1/23
Ethical guidelines for psychology research
What is research ethics?
The principles and rules that help protect people and animals involved in research
What do you do to make sure the research is ethical?
Make sure the study won’t harm the participants, that it is voluntary and that they understand what they are agreeing too, that their personal info is protected and whether benefits of the research justify its risks.
What are some study examples regarding unethical research?
Tiskegee Syphilis study: Illustrates serious ethical violations - Participants were harmed nor were they properly asked for consent or informed, and a particular group was targeted
Milgram obedience studies: Illustrates difficulty of balancing the scientific value of research against possible harm of distress to participants
What are the three core ethical principles?
Respect the persons: Respect the participants choice and rights (their decision - autonomy) and protect those who may have limited ability to make decisions
Beneficence/ concern for welfare: There should be more benefits that harm (assess possible risks before conducting study
Justice (Fairness): The selection and treatment throughout all participants should be fair as well as beneficial and burdens of research should be distributed fairly
Where did the core ethical principles come from?
Belmont report
What is informed consent?
After receiving and reviewing info about the study, participants can decide whether to participate
What should participants be informed about?
General purpose + Participants involving + potential risks & benefits + personal info is collected & how it will be handled + right for participants to stop
What are the two important terms about data not being shared without permission? And what do they mean?
Anonymous study: No info about participants is collected that may identify them
Confidential study: Researchers know participants, but info is protected - where it’s not revealed to others
What does deception mean?
Where researchers mislead participants on purpose or withhold smtg so they don’t know the true purpose of the study
Why is deception used?
Used if the participants know they real hypothesis as their behavior may change which could have an influence on the results
What are the disadvantages of deception?
It raises ethical concerns as the participants cannot fully understand the study beforehand
When is deception acceptable?
When it is necessary for research + no suitable alternative + Potential benefits justify risks + no expose to unjustified harm
What is debriefing?
When researchers explain the truth about the purpose of the study and reveal any deception after the experiment had taken place
What is included in a debrief?
Why deception was necessary + actual purpose of hypothesis + they answer any relevant questions + Provide further info or reference when appropriate
What are the two important organization that provide ethical principles and standards for psychologists?
APA: American Psychological Association
CPA: Canadian Psychological Association
What are the two organizations that evaluate research proposals before studies are conducted?
IRB (Institutional review board): Reviews research ethics in institutions in the US
REB (Research Ethics Board): The equivalent type of research ethics committee in canada
What is research misconduct?
Where dishonest or inappropriate behavior that damages the reliability and integrity of science
What are the types of research conducts and their definitions?
Fabrication: Making up data that were never collected
Falsification: Changing or manipulating research data or results dishonesty (Change in results so they appear to support your hypothesis)
Plagiarism: Using another person’s work without their acknowledgement
What is self-plagiarism?
Using your own work and republishing it without acknowledgment and all can be misleading
What are the three important stages of discovering and dealing with misconduct?
Discovery: How can misconduct be discovered? Where statistical problems or unusual patterns in data + inconsistency in reported results + concerns raised by other researchers
Hard to tell if smtg is misconduct: Researchers need to consider if the error was accidental or intentional (as not all mistakes are research misconduct).
Consequences: A possible consequence is retraction
What is retraction?
When an article is completely withdrawn from scientific record as believed to be unreliable and seriously problematic
Why are animals used in research?
Used in research when humans cannot be ethically investigated (It is subject to legal + institutional controls)
What are the three R’s related to animal research? and their definition?
Replacement: Find alternatives to animals whenever possible
Refinement: Improve procedures to reduce pain, distress or suffering
Reduction: Use the smallest number of animals necessary to obtain scientifically useful events