1/327
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Personal Jurisdiction
ability of a court having subject matter jurisdiction to exercise power over a particular defendant or item of property
Limitations on Personal jurisdiction
Personal jurisdiction must be authorized by statute and constitutional
Statutory authorization
States have the power to decide who their courts can exercise jurisdiction over
Look to state statute
long arm statute
Long arm statute
state statute that specifies when a state may exercise personal jurisdiction over defendant from another state
Long arm of state can reach out and bring someone from a different state within their jurisdiction
unlimited, hybrid, or limited
Unlimited Long Arm Statute
authorize personal jurisdiction up to the constitutional limits
As long as PJ is constitutional, state has PJ over citizen of different state
Limited Long Arm Statute
specify acts that subject out of state defendants to personal jurisdiction
If common→ likely to be constitutional
traditional bases for PJ
Where the defendant is present in the forum state and is personally served with process
Where the defendant is domiciled in the forum state
Where the defendant consents to jurisdiction
Where the defendant has committed acts bringing him within the forum state’s long arm statutes
exceptions to presence at time of service for PJ
cant force the defendant into state by fraud or force to serve
immunity from PJ to nonresidents present solely to take part in judicial proceedings or passing through for proceedings elsewhere
common limited long arm statutes
torts cases
contract cases
property actions
martial dissolution cases
Torts limited long arm statute
Subject to personal jurisdiction in state if commit a tort in the state
Other states require tortious act
Contract limited long arm statute
Cause of action arises out of transaction of business
Some require defendant or agent physically present others take broader view (i.e phonecall to state)
Property limited long arm statute
Nonresident defendants when cause of action arises from ownership of property within the state
Marital dissolution limited long arm statute
Married couple last lived together in the state and one abandons the other, remaining spouse may obtain PJ over the absent spouse for divorce or legal separation
Hybrid long arm statute
specific acts with a catchall provision at the end that says you can go to the constitutional limits
Constitutional authorization of PJ
Due process clause of constitution places two restrictions on the exercise of PJ
Contacts and notice
traditional and modern standard
Traditional rule- Physical power; sufficient contacts for PJ
A state could exercise personal jurisdiction over a defendant physically present within its borders and properly served with process.
Test for constitutionality- modern due process standard
Defendant must have such minimum contacts with the forum that exercise of personal jurisdiction does not offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice
contact, relatedness, fairness
contact
must be purposeful and foreseeable
Purposeful availament
Defendant reaches into the forum in some way
NOT accidental
“purposefully availed herself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum state, thus involving the benefits and protections of its laws”
stream of commerce- contacts for PJ
Arise when the defendant manufactures products in state A and sells them to a second party in state B, placing product in steam of commerce . Product winds up in state C and injury occurs
Merely placing an item in the stream of commerce by itself is not sufficient basis for PJ
Look for intentional targeting (purposeful availment)
foreseeability - contacts PJ
Purposeful makes it foreseeable
Defendant must have known or reasonably anticipated that her activities in the forum would render it foreseeable and that she may be “haled into court” there
three types of PJ
in personam jurisdiction
in rem jurisdiction
quasi in rem jurisdiction
In Personam Jurisdiction
Exists when the forum has power over the person of a particular defendant
In Rem Jurisdiction
Exists when the court has power to adjudicate the rights of all persons in the world with respect to a particular item of property
Limited to situations where property is located within the physical borders of the state and where it is necessary for the state to be able to bind all persons regarding the properties ownership and use
Quasi In Rem Jurisdiction
Court has power to determine whether particular individuals own specific property within the courts control
Relatedness- constitutionality of PJ
Cause of action sufficiently related to defendants contacts with forum
general personal jurisdiction
specific personal jurisdiction
General Personal Jurisdiction
personal jurisdiction over defendant for all causes of action
Where they are “at home”/ domiciled
Corporation→ “at home” where it is incorporated and principal place of business
Specific Personal Jurisdiction
Claim arising from activity in the state
where there are minimum contacts with this state that are related to this lawsuit.
