes Unit". Both show human rights language being attached to criminal enforcement.

UN Rights Bodies Are the Wrong Tool The UN Human Rights Council and the UN human rights office (OHCHR) are poorly suited to decide whether war crimes occurred and can do little to affect armed conflicts. Invoking human rights in such conflicts rarely works and may make human rights look ineffective.

3
New cards

Hannum, "Reinvigorating Human Rights for the Twenty-First Century”: “Responsibility to Protect” separate from Human Rights

Two Links Between Rights and Force Mass abuses may be used to justify one state attacking another, which conflicts with the UN Charter's ban on using force. Human rights law and the law of war also apply together during conflict and may change each other.

The "Human Rights Hawk" John Shattuck, a former U.S. official, argues that security should include protecting human rights worldwide. Hannum says his "human rights wars" were really about genocide and mass atrocities, so the broader label confuses things.

Activists Who Backed Going It Alone Ruti Teitel notes that some activists supported humanitarian intervention even without proper authorization. Michael Glennon describes a "cottage industry" of new intervention rules after the 1999 Kosovo bombing.

Slaughter's Legitimacy Over Legality Anne-Marie Slaughter calls intervention "legitimate" in response to gross rights violations, going beyond genocide and crimes against humanity. She admitted striking Syria would be illegal but still urged U.S. attacks.

Problems With the Responsibility to Protect The vagueness and neo-colonial undertones of the "responsibility to protect" (R2P) may make agreement on intervention harder, not easier. Blurring R2P's moral and political goals with binding human rights law could hurt human rights.

Where R2P Came From R2P began with a 2001 report by a commission set up by Canada. The commission chose "responsibility to protect" over "humanitarian intervention" to focus on victims and win states' acceptance.

Iraq and Spreading Democracy The 2003 Iraq invasion was justified partly by Saddam Hussein's abuses and the goal of spreading democracy. The Bush administration's talk of "freedom" sounded like human rights to many people, despite the huge human cost.

Rights Advocates as Warmongers The Obama administration also used force, though more reluctantly. A 2014 op-ed claimed some of Washington's loudest warmongers were human rights advocates.

The UN Narrows R2P in 2005 The UN General Assembly limited R2P to protecting people from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing, and crimes against humanity. Outside states were limited to peaceful means unless the Security Council authorized force.

The 2009 Report Widens It Again The Secretary-General's 2009 report added "and violations" to most mentions of the four crimes. This tied R2P to states' general human rights duties.

Libya as a Warning The 2011 Security Council authorization to protect Libyan civilians was first hailed as R2P's high point. But the push to overthrow Qaddafi and the chaos that followed hurt R2P's credibility.

Keep R2P and Human Rights Apart Linking R2P to state responsibility for human rights risks weakening that widely accepted principle for no good reason. Hannum says putting human rights into practice is hard enough without R2P's baggage.

Human Rights Law in Wartime The International Court of Justice has confirmed that human rights law keeps applying during armed conflict, alongside humanitarian law. Some rights fall only under one body of law, and some fall under both.

4
New cards

Brighton Declaration: State and Court Responsiblities

Renewed Commitment The states that signed the European Convention on Human Rights reaffirm their commitment to it. They promise to secure its rights for everyone within their jurisdiction.

The Right of Individual Application States reaffirm that individuals' right to bring cases to the European Court of Human Rights is a cornerstone of the system. They praise the Court's contribution over more than 50 years.

Shared Duty and Subsidiarity States and the Court share responsibility, with states expected to fix violations at home first (the principle of "subsidiarity"). The Court is a backstop, and states must obey its final judgments.

Keeping the System Working States and the Court also share responsibility for keeping the system viable. States will work with the Court, other Council of Europe bodies, civil society, and national human rights institutions.

Earlier Reform Conferences The 2010 Interlaken Conference warned that the growing backlog of cases threatened the Court's credibility. The 2011 Izmir Conference welcomed the progress made since then.

Protocol No. 14 Is Not Enough Reforms under Protocol No. 14 helped clear clearly inadmissible cases, but well-founded cases keep piling up. More measures are needed to protect over 800 million people.

