1/10
mgt 432
After Ratification and Beyond
Hold meetings with your leaders to review new provisions
Outline the changes and ensure understanding (provide examples)
BEST PRACTICE – show old and new policy side by side and highlight changes for discussion
Ensure that leaders understand changes to the CBA and the intentions behind them
Why we are making a change is often more important that the actual change itself
Do not have them rely on employee interpretations
Remember – employees may have a different interpretation than leadership does
Grievance Process
when employees feel like something that is in the cba, and the employer has violated it, they file this (Will be outlined in the Collective
Bargaining Agreement)
Several steps of the grievance process
Step 1: Employee files it
An employee believes the employer violated the union contract (CBA).
Example: An employee believes they were unfairly denied overtime pay.
Step 2: Informal discussion
The employee and supervisor attempt to resolve the issue informally.
Step 3: Formal written grievance
If the issue is not resolved, the union submits a formal written complaint to management.
Step 4: Further review and negotiations
Union representatives and management meet to discuss the it and attempt to reach an agreement.
Step 5: Arbitration
If the issue still cannot be resolved, it may go to an impartial third party called an arbitrator, who reviews the evidence and makes a decision.
Mediation
Parties have reached an impasse in negotiations, bargaining or on a grievance.
There is a formal legal process under the FMCS guidelines
Non-binding on either party in negotiations.
A third party is engaged to resolve the conflict.
Some CBAs will call for this for all terminations.
Remember, this is voluntary for both sides.
Fact Finding
A semi-judicial process allowed by Labor Manager Relations Act and the Railway
Act.
Used primarily in government negotiations
No legal authority to bind interested parties
Organize and publicize the facts with the hope that the public will exert pressure on
the parties to resolve labor conflict
Arbitration
quasi-judicial process in which parties agree to submit unresolved disputes to a
neutral third party for binding settlement
Both parties submit their positions, and the arbitrator decides what each party is entitled to
Two major topics of labor arbitration involve
Interest arbitration - Occurs when issues not resolved between employer and a representative union are
presented to Arbitrator for a decision.
Rights or grievance arbitration – Occurs when parties submit a dispute that involves the language or terms of
a “certified collective bargaining agreement”
Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement
Once parties reach a point that there is no agreement then
List possible alternatives to solution
Evaluate your best alternatives by assigning some value to each
Select an alternative that party believes has the best value proposition for them
Finally, make a decision related to the final and best solution
Reaching a Decision Point
Need to understand how decisions are made.
The other party wants some problem resolved or solved.
Look for answers in discussions.
Ask probative questions without prejudice.
You should be looking for questions such as:
Who? What? Why? When?
Find “summary” point. “Richard, let me recap or in summary it sounds as if you are
seeking this…”
Documentation – Best Practices
Keep all notes professional
Do not include personal opinions or anything that could be perceived as not professional
Save both physical and digital copies, just in case
Think about who might be reading your documentation and write in a style that
explains what you mean
Use first and last names, you can include nicknames, but make sure you spell out
who you mean
Include job titles the first time you mention someone, people often change roles
Make sure you include, month, day and year on dates. Sometimes people forget
part of that, or they say last week or last Friday.
Include the details – little things matter
Case Process
Who – employees, witnesses, Manager/Supervisor, department, organization
Where – physical location, on-site, off-site
What – the incident and facts of the case – unbiased, don’t pre-judge, using the
employee handbook and policy determine what happened
When – specific times and dates, recorded for record
How – what are the key issues, how did the key players act and what was their
motives, look for truth telling and falsehoods
Why – the key component of the case – the other answered questions lead to this
answer
Process of Discovery
Interrogatories
Listen, listen, listen – they are speaking to you so pick up the key phrases. Write
them down and refer to them later.
You really don’t know anything until the other party explains what they are seeking in
these discussions.
Observation: what drives the other party to negotiate. Could be:
Better sales price
New supplier
New labor agreement
Depositions