Fairness- PJ
not a consideration for GENERAL personal jurisdiction (fair to be sued at home)
Convenience
Forum state’s interest
Other factors
Convenience- PJ fairness
constitutionally acceptable forum unless it is so gravely difficult and inconvenient that a party is unfairly put at a severe disadvantage in comparison to his opponent
Difficult for standard to meet
Forum state’s interest - fairness PJ
May have legitimate interest in providing redress for its residents
other factors for fairness PJ
Plaintiffs interest in obtaining convenient and effective relief
Interstate judicial system’s interest in obtaining most efficient resolution of controversies
Shared interest of states in furthering fundamental substantive social policies
Notice- PJ
Must be given appropriate notice of the action and an opportunity to be heard
Traditional methods of personal service satisfy due process notice requirements
Requirement that agent notify defendant
Requirements for Cases Involving Multiple or Unknown Parties
Knowledge that notice by mail was not received
Traditional methods of personal service satisfy due process notice requirements
Personal delivery to defendant; leaving papers with responsible person at defendant's residence or place of business; delivery to an agent appointed to accept service; delivery by registered mail, return receipt requested
Requirement that agent notify defendant
If agent is appointed by contract or by operation of law→ failure of agent to notify defendant will prohibit jurisdiction
Requirements for Cases Involving Multiple or Unknown Parties
Notified by best practical means available
Addresses known or reasonably ascertained had to be notified by ordinary mails, unknown can be notified by publication
Knowledge that notice by mail was not received
If a party knows notice by mail was not received, he may not proceed in the face of synch knowledge if practicable alternative to apprise defendant of action exist
PJ in federal courts
Rule 4 of the Federal Rules provide absent special federal statute, each federal court must analyze personal jurisdiction as if it were a court of the state in which it is located
Does the court have PJ?
Does the state have a long arm statute authorizing PJ
No → no PJ
Yes
Is the exercise of PJ constitutional?
1. Are there contacts with the forum?
2. Were the contacts purposeful?
3. Was suit foreseeability in forum?
**if no to any of these three → No PJ
4. Are the contacts related to the cause of action
No
Is D at home in state?
No → no PJ
Yes → general personal jurisdiction
5. Is jurisdiction fair?
Yes
Specific personal jurisdiction
Sample PJ rule statements
For a federal district court to have personal jurisdiction over a particular defendant, there must be a state statute authorizing personal jurisdiction (because a federal district court must analyze the personal jurisdiction issue as if it were a state court in the jurisdiction), and the exercise of such jurisdiction must be constitutional.
The state statute can either be an unlimited long arm statute, meaning it authorizes personal jurisdiction up to the constitutional limits, or a limited long arm statutes, where the it specifies acts that subject out of state defendants to personal jurisdiction
For the exercise of personal jurisdiction to be constitutional, the nonresident defendant must either have conducted continuous and systematic activity within the state such that it is considered to be “doing business” within the state such that it is “essentially at home” therein, thereby subjecting itself to personal jurisdiction for all causes of action (“general jurisdiction”), or it must have sufficient minimum contacts with the state such that the exercise of personal jurisdiction over it for the instant cause of action only would be fair and reasonable (“specific jurisdiction”)—in other words, whether defendant had purposeful contacts with the forum such that he could reasonably anticipate being haled into court in the forum state.
Subject Matter Jurisdiction
the court’s power over a particular type of case
federal question jurisdiction
diversity jurisdiction
supplemental jurisdiction
Federal Question Jurisdiction
Cases “arising under this constitution, the Laws of the US, and Treaties made, or which shall be made under their authority”
Federal question must appear as part of the plaintiffs cause of action as set out in a well pleaded complaint
Rule: For federal question jurisdiction to be proper, the case must arise under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States. Whether a case “arises under” federal law is determined from the plaintiff’s well-pleaded complaint, but the plaintiff cannot anticipate a potential defense that is based on federal law in order to provide the court with federal question jurisdiction.
