1/22
2 different articles
Work Family Conflict definition
(Shockley 2018) Conflict that arises from role pressure at work and family. These demands are mutually incompatible,
Two directions of WFC
(Shockley 2018) \
1. Work interfering with family
2. Family interfering with work.
Three types of WFC
(Shockley 2018)
1. time-based
2.Strain-based
3. behavior-based
Time-based (WFC type)
Work and family activity occurs at the same time, and one cannot attend both.
Ex: Child’s doctors appointment and merger meeting happen on the same day at 10am.
Strain-based (WFC type)
When one role makes it difficult to perform well in the other role.
Ex: Stressful day at work causes withdrawal from family interactions in the evening.
Behavior Based conflict (WFC type)
Behavior needed to perform one role is not compatible with the other.
Ex: Tax collector remains emotionally detached at work. Then brings the same energy to conversations with spouse.
Energy Based conflict
(Shockley 2018)
One role drains energy, causing lack of energy in the other role.
Psychological preoccupation
This happens when one is physically present but mentally absent.
Three dimensions of Capital
(Shockley 2018)
Increase psych resources.
Sense of security, accomplishment, self-fulfillment
Affect:
Increase in positive emotional state. This can enrich performance at work or family
Developmental: Increase in resources like skills, knowledge, and Perspectives that enrich performance.
Theory of domain specificity
Work-to-family conflict comes from work
Family-to-work conflict comes from family.
WFC and FWC correlations
Work related consequences are stronger correlated with WFC.
Family related consequences are stronger correlated with FWC
Most discussed non domain specific WFC and WFE
Gender. Division of labor.
Men performed greater paid labor. Men don’t pick up on intrusions to Work-to-family conflict, causing them to have greater Family-to-work conflict.
Women spent more time in household and childcare labor. Women place greater value on family and are sensitive to any intrusions of this role.
For WFE there are no strong evidence to show gender differences.
Denunizo, Arvan, Knudsen Meta analysis results
They studied WFC and FWC relationship with gender.
Findings suggest no meaningful association. This could possibly be because both genders experience equivalent amount of WFC. But women are socialized to expect this difficulty, but men are not.
Social Economic status.
small, positive correlation between income and WFC
no correlation between income and FWC
Low income report high WFC and low WFE in comparison to higher income.
Age and Life
Empty Nesters and DINKS had the lowest WFC vs those with kids.
WFC may arise when dealing with caring for elderly parents, grand kids, managing retirement, or dealing with negative stereo types about age.
Delaying childbirth is an advantage for women’s career success.
Martial status
Married people have higher WFC than single.
Married people with children experience less WFC than single people with children.
Kinship Responsibilities
Responsibility for any dependents have a correlation between WFC and FWC.
Larger correlation # of kids < Ages of kids, Living arrangements, or elder care.
More likely to have WFC with special needs kids.
Personality (Big 5)
All but Openness are affected.
Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, and extroversion correlated less with WFC and greater with Work Life Enrichment
Neuroticism is correlated more with WFC and less with Work Life Enrichment.
Well-Being Consequences
WFC is associated with outcomes like life satisfaction, mental and physical health, health behaviors (oppositie for Work life enrichment).
High WFC correlates with poorer well-being (opposite with Work life enrichment).
Formal “Family-Friendly” Benefits
Flexibility policies include: Flextime, flexplace, compressed work week, reduced hours, pt work, and job sharing.
Dependent care supports: Policies that help those care for dependents (kids daycare, or elderly living facilities).
*This is the key solution to Work-Family management.
No significant correlation between flextime and WFC.
Small correlation between flexplace and WFC.
mixed to no results for correlation between Work family enrichment and flexible schedules.
Informal support
*Work family support culture is a moderator between those that use family friendly benefits and outcomes.
little to no empirical support for this.
Changing norms about physical presence at work reduces WFC and improved work schedule.
Article recommendations
to maximize the impact of family-friendly benefits, would be to work at a culture that influences one to use it.
Those with long work hours should get a designated day off during the week.
How the government can help
Change laws on work week hours and parental leave.
Parental leave policies are positive associated with individuals actually using it, length of leave, and re-entering the labor force. But negatively associated with child or infant mortality rates.
Parental leave positive implication: longer duration of breastfeeding and more immunization for children, increased labor force participation from women.
Parental leave negative implication: Longer leaves is related to larger gender pay gap and greater gender segregation.