5
New cards

Brighton Declaration: State

Preventing Violations at Home States must prevent violations, make laws that respect the Convention, and provide remedies at home. This should mean fewer violations and a lighter caseload for the Court.

Council of Europe Support The Council of Europe helps states implement the Convention, including through technical assistance. That help should be efficient and aimed at clear outcomes.

Concrete Steps for National Implementation States commit to steps such as setting up national human rights institutions, checking new laws against the Convention, and training officials and judges. The Conference also calls for translating key judgments and for better-targeted technical help.


6
New cards

Brighton Declaration: Court

The Court's Role States must secure Convention rights and provide effective remedies at the national level. The Court gives the authoritative interpretation and protects people when states fail.

Margin of Appreciation States have some leeway in how they apply the Convention (the "margin of appreciation"), because national authorities usually understand local conditions better. The Court reviews whether national decisions fit the Convention while respecting that leeway.

Writing Subsidiarity Into the Convention The Conference wants references to subsidiarity and the margin of appreciation added to the Convention's preamble by the end of 2013. It also supports dialogue with national courts and an optional protocol for advisory opinions.

Access to the Court Individual application is a cornerstone of the system, and filing a case must be possible in practice. States must not interfere with this right in any way.

Admissibility Rules The admissibility rules in Article 35 decide which cases get a full hearing, so the Court can focus on important ones. The Court should apply them strictly and consistently.

Tightening Admissibility The Conference proposes cutting the filing deadline to four months and tightening the "significant disadvantage" rule. It also says cases already properly decided by national courts can be treated as manifestly ill-founded, unless they raise a serious question.

Growing Backlog Applications to the Court doubled between 2004 and 2012, and huge numbers are pending. Many applicants, including those with strong cases, wait years for an answer.

Handle Weak Cases Efficiently The Court must dispose of inadmissible cases as efficiently as possible. It has already made significant progress under Protocol No. 14.

Repetitive Cases Repeated, similar cases usually come from systemic problems inside a country. That state must fix them, under the supervision of the Committee of Ministers.

Chamber Cases Pile Up The growing number of cases pending before the Court's Chambers is a serious concern. The Court should be able to focus on new violations that may be well-founded.

Processing Reforms The Conference welcomes the Court's priority policy and pilot judgments, and encourages states to second national judges and lawyers to its staff. It also explores ideas such as extra judges and online filing, aiming for a decision on communicating a case within one year.

Rethinking the Court's Role It may be necessary to reconsider the Court's basic role and nature. Any reform must keep individual application and handle serious violations promptly.

A More Focused Court Better implementation at home would let the Court take on a narrower role over time. The system must help states meet their primary responsibility.

Fewer, More Important Cases The Court should concentrate on serious or widespread violations, systemic problems, and key questions of interpretation. It would then issue fewer judgments

7
New cards

Brighton Declaration: Judges

Quality of Judges The Court's authority and credibility depend on the quality of its judges and judgments. Strong judges are the foundation of the system.

Picking Good Candidates States must nominate the best possible candidates for election as judges. A high-quality Registry staff is also essential to support the judges.

Clear and Consistent Judgments Clear, consistent judgments promote legal certainty and help national courts apply the Convention. Consistency does not mean every state must implement the Convention the same way.

Full Terms for Judges A stable bench makes the Court more consistent. Judges should therefore generally serve their full terms.

Reforms on Judges The Conference welcomes the guidelines and expert panel for vetting judge candidates and asks the Court not to depart from precedent without good reason. It proposes removing parties' power to block a Chamber from handing a case to the Grand Chamber, and requiring judges to be no older than 65 when their term starts.

Obeying Judgments Each state has promised to obey the Court's final judgments in its own cases. The Committee of Ministers makes sure judgments are carried out, including fixes for wider problems.

8
New cards

Brighton Declaration: Committee of Minister

Committee of Ministers Oversight The Committee of Ministers must fairly judge whether a state has fixed a violation and act against states that don't comply. It should focus on systemic problems and make sure pilot judgments are implemented quickly.

Growing Supervision Workload The Committee of Ministers is overseeing more and more judgments. Its workload will keep growing as the Court clears its backlog.

Better Execution of Judgments States are encouraged to build systems at home to carry out judgments quickly and to publish their action plans. The Committee of Ministers is asked to improve its procedures and consider stronger measures against states that delay.