Well pleaded complaint rule
Court looks only to plaintiffs complaint to determine federal question jurisdiction
Federal question must appear as part of plaintiffs cause of action
Defenses cannot be basis for federal question jurisdiction
Answer or defense is irrelevant
Diversity jurisdiction rule statement
For diversity of citizenship jurisdiction to be proper, there must be complete diversity of citizenship, meaning each plaintiff must be of diverse state citizenship of every defendant when suit is filed, and the amount in controversy must exceed $75,000 based on the plaintiff’s good faith claim.
complete diversity
No plaintiff may be a citizen of the same state as any defendant
Alienage Jurisdiction
Subject matter jurisdiction over alienage cases in which the dispute is between a citizen of a US state and an alien ( a citizen or subject of foreign country)
Constitution does not provide federal jurisdiction over cases by an alien against an alien; need a citizen of US state on one side of suit
Domicile
Permanent home to which he intends to return
Change of domicile→ established by physical presence in a new place and the intention to remain there with no present intent to go elsewhere
Citizenship of a corporation
Corporation is a citizen in every state and foreign county in which it is incorporated and the one state or foreign county where it has its principal place of business
*if either place of incorporation or principal place of business are in foreign country and corp is in an action with another alien→ no alienage jurisdiction
principal place of business
State from which corporation’s high level officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation's activities
Unincorporated associations capacity
Federal question→ Unincorporated associations are entities that may sue or be sued
Diversity→ unincorporated association may sue or be sued in its own name if local state law permits
unincorporated associations citizenship
Unincorporated association’s citizenship is that of each and every one of its members
LLC citizenship
Citizen of all states of which members are citizens
legal representatives citizenship
Legal representative of an infant, incompetent, or an estate of decedent is deemed to be a citizen of the same state as the infant, incompetent or decedent
class action citizenship
diversity determined on basis of the citizenship of the named members of the class who are suing
Nonresident of united states citizens
United States citizen domiciled abroad is not a citizen of any state and also not alien
Alien status depends on nationality, not domicile
creating or defeating diversity
Class actions→ allowed to select named members of class to ensure diversity jurisdiction even if unnamed members of class are co xitixens and naming would prevent diversity jurisdiction
Voluntary change of state citizenship→ plaintiff can create diversity by changing his state citizenship after cause of action but before suit commenced; must be genuine; motive is irrelevant
domicile rule statement
A person’s state citizenship is determined by his domicile, the state in which he is physically present and in which he intends to remain permanently, whereas a corporation is a citizen of every U.S. state and foreign country in which it is incorporated and the one U.S. state or foreign country in which it has its principal place of business, which the United States Supreme Court has recently held to be the location where the corporation’s high level officers direct, control, and coordinate the corporation’s activities
Amount in controversy
Amount in controversy must be in excess of $75,000
Amount determined from what is claimed in complaint , need good faith allegation that the amount of damages or injuries in controversy exceeds 75k
Excludes interests and costs from amount in controversy
LITIGATION Interests→ resulting in delay caused by litigation
Interest due on note or loan can be used!
