1/164
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the two views in the debate about Caribbean society and culture?
One says the region is so culturally diverse that a Caribbean consciousness or culture exists only in the imagination; the other points to common historical experiences (genocide, slavery, plantation, indentureship, migration, independence, integration)
What is the most enigmatic thing about Caribbean society and culture?
There is so much difference amidst admittedly common experiences
Why is culture diverse even in an ethnically homogeneous society?
People interpret and act on their culture from their own social location, so culture is never uniform
Why is "cultural diversity" a social construction?
The term emphasises differences and creates the image of neat categories, hiding unique ways individuals express and experience shared beliefs and values
What is "social race"?
Racial categories we have created and agree on, based largely on phenotype (physical appearance), rather than on biology
What are the three main racial groupings used in the Caribbean?
Mongoloid (Amerindians, plus Chinese and Indians), Caucasoid (Europeans, plus Syrians, Jews and Lebanese) and Negroid (Africans)
Why is the concept of race considered flawed?
No consistent biological difference has been found between races; traits occur along a continuum; the categories cannot accommodate mixed peoples and groups (e.g. Australian Aboriginals); and it was used to justify a European-dominated hierarchy
Give THREE reasons race is flawed (exam question)?
It has no basis in biology, physical traits blend along a continuum, and the classifications cannot accommodate people of mixed heritage – it is a social construction
Why are race and ethnicity often used interchangeably?
People use "race" as a synonym for nationality or genealogy (e.g. the "Indian race") when they really mean ethnicity – belonging based on social and cultural ties
Define ethnicity (exam question)?
Social and cultural "belongingness" – the ties that bind people who see themselves as similar in some way (race, colour, religion, heritage, language, nationality) and who regularly interact
What criteria identify cultural groups?
Race, colour, religion, heritage and language; finer distinctions include wealth, kin, education and urban or rural residence
Why is race alone not a good basis for ethnic groups?
People of the same race can have different cultures (British and French; Africans from Guyana and Barbados) or different religions, and people of mixed race may identify with a nationality rather than a race
Which racial group is the largest in the Caribbean?
People of African descent (Negroid ancestry)
Give examples of African-descended groups that are ethnically distinct?
Maroons, Bush Negroes and Rastafarians – their cultural practices and beliefs set them apart
Why are the Maroons considered an ethnic group?
They share common descent, history of escape from slavery, own traditions, customs, treaties and territory, and see themselves as distinct
How are the Maroons similar to and different from mainstream society?
Similar – African descent and shared history of slavery; Different – autonomous communities, communal land, treaties with colonial governments, own customs and sense of identity
How diverse are the Amerindians of Guyana?
About nine distinct ethnic groups (about 7 per cent of the population) with own languages – coastal Arawaks, Warau and Caribs and interior groups such as Akawaio, Patamona, Arekuna, Makushi, Wapishana and Waiwai
How diverse are the Maroons of Suriname?
Several distinct groups (Ndjuka, Saramacca, Matawai, Kwinti) with their own traditions, customs and languages
Why is St Kitts and Nevis an example of apparent uniformity?
The people are mainly of African origin with similar practices and history, so they seem to be one people – yet Nevis has repeatedly challenged the union with St Kitts
What did the Nevis secession dispute show?
That loyalties and identities can differ within a seemingly uniform culture because of historical grievances, development funds and local autonomy
Why must commonalities exist before we can speak of differences?
Differences only make sense between things that are recognised as similar – so "cultural diversity" in the Caribbean acknowledges commonalities
How does history view cultural diversity?
It studies differences in order to understand commonalities – the meeting and mixing of groups forcibly uprooted for plantation labour under European dominance
How does sociology view cultural diversity?
It studies relationships among groups at a particular time (e.g. social stratification) – the same cultural processes occur in all societies and differences arise from how groups relate
How does anthropology view cultural diversity?
It looks at how a group develops a sense of self and identity through shared experiences and how others perceive them, giving insight into symbolic culture
What common experiences did Caribbean groups share?
Being uprooted, transported, transplanted and colonised, with colonial policies controlling and transforming them through conquest, settlement, the plantation and colonial laws
How did the colonisers keep ethnic groups divided?
Maintained a highly stratified system separating groups and kept the races divided so unity could not threaten the few whites in control
What is a lingua franca?
A language spoken by everyone in countries or areas where more than one language is used (e.g. Sranan Tongo in Suriname)
How is language a divisive force in the Caribbean?
Interaction between countries depends on whether they speak the same language, and minority groups fear losing their language to the dominant culture
Describe Suriname's linguistic diversity?
Dutch is official, English widely spoken, Sranan Tongo is the lingua franca, plus Javanese (Surinaams-Javaans), Hindustani and Maroon languages
Which Amerindian languages persist in Guyana and Belize?
Guyana has nine pre-Columbian languages; in Belize Kekchi and Mopan are Maya languages still spoken
Which Indian languages came to the Caribbean?
