1/19
Looks like no tags are added yet.
FQ statutory authority
1331 + Article III - district courts shall have original jurisdiction over all civil actions arising under laws of US
Mottley well-pleaded complaint rule:
an action arises under federal law when P’s statement of its own cause of action shows it is based on fed law or P’s right to relief depends upon a resolution of a substantial q of fed law
Grable-Gunn embedded federal question test:
1) necessarily raised
2) actually disputed
3) substantial
4) capable of resolution in fed court w/out disrupting fed-state balance
1) and 2) (?)
if the federal issue involves a question of interpretation, then federal court has smj. if the federal issue involves merely a question of application, then federal court will not have smj
3) + 4)
if it is important that fed courts set binding precedent on the matter and if it does not conflict w/ interests of the state courts, fed court can exercise smj
diversity jurisdiction statute
1332 - district courts shall have original jurisdiction of all civil actions where matter in controversy exceeds the sum of $75,000 and is btwn citizens of different states
complete diversity
all Ps must be diverse from all Ds
citizenship of indv
domicile - physical presence + intent to remain (Sheehan)
citizenship of corporation
state of incorporation, PPB
what is PPB?
nerve center - the place where managers direct, control, and coordinate activities (Hertz)
citizenship of unincorp business
share citizenship of all its members
amount in controversy rule
whatever amt the P claims in good faith will govern, unless it is clear to a legal certainty that she cannot recover more than $75000 (JHT)
aggregation rule
if 1 P vs. 1 D, may aggregate P’s claims
if multiple P or multiple D, cannot aggregate UNLESS Ps have common interests or Ds have joint liability
supplemental jurisdiction
for claims in a fed case that may not satisfy original smj through FQ or diversity (1367)
1367(a)
district courts shall have supp j over all other claims that are so related to claims in the federal action w/in original jurisdiction that they form part of same case or controversy under Article III
Gibbs (mining union)
common nucleus of operative fact - claims arise out of sto
1367(b)
DIVERSITY CASES ONLY - if additional claim is made by P against parties under 14, 19, 20, 24 OR made by a 19, 24 P AND it destroys diversity, no supp j
Allapattah - amount in controversy + supp j
as long as other jurisdictions reqs met, and at least 1 P has >$75000, supp j over other claims in case
removal basics 1441
D may remove if case could have originally been brought in fed court under FQ or diversity UNLESS (in diversity case) in-state D; P may not remove
must remove w/in ___ that it becomes apparent smj exists
30 days