LITIGATION Costs→ related to litigation
If allows attorney fees , can be used
Collateral consequences of judgement → not considered
good faith amount of controversy
Must be legally tenable possibility that recovery will exceed jurisdictional amount
Equitable relief- amount in controversy
Some courts look at issue from plaintiffs viewpoint
Ask what value of the harm caused is
Other courts look at issue from defendant’s viewpoint
Ask what it would cost the defendant to comply
Some allow amount in controversy satisfied under either plaintiff or defendant viewpoint
aggregation of separate claims
combining claims to meet amount in controversy
One plaintiff against one defendant
One plaintiff against several defendants
Several plaintiffs against one defendant
Class actions
one plaintiff against one defendant - aggregation
Plaintiff can aggregate all claims against a single defendant
Regardless of whether they are legally or factually related to each other
one plaintiff against several defendants- aggregation
Plaintiff against several defendants cannot aggregate claims based on separate liabilities
No aggregation problem if plaintiff asserts joint claim against multiple defendants
several plaintiffs against one defendant - aggregation
Several plaintiffs can aggregate their claims only where they are seeking to enforce a single title or right in which they have a common or undivided interest
Cant be used if claims are separate and district
class action - aggregation
Claims of class members cannot be aggregated if their rights are separate rather than joint or common
One class representative's claim must exceed 75k , court has supplemental over claims not exceeding 75k
Exceptions to diversity of citizenship jurisdiction
Domestic relations
Probate proceedings
Supplemental jurisdiction
A way for a court to hear a claim that it otherwise wouldn't have subject matter jurisdiction over
Must have a claim to supplement (invoked either federal question or diversity jurisdiction )
Supplemental claim must share common nucleus of operative fact with first claim
Federal Question - Supplemental
Plaintiff has federal and state claim against the defendant
Federal court has discretion to exercise supplement jurisdiction over claim based on state law if two claims derive from a common nucleus of operative fact and are such that a plaintiff would ordinarily be expected to try them all in one judicial proceeding
Two claims must arise from the same transaction or occurrence
Loss of supplemental→ over state law claims if following removal based on federal question the plaintiff amends complaint to eliminate all federal law claims that enabled the removal
Diversity- Supplemental
A claim by joined plaintiff that does not meet amount in controversy requirement for diversity of citizenship may use supplemental jurisdiction if claim arises from a common nucleus of operative facts as the claim that involved diversity citizenship
Supplemental jurisdiction cannot override complete diversity between co plaintiff and defendants
Plaintiffs generally not allowed to use supplemental jurisdiction in diversity case
Plaintiff cant use supp jurisdiction to destroy diversity but if a second plaintiff is diverse and just does not meet amount in controversy → they can use it
If only flaw is amount in controversy
Restriction on the use of supplemental jurisdiction in diversity cases
For cases that are in federal court based solely on diversity, supplemental jurisdiction may not be used to support:
(i) Claims by plaintiffs against persons made parties under Rules 14 (impleader), 19 (compulsory joinder), 20 (permissive joinder), or 24 (intervention);
(ii) Claims by persons proposed to be joined as plaintiffs under Rule 19; and
(iii) Claims by persons seeking to intervene as plaintiffs under Rule 24;
When the exercise of supplemental jurisdiction would be inconsistent with the requirements for diversity jurisdiction.
Court has discretion to decline supplemental jurisdiction
Claim raises novel issues of state law
Supplemental claim predominates over original claim
Original claim has been dismissed
questions for supplemental jurisdiction
Is there diversity or federal question jurisdiction?
No→ case dismissed
Yes→ move to question 2
Does the claim arise from the same important facts (common nucleus) as the original claim?
No→ no supplemental jurisdiction
Yes → move to question 3
Is the original claim based on federal question jurisdiction?
No→ move to question 4
Yes→ supplemental jurisdiction
Is the plaintiff trying to use supplemental jurisdiction in diversity case?