Hindi, Urdu and Bhojpuri (a Hindi variant); Arabic is the language of prayer for Muslims; today they are reserved for special occasions
How have Hindi words entered Trinidad creole?
Mainly for foods and vegetables – bodi, bhaggi, bhaigan, channa, alloo
Why is language an issue of cultural identity?
Groups often refuse to recognise others' languages as equal, causing heated debates about national languages and fears of enculturation
What is cultural pluralism?
Cultural diversity resulting from European colonisation, when different groups were brought forcibly or under contract as plantation labour and share a space without mixing much
Describe a plural society (exam question)?
A society with two or more ethnic groups who share the same space but do not mix significantly – they meet at work and school but live in different areas, have different occupations, celebrate different festivals and do not intermarry
Name examples of plural societies?
Guyana, Suriname and Trinidad and Tobago in the Caribbean; also Mauritius, Fiji and Sri Lanka
What problems have occurred in plural societies?
Mistrust, ethnic hate, polarised politics, discrimination, social unrest, ethnic violence and in extreme cases civil war (e.g. Sri Lanka, Fiji tension, Suriname)
What happened in Suriname in 1980?
A military takeover removed the system of checks and balances among ethnic groups and led to persecution of the Maroons and a civil war
Describe the ethnic composition of Suriname?
Indians about 36 per cent, Creoles about 31 per cent, Javanese about 15 per cent, Maroons about 10 per cent, plus Amerindians, Chinese and others
What are the forms of accommodation among ethnic groups in a shared space?
Cultural pluralism (live side by side), hybridisation or miscegenation (mixing), and maronage (running away to build a separate society)
How did ethnic groups try to forge identity under colonialism?
Each claimed value – Africans claimed superior education, urban sophistication and long residence; Indians claimed hard work, thrift and business acumen – to show they belonged
Why did Africans and Indians begin in mutual antipathy?
Indians accepted low wages and drove down the price of labour; Indians were seen as social outcasts and remained isolated on plantations
What is the "them and us" syndrome?
Socialisation that makes people from different ethnic groups keep their distance, believing outsiders cannot understand their culture
Why is "no one can understand a culture unless they belong to it" problematic?
It encourages suspicion and distrust between groups and ignores that culture is diverse and shared experiences exist
Give POSITIVE effects of cultural diversity (syllabus)?
Variety of foods, festivals, music, fashions and crafts; opportunities for dialogue and learning about others' values (e.g. the hijab and dreadlocks school cases in Trinidad); learning negotiation and balance; mixed-race people providing alternative perspectives; creative cultural hybridisation in music, art and literature
Give NEGATIVE effects of cultural diversity (syllabus)?
Prejudices perpetuated through socialisation; ethnic hate and superiority; ethnic politics and discrimination in jobs and promotions; social unrest and violence; possible civil war and genocide
How does ethnic politics develop?
Parties become polarised by race, politics becomes a contest between ethnicities, and jobs and opportunities go to the ruling party's ethnic group
Give an example of accommodation regarding political power?
Coalitions or power-sharing between ethnic groups and balanced representation in government (as in Suriname before 1980)
Give an example of accommodation regarding economic power and social visibility?
Different groups gaining access to business and professional positions, and festivals, dress and cultural symbols of all groups being publicly recognised and given national holidays
Define social stratification?
A system that ranks the population into social classes or groups arranged in a hierarchy
What are social strata and status?
Strata are the levels of the hierarchy; status is a rank or position in the social hierarchy
What do groups in the hierarchy have more or less of?
What the society values – money, power and/or prestige
What is a closed system of social stratification?
One where groups are unequal and the pattern of inequality persists across generations because position is based on ascribed criteria
What are ascribed criteria?
Categories you are born into and cannot change, such as race, colour or caste
What are achieved criteria?
A person's performance in earning what the society values – wealth, status and prestige
Distinguish between ascribed and achieved status (exam question)?
Ascribed status is fixed by birth (race, colour, caste); achieved status is earned through effort, education, occupation or wealth
What were the bases of stratification in aboriginal societies?
Fighting prowess or descent
What were the bases of stratification in plantation society?
Race and colour (ascribed) – a closed system
What are the bases of stratification in the post-Emancipation era?
A combination of race, colour, class, wealth and/or education
Describe the caste system?
Based on ascriptive status (birth); a person marries within the caste (endogamy); lineage defines status and inheritance of wealth, power and prestige; seen as permanent with practices to keep castes separate
Name the castes in the Indian caste system?
Brahmins (priests, scholars, teachers), Kshatriyas (rulers, warriors, administrators), Vaisyas (skilled workers, merchants), Sudras (unskilled workers) and Harijans (the "Untouchables")
What is endogamy?
Marrying within one's own group (e.g. caste)
Describe the plantation hierarchy under slavery?