Planning for the Long Term The Declaration deals with immediate problems, but the system's future also needs a plan. A process is needed to anticipate challenges and develop a long-term vision.

Review Deadlines Interlaken asked the Committee of Ministers to evaluate progress from 2012 to 2015 and decide by the end of 2015 whether more action is needed. By the end of 2019, it must decide whether deeper changes are necessary.

Process for the Future The Committee of Ministers should set its process by the end of 2012 and examine options for the Court's future role, drawing on outside experts. It should also look at the execution of judgments and compensation, with an interim view by the end of 2015.

Final Steps The UK Chairmanship is to send the Declaration to the Committee of Ministers. All bodies are asked to give it full effect, and future chairs are asked to keep reform moving.

9
New cards

Brighton Declaration: Convention

EU Accession The European Union joining the Convention will make human rights protection in Europe more coherent. The Conference calls for the accession agreement to be finished quickly.

Easier Amendments The Conference supports ongoing work on a simpler way to amend the Convention's organizational provisions. That work must respect states' constitutional arrangements.

10
New cards

Moyn, "Human Rights Are Not Enough"

Time to Reassess Forty years on, we should rethink how human rights fit into today's economy and push back against inequality. We should revive Tominová's vision of combining rights with social welfare.

Old Idea, New Prominence The idea that individuals have basic entitlements goes back centuries. But human rights as a global language of justice is historically new.

Rights Began Inside Nations Rights claims first served revolutions and nation-building, operating within borders. Even the 1948 Universal Declaration, full of economic and social rights, focused on citizens.

The Shift to Survival and Shaming By the 1970s, groups like Amnesty International focused on basic survival and "naming and shaming," not broad economic rights. That shift happened just as welfare states were being hollowed out.

Don't Scapegoat Human Rights Some on the left blame human rights for serving capitalism, but human rights did not cause the neoliberal age. It is unfair to blame them for the left's setbacks.

The 19th-Century Version In the 1800s, rights rhetoric mainly protected free contracts and private property. That is why Marx saw rights as a defense of capitalists.


The Social Democratic Era In the mid-20th century, rights became part of a politics seeking more equality within nations. This showed that the idea of rights could be flexible.

Neoliberalism Changed Things Neoliberalism didn't shrink rights back to protecting property. But it cut their link to redistribution and left them a minor, defensive role.

Dropping Economic Rights Groups like Amnesty and Human Rights Watch dropped economic and social rights and focused on shaming oppressors. They never challenged the gap between rich and poor.

No Ceiling on Wealth Focusing only on a minimum floor, the movement did nothing to stop unlimited wealth at the top. Human rights became a companion to rising inequality, which helped fuel populism.

Partner, Not Culprit We shouldn't blame or abandon human rights ideals. They make sense only as one partner in a fairer economic politics.

Keep Fighting Abuse Inequality has helped bring populists to power, and it is tempting to double down on human rights strategies. Activists should not stop denouncing repression or helping the very poor.

Not a Cure-All Activists should reflect on their success, and the rest of us should admit we failed to offer bold ideas beyond rights. Human rights aren't to blame for inequality, but we were wrong to treat them as a cure-all.

Others Must Tackle Inequality Human rights groups are unlikely to solve inequality alone, since they lack the strengths of unions and local actors. We can keep their benefits while rejecting neoliberalism.

Stick to What It Does Best The movement should focus on shaping citizenship and condemning evil, not claim to represent all of global justice. Supporters should not mistake one part of justice for the whole.

A Broader Future The movement's future must include a wider community fighting for equality. Tominová was a human rights activist, but not only that.

Supplement Human Rights Human rights movements can break free of their link to neoliberalism while others revive the goal of equality. Without other ideals alongside rights, global justice will stay unfinished.

11
New cards

Declaration of Five States on the Inter-American System

Commitment to the Convention Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, and Paraguay reaffirm their commitment to the American Convention on Human Rights. They pledge to secure its rights for everyone in their jurisdictions.

Individual Petitions and Settlements The states call individual petitions a fundamental part of the system. They also value friendly settlements as a tool for improving state institutions.

Two Sides of Subsidiarity States must investigate every violation on their territory. They also have the right to let their own courts resolve a case before an international body steps in.