Yes → no supplemental jurisdiction unless exception
No → supplemental jurisdiction
pendent parties
Plaintiff sues more than one defendant, there is federal jurisdiction over the claim against one defendant, and the claim against the second defendant does not invoke federal question or diversity jurisdiction
Claim against second defendant may invoke supplement if it arises from common nucleus of operative fact as the claim against first defendant
Can also arise when multiple plaintiffs assert claims against one defendant
Joinder
Joining two or more parties in one action or two or more claims against someone else
Intervention of right- rule 24(a)
Must be allowed when
The intervenor claims an interest relating to the property or transaction that is the subject of the action
The disposition of the action may adversely affect that interest, and
The current parties do not adequately represent the intervenor’s right
No supplemental jurisdiction for claims by original plaintiffs against intervening defendants or for claims by intervening plaintiffs
Needs to be timely which is at courts discretion
Permissive intervention - rule 24(b)
May be permitted in the court’s discretion when the intervenor’s action and the main action have a claim or defense involving common question of law or fact
Must invoke either diversity or FQJ
No direct personal or pecuniary interest required
Cant destroy complete diversity
Needs to be timely which is at courts discretion
amendment allowing replacement of parties
Original party replaced by party whom or against whom the action properly lies
Must be diverse to the party or parties on opposing side
venue
Relates to the proper geographic district in which to bring the action
Special venue provisions
Where the defendant is in the US or an agency thereof, or an officer, employee etc of US acting in his official capacity, civil action may be brought in federal district where
Defendant resides
Substantial part of events or omissions giving rise to the action occurred, or a substantial part of property that is the subject of the action is situated or
The plaintiff resides if no real property is involved in the action
residence for venue- natural persons
Reside in federal judicial district in which person is domiciled
reisdence for venue- business entities
Reside in any federal judicial district in which defendant is subject to the courts personal jurisdiction with respect to the civil action in question
General PJ→ where corp lives (incorporated and principal place)
Specific PJ→ minimal contacts; contacts related to cause of action
residence for venue- nonresident
may be sued in any federal district
venue transfer- original venue proper
to another more convenient forum in which the action might have been brought or to which all parties have consented
venue transfer- original venue improper
Court must dismiss or transfer case to federal venue in which it could have been brought
Transfer is more appropriate
proper venue
A federal district court in which any defendant resides, if all defendants are residents of the state in which the district is located;
A federal district court in which a substantial part of events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred, or a substantial party of property that is the subject of the action is situated; or
If there is no federal district court that satisfies (i) or (ii), a judicial district in which any defendant is subject to the court’s personal jurisdiction with respect to the action
Forum selection clauses- venue transfer
If transaction involved in suit included agreement as to where a suit should be brought in case of litigation, clause will be enforced by means of a motion to transfer “in the interest of justice” unless exceptional public interest factors dictate otherwise
Lack of PJ relating to venue
Original court’s lack of PJ over defendant does not affect power to transfer case
Commencement of the action
an action is commenced by filing a complaint with the court
Process
The papers!
Complaint along with summons that formally gives defendant notice of suit and time for response
Service
way the papers were delivered
Insufficient service= papers didnt get to you the correct way
who can serve process?
Any person who is at least 18 years old and NOT a party to the action may serve summons and complaint (process)
Party can request service made by United States marshal
time limit for service of process
Must be made within 90 days of complaint being filed
Court must extend this period for good cause shown
service on individuals
An individual may be served by personal service, service left at the defendant’s usual place of abode with one of suitable age and discretion residing therein or service upon an authorized agent of the defendant
personal service
Papers are personally given to defendant
Defendant's usual place of abode with someone of suitable age and discretion who lives there too
Person at residence does not need to have particular relationship to the defendant; they just have to live there
Suitable age is generally a person older than 14
service on minors or incompetent persons
Has to be served in accordance with the rules of the state where service is made
service under state rules
State where federal court sits
State where service is to be made
service on corporations and business entities
Serving an officer, managing or general agent, authorized agent of corporation
waiver of service by mail
Plaintiff must mail defendant certain items such as a formal request to waive service, two copies of the waiver form, and a copy of the complaint
Defendant has 30 days in US and 60 days outside US from date that the request was sent to return the waiver
Effect of waiver of service
Defendant who waives formal service of process has 60 days in US and 90 days if outside US from date request was sent to answer the complaint
This is instead of the usual 21 days to answer complaint
Does not waive defendants right to object to venue and jurisdiction