✅ Equitable Property

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/54

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

55 Terms

1
New cards
Which of the following are regarded as indicia of property interests:
Recoverable against third parties, Transferability
2
New cards
Connect the principle with the right description:
Mere equity → A claim which if successful will lead to the recognition of an equitable proprietary interest. Personal equity → A claim which if successful will lead to an equitable remedy other than an equitable proprietary interest.
3
New cards
Debentures and shares are recognised categories of:
legal choses in action
4
New cards
Equitable proprietary interests are lost under general law if legal title to the property in which the interest lies is sold to a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of the interest: T/F
True
5
New cards

Hello

Hello



6
New cards
Interests in a partnership and beneficial interests in a trust are:
equitable choses in action
7
New cards
In DKLR Holding Co Ltd (No 2) Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) (1982) 149 CLR 431, Aickin J stated that “If one person has both the legal estate and the entire beneficial interest in the land he holds an entire and unqualified legal interest and not two separate interests, one legal and the other equitable…”: T/ F
True
8
New cards
Following the Judicature Acts 1873, the distinction between equitable interests in property and common law interests in property became redundant: T / F
False
9
New cards
What is equity in the context of the legal system?
The body of law derived from the specific jurisdiction developed by the Chancellor and exercised by the English Court of Chancery before 1873.
10
New cards
Did the administrative restructure under the Judicature Acts fuse the substantive principles of common law and equity?
No, the Judicature Acts empowered superior courts to administer both common law and equitable remedies concurrently, but did not fuse the underlying legal and equitable principles.
11
New cards
How did equity historically operate in relation to property?
Equity historically operated in personam by making orders against individuals to prevent them from unconscionably abusing their common law legal ownership rights.
12
New cards
What is a personal equity?
A right of access to a court of equity to seek a non-proprietary remedy.
13
New cards
Can a personal equity be assigned or attached to specific assets?
No, a personal equity is not an interest in property, cannot be assigned to others, and does not attach to particular assets.
14
New cards
What is an example of a personal equity?
A Mareva order issued against a defendant within the court's jurisdiction concerning assets located overseas.
15
New cards
What is a mere equity?
An ancillary, non-proprietary claim that requires judicial intervention to perfect or restore a full equitable property interest.
16
New cards
What are three common examples of a mere equity?
The right to set aside a transaction for fraud or undue influence, the right to seek document rectification for mistake, and a claim under proprietary estoppel principles.
17
New cards
What is an equitable proprietary interest?
An intangible property right (chose in action) enforceable in equity regarding property legally titled to another party.
18
New cards
Name four examples of equitable proprietary interests.
Beneficial interests under a fixed trust, partnership property interests, unregistered mortgages, and vendor or purchaser liens.
19
New cards
What four criteria did the House of Lords set out in National Provincial Bank v Ainsworth for an interest to be recognised as property?
The interest must be definable, identifiable by third parties, capable of assumption by third parties, and possess a degree of permanence or stability.
20
New cards
In Latec Investments v Hotel Terrigal, what was the nature of the mortgagor's right to set aside the fraudulent mortgagee sale?
It was classified by Kitto J as a mere equity.
21
New cards
Why did the debenture holder's equitable charge take priority over the mortgagor's right in Latec Investments?
Because a later equitable interest acquired for value in good faith without notice defeats an earlier mere equity.
22
New cards
What alternative reasoning did Taylor J offer in Latec Investments regarding the priority dispute?
Equity will refuse to assist an earlier claimant to remove an impediment to title if doing so would prejudice a later innocent purchaser of an equitable interest.
23
New cards
What core principle was established in Baker v Archer-Shee regarding trust beneficiaries?
A beneficiary's right to income under a fixed trust is a proprietary interest in equity, not merely a personal right to compel performance by the trustee.
24
New cards
In Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) v Livingston, why was succession duty not payable on the Queensland assets?
Because a residuary beneficiary of an unadministered estate has no beneficial proprietary interest in specific estate assets, holding only a personal right to compel proper administration.
25
New cards
According to DKLR Holding Co v Commissioner of Stamp Duties, does an absolute legal owner hold separate legal and equitable estates?
No, an absolute legal owner holds a single, entire, unqualified legal interest, not two separate legal and equitable estates.
26
New cards
In Farah Constructions v Say-Dee, why were the wife and daughters not liable under the first limb of Barnes v Addy?
Because general, non-confidential commercial information is not property capable of being received for the purposes of the first limb.
27
New cards
What are the three certainties required to establish an express trust?
Certainty of intention, certainty of subject matter, and certainty of object.
28
New cards
What formal requirement applies to the creation of an express trust over land?
It must be manifested and proved in writing signed by a relevant person, though this writing requirement does not apply to implied or constructive trusts.
29
New cards
How does a fixed trust differ from a discretionary trust regarding beneficial ownership?