Planters (plantocracy) at the top, then other whites (overseers, agents, bookkeepers, artisans), then free coloureds and free blacks, with chattel slaves at the bottom
What is the plantocracy?
The influence wielded by planters as effectively the ruling class
What were chattel slaves?
Enslaved persons seen as owned entirely by their masters, with no rights
How were the free coloureds a buffer group?
They shared European values, were rewarded with privileges and would hardly risk losing them by uniting with blacks against the whites
Describe divisions within the white and coloured groups?
Creole whites were often above European-born absentee owners; poor whites ranked below planters but above free coloureds; coloureds were ranked by degree of whiteness (octaroon, quadroon), education, wealth and white protection
Describe divisions among the enslaved?
House slaves (privileged, close to whites) versus field slaves (hard labour, harshly punished)
What is institutionalised inequality?
Inequality that is part of how a society is organised and functions, so groups with more money, status and power act as gatekeepers blocking others' progress
What is a gatekeeper in social stratification?
A group or person with power who prevents others from moving up the social hierarchy
Give examples of how elites obstruct mobility?
Hiring through family connections, favouring lighter skin colour or caste, controlling credit and land, and unequal access to schooling
What is social class?
Levels or strata of society based on those with the same social and economic resources and so the same social status, using achieved criteria in modern society
What is the class structure of a typical Caribbean country?
Upper, middle and lower classes (with subdivisions)
How did Karl Marx describe social class?
Two main classes – the bourgeoisie (capitalists who own the means of production) and the proletariat (workers who sell labour) – in constant conflict, with the petite bourgeoisie (farmers, small business owners) between
Who are the bourgeoisie?
The capitalist class who own the means of production and aim to maximise profit by exploiting workers
Who are the proletariat?
The worker class who sell their labour to the bourgeoisie
Who are the petite bourgeoisie?
Farmers and small business owners in between the bourgeoisie and proletariat
How did Max Weber challenge Marx?
He argued class is also based on power and prestige or status, not only wealth, and that capitalism produced a differentiated middle class not always in conflict with workers
What are the Weberian bases of class?
Wealth (class), power and prestige (status)
Give an example of prestige without wealth?
A lawyer who is poor but moves in high social circles because of the respected profession
Give an example of power without wealth?
A politician from a poor background who gains access to high social circles because of the power of the office
What is the intelligentsia?
The educated intellectual elite who comprise the managerial and professional class
What is the middle class?
A class that evolved with capitalism and divided into layers (upper and lower middle) including professionals, white-collar workers and small business owners
What is a white-collar worker?
Non-manual worker in offices, business, industry and services such as bank tellers and clerks
What is a blue-collar worker?
Manual worker – skilled, semi-skilled or unskilled – such as plumbers and factory workers
What is the working class?
Mainly manual wage workers (blue-collar, skilled, semi-skilled, unskilled and self-employed non-professionals); a skilled tradesman may earn more than a white-collar worker
What is the underclass?
The lowest stratum, mostly living below the poverty level though some may be employed
What are the main groups in a typical Caribbean class structure?
Upper (inherited wealth, owners and managers of business), middle (professionals and managerial) and lower (workers and the poor)
Who tends to be in the upper class in the Caribbean?
Those who inherited wealth or married into it – in some countries (Barbados, Jamaica) descendants of Europeans; in others (Dominica, St Vincent) the old white elite is almost non-existent
Which groups have moved from the bottom to the top in some countries?
Portuguese, Chinese and Syrian-Lebanese – newly arrived poor immigrants who are now in the highest classes
How does today's class system differ from plantation society?
It is open and based on achieved criteria rather than closed and based on race and colour, but many similarities to the old structure remain
Define social mobility?
Movement of individuals and groups from one social class to another – up or down the hierarchy
What is a meritocracy?
A society where one can advance socially based on what one has achieved
What are the main ways of achieving upward social mobility?
Marrying someone with money, acquiring educational credentials for a well-paying job, and owning a successful business and investing wisely
Why is education the most popular route to mobility?
It is accessible to all income groups, opens up new occupations and gives the lower classes their main chance – it created new class formations such as the intelligentsia
How has education changed the class structure?
Previously disadvantaged groups (African, Indian, Amerindian) can attain greater wealth and prestige than their parents, increasing diversity and challenging the traditional stratified picture
What is intergenerational mobility?
A family moves to a higher socioeconomic bracket over generations through thrift, small business, land purchase and educating children
Why is mobility through education often limited?
Movement is usually only from one level to another within a class (e.g. manual to skilled labour), not across classes
Is the Caribbean really a meritocracy?
Not fully – many African and Indian descendants remain poor while white, near-white and coloured groups stay in higher classes with little downward mobility, suggesting some are prevented from mobility
How does education relate to new class formation (syllabus)?
It is a basis for new class formation and upward mobility, producing an intelligentsia and new white-collar and technical occupations