Respect State Autonomy States should have room to protect rights through their own democratic processes. They should also be able to do so within their own constitutions.

Fairness While Clearing the Backlog The Commission is working to reduce its case backlog. That effort must still guarantee the right to a defense, legal certainty, and equal procedural treatment.

Strict Sources and Leeway The states call for strict use of the sources of international human rights law and recognition of a "margin of appreciation" for states. They add that rulings bind only the parties to each case.

Consider Local Realities The bodies should understand each state's political, economic, and social conditions. Reparations should be proportionate and respect each state's constitutional order.

12
New cards

Hopgood, The Endtimes of Human Rights - Critical of Robinson

Robinson in East Timor In 1999, UN High Commissioner Mary Robinson opened a human rights workshop in newly freed East Timor. Participants received rights documents and badges reading "know them, live them, defend them".


A Brutal Occupation More than 100,000 civilians died during Indonesia's 25-year occupation, while the world offered only empty protests. The fighters saved themselves, and no one has been held accountable.

An Arrogant Lecture Hopgood finds Robinson's lecture arrogant, since international human rights had failed East Timor and she owed an apology. Because the guerrillas used violence, global agencies would not even call them "human rights defenders".

13
New cards

Hopgood, The Endtimes of Human Rights - Types of Human Rights and Solution

Lowercase "human rights" One kind of human rights is local activism that exposes abuse and pressures governments, often at great personal cost. Any language that helps this cause, whether rights, religion, or solidarity, is useful.

This Kind Never Ends This grassroots form can never die, because people will always band together to demand justice. It is a flexible tool that protects the person, not an end in itself.

Capital-H "Human Rights" Robinson meant "Human Rights": a global structure of laws, courts, and organizations claiming to speak for all humanity. Hopgood calls it a rigid "secular monotheism" with Robinson as its "high priest".

The Coming Decline Hopgood argues that the global human rights regime is close to decay. Its institutions have interests and ambitions that outweigh the simple urge to help the abused.

The Global Overrides the Local Big organizations tend to stifle protest, and the global system ends up dominating local movements. Human Rights aims to become the supreme authority above all politics.

Humanism Replaced God Humanism took the place of the Christian god for 19th-century Europeans, who built institutions like the Red Cross. They then spread that moral authority worldwide through empire.

Collapse and Rebuilding World War II and the Holocaust destroyed Europe's moral authority, and new global institutions tried to repair it. Amnesty International, founded in 1961, looked back to the past rather than forward.

American Power Takes Over From the 1970s, advocates pushed the U.S. to use its power for human rights abroad, and elite groups like Human Rights Watch emerged. Many supporters treated human rights as a lifestyle choice.

Rights Tied to Democracy Export Human rights became bound up with spreading neoliberal democracy through American power. Hopgood calls Robinson's view naive and notes that both U.S. camps backed the 2011 Libya intervention.

The High Point Hid Decline From 1991 to 2008, U.S. dominance helped create war crimes tribunals, the International Criminal Court, and the responsibility to protect. Yet decline had already begun.

The Old Model Earlier groups got their moral authority by staying away from power, though this led the Red Cross to keep silent about the Holocaust. That neutrality had little real political impact.

Allying With Power Costs Credibility Teaming up with powerful states destroyed the selfless core of the movement's moral authority. When the powerful exempt themselves from the rules, human rights look ideological.

A "Neo-Westphalian" World U.S. power is shrinking while China, India, Brazil, and Russia assert their sovereignty. Global liberal norms will stall or shrink in people's daily lives.

Religion Returns Religious authorities are gaining ground as advocates turn to the language of "dignity". Europe's decline means the fading of universal rules that can never be broken.

Humanitarian Aid Survives Simple Good Samaritan-style aid will last because states benefit from it. Hopgood argues that human rights norms have taken over humanitarian law, as at the International Criminal Court.

Think Smaller and Local Lower ambitions will let rights become locally owned, because politics beats law and local beats global. Sergio Vieira de Mello said a rights culture must be a popular culture.

Democratize Human Rights De Mello stood for global Human Rights but saw that rights must belong to the people. To survive, rights need local interpretation, which means turning "Human Rights" into "human rights".