Beneficiaries under a fixed trust hold a proprietary interest in the trust property, whereas beneficiaries under a discretionary trust have only a personal right to compel proper administration.
30
New cards
What equitable interest arises when a binding contract for the sale of land is executed?
The purchaser acquires an estate contract in land and the vendor holds the property on constructive trust for the purchaser, provided specific performance is available.
31
New cards
What rule from Milroy v Lord and Corin v Paton governs voluntary assignments of property in equity?
A voluntary assignment is effective in equity if the donor has done everything necessary to be done by the donor personally to vest legal title in the donee.
32
New cards
When does a resulting trust arise by implication of law?
When property is purchased in another's name without consideration, when purchase price contributions are unequal, when an express trust fails, or when surplus funds remain after a specific purpose is fulfilled.
33
New cards
What is a vendor's lien?
An equitable lien implied by law over sold land in favour of an unpaid vendor to the extent of the unpaid purchase money.
34
New cards
What is a purchaser's lien?
An equitable lien over the vendor's interest in property for a deposit paid under a contract that is lawfully terminated before title is transferred.
35
New cards
Give four circumstances where a court will impose a constructive trust by operation of law.
Breach of fiduciary duty, fraudulent acquisition of property, failed joint ventures, and unconscionable retention of a benefit.
36
New cards
What happens when legal title and equitable title are split in a fixed trust?
Legal title is held by the trustee owing equitable obligations to the beneficiary, but adult beneficiaries of full capacity may call for the legal title to terminate the trust.
37
New cards
What writing formality applies to the disposition of a subsisting equitable interest?
It must be in writing signed by the person disposing of the interest, contained in their will, or signed by an authorized agent in writing.
38
New cards
Under Torrens land registration, what is the effect of registering a later legal interest over an earlier prior equitable interest?
The later registered legal interest defeats the earlier equitable interest, unless an exception such as fraud, a caveat, or rights created by the registered proprietor applies.
39
New cards
What four elements constitute the bona fide purchaser for value without notice defense?
Acquisition of the legal estate, provision of valuable consideration, acting bona fide, and lack of actual, constructive, or imputed notice prior to payment and transfer.
40
New cards
What is actual notice?
Direct, sufficient awareness of relevant facts, beyond mere rumours or vague statements.
41
New cards
What is constructive notice?
Notice of facts that a purchaser would have discovered if they had made reasonable due inquiries and inspections of property and title documents.
42
New cards
What is imputed notice?
Notice acquired by an agent of the purchaser acting within the scope of their authority during the transaction.
43
New cards
What is the general priority rule between competing equitable claims?
Where the merits of competing claims are equal, priority in time of creation gives the better equity (qui prior est tempore potior est jure).
44
New cards
Under what priority exception does an earlier equitable interest yield to a later equitable interest?
When the earlier claim is a mere equity and the later interest was acquired for value without notice of the earlier claim.
45
New cards
How can disentitling conduct postpone an earlier equitable interest?
If the earlier holder's conduct misleads a subsequent claimant into believing the prior interest does not exist, such as by handing over blank transfer forms or title documents.
46
New cards
How was disentitling conduct established in Abigail v Lapin?
The earlier owners allowed another person to hold absolute, unencumbered title documents, enabling a later lender to acquire an equitable interest without notice.
47
New cards
How was disentitling conduct established in Breskvar v Wall?
The owners executed a blank transfer form and delivered title documents, enabling a fraudulent transfer to a third party who created a subsequent equitable interest.
48
New cards
What principle was established in Heid v Reliance Finance Corp?
Handing over signed transfer documents acknowledging full payment before receiving the purchase price postponed the vendor's equitable lien to subsequent equitable mortgagees.
49
New cards
How does a waiver of priority apply to floating charges?
A floating charge arrangement implies that subsequent equitable claims created in the ordinary course of business take priority over the earlier floating charge.
50
New cards
What is the priority rule for competing equitable assignees of personalty established in Dearle v Hall?
Priority is determined by the order in which assignees give notice to the legal holder or trustee of the personal property.
51
New cards
What three conditions must a subsequent assignee fulfill under the rule in Dearle v Hall?
The assignee must give value, take the assignment without notice of the earlier claim, and give notice to the trustee.
52
New cards
Why are commercial trading trusts commonly used as alternatives to corporations in Australia?
They offer tax advantages by distributing gross income or capital directly to beneficiaries and operate with fewer regulatory restrictions than corporations.
53
New cards
Name three common examples of commercial trust structures in Australia.
Superannuation funds, managed investment schemes (such as unit trusts), and corporate trading trusts.
54
New cards
When does a proprietary estoppel equity arise?
When a person detrimentally relies on a promise or encouragement by a legal owner that an interest in land will be granted, or acts on a mistaken assumption of ownership permitted by the owner.
55
New cards
Is a court obligated to grant a proprietary remedy to satisfy a proprietary estoppel claim?
No, the remedy remains discretionary, and the court may structure relief merely to reverse the detriment suffered rather than fulfilling the full expectation.