week 1 - historical development of hk legal system

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/33

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

34 Terms

1
New cards

institution that create operate and carry out laws of jurisdictioin

legco enect law

police enforce

courts operate and uohold legal system

2
New cards

legal system viewed as partof the

system of government

3
New cards

upon colonization in 1841

hk only few thousand habitants - fishing port

part of chinese empire qing dynasty

used chinese laws under imperial code and customs

4
New cards

economic interest of uk in china

china has tarde restirctions - one port for maritime trade only

british wants expand

trade opium for tea and silk - outflow of silver from china to pay for drugs - undermine economy - addiction

5
New cards

stopping the opoium (first act)

lin ze chu - public burning

increase tension between bristish and cn

6
New cards

following first opium war

treaty of nanking 1842

7
New cards

treayu of nanking 1842 details

forced china

  • open 5 ports to british trade

  • pay indemnity of 21 m

  • cede hk island

—> under article III


8
New cards

following second opium war

convention of peking 1960

9
New cards

convention of peking 1860

cede kowloon to britain

—> article VI convention of peking 1860

10
New cards

second convention of peking 1898

leasing the New Territories to Britain for 99 year

other powers were grabbing land in China, and Britain didn't want to be left behind. When France leased Guangzhouwan, Britain demanded its own "compensation."

11
New cards

order in council in 1898 in name of queen

linking the New Territories and Kowloon into one colony with Hong Kong Island

Britain was the largest empire in history and did not believe China had the power to change the arrangement.

12
New cards

key consequence of order in council

New Territories were legally merged into Hong Kong as a single whole, when the 99-year lease expired in 1997, the entire territory had to be dealt with together

13
New cards

chinas position on treaties

Both the Kuomintang and Communist governments refused to recognise the treaties, calling them "unequal treaties":

  • They were involuntary, forced contracts made under war pressure, so not binding on China.

  • Sovereignty was never given away — China argues it never legally relinquished sovereignty in the first place.

But China did not want to disturb the status quo, because Hong Kong was China's window to the world (trade, finance, foreign contacts).

14
New cards

taiwan in late 1970s

Late 1970s, Beijing wants reunification with taiwan - not on hk

9-point plan:

  1. high degree of autonomy

  2. retain its armed forces

  3. socio-economic system,

  4. existing way of life

  5. economic and cultural relations with foreign countries

  6. no encroachment on proprietary rights

  7. people in Taiwan may take up leadership posts in running the state,

  8. settle in the Mainland


15
New cards

law under colonial rule

under english principles - acquisition of a colony by conquest or cession - no automatic application of englihs law

unless altered by british crown

16
New cards

introduction of english law in hk why

protect private and commercial interests in hk business for british

ensure order n stability to faciliate british trade

ensure british subjects governed by laws familair to them

17
New cards

first two laws in 1841 a bout english law

chinese goverened by laws and customs of china

british and foreigners governed by principles and practice of british law

18
New cards

charter of the colony of hk by qyeen of england on 5 april 1843

governor with advise of legco granted power and autjroiyy to make any law needed to run hk peacefully and properly

transplanted formal institutions of english legal system and formal aspects of rule of law into hk

19
New cards

hk letters patent 1917

suspended 1842 letters patents

governeor with or by advise and consent of legco - make law for peace

supplemented by hk royal insturctions 1917

20
New cards

in 1844 what happened about english law

law application (only for law exixted before 5 april 1843) extended to all persons except for inaplicable local circumstances

  • supreme court ordiance no 15 qne 3


21
New cards

result of extension of eng law to chinese ppl

increase control of local population imporve living conditions of locals to assert british sovereignty over colony


BUT

rapid immigrayion

uncontrolled crime

view chinese meghods of justice were inferior

22
New cards

application of english law ordinace 1966

s4(1) - ist of specific English Acts are in force in Hong Kong. So Parliament in London passed certain laws, and Hong Kong formally adopted them by name

s 3-1 English common law and the rules of equity are in force in Hong Kong, but only:

(a) So far as they are applicable to Hong Kong's circumstances or its inhabitants. If an English rule makes no sense in Hong Kong, it doesn't apply.

(b) Subject to modifications that local circumstances require. Hong Kong can adapt English rules to fit local conditions.

(c) Subject to amendment by:

(i) an Order in Council applying to Hong Kong

(ii) an English Act applying to Hong Kong

(iii) any Hong Kong Ordinance — meaning Hong Kong's own legislature can change the imported English law..

23
New cards

does chinese law in colonial hk still applies

yes

English law only applied "so far as applicable to local circumstances," Chinese customs and laws were not automatically wiped out.

24
New cards

problem for chinese laws

Expatriate judges struggled to interpret Chinese law. British judges didn't understand Chinese customs, so they distorted the meaning and effect of Chinese law and custom in Hong Kong.

Courts applied Chinese law only in narrow circumstances — they were reluctant to use it widely.

By the late 20th century, Chinese customary law mattered only in limited areas — mainly marriage and property law

25
New cards

problem after 1843 charter (good side first)

create legco and import english laws

  • appoint chief mahistrate

  • police force set up

  • supreme court create


26
New cards

problem after 1843 charter (bad side

professionalism and competence lacking

police force unreliable and corrupt

jusicial officers and lawyers ot adequate knowledge of the law

procedural protections and rules of evidence ignored

much bias against chinese in court and law itself


27
New cards

What happened after Britain surrendered to Japan?

Japan imposed martial law and ruled Hong Kong during the occupation.

28
New cards

Why did Hong Kong have limited democracy under Britain?

The Governor was appointed by Britain, not elected by Hong Kong people; Britain held ultimate authority.

29
New cards

What kind of autonomy did Hong Kong gain before 1997?

Increasing practical autonomy, especially in economic affairs; from 1958, Hong Kong had greater independence in economic matters.

30
New cards

What were MacLehose’s major reforms?

Public housing through the Housing Authority, the MTR, the ICAC, and judicial-service reforms.

31
New cards

Why did China decide to negotiate over Hong Kong first?

Deng Xiaoping was pragmatic; Taiwan showed little interest in reunification, and Britain pressed for a clear arrangement, so China dealt with Hong Kong first.

32
New cards

What is “one country, two systems”?

Hong Kong is part of China (“one country”), but keeps its capitalist economy, legal system, and way of life (“two systems”).

33
New cards

sino british declaration

  • p3 - high degree of autonomy

Para 1: China “has decided to resume the exercise of sovereignty over hk with effect from 1 july 1997”

Para 2: britain would “restore hk to the prc”


34
New cards

draffting basic law

Basic law drafting committee established by china’s national people’s congress

23 of the 59 members coming from hk

Basic law consultative committee- 180 members from hk;no formal role in the drafting process

Provisional legco

The hkbl was adopted as a national law by the npc on 4 april 1990

Birth of the hksar on 1